that's definitely ryan adams lol, listen to THIS IS IT album, in particular 1974 and if you still can't hear it, you're what's called tone-deaf. and obviously thats noel.
@ihadurmum Massive fail... Ryan Adams wasn't born until 1974 so how did you work that one out? If you can't figure that out, you're what's called a retard.
Well, I don't think it's that bad, but what is pretty bad, is that he obviousley can't some of the lyrics. I think that's a little disrespectful to Noel, espescially since he's playing toghether with him live.
there was once i time when i know little of music and appreciated oasis but now ive got older and my music taste has expanded it is easy to say ryan adams is 100 time better, he can change his style from song to song. he can take an overplayed showtune like wonderwall and turn it in to a meaningful heartfelt song. ryan kicks oasis's ass any day of the week. and i''d rather go see him play at a dingey bar or coffee shop than see oasis at wembley or other arena's any day of the week!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This is Ryan and Noel singing at the Brixton Academy April 9 2002. Last song of the set. There's a video which shows both of them playing this, unfortunately it's incomplete. Ryan sings most of the lead vocals. Backing is Ryan's band at the time (Sweetheart Revolution)
This is clearly Ryan Adams, but it is definitely not Noel Gallagher. If you did some research you would find out that they have never played on the same song together!. And btw, Noel's voice is unique, yes, but that backing-vocalist sound nothing like him...
that's definitely ryan adams lol, listen to THIS IS IT album, in particular 1974 and if you still can't hear it, you're what's called tone-deaf. and obviously thats noel.
ihadurmum 2 months ago
@ihadurmum Massive fail... Ryan Adams wasn't born until 1974 so how did you work that one out? If you can't figure that out, you're what's called a retard.
Robbrad91 3 weeks ago
Had my doubts but thats defo Noel on backing vox.
Mubble 2 months ago
This is not either of them!!!!!!!! after 10 years of listening to them both......this is not them!!!
Becks4781 2 months ago
@Becks4781 It definitely IS Ryan Adams singing lead vocals.
kneeXkohl 1 week ago
that sounds like paul weller not noel i konw noels voice and the way he sings live and that aint him!!!!!!!
pmurf76 3 months ago
Arrest him for murdering this song!
ThatGuyDavidT 5 months ago
あんまし好きじゃないな。ライアン・アダムスっぽくない。
bigpan39 9 months ago
I'm have no doubt that it's Ryan and Noel, two of my favorites in music. But I still think this performance is just awful.
They should be embarrassed...
Ryan's vocals are flat left and right. He should stick to what he does best, alt. country.
Thomree 1 year ago
How can nobody hear that that's DEFINITELY RYAN ADAMS. Give Demolition or Rock N Roll a good listen kids.
jeffreyarbeau 1 year ago 2
anyone who thinks this isn't either of them is death, or just a complete fucking idiot!
Drix231 1 year ago
Comment removed
JeVeuxAlex 1 month ago
how can any1 say that isnt them lol.
mckyle9 1 year ago
that is ryan adams
bortjonesjr 1 year ago
highly doubt that it is either of them
Cloverlea 1 year ago
Ryan should stick to Wonderwall.
NathansWatchinYou 1 year ago
thats obviously not noel
Hwatson1990 1 year ago
this sucks
rockypc24 1 year ago
what's this from?
SeanSM92 1 year ago
This is not Noel only on the chorus...Ryan Adams is killing the rest of the song
kimallenbewick 1 year ago
That's Ryan
pattheguitar 1 year ago
sounds like weezer....
andy0mara 1 year ago
thats not noel
antz900 1 year ago
sounds like noel...not too bad
seifukusha 2 years ago
Noel does not appear on this version ;)
decrepit666 2 years ago
Well, I don't think it's that bad, but what is pretty bad, is that he obviousley can't some of the lyrics. I think that's a little disrespectful to Noel, espescially since he's playing toghether with him live.
kenny01985 2 years ago
sry ! this suck ! rosak kn lagi music ad la .
oasis live forever <3
95izreen 2 years ago
This is garbage, butchered this tune
Flashbax16 2 years ago
seriously? it doesn't sound like Noel/ Ryan ...
