Added: 3 years ago
From: Nadeen5
Views: 319,412
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (260)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Julia complicated their lives. By falling in love with him. Lena doesn't know why. She has to try.

  • He loves Lena, he loves her not. Julia loves Lena, she loves Lena not. He loves Julia, he loves her not. Lena loves Julia, she loves Julia not.

    Lena loves Julia. Julia loves Lena.

  • I still like the Spasm cover better but this one is not too bad either.

  • the best song of tatu ever

  • I am not too fond of Lesbian couples... but This one is the most beautiful... and I see that they love eachother so much... thats true love... I respect these girls so much... so talented...

  • @DJFAXONATION They are not Real Lesbians it was made up to sell records and it worked =D

  • @iwih505 u gotta be kidding me

  • FRENCH PLEASE JE ME SENS SEULE ALLEZ LES FRANCAIS FAUT MONTRER QU'ON AIME TATU!

  • HAY

    

  • @3cheers4Ger they were never forced to do anything. if they wanted to find another producer or decide to do something else with their lives, they could have. they chose to stay with ivan and at the time they actualy likes

  • there pretty and good singers

  • THEYRE NOT LESBIANS, STOP! It was an act, they said themself. It doesnt mean they're bad, they're my fav band!

    Want proof? loook up "Livestream Lena Katina" and she admits it

    or "Interview with Yulia Volkova" she does aswell

  • @roemer024 It says so in Anatomy of t.A.T.u., too. :) They were forced to act like it for attention. :) I love them!

  • @3cheers4Ger

    yup, not denying lol, and i am obsessed with tatu <3

  • @3cheers4Ger

    It's all true, but the only thing that's got me puzzled is for why they kept making songs with the theme of them (not) being (like 'You and I', 'Friend or Foe', 'Loves me not', etc together after Shapolov. That doesn't really make sense to me..

    They are still one of my favorites bands though, and I love Lena's solo career. (Yulia's voice is unfortunately completely messed up because of the excessive smoking :-( )

  • @li1986 I freakin LOVE You and I. Anyway, I know what you're saying. I personally don't care what the songs are about, English or Russian. Hence one of the many reasons I will NEVER smoke. I'm allergic to it anyway.

  • now im so confused.. I DONT WHAT TO DO!!! i suppose ill favorite/like this song! :)

  • DAMN LESBIANS!

  • lol i only came on here to get the lyrics for the SPASM porngrind version

  • I complicated our lives

    By falling in love with him

    I complicated our lives

    Now I'm losing my only friend

    I don't know why, I had to try......!

  • fisrt time i have heard such a cool voice like this ohh great :D

  • her voice relly really great

  • they are so so sweet couple...why they are not together any more

  • @GalleryOfSuiside666 They disbanded cuz they had creative differences. Now they've gone solo after releasing their last album Waste Management Remixes. It was released in March of 2011. The album is out of copies, so now it's only online. It's on iTunes, disc 1 and disc 2. I'm gonna download it!

  • He loves me, he loves me not

    She loves me, she loves me not

    He loves me, he loves me not

    She loves me

  • oh shit it is very cooooooooool

  • @96VoRteX they are not lesbians, they said it in an interview recently, they just make us think it for fun.

  • @JrdMercier not for fun its just marketing

  • T.A.T.U is lesbian..? it doesnt matter who care... i love their voice

  • @JiyeonPark1995 im not complaining either way ;D

  • I find it hilarious that people think I dislike their music just because they are pretend-lesbians. Stop assuming things

  • Yulia is bi, but they arent lesbians.

    But I think that doesnt matter, they are great even if they arent really lesbians.

    (Sorry for this bad english, I am from germany ;))

  • @Wellensittichfreund Germany's cool. :) I'm American and I don't know German and I've never been out of the US, but I like the language. I would learn it but my school doesn't offer it. Do you like Tokio Hotel? They're from Germany. :)

  • I thought only one of them was a true lesbian while the other was only pretending... I couldve sworn it was in a interview they did.

  • the morons who disliked are homophobes ;3 who gives a shit if they're a lesbian couple? they're still an epic band! <3

  • @EmoNinjaGirl15 They aren't Lesbians though. One has had two children, with two different guys. They were precieved as lesbians because their manager thought that a lot of people would like the Lesbian schoolgirl image (I.E. Asian Otaku Boys.) Just saying.

