there are 2 ways people look at this, i reckon about 95% of people see a drunken old bastard rambling senselessly into a microphone, whereas the rest of us see something beautiful and completely unsurpassed by any of the drivel that people call music nowadays. God Bless You Shane MacGowan.
@mdwo01 so true, the pogues started off with such potential, it seems like after 'rum sodomy and the lash' they never reached the heights they could have. so unfortunate but still god bless shane mcgowan, a poet
This song is deceptively difficult. Ronnie Drew changed the words as he sang it because he sang it just as it came and so fine and clear. Liam Clancy sings it perfect as perfect can be but aul shane has my heart...
This performance is one of the best I have ever seen of any song by anyone. Shane sings with his heart. Yes, it's sad that he is drunk all the time and can't remember some of the words but this about being sad and getting old and you can tell that he feels what he is singing. beautiful song.
Guessing you have to be from Ireland to appreciate this. Doesn't translate well in some other English speaking countries, I bet. Rather watch a wasted Russian.
@parade0000 always off his face when performing. period. don't get me wrong, though. i love his work. there is something about his messy demeanor that utterly enthralls me. he's clearly not ALL there, but he's still an inherently quick-witted fellow. you need only look at his recovery @2:40 . admittedly not the smoothest, but nonetheless reasonably quick. even when he is off his face, still a class A entertainer
Yeah I seen him last year perform and he was sober and singing like a bird, he has a recored verison of this song aswell and hes drunk on that too lol
He's magic. The one and only, we will never see the likes of him again.
RIProrygallagher 1 week ago
Good Man, Shane, Good Man!
BernieMAC141 2 weeks ago
From The Netherlands.I Love Shane.
Thank You.
TheMyrjan 2 months ago
Yes,he is a rare human,more human than most,god blees you shane!
westone4u 2 months ago
a bad shane has more sole than any shite that you will see in this day and age.
xxdanny 2 months ago
What a cunt
funkypotamus 2 months ago
Poet
jm72th 2 months ago
no matter how old and worn down shane gets hes always legend
26pinkmist 3 months ago
The state of that lad!
funkypotamus 4 months ago
Utterly ramshackle, but there is a beauty,poignancy and truth in his voice that only the greatest singers and artists possess.
Fucking beautiful.
hautelick 4 months ago
Comment removed
PeterReidy7 5 months ago
Shane's a genius!
novascot60 5 months ago
take shane for who he is a grate man . a singer ,actor, friend and hold him up for all . time is short . miss ya liam !
MyUlster 6 months ago
@MyUlster he's a "grate" man? So he likes grates? what kind of grates? wrought iron? steel?
jros83 3 months ago
pathetic - sorry -
blumenthol 6 months ago in playlist IRISH
This has been flagged as spam show
Live as you choose.
gwcstudio 7 months ago
there are 2 ways people look at this, i reckon about 95% of people see a drunken old bastard rambling senselessly into a microphone, whereas the rest of us see something beautiful and completely unsurpassed by any of the drivel that people call music nowadays. God Bless You Shane MacGowan.
GoingToPasalacqua12 7 months ago 27
@GoingToPasalacqua12 Spot on. Saol fada Seán Mac Gabhann!
FrancisMacShane 6 months ago 3
Comment removed
jros83 3 months ago
@GoingToPasalacqua12 thank you.
DesertCFMike 3 months ago
@GoingToPasalacqua12 Absolutely no doubt Shane is a musical genius.
ScottInVa1760 4 weeks ago
@GoingToPasalacqua12 I'm not going to lie. This is one of the greatest YouTube comments ever...
Mozzer232 3 weeks ago
truly a pleasure to listen to
GoingToPasalacqua12 8 months ago 2
from now on.. this song shall be sung like this! captured the spirit exactly. long live Shane.
onaughto 8 months ago
Sad to see such a great talent brought low
But Shane is Shane Still Brilliant but again Sad
mdwo01 8 months ago
@mdwo01 so true, the pogues started off with such potential, it seems like after 'rum sodomy and the lash' they never reached the heights they could have. so unfortunate but still god bless shane mcgowan, a poet
tedtedted87 8 months ago
Shane looks totally dissipated, and doesn't sound so great, either. What a shame, Shane.
stflaw 10 months ago
4 people have psychological problems
wildrolf 10 months ago
haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa !
in Flemisch ... ZALIG !!!!