LesterTiD 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
LiveForever90 2 years ago
there was once i time when i know little of music and appreciated oasis but now ive got older and my music taste has expanded it is easy to say ryan adams is 100 time better, he can change his style from song to song. he can take an overplayed showtune like wonderwall and turn it in to a meaningful heartfelt song. ryan kicks oasis's ass any day of the week. and i''d rather go see him play at a dingey bar or coffee shop than see oasis at wembley or other arena's any day of the week!!!!!!!!!!!!!
libs93 2 years ago
reading the comments, i thought this would be awful...but its not to bad.....Ryan could have learnt the words thou :)
mancdave123 2 years ago 2
ryan adams is trying to make a country song out of a alt rock song
rockypc24 2 years ago
this is awful he cant even get the damn lyrics right
rockypc24 2 years ago 2
I know wtf lol.
Trikz1990 2 years ago 2
@rockypc24 i'd imagine he was so damn drunk that night it sounded great to him. this was during his binge balls to the wall days. so chill.
gayfarmerboy 1 year ago
@gayfarmerboy no this was in 2002 when he stoped
rockypc24 1 year ago
dirt
vanderfoxe 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
noel gallagher is nowhere near ryan adams in that song,
Agustinaa92 2 years ago
why does ryan adams have to keep killing oasis songs
rockypc24 2 years ago
I was there, hows that? It was Noel.
benbentley 2 years ago
bless! DEFINITELY Noel - you can hear that it's him!!!!
littlestar3103 3 years ago
This is Ryan and Noel singing at the Brixton Academy April 9 2002. Last song of the set. There's a video which shows both of them playing this, unfortunately it's incomplete. Ryan sings most of the lead vocals. Backing is Ryan's band at the time (Sweetheart Revolution)
cornelissimon 3 years ago 8
Comment removed
cornelissimon 3 years ago
hard 2 believe but yes it is Noel + Ryan. Noel joined onstage at end of a show in London in 2002 to do just that song.
KakkoiiNY 3 years ago 3
It is Noel. This was recorded during a sound check at one of their gigs..
wynter66 3 years ago
This is clearly Ryan Adams, but it is definitely not Noel Gallagher. If you did some research you would find out that they have never played on the same song together!. And btw, Noel's voice is unique, yes, but that backing-vocalist sound nothing like him...
KMileSupernova 3 years ago
no doubt, is ryan adams, and noel gallagher on backing vocals.
Rashcroft 3 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
That isn't adams or gallagher on vocals, sounds like crap
mlb2014 3 years ago
haha no offense, but you dont know what your saying mate. easy to hear both voices in chorus of song.
raremusictv 3 years ago 2
@mlb2014
you're crazy
gayfarmerboy 1 year ago
@mlb2014 Yes it is Ryan and Noel. It's also a shitty soundboard recording.
buddybopper 1 year ago
its clearly ryan adams & noel gallagher... you cant mistake their vocals for anyone elses... and thats definitely noel on lead guitar
pjfmnet 3 years ago 5
agree
raremusictv 3 years ago
no way is that ryan adams, sounds fuk all like him
malonenufc 3 years ago
it is listen to him, listen to his heavier songs and youll hear it.
raremusictv 3 years ago
Noel Gallagher did not feature on this recording! He's just thanking Noel for writing the song, thats it....
KMileSupernova 3 years ago
Who is the guy doing backing vocals during the chorus then?
Chr0nict0wn 3 years ago
Probably Neil Casal ;)
KMileSupernova 3 years ago
good guitarist, went all the way from St. Louis to Detroit to see Ryan Adams and Oasis.
mlb2014 3 years ago
no its noel gallagher for sure! ! ! his voice is easy to hear, for its so unique.
raremusictv 3 years ago
i dont think so mate. noels voice is easy to hear in this.
raremusictv 3 years ago
shit makes my skin crawl. wonderful. they seem drunk. but still. great.
barbedheart 3 years ago
nice. thanks for the upload!
jesuslover037 3 years ago
Never new this existed, quality find and upload mate!!
Proper Rocking
statician1 3 years ago
Heavy Duty
Dorian8va 3 years ago
awesome!
sarajanedave 3 years ago 2