Going Going Gone

[fakeKilroy]

美しいとしかいいようがない

[fhthbvisjfhfjkf]

why my generation listen jb ?? and those disney channel "artists" why i didn't born before??

[42awww]

Seek and you shall find! I've never heard this!!!!! I am always amazed when I hear Dylan's demos with just guitar like he is in his basement, then I listen to them so much I start to like them better than recordings. Like "Idiot Wind" Of the 3 versions I know, they are all different songs, tho I LOVE the venom of the HARD RAIN version. Thanks for posting.

[LUCKas1212]

@42awww yea i never seem to be let down when searching Dylan songs , you should check out the demo of "mama you've been on my mind"...

[ohiodixiechick2]

DYLAN & HIS GUITAR......ALWAYS AMAZING & EITHER SWEET OR GUT WRENCHING! Such a beautiful haunting song. No one will ever deliver this song like it's masterful creator. He's definitely wearing his heart on his sleeve in "Going, Going, Gone." What a great line (Dylan always the visionary) ALL THAT'S GOLD ISN'T MEANNT TO SHINE! A life lesson in this amazing song!

[broomenpenny]

Beautiful.

[joanlagoy]

I love this version...its just so very beautiful...thank you Bob and also thanks for

posting...j. LaGoy

[No1TaffWill]

Ialways thought, "Planet Waves" was Dylans finest hour, Not an ounce of fat on it.

[ripthisjoint908]

@No1TaffWill i feel the same. brilliant record.

[Jolene1959]

...beautiful, brilliant, amazing, great...my english vocabulatory is not adequate to this I think...anyway, I am glad I discovered it...thank you for posting...

[DoG7510]

I won't repeat all the praise though I share it all.

The singing is so swell and serves the text so well.

But, there may be more to say about that "place

where the willow don't bend".

If "It's the top of the end"

then the times have changed.

As ohiodixiechick2 said Bob himself is surprised

to see hatching new gems all the time.

As if oblivion was no more an option for anyone.

[doretgar]

iiiiiiiitssss the top of the end!!!!

[JBinOtown]

This version is haunting. It's amazing how different he can make his own songs from the studio versions. I heard this unreleased version of "Idiot Wind" that was just

brilliant.

[BOBDYLAN0199]

Keep on keeping on Bob

[NevadaBoss]

we may never know from where he came

we may never know his real name

but we sure know the brilliance he has sent so

we say thanks Bob for 7 decades

so well spent

and birthday wishes we cast upon

our favorite man of song

before he's going, going

gone

Happy Birthday Zimmy.

[ohiodixiechick2]

Beautiful..............Dylan ..............Always on the edge of something brillant!

From what I have heard a lot of his best versions of songs have been left off albums. So glad these gems surface. Who knows what all is out there? Bob has said himself, He's not sure of what all is still out there & is surprised to hear some of the gems. Pray the surprises keep coming. As his material continues to surface the music makes him even a more significant LEGEND.

 HAPPY BIRTHDAY, Bob!

[rman761]

Robbie Robertson's lead guitar audio is turned down, Richard Manuel's piano is off completely and no drums by Levon Helm. A completely different take from the album version.

Great Song by Great Artist

Bob Dylan :)

[TerrySleeper]

A better vocal than the official "Planet Waves" release.

Thanks for uploading.

[macmaghnusa]

You can hear The Band in the background, everything's been 'turned off' except the vocal & Bob's geetar.

[krustyburger66]

@macmaghnusa Yeah, this is most certainly the album version with all the audio levels turned down except for Bob's vocals and guitar. It makes for an interesting listen.

[MrDylan73]

Bellissima

[MrDylan73]

Beautiful! Thank you!

[Isis7585]

1973 panet waves recording session'

[peerman2006]

So goog! Where is this from? Certainly mid to late 1970's.

[aztiff]

Wow, from where hails this gem??

[MasterOfKnowing]

I like this version more than the electric one :}

[Tifa113]

Beautiful

[shobdokolpodrum]

@Tifa113 : ) thanks to Bob Dylan