Happy St. Patrick's day !!!
Bekkerken 10 months ago
haaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa !
in Flemisch ... ZALIG !!!!
Bekkerken 10 months ago
This song is deceptively difficult. Ronnie Drew changed the words as he sang it because he sang it just as it came and so fine and clear. Liam Clancy sings it perfect as perfect can be but aul shane has my heart...
couthyband 11 months ago
Oh come on, get real. This stinks
bdfeil 1 year ago
He's drunk like hell, but still gives an outstandig performance!
aaaaaarghh 1 year ago 4
how drunk is him? LOL
ebolucion 1 year ago
"Shane MacGowan cannot die because he is in fact the Angel of Death"
ryanhertz 1 year ago
The man can't walk or talk but still sings like a legend every time
13081742 1 year ago 3
shane is the best...
lexicondevilfilms 1 year ago 3
fuck i love him hahaha
DanijelVikernesCado 1 year ago
This performance is one of the best I have ever seen of any song by anyone. Shane sings with his heart. Yes, it's sad that he is drunk all the time and can't remember some of the words but this about being sad and getting old and you can tell that he feels what he is singing. beautiful song.
zombiewoofN 1 year ago 3
what a beautiful voice
nicx66 1 year ago 3
^jetzt fühl ich mich verstanden, danke Shane
reporunner 1 year ago
thats one of the clancey bros singing with shane if im not wrong
TheCaindingle 1 year ago
@TheCaindingle Yeah, that's the late, great Liam Clancy with Shane. It was actually Liam's concert. Shane was the guest artist.
rmm413c 11 months ago
Never mind all the people who left their homes and paid their money to see this song casually and selfishly fucked.
TheJimmyNewc 1 year ago
@TheJimmyNewc this man is a fekin legend
1811po 1 year ago
@1811po I know. Unfortunately for him his legendary status does not excuse him from performing like this.
TheJimmyNewc 1 year ago
Guessing you have to be from Ireland to appreciate this. Doesn't translate well in some other English speaking countries, I bet. Rather watch a wasted Russian.
brelfan 1 year ago
completely wasted, but everybody loves shane.
barakaldo55 2 years ago
Shane is a legend man what a talent.
stylinnprofylin 2 years ago 3
we heard it all before he will probaly outlive you!! Good bless you now fuck of to bed
SimonOHooligan 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The last stages of a dying alcoholic. Its a damn shame, I love his music and talent, but to watch that is a shame... that was awful.
darkklaxxon1 2 years ago
What a moment! All the heart and guts in world Shane - Take a bow, you deserve it.
snowpatroler99 2 years ago 3
Life is a waste of time,
Time is a waste of life,
Get wasted all the time,
And you'll have the time of your life!
Superb performance despite being a little 'sedated'
mikeyjud 2 years ago 2
drunk but a great performance, love it
albertcorn 2 years ago 2
Shane is a legend.. missed a few words in this but still a great performance......A writer of remarkable songs ...long live shane
gowayyadirt 2 years ago 12
Hes always off his face performing this song lol Nice upload.
parade0000 2 years ago 2
@parade0000 always off his face when performing. period. don't get me wrong, though. i love his work. there is something about his messy demeanor that utterly enthralls me. he's clearly not ALL there, but he's still an inherently quick-witted fellow. you need only look at his recovery @2:40 . admittedly not the smoothest, but nonetheless reasonably quick. even when he is off his face, still a class A entertainer
dhalloran88 2 years ago 2
Yeah I seen him last year perform and he was sober and singing like a bird, he has a recored verison of this song aswell and hes drunk on that too lol
parade0000 2 years ago