  • @MultiAwkwardRabbits I looked it up recently, and they actually used to be lesbians but Yulia betrayed Lena for some guy named Parvis...look it up on google images, you see some pics with them..

  • @EmoNinjaGirl15 Yulia is bisexual and has been with one girl. Lena is straight. When the project t.A.T.u. started, and throughout the ten year span, they both had boyfriends. They both admitted to having feelings for each other (multiple times) - Lena mentioning that Yulia is the only girl she had ever felt anything for romantically. Although they had been talking about solo careers for years, the girls told interviewers at the You & I premier that they were officially going their seperate ways.

  • @ThunderCloudNine aww D:

  • @ThunderCloudNine Lena's Never Forget video made me cry the first time I saw it! ;_;

  • @EmoNinjaGirl15 The lesbian pics were for publicity and marketing. They've always said they love each other, but not in a lesbian way.

  • @MultiAwkwardRabbits Exactly. He made them act like it for attention. Did you see Anatomy of t.A.T.u.? I saw it with English subs, and it said how being in t.A.T.u. endangered Yulia's health, with her throat. That vocal cyst...Also, Ivan really messed the girls up mentally, and....so much drama. The documentary is amazing but so sad...

  • liek omg lezbians nooo!!1 lolno. it's not a bad thing to be lesbian. not a bad thing to be gay. not a bad thing to be straight.

  • @xDAWNiiE thats very true, there is nothing wrong with it at all, love is love no matter what

  • ok, i am never watching this again..

  • @Silverfan717 If you don't like t.A.T.u., then don't watch it!

  • @3cheers4Ger Hey, I specifically said I wouldn't watch it again! So leave me alone..

  • o_o no comment

  • wish they were together...

  • I love thise song for some resin it makes me wana cry

  • I FUCKING LOVE T.A.T.U <3 :'(

  • lesbians? xDDD its been said a million times that it was a part of their image!! like the girlpower of the spice girls!!

  • I love them but they lesbians :'(

  • @Dilaraunbay  they're not ;)

  • I love this song!!

    

  • I like them younger than older especially yulia her skin t's so yellow when she's older

  • I love them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • I love lesbians :P xD ...

  • Mee too

  • @96VoRteX why do u luv them so much?

  • Basically, the manager wanted more fame so made them fake lesbians, but then yulia got with a man in real life and there was a whole world speulation on everything and a lot of controversy. then yulias husband didnt want someone else that yulia loved in the picture, so made her forget bout T.A.T.U and then leaving lena

  • are they gay in real life?

  • this is my life!

  • 8 people aren't loved by him or her

  • @3cheers4Ger And the other four don't know what love is

  • @snowy98023 Exactly.

  • These girls are very Beautiful, I Love them! <3

  • @silenced587 They weren't. Their manager forced them to.

  • @silenced587 Who cares? Just listen to the damn music, their sexual orientation shouldn't be a factor in whether you like their music or not...

  • @silenced587 they pretended to be lesbians bcuz their manager or watever u call him told them to

  • @silenced587 Omfg, srsly? are you kidding me? you've never read anything about they?

  • @silenced587 actually, there former manager forced them to pretend that they're lesbians. plus, who cares? their music is good.

  • they kissed...........o.0 are they really lesbians?? they told me they were not lesbians but when i saw the kiss......... now in know the truth.

    And i still love theyre music ^^ go t.AT.u go!!

  • I'm fine with same-sex marriage......I just think that when it's guys marrying each other, it's nasty(straight guy here).

  • @Dirax115 what do you care lol gay marriage is as ok as lesbian =)

  • @Dirax115 So, like... you're ok with, as long as you don't have to watch it? I'm cool with that

  • @Dirax115 You are so bigotted..... if two chicks can make love to eachother then what's the hell wrong in ,if two guys make love to eachother...... gay sex is as humane as lesbian ...... men are no less than humans...... so better start accepting it...as gays are found everywhere and if it was wrong then it wouldn't be legal in the european countries and most of the asian countries.........

  • @gorsiification Well, put it this way, I'm fine with it. I just do not want to watch the marriage, making love, etc. Most straight guys do not want to see gay guys doin anything special. I am one of those people who do not want to see that. On the other hand, most straight guys think lesbian action is hot, and again, I'm one of those guys.

