George Tiller, Scott Roeder: Trying to Justify Murder

[fasteddie847]

George Tiller was a scumbag piece of shit. I have no sympathy for him or his family. Tiller the Baby killer murdered over 50,000 innocent defenseless babies. Scott Roeder is a hero and should be awarded the medal of honor for removing such scum from our streets. Tiller is in hell and Roder is going to heaven. God Bless Scott Roeder!!!!!!!!!

[Ultimaton100]

@fasteddie847 Tiller never killed one baby. He just conducted abortions. He was the real hero for giving women a choice. It is him who is in heaven and Roeder is doomed to an eternity in Hell. God bless George Tiller.

[Shawnster65]

Tiller's death was an unjustified act of murder? Just asking here, but what do the same people who think this, think of the murder of Pro-LIFE activist Jim Pouillon in Owosso, Michigan, last year? I certainly hope that this act of Pro-CHOICE violence will be recognized as equally wrong, and not largely buried by the media to concentrate on a man who towed their moral-political-philosophical ideology.

Short version-2 wrong's don't make a right.

[dunnonuffink]

He deplores killing..."ESPECIALLY on a Sunday morning, for God's sake".

So...murder is a lesser crime on a weekday. Ugh!

[fastfiero3]

i agree with the extermination of the baby killer, im on roeders side!!!

[greg357159]

The killer of Tiller gets my thanks ! Kudos to Scott ! YEA !

[chadpopstar]

I would not call abortion "child murder" since a fetus is not a child. It's not born. It's not breathing. It hasn't taken a breath. A child is a child when he/she is born and breathing. I am pro-abortion / pro-choice, BUT I think condom use and the pill (birth control) are a much better option!

[sickofgod69]

Ummm... EPIC FAIL!!! There has been ongoing terror to doctors and nurses, pipe bombs and the like. It is only due to the low IQ and general incompetency of the religious fanatics that more people haven't been injured. FAIL Krestaln!!

[CatholicAmerican]

Is delivering a baby part way, punching a hole in his/her skull, and sucking out his/her brain a "service"?

It is a barbaric act against humanity. Tillers actions provoked the beastly actions of Roeder. If U.S. law was consistent with nature and reason then Tiller would be alive and safe in jail.

Scott Roeder's actions were unjust but very understandable. Abortion kills a unique member of the species homo sapients.

[CatholicAmerican]

"ongoing terror"

Well, acts of terror have police reports attached to them. Can you please list the acts of "ongoing terror" you are referring to. Did Al misspeak when he said that the last act of terror was committed in 1998? Reference minute 0:50

[sickofgod69]

1/22/2009 Matthew L. Derosia, 32, who was reported to have had a history of mental illness rammed a SUV into the front entrance of a Planned Parenthood clinic in St. Paul, Minnesota

12/ 6/2007Chad Altman and Sergio Baca were arrested for the arson of Dr. Curtis Boyd's clinic in Albuquerque. Altmans girlfriend had scheduled an appointment for an abortion at the clinic.

5/9/2007  An unidentified person deliberately set fire to a Planned Parenthood clinic in Virginia Beach, Virginia.

More?

[CatholicAmerican]

Yes, Please.

[sickofgod69]

December 12, 2005: Patricia Hughes and Jeremy Dunahoe threw a Molotov cocktail at a clinic in Shreveport, Louisiana. The device missed the building and no damage was caused. In August 2006, Hughes was sentenced to six years in prison, and Dunahoe to one year. Hughes claimed the bomb was a memorial lamp for an abortion she had had there.

[sickofgod69]

May 28, 2000: An arson at a clinic in Concord, New Hampshire on resulted in damage estimated at US$20,000. The case remains unsolved.

September 30, 2000: A Catholic priest drove his car into the Northern Illinois Health Clinic after learning that the FDA had approved the drug RU-486. He pulled out an ax before being shot at by a security guard.

[sickofgod69]

June 11, 2001: An unsolved bombing at a clinic in Tacoma, Washington destroyed a wall, resulting in US$6000 in damages.

July 4, 2005: A clinic Palm Beach, Florida was the target of an arson. The case remains open.

[sickofgod69]

Also, since you choose to hyphenate your citizenship, I must ask, catholic first or American first? This is a test!

[CatholicAmerican]

Proudly Catholic first but also proudly a United States Citizen.

[sickofgod69]

That makes me think we should immediately revoke the catholic's tax status. Since catholic is not just a cult, but in fact a nationality (Vatican City) that would make you, by your own words, bowing down to a potentate before your allegiance to your country. PATHETIC!!!

[CatholicAmerican]

My brother. This great melting pot was built by Catholics.

Thousands of names of cities are named after Catholic Saints. Catholics built the first schools and hospitals. The United states has visible signs of prosperity due to Catholic hard work. Tangible things that cut through your ridiculous atheistic mockery.

[CatholicAmerican]

It is "pathetic" that you have a very selective education of historical events. Catholics build institutes of higher education. God created this world and Catholics have been advancing science as a way of honoring God's command to subdue the earth.

[CatholicAmerican]

Did you know that the Catholic Church has built the largest number of hospitals in the United States? So while atheists ignorantly accuse Catholics of being "faith healers", the real hospital buildings that people are treated at are proof that Faith and Reason are not at war, but are 2 wings by which man soars to the heights of Truth.

[CatholicAmerican]

It is "pathetic" that your dysfunctional world view causes you to persecute the Church that has caused the greatest advancements that mankind has ever seen.

