As Long As You're Mine

[Tigerbai1]

I've saw Wicked in Rochester NY a few years ago and it was amazing. That entire soundtrack was fantastic-its rare to like every song. You did a superior job with this vid. Phantom of the Opera was a great movie also. Thanks for putting them together.

[hannabus18]

This is awesome!! I absolutely love this song!! This is one of my all time favorite songs from Wicked...and I adore PHONTOM OF THE OPERA!! Thank-you for sharing!!!

[CaptainHooksGirl]

I love this song, and I've been thinking for awhile that it would go well with Phantom, so I was really excited to come across your video! :D I kind of think that Elphaba's part actually fits Erik better than Fiyero's part, but either way, it turned out GREAT :)

[hannahloveshistory]

Awesome!

[ZeAriel]

I always thought this song would fit! Both of my favorite musicals!

[Allday232]

I think this video is perfect! :D And how it ended with the rose? Priceless! It went perfectly with the song! And Erik and Christine deserve each other, so the song fit them perfectly! :D

[tonigke]

amazing video , i love phantom of the opera and wicked !

[redberry0]

good

[musicallover170]

Both of my favorite musicals! THANK YOU!!!!!

[daughterofares10239]

I think its perfect

[JustineifyYourLife]

Perfect

[inlovewithKStewart22]

beautiful. Really well done. But I still think this song fits Raoul and Christine more than Christine and Erik. Because she belongs with Raoul.

[tendertouche]

Awesome



[phantasma616]

oo i love this!!

[Sprx77AntauriGibson]

this is great! <3 love it! :)

[Joyfuljoyishepic]

This should be a song in "The Phantom of the Opera"!! ;3

[kiokowashio23]

now that is an amazing video! good job!!!

[Mckean48]

that was fantastically done :)))

[yesnonotexactly25]

1:55 until the end was the best and by the best i mean that's when i started crying T_T but the whole this was excellent! oh my god this is AMAZING i loved all the clips you used. i never would have thought of this song with them (maybe im just slow), but you really made it work this is beautiful :D <3

[carmelita1993]

wow, this is really good. you made me cry. it's very impressive. ;)

[MegaPocketninja]

You managed to combine to two best musicals ever....Impressive. Bravo :)

[VampireCrazyGirl]

thsi made me cry

[girlsxred]

you should make a poto video with dont go breking my heart

[GottaLoveShowbiz]

Thank you! You have combined two of my favourite musicals! Great job and a wonderful video - well thought out and put together!! :D

[TheEpona92]

greatest Broadway love song of all time!!! and it goes perfectly with this movie, and i've never even seen it before

[VampsSparkle]

A perfect medley of my two favourite musicals

[Aqua2Kitty]

Wow...you did great job =) Luv'd the video dude =D

[funtownmandy]

just how it should be! Erik and Christine forever<3

[simzproductionz]

omg, best thing ever, the two most best musicals ever in ONE!!!

[aliali1223334444]

Please watch and comment on some of my videos. Not a lot of people watch them and I really want people's opinions :)

[TheMeganAlyson]

I loved it!

[lynabeean]

The Phantom was a bit harsh to Christine, but yes, I do think they should of been together.

[Shimathe]

A perfect song and an amazing video. You did wonderful !

Thanks for sharing.

Shirley.

[nibblesfan]

Never really wanted to see Wicked but after hearing all your vid's with the music, I think I might.

[lynabeean]

@nibblesfan Wicked is a beautiful, beautiful masterpiece of art. I loved it so muchh. Sadly- more then Phantom Of The Opera. It was so muchh!

[nibblesfan]

@lynabeean idk still haven't seen it...its not anywhere near my area...I must admit I'm obsessed with Phantom...I'm pathetic...I come home everyday to watch the movie and songs like this one

[AlyssaMG123]

just amazing! I absolutely love this! this is how it should of been with Christine and the PHANTOM not stupid Rauol!!!

[nothinbuttruth]

I love this song its sooo beautiful

[yasminbella4]

:X:X:X:X:X:X:X

[LizSmiles1]

This is great! Awesome job, the song is perfect (plus I love these two musicals, and having them together is heaven!!!)

[youkaianna]

beautifully made. great work.

[ROXYlife292]

Lovelovelove it! The song fits perfectly.

[EriksShatteredMirror]

Wow, that sent shivers up my spine! This song is amazing... I think I just might add "Wicked" to my list of favorite musicals. The video is fits and emotional and gives me goosebumps... good job!