  • @Dirax115 And that's exactly why all you guys are fucked up. It's okay to watch girl on girl action according to all straight guys. That's just sooo hot according to them. But guy on guy is nasty to these bigoted men. They are partial towards lesbian love but get so terrified of male gay love. That's pathetic and hypocritical... just bullshit.

  • @XAstoriaGreengrassX yeah i agree with you but did you know that (in the workplace especially) more gay women get criticised and bullied then gay men, so more acceptance there. also gay men get preference over gay women in most ways of life and these men need to see that not all gay women are sexy feminine beings and that not all gay men want to sleep with them. their not that desirable.

  • @XAstoriaGreengrassX THANK YOU, that's one argument I have a lot with many of my guy friends, I personally don't see the difference between any couple same sexed or other wise, none of it is gross, love is very beautiful, no matter gender. Hypocrites rack my damn nerves

  • j'adorrr grav !! mé sa fait long temp qelle son disparue

  • I looove this song!!! And I love tatu!!!they're too adorable -3

  • seriously people, it's just so annoying that everyone's keep asking about their sexuality! there are 18 (or sth) pages of comments to this video and there are about 5 comments that actually say something about the song or the video.

    It doesn't matter, does it?

    (+ If you REALLY wanted to know about their sexual orientation, you could just google it or something instead of spamming yt full.)

  • @BlackPsychoPrincess Yeah.. and that's the 6. comment about their sexuality.. Wanna start with a feedback therefor? :P

  • Check Spasm Cover its awesome

  • This song is awesome point blank.

  • Whta´s the name of this song in russian? If there is a russianversion of this :)

  • The guy at 0:07 has a boner.

  • Nice lesbians!:)

    lol

  • the spasm cover is better.

  • the choir is the headbang part \m/

  • i likeeeeee

  • i love this song! being mix up in a situation like this sucks. i love her but she also loves him and this mix up she complicated her life in seeing me and lying about it and now its all complicated and it hurts bc i cant stand her being with him, but i was in a relationship as well and i complicated my relationship of 3yrs with a girl see im lez and she well ? but 2 yrs later i fell in love with her but she is so lost in whom she loves him or me & IT HURTS

  • Comment removed

  • are these girls like...uh...lesbo?

  • @EthDioRenDaySta No. Their manager made them out to be liesbians. They're not. They just sing for them to show everyone else that lesbians are as free as anyone else. The kissing on stage/in vids is for show.

  • them kissing on stage.. thats called fan service -.- the German band Cinema Bizarre does that as well, doesnt mean they are gay/lesbian

  • Spasm covered this song lmao

  • .

    "She loves me, She loves me not

    Loves me not..."♫❤

  • They aren't lez or bi they're just best friends me and my Bff aren't lez and we kiss it's not gross or anything so shut up

  • They are so beutyfall <'33

  • One of my favorite songs

    From t.A.T.u. I also love:

    -Running Blind

    -Sacrifice

    -Snegopady

    -Ja soschla s uma

    It´s my favorite band :)

    AND STOP WRITING, THAT THERE ARE BI

    THATS JUST FOR THE PUBLIC

    I HATE THAT WHEN SOMEONE WRITES SHIT WHEN HE DONT KNOW ALL THE DETAILS; SO PLEASE STOP

  • @ShwingDainDing Ur side hun :)

  • spasms cover of this is aweshum.

  • @Warrior300000

    Yeah indeed, Spasms' cover is way better, first time I actually hear the original song.

  • LOVE it no matter wat gay tr8 who cares DY HOT!! song is sick..mind ur buisness ppl..listen2 music

  • Bella.. (Y)

  • 1. THERE NOT GAY OR BI OR LEZ THERE ST8

    2. THAT ONE WHO HAS BLACK HAIR HAS A BABE AND SHE IS MARY TO A GUY

    3. THEY BUT MADE THEM THING THERE LUZ TO GET MORE FAM

  • ok for the people who dont like gays! if u dont like them ok watever but nobody needs to hear/read about wat u think it realy hurts ppl wen u talk shit about it ok so plzs keep the rude comments to urself plzz

  • TATU FOREVER WOOOOOOOOO!!!! :)

  • Incredible Song! =^u^=

  • this song is amazing!!!

  • They're married idiot.

  • either way, they have made a lot of money from it!!

  • me recuerda a tí esta canción. me encanta

  • Everyone has people in their lives that are gay, lesbian or trans gender or bisexual. They may not want to admit it, but I guarantee they know somebody. I consider myself a lesbian, but I'm a bisexual lesbian.

