范曉萱~證據

[jewelran]

MAVIS的版本让人心碎

[huip68]

喜欢绮贞的烟火^_^ 喜欢扬乃文的证据；）

[haleyyew]

范曉萱 the only lady who looks good with all kinds of hair, especially blonde

[lytlife66]

OMG...Impressive...



[wtfgogogo]

你媽的，還不夠嗎?

[wengyenyen]

@wtfgogogo hahahahaa...笑死我，因为你，我post了！哈哈！­

[YAN1234565]

超正..超喜歡這個版本

[fiona104]

楊乃文唱的 如歌詞裡"用最溫柔的復仇" 比較內斂堅定, 范曉萱的唱法還帶有哽咽 心痛的脆弱..... 青菜蘿蔔各有所好, 個人偏好楊乃文版本.

[albus851125]

不欣賞林暐哲把歌詞改成這麼奇怪

[yuchingliao]

好聽我喜歡

[wilnet666mario]

我雙魚 為什麼天蠍要恨我....

明明雙魚和天蠍是很配的呀..

可惜一旦鐵了心...雙魚比誰都要絕情

[AmazingLizzie]

我覺得楊乃文也許是比較會唱歌的。可是讓我一直重複播放的卻是范­曉萱的版本聽到都哭了。



[jamesch777]

很想聽聽范曉萱的聲音唱「煙火」版本的感覺，搞不好還蠻適合的。­不過以范曉萱本人的個性應該是比較喜歡「證據」的歌詞 XD

[gunsncold]

我是天蠍男耶~~曉萱這個妝很有女人味~~>3<~~ 不知道這個妝在別的女生身上會怎樣......-.-?? 不過曉萱真的好特別~~

[jkmanboy]

「我要 『 飛 走 』 ~~~」

[jkmanboy]

一點點沙啞的聲音~真棒。很有感覺~

[wkchan27]

離開你，是對你還是對自己的報復?

[sherrychica]

楊乃文的版本也很好聽, 但我更喜歡這個版本. 楊乃文唱起來像比較像天蠍女, 范曉萱的演唱就很有雙魚女的感覺, 和歌詞很搭

[xxxdawson]

@yikuan 恩感覺你蠻有淺力當評審的 不過你是哪位^^?

[eddiey4k]

@yikuan I was there in the concert on that night. You are right that she did not sing very well. But it was partly because she got sick just before the concert.

[pyipyifish]

@yikuan 事實上我很喜歡楊乃文！但我認為范曉萱這唱法很棒！很有感情，如­果要把楊乃文版本廳二十次，那他也不用唱呀！我們直接聽楊乃文的­就好啦^^

個人淺見^^

[TAIPEI0325]

范曉萱！聲音真的是一種魔力。吸引人一直聽下去。

[tearingchloe]

prefer楊乃文版本 一聽就痛入骨的.....

[filawyer]

我個人覺得，楊乃文唱得是最好的。

[cmv039]

煙火..



[justiceclapton]

I love this.

[a71595939]

原唱是杨乃文..作曲是陳綺貞...詞是林暐哲

[0404x]

好爱听

[kevinyam1993]

范曉萱 的這個版本真係很好聽。

[syf19840803]

哈哈~~~我剛剛把音樂放著~~

就去看別的網頁了~~

范曉萱唱到0:53的時候我突然嚇一跳~~

他怎麼罵髒話了~~

哈哈哈耍笨了~~

[KIERANGUITARMAN]

好好聽~好有特色的風格

[keigoxoxo]

真係好好聽，唱得很有感情，百聽不厭

[nixie313]

I love this Concert!! And this song is the BEST!!!!!!!!!!!

[moomiu]

做过的梦是一场旋涡，没了你，才有出口

[bigtong]

真係好鐘意依首歌

[stacy0428]

今天才知道這首歌~ 真的好好聽ㄛ~ 陳綺貞的曲 + 林暐哲的詞 +范曉萱的演唱~~根本就是絕配~!!!! 我個人認為比陳綺貞唱地下道(煙火)跟楊乃文唱證據的版本還要好­聽~!!!

[nihonjinjyanai]

原版不是杨乃文的吗？好多年前已听过这首歌了。

[airmanchan]

我 天蝎

[LiYisha]

喜欢陈绮贞，喜欢这样的范晓萱...

[77446633]

告訴我誰是寫歌ㄉ人?!

[ink65536]

是陳綺貞

原版叫做煙火

收錄在綺貞最新專輯太陽裡

我比較喜歡綺貞唱的原版

[pinkgirl1002007]

what a beautiful song sang by a very talented singer. It has touched my heart in every way. I have been hurt and cheated. I really want to learn from the song to give the guy the slient treatment, to be nice and gentel to them................So, i won't be dispensable when they want to dump me.......... they would feel pain as well.

[pureecstasy]

she looks like Xiao S!

but i think shes prettier:)

[fankyw]

喜欢她还有陈绮贞版！ 这歌声音很美,可她感情路有过多的悲伤...支持范曉萱

[zhongzheng]

她很美麗.

但我總搞不清楚她的憂鬱

但同時 我絕對承認憂鬱症存在

[deenjor]

can any1 upload more songs of dis concert??? juz 2 songs of dis concert at youtube ne... i want songs like u dun trust me at all........ yes! thx u....... :)

[cynicgloomy]

每次听这首歌都会心痛，萱承受了很多的痛，她讲自己的情感都融入­这首歌中，最后的那句更是将痛传达得深远。。。。。。

[jeffdaniel86]

can somebody tell me where I can find the lyrics of this song in english ?

[saschalin]

在結尾范曉萱有點嗚咽的唱法

把這首歌呈現出一種小女人的感覺

我覺得這是很迷人的

[zynicholas]

各有各的特色！！~~

[saschalin]

我喜歡這個版本多過楊乃文的～

[EvenD]

I've always heard: "'你媽的'還不夠嗎？" Today I finally saw the correct lyrics...

[onlyily]

lol, ever since I read your comment, I always hear your version of it... it does sound like she is cursing, even though i know she's not.

Man, you are funny~

[strawbea]

luv it!!

lyrics match her, she's a Pisces =P

[roy7777]

Song is great, but not suitable for 范曉萱.

[wen00026]

有Feel

[sunnycoc]

mavis makes this song so beautiful!!

[sclwj]

love Fan Xiaoxuan in her own unique style

[tonykychow]

Best lyrics match with best voice by Mavis, Yeah!

[v2jk]

i love maVis*

[JayCRuby]

She is beautiful~ and love when she sing this song~

Thx for uploading~

[betty29]

i love this one! i think mavis sings it better than the original singer.

[divaexpatriate]

she has a really strong and beautiful voice.

[ocnj179]

Such a beautiful song.

[weng221]

i like it very much