[mjrent]

Absolute Perfection!!!! You did an AMAZING job!!!!

[Showaholic]

love it! great song choice for it too

[thewylion]

beautfiul really beautiful

favourited

* * * * *

[Devine80]

Incredible!

[sk8rKim]

i think this is quite genius!

[RienGesine]

I love this so much. I normally don't have a lot of patience for mmvs, but this is really well done!

[wowbottledwater]

hey janelovesdrama, dont criticize her mixing. it's her own hard work , time and effort here. if u dont like it, dont watch the vid. or better yet, why dont u spend all that time making a vid and letting others criticize your work? personally, i think all ur poto vids are excellent, carolynroxsox. the picture quality is better than most vids. and u have the complete set of songs in ur channel. thank you for spending ur time to put them up on youtube for me and everyone to enjoy :)

BRAVA!

[JackSparrowluvr25]

you never realize till someone else does it that some broadway songs go toother shows.

[wong302006]

a beautiful video

[janelovesdrama]

I recognize you as the person who mixed Les Mis and Phantom.

I'm sorry I was a little snappish in the other review, but I don't like it when people mix musicals.

I say this respectfully:

Can't you keep Phantom songs to Phantom clips and leave Wicked and Les Mis out of it?

[wosica]

I think the song fits well with the clips from Phantom. Now if sound clips from both Wicked and Phantom had been used then okay...I might agree with you. But that song...even though it is from Wicked...just works with those Phantom clips...plain and simple.

Well done, carolynroxsox! :)

[Vampanezegirl]

That was a amazing video! i love the Phantom of the Opera, and i like the song, where have you got the song from? :)

[2RandomGirls]

Wow, wicked plus Phantom of the Opera. Awesome! I wish I could see Wicked. I only know the songs.

[sweetcat09]

amazing job on the video! its really good its like perfect =D

[phantomgirl1257]

I know I just can't get enough of this song. It is just so romantic. Just simply beatiful.

[TeenInMusicals]

It looked like it was gonna b really cheesy just because its combining too AMAZING musicals, but WOW this was really really good!

[phantomgirl1257]

i love this video it is so romantic. it's going on my fave list.

[KitsuneUdon95]

Hmm, alright. Where should I find it?

[KitsuneUdon95]

picture or possibly*

[KitsuneUdon95]

Oh, and in regards to this video, I love both Phantom of the Opera and Wicked, so it recieves a thumbs-up from me!

[KitsuneUdon95]

This sounds stupid, I know but...can someone tell me how to make a video? Just a simple one, like putting a song to a picture of possibly a slideshow? I'll be grateful for any help I can get.

[greatbigseafan]

If you're using Windows, you should have a Windows Movie Maker program somewhere on your computer. Open it up and see what you can do. It's a pretty user-friendly program (:

If you're using a Mac, I can't tell you, because I don't know. :P

[twimper]

wow...nickaly done...that song from wicked fits realy well with this.

you should do one to 'no good deed' i think that would be cool :)

[HoneeMustard]

cool :]

[doeby2]

good vid. nice song. i love TOPO it's one of the best movie i've ever seen

[teteds06]

OMG!!! this was the most amazing thing i've seen in a looonnggg time! *favorited* keep up the good work!!!

[miguelgunner]

Simply awesome, I´ll love the Phantom and Wicked forever!!. Amazing video montage!. Bravissima!! ;-D

[littleana35]

ooooh wow good!

[MusicalTheatreIsLife]

loved it that was brilliant!!it was very well done!!and i always loved Erik and Christine together!!

[elbishaskim]

wonderful! great!

[JediPirateWitch]

I liked it. The clips matched the music really well. Brillantly done.

[GlindyUpland]

Escuse me for asking, but who is Erik? (I'm new to Phantom) :P

[Lemmerman]

Erik is the Phantom's real name. It's only ever used in the book, as far as I know.

[GlindyUpland]

Oh! Okay! There's a book? Well then I'll have to read it! (As soon as I'm done with Oliver Twist and Sweeney Todd. :P)

[Lemmerman]

Yep, the book was what the film and musical were based on. It was originally written in French, by Gaston Leroux, but the English version can be found in most libraries or good bookshops as far as I know.

I read it in a day, it was very, very good.

[GlindyUpland]

And it goes by the same name, right? The Phantom of the Opera?