    I think people are born bisexual and the make subconscious choices based on the pressures of society. I have no question in my mind about being bisexual....

  • i love that song.

  • FYI they said publicly that they aren't actually lesbians its for the band but honestly they are awesome so y should u care.

  • Aw I love this song v_v :D <3 t.A.T.u !!

  • whoa, is the opening scene in Washington D.C.'s Warner's theater???

  • They R nae a band anymore

  • It's been said that their being lesbians was just publicity, and I think it's true. But whatever they are not, their songs might not be so great but some of them speak the truth about being gay, lez or bi and how you feel that kind of love. And they helped me through sometimes.

  • this is a good song

  • Song in the top extravaganza

    Dedicate

    Nora

  • they didnt start out bi or gay they started out straight and became more bi as they went on..... and idc what people say about them not being gay and having bf's and husbands i think that at the end of the day when i comes down to it they would turn to each other instead of anyone else.

  • yeah, i don't know why people are downthumbing this because its kinda true

    just watch the t.A.T.u.:Paving Road to Fame, video it explains that they don't love eachother like before, and that their love was in fact real, opposing from livewithsin's comment and also that Lena wasn't used to the same-sex love before, while with Yulia, it wasn't the first time, for she had a past grilfriend, Anya ^^ there you go guys!

  • ty man, i mean they loved each other to death before and they still do now its just that there not a couple anymore like before

  • @XxChibiChiChixX u r right but who's bysexual and who's fully lez?

  • @XxChibiChiChixX Confused, theyv never been lesbiens, always been straight, they made all that stuff up lol

  • no, they're not

  • @HomoCallidus -They are bother bisexual

  • oops i meant to say both lol

  • @HomoCallidus - also they broke up a while ago...

  • you think that you've just said something new for me? lol

  • what, the band? no theyre releasing a new album

  • i mean sexually...

  • it was an act

  • Rlly I couldn't tell?

    I think it's cute between both of them ^.^

  • i loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee tau sooooooooooo muuuchhhhh 3 band favorite

  • tatu<333

  • are they in love?

  • Yes they are =)

  • If they werent,this song proves that they are now.....:)

  • Great vid, could have used more of "All About Us" as "he loves me" could relate to Yulia's boyfriend, or "30 minutes" as in that video Lena cheats with a guy.

    Just my personal preference :)

  • Aw! Maybe u can ask ur hairdresser which style would suit you? Everyone is different :3

  • amo a t.A.T.u

    ellas son las mEjOrEs

    de todo el planeta

    su musica es lo MAXIMO

  • digan lo que digan, para mi son las mejores amigas del mundo y a los demás que.

    ellas son cool, friends.

  • bisexuality doesnt matter the song matters

  • yes its one of mmy favourite songs^^

  • i think that the one with the curly brown hair looks like Darlene from Roseanne. also, I FREAKING LOVE THESE GUYS!!!!!!!!!!!

  • they are bisexual they clearly stated that in a interview, they go both ways just like me! :)

  • they are bi as they stated on before and if you watch all about us you can tell there message so stop saying they are completely lez.

  • SEXUALITY doesnt matter they are ppl it shouldnt matter if they are lesbians or not and so what if they are??? love is love ppl come on grow up its 2009 stop foucsin on gay and focus onurselfs

  • You can relax.. they're not lesbians and they made that pretty clear several years ago.

    It was just an image they portrayed for publicity reasons. It worked and fair play to them for cashing in on it.

  • theyre not lesbians ... it was all a publicity stunt

  • @spikeconfused17 it's 2010 but you're right ;)

  • @MiSsBeAuTiFuL333 You just said it was 2010 to a comment that was posted a year ago...therefore it was 2009 then, Lol.

    but yeah, agreed.

  • @theguywithastick yeah i know :)

  • @spikeconfused17

    "love" as you know it is basically our procreation instinct, that's why homosexuality is unnatural, since to people of the same gender cannot procreate.

    Who the fuck cares though, people should live how they want *thumbs up your comment*

  • @spikeconfused17 I totally agree.My motto:you can be that way.Just don`t force me into it.

  • @spikeconfused17 Well said. I hate it when people treat homosexuals badly. They were born that way; it's not their choice.

  • @kanekoaikawa Plus, it's not like it's a bad thing.....