I think you're only "sickofgod" because you occupy your time living in a fantasy world of relativism and hate. You make up your own reality which distinctly departs from nature and reason.

[sickofgod69]

Pardon me, what church was it that denied that the sun was at the center of the solar system? How many years was Galileo Persona Non Gratia? Whose dysfunctional dogma leads to systematic sexual abuse of children? Whose PERVERTED DOGMA sentenced unbaptised babies to limbo? Do you realize how ignorant and vain you sound?

[CatholicAmerican]

Quit posturing.

The Heliocentric model was first posited by Fr. Nicholas Copernicus.

The Big Bang Theory was posited by Fr. George Lemaitre.

Your shallow comprehension of history is causing you to say very nasty things. Just accept the fact that atheism feeds on angry ignorant people.

[CatholicAmerican]

Do you pretend that Galileo didn't posit that the tides moving in and out was proof that the earth revolved around the sun?

Have you conveniently forgot that fact or have you just never read an historical account of the trial of Galileo?

[CatholicAmerican]

Do you know what the term "Dogma" means? You are not using it properly.

[sickofgod69]

To imagine your BLOOD CULT had anything to do with advancing the human condition is as reasoned as the concept that vicarious redemption is moral.

You feed on the downtrodden, like that sick woman Teresa of Calcutta, who had the nerve to proclaim that the greatest evil ever is contraception!!! HOW SICK!!!

[CatholicAmerican]

We need to minister to the downtrodden. That is a work of love. But are you trying to tell me that the University of Paris, Universitas Magistrorum et Scholarium, Abbey of St. Denis, University of Reims, Collège de Bons Enfants, University of Cologne, University of Vienna, Charles University in Prague, Notre Dame, University of Dallas, Boston College, Ave Maria University, Georgetown, Gonzaga University, Villanova and Fordham University aren't the works of a healthy noble people?

[sickofgod69]

4/25/2007 A package left at a women's health clinic in Austin, Texas contained an explosive device capable of inflicting serious injury or death. A bomb squad detonated the device after evacuating the building. Paul Ross Evans (who had a criminal record for armed robbery and theft) was found guilty of the crime.

[sickofgod69]

9/13/2006 David McMenemy of Rochester Hills, Michigan crashed his car into the Edgerton Women's Care Center in Davenport, Iowa. He then doused the lobby in gasoline and then started a fire. McMenemy committed these acts in the belief that the center was performing abortions, however Edgerton is not an abortion clinic.

[decimator333]

Murder is by definition unjust. The title should be 'Trying to justify killing'. The death of Tiller was just.

[Cockroach2008]

One thing I learned from the mob, if you want to hurt them, you don't go after them.

You go after their families! Then they get the message!

Kidnap & behead the children of Scott Roeder!

I hope Scott & his family are sleeping well at night.

His family is so exposed, vulnerable & make such easy targets! The work would be easy!

Think about it, Scott!

[RichyRich2k8]

I don't think that's a kind thing to do! I know what Scott did was deplorable, but killing his family Med-Evil style is not fair to Scott's family! Trust me, Scott has 25 years of chocolate dick to deal with. Just think about it.....................Once he is processed into the penitentiary................th­ere will be a long line of dicks waiting on him to lick. There will not be any lube for his tube..................just 25 years of anal thrashing.

[Cockroach2008]

I think it is the correct thing to do. No matter awaits Scott in prison, he can think about what he did to his family as well.

His children is where to start! Disembowel them, dismember them, then scatter their bodies so the wild animals can feed upon their carcasses. He can think about it for more than 25 years, for he may get out in 25 years, but the memory of his dead children will haunt him until the day he dies.

Besides, knits turn into lice! Slaughter Scott Roeder's children & family!

[Cockroach2008]

Scott should have thought about what he has done.

We know where his family lives, telephone number, what his wife & children look like, what their vehicles look like, where his children attend school, when they attend school, where they make their purchases, when & who reads their utility meters, their garbage collection dates & times and who their neighbors are.

He is not in any position to do anything about it.

Sleep tight Scott!

[dilemmix]

Christians who do crazy things always have an excuse- like they are nuts.

Thing is, everybody should be responsible for their own actions, nobody should be above the law.

So I agree, this nutty Christian should be safely locked away behind walls.

[dilemmix]

"especially on Sunday morning" Lol, should he have waited till Monday?

[KrestaInTheAfternoon]

If you are not familiar with the events, Tiller was murdered at church on a Sunday, the day of rest and worship. "On a Sunday" further highlights how these actions are antithetical to Christianity and the pro life movement.

Is a person who brings a football to a hockey game instead of a stick, ready to be the goalie?

Did you come here today to nit pick or did you have an argument of substance.

It is obvious that this murder shouldn't have happened on Monday or any day.

[KrestaInTheAfternoon]

"Pro life people deplore the killing of George Tiller"

Do you posit that pro life people applaud the killing of Tiller? Show us a pro life leader that has stated that.

It is clear by your "Lol" that you don't appreciate the fact that members of the pro life movement are concerned for the souls of people who commit abortion. George is dead and his death is tragic. The pro life movement works for conversion, not death. This isn't an "Lol" matter. Shame on you.

[KrestaInTheAfternoon]

Abortion is the extermination of a human being to achieve a goal that someone else thinks is suitable for the world.

Murdering an abortion doctor is the extermination of a human being to achieve a goal that someone else thinks is suitable for the world.

The actions of Scott Roeder were more in line with the pro abortion mentality; The culture of death which views humanity as a commodity that can be executed according to the utilitarian will of another.