[RadcliffeRox101]

oh i LOVED Oliver Twist and Sweeney Todd, both good books AND movies =D

[nightmarequeen70]

Best Broadway song ever with the best movie ever!So beautiful!!!^^

[performingmadness]

Very well done! I really liked this. As someone said earlier, the clips matched the song perfectly. Keep them coming :)

*nudge* you could do ''For Good'' ;)

[mariahsupial1627]

the clips u picked matched the song perfectly

i love wicked!

and POTO, of course :)

[casturtle]

Wow - this really works! I love it :)

[psychgeek101]

I SO LOVE THIS ONE!!! I never thought it could be. But it did and it is JUST SO PERFECT! Thank you!:)

[Celestialdome]

I love how it fits. Like for those few moments where you can tell that Christine almost forgets Roul exists and only wants to be with Eric and how Eric seems to know that he'll never truly have Christine.

[catholicteen]

I loved this! POTO & Wicked, possibly my two favorite musicals ever. Just perfect <3

[ZoeFlames]

Wow. Speechless.

[awesomeinuyashagirl]

This is a really good vid!

[12vampiregirl]

interesting

[SarahTheInvisible]

wow, uhm AMAZING!! perfect clips selection and placement

[XxSingYourHeartOutxX]

Awwh I love it! Great job! It's so cute :)

[SweetBlondeMare]

That is sooooo beautiful! Great job!

[awesomeinuyashagirl]

This is a really beautiful song! 8)

[RadcliffeRox101]

Wicked rox!

[Skiingirl100]

POTO is betta!

[RadcliffeRox101]

I LOVE THAT SONG

[shelbyseashore]

2 of My Fav Musicals Put Together !! Good Job !! xx

[SaraMUSt]

Excellent!!!

^_^

*props*

[sier96]

Absolutely GREAT!!I love the music and you have made one marvelous video. Good job, I´l be playing this over and over again. You rock!

[wickedchic15]

i can't think of anything that could have been better=D perfect placement of clips=P not to mention you've combined my personal FAVORITE shows on bway of all time=D

[fizorowits]

those are two COMPLETLY different shows

[RawEggsFromMars]

amazing thanks for bringing two of the best shows together

[lalalolaland]

Very passionate, I LOVE Wicked, and I'm seeing the Phantom of the Opera today!

[sarahisawesome96]

all i have to say is BRAVO BRAVO!awesome video. except the phantom without his mask is kinda CREEPY

[PiecesofEternity]

Holy hell! Awesome work!

[bmr9518]

holy shit this is amazing! phantom and wicked are my fav shows!

[sngr2012]

oh,my god, i love how you interpreted a song from Wicked into Phantom of the Opera. P.S. They are like my two fav. musicals ever! Saw wicked on Broadway, but only the Phantom movie...

[edscissor9211]

i luv this song...

great choice

[Vitamin2012]

Nice song choice. That is one of my favorite songs from the musical Wicked. The Phantom of the Opera is just a classic. Amazing video.

[kayti11]

amazing video, i hope you will make more in the future, i love phantom of opera and wicked and all musicals!!!

[mvmichelle]

Wow, I soooo love this video! This song, Wicked, Phantom of the Opera, and all the songs are amazing! Someday I hope I can perform these on Broadway :]

[123pieface123]

My two fave plays thanks

[CookieDough246]

Best Song Ever!! I love Idina and Norbert. And Phantom of the oprea is one of my favortie musicals. Gerald and Emmy are both great actors!!

[kayti11]

wowowowow

[Sonia98]

Nice vid!

Luv Gerald Butler & Emmy Rossum 4ever!

[chachachic14]

beautiful song. beautiful movie. This was a wonderful mix between these two musicals. Bravo

[TimKoopman10]

5/5

really cool

[snowstormroxs]

This combines my 2 fav musicals of all time!! And it was good!! YAY!! Thank you!!

[christineadorno]

i could so see erik singing this to Chrisitne like on the rooftop

(I stand for Idina Menzel cuz Its my Turn to be BRAVE!!!)

[TheChosenOne613]

My G-d, I NEED that CD!

[christineadorno]

my too i wanted to pre order it so bad so i could get the idina tote b ag but im broke!!

[TheChosenOne613]

Incredible! Wicked+Erik=Heaven! 1:59 was a masterpiece.

[Glindathegood01]

The Phantom makes me melt like butter. This video was great. Erik + As long as you're mine = hell yes.

[talis1234567]

holy mackerel, i haven't watched this in ages, and im still in love with it! SO GOOD.....

[Godsangel701]

just perfect

[tfdmgurl]

sweet!

[darkli6ht3r]

I love all yoru videos but this one is my favorite!

[lovelyphantomess]

LOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT!!!!!!!!!!

