Pia Toscano - River Deep Mountain High - American Idol Season 10

[AlejitaTowers]

0:48 THE VOICEEE THE VOICEEE!

[musicislife212]

I love her, and she is so gorgeous! Looks and confidence wise, she reminds me of Selena Gomez a little!

[TheBaseballfrek]

Pia does it her way = She stays.

Judges tell her to do an uptempo song = she gets voted off.

WOW.

[arfurlife]

she did great witha lousy song. so sad she did nt get away with it because she was by far the most gifted peformer at that point. The others must have been gob smacked and delighted at their good fortune. Pia is a very very special talent.

[abclairez123]

Haha... Jennifer from 1:37-1:45... :)

[pyrofreak007]

I still think they screwed up the votes. Because its really based on a majority vote...And the ENTIRE audience was booing. So how is it possible that she got the lowest votes?

[xtimantazx]

nah, I like glee's version better...

[DEVASTATOR478]

i prefer CELINE DION !!!

[tanylda]

Christina Aguilera rests :)

[misstalentgirl1]

she can sing so good

[thegritch42]

This girl is good. I had to see who was trying to sing a Tina Turner song..she surprised the hell outta me! Is okay she got voted off..seems like the ones that get voted off go further...she won't disappear, she's too good.

[SecillianOEspanol]

wow, she's good!

[eccentricgurl55]

So, I'm actually glad I didn't watch idol this season because finding out this gurl was voted off after this dynamite performance, would have pissed me off!!!! By the way she MURDERED THIS SONG! (IN A GOOD WAY)

[Riesvandijk]

WOW Real GOOD , She Should have Won , and Love Her single THIS TIME!!

[vincenzotaylor]

How could she get eliminated the day after this performance, like really?

[LouisianaCityboi]

How could the best performance of the night be sent home..so confused..

[xtcvsop]

she already was a winner and to be fair they eliminated her for someone else to get a chance. Think of it as win win for her and other contestant.

[pko322]

They changed the rule in AI....it should be like America's best dance crew. The fans votes the bottom 3 and the judges decides who will be eliminated.

[123amfa123]

And by the way, Haley is always rocking too!

[123amfa123]

I understand you're here to defend Pia, but please stop saying that the other contestants should have gone home. James is always an outstanding performer, he may not sing the kind of music you listen to, but you can't deny his fabulous talent and his great creativity

[123amfa123]

I understand you're here to defend Pia, but please stop saying that the other contestants should have gone home. James is always an outstanding performer, he may not sing the kind of music you listen to, but you can't deny his fabulous talent and his great creativity

[tdigirl101]

AMAZING!this just proves how the rest of the world thinks us Americans are dumb asses that Haley ! got farther than her! Haley was TERRIBLE !

[yupmonk3yzrul3]

but even if you don't like the song her voice is clearly amazing here

[BluePolcadots]

Im A Haley Fan.... But This was Awesome:))))))

[thatsalligot2say]

amazing in this video

[CatelynMusic]

NO DISLIKES!! THUMBS UP:)

[jcmehsmom]

It's too bad this performance voted her off. I thought she was pretty good.

[KxRainnxForeverr]

Haley would have sang this WAAAAAAY better.

[Idolfan21785]

If Simon were still on Idol there is NO WAY she would've been voted off he would've done something to prevent it.

[HuzkyMe]

Am I the only one who blame Gwen Stefani for this?

[NomorelGN]

i rather jacob and stephano to be voted off first :/

[liezlpecho]

she's good

[planman422]

everyone close your eyes..... can you picture anyone else sing this song like she did. there are no wrong answers. let us know

[weaslepower]

Pia shouldn't be eleminated!!!! I even voted for her!!!

[psat21]

@weaslepower Oh well, she has a record deal now :)

[happydamned]

i still cant believe she got eliminated

[rhei1726]

take hailey, paul and stefano return pia =)

[Royours]

@rhei1726 oh and you forgot jacob too

[jlucasm1982]

She is going to be so succesful in life and with her career! Americans are MORONS...but again I'm not surprised....america voted for Bush TWICE. Idiots. We love you Pia!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[golden454]

Bad styling by Gwen Stefani very fugly outfit, I am sure didn't help.

[mayevck]

Bring her back please, she is amazing. That s not fair!!!

[mayevck]

Bring her back please, she is amazing. It is not fair!!!

[rylee11]

America just made the biggest mistake ever! She was the best on American Idol!! I hate America, they don't know how to vote for the right people! If anyone needed to go home, it's James. Not Pia! Bring her back!

[jaylovezmusic]

@rylee11 thats exactly what i said when she got voted off, i yelled at the top of my lungs i hate america, america doesn't know how to vote, but i'm glad she has a recording contract

[Elisjevian]

@rylee11 Wow if you start hating countries because their musical preferences are different from yours, you must hate a lot of countries :)

[BriaBoo756]

@rylee11 But think about it shes bigger and doing more than the winner of American idol. Things happen for a reason :)

[Nues0302]

the three best singers all in the bottom three.....

Pia you will be missed

[ao1910]

i hate americans.. they don't know how to vote..

[I9IIEIIYIIEIIS]

i didn't care for the song choice that much either, but Pia is best. YOU FUCKING MORONS!!!

[MonsonNicole]

@I9IIEIIYIIEIIS  amen^^^

[BoiFavSongs]

fuck american dont even know how 2 vote their fav !!

this show is a joke!!! My favorite made it, but the wrong person still got sent home! Big mistake AMERICA wake up!!!!!

[yourimaginaryenemy]

Go Pia!!! Best pipes in the competition this year by far.

[Ikurun]

Amazing!