[yumichan89]

Although I'm not a huge fan of the movie anymore like I once was, I don't generally watch 2004 music videos. However, I thought this was very well made and, although you're probably not reading your comments, I'll just say I really like it. Very creative. =T

[shadicon91]

Ooooooh yes...I love this song!

[Phantomwife]

I love Phantom and I love Wicked! Thank you for making this video. I watched it before I even saw the play and it just made me want to watch it more. Now I love it!

[MCDRaddictedrose]

*melt* That is simply adorable. <3

[Christina1572]

omg... my two favorites ... that was lovely

[ElphabaDaae]

carolynroxsox , I would LOVE you if you'd make more! You know of Wicked/POTO!

[ilovesinging656]

love it!!!!my 2 favorite musicals put together

[ElphabamostWicked]

Ahhhh yay. My two favorite musicals..combined..WOOOOOOooo­...

[seraphim1983]

omg omg omg omg omg it's so awesome!

[dinchen1989]

Im searching for the lyrics of this song! If someone have these, please send it to me

( sorry for my bad english! )

[almightydaleksupreme]

Very slick and sooo right!

[DarthxErik]

wow i stopped liking wicked about a year ago but I still like this song because of this! :D great job

[beyondtheflowers2]

CAROLYN Loverlyful I made an R/C one that's on my other comp I will find it lol but yes you are amazingful

[sheryyl]

Nicely done!

[tebedard]

awsome my god two great musicals in one you are an amv genius!

[falloutgirl5011]

CUTEE!

[earthfaerie9283]

amazing! *huge applause comes from nowhere*

[AnnaAsakura24601]

O_O...WOW THATS REALLY GOOD!! *favs* ^^

[princesslikethra]

brava! i loved it! i love the song and the video you used. brava!

[X0SugargirlX0]

Brava! brava! bravissima! great job on the video!

[demonchild101]

i lik how it was put together

[JohnnysGirl01031992]

OMG! This is so frickin' awesome! Erik and Christine make the perfect couple. I don't really like Christine/Raoul ships 'cause Raoul is a pretty boy fop in my opinion. Anywho... great job and keep up the good work!

[MadyGirl1987]

Awesome! I love these musical crossovers!

[MegsOnTheTube]

Oh my god! Carolyn, you are my hero. I've been waiting for someone to do this for a long time.

[PhantomCake]

ooh i've gone all goospimply like a pimply goose!

[MusicManiac]

wow. i want to see wicked so bad! Butmy dad says it s exspensve :( . i am obsessed with this song now! lol

[abanana83]

me to i wanna see it so bad!!!!

[hersheykissesaeg]

wow! amazing job! you put together 2 of my three favorite musicals (rent being the other) i got chills. you picked the perfect clips for the perfect parts of the song, wow.

[HiddenBeauty]

Can you do some more POTO/Wicked MVs?

Please?

I liked this muchly.

[truekyoshi]

omg This is PERFECT and PURE GENIUS! *Sobs* Amazing!!!

You are my new best friend!

[DiCourtrio]

omg...awesome!  instant fav!

[DEFYiNGRAViTYx3]

the footage WAS perfect!

[AngelGhostchild]

Your awsome you pick songs from musicals that fit not a throw together songs and clips, perfectly ingeniously done.

AngelG

[erikiloveyou]

Finally! Someone who appreciated the genius of both these musicals!!

[xangexdexmusiquex]

OMG this was ADORABLE! I LOVED how you ended it!

Great job! and keep up the good work!

[SashaDaae]

Haha this rocks, the song is great POTO is great...E/C is great..LOL!

[seasonmyduck]

orgasmic! amazing work :)

[MusicalxAngelx3]

That song has always reminded me of Erik and Christine!! THANK YOU. That was awesome... I got chills!

[AngelxBehindxMyxMask]

I just saw wicked!!!! I love you!!!!!!!you cant even imagine

[skyblueangel6]

:D!!! Who knew that Wicked music fit POTO theme so well???

You did, you genius, carolynroxsox!!!!!

you do rock sox!!!

POTO rocks! and so does Wicked. but if I had to choose, it'd be Phantom as my favorite. awesome job, tho!!!

[LittleWanderingChild]

Wicked + Phantom = <3

You = Genius

Just....awesome.

[ravensboy]

Such a grand song and the footage from the film used was perfect for it. Bravo...

[broadwaybuff]

Whooo...Niiiice, man!

[demonchild101]

this is really nice, some of my 2fav musicles