This is the only one of their songs that I enjoy. I really don't like the band because, whether purposefully or not, they employ such a simple harmonic language and add in electronic effects to extrapolate their musical ideas (instead of expanding the ideas using more complex harmony). This song has more interesting harmony than most of their others.
@Parvenu333 you are officially a musical idiot. they are a minimalist band. they blur the distinction between noise and music and that is truly unique... who fucking cares if the language is simple? it's powerful.
@Parvenu333 wow, i'm a musician and im glad im not like this guy. shut the fuck up theory lesson kid. not very punk of you. noone talks about music like that, only school band fags and espicially not xiu xiu. noone gives a shit about your opinions. yes it is simple pop melodies. its how its done not what is done. please shut the fuck up and listen to the music. if anyone ever talked about my music the way this guy does with harmonic timbre & shit id have to probly smash a tube amp over his head
i respect that you want to question and discuss, that's important. but you have to know there's more to music than this math. art is heart, needn't be 'smart'.
@FreeFiggyTree I've fully concluded that all xiu xiu fans are just completely dominated by emotion and have no insight whatsoever into what I'm talking about, so I'm not talking about it anymore...
By the way, analysis isn't math. Analysis is a way of understanding the world through experiences, just like words are a way of categorizing ideas. Your little catchphrase there is cute, but completely misinformed I have to say. Louie Armstrong didn't wake up one day with the blues...
ah, you're one of the ones who think that cos someone disagrees, the only possibility is that they don't understand. truth is, -you- don't understand. analyze your feelings. this music, simplistic though it certainly is, makes us feel great. probably -because- it's so simple.
You still haven't proven me wrong. Nobody I've seen on this board has been able to communicate with me on any level of theoretical terminology. You can tell me how the music makes you feel, and while I think it's great that you can connect with music, it's not at all what I'm talking about. I was trying to make a statement about the compositional qualities of the music, not whether I like or dislike it. You're listening, I'm listening and then analyzing; I have no interest in continuing this.
@Parvenu333 blah blah blah gtfo ...... if you wanna discuss music with "theoretical terminology" get the fuck off youtube. i don't even know what this is about but i'm sure glad you're fucking leaving.
fuck the what? i like what they're going for, but the last thing i need to hear is another overly angst ridden voice. it's annoying the way this guy sings.
I think The Cure's influence comes through a little stronger on this on than most Xiu Xiu songs. But that's not to say it's in any way an imitation-- something I couldn't say for a lot of other bands. Xiu Xiu fills a special and unique niche in modern music, and I hope it stays that way.
shall i remind you that zach pennington learned everything from jamie stewart? fuck, i hate parenthitical girls... it made xiu xiu remind me of them...thus forever ruining the idea of xiu xiu
Haha, you kind of have to wonder what the hell is going through Jamie's mind. He is either a misunderstood genius, or he is insane. I like to think the first one.
And what is with his new obsession with fruits and vegetables?
I don't understand that. It has meaning and is beautiful. To me an "anti-music video" would have nothing or they just wouldn't bother themselves to make one.
Assumed by you, perhaps. I'm pretty sure the actual definition of "anti-music video" was established in 1987 when "Bastards of Young" first aired on MTV.
Н.В. Гоголь "Записки ебанутого дизайнера" ... +;)))
poverhxxx 11 months ago
how about we just enjoy the music. shut up.
mychemicalwhatever 1 year ago 2
Should I wear my black xius or my red xius to their show tomorrow night?
adamgress 1 year ago
This is the only one of their songs that I enjoy. I really don't like the band because, whether purposefully or not, they employ such a simple harmonic language and add in electronic effects to extrapolate their musical ideas (instead of expanding the ideas using more complex harmony). This song has more interesting harmony than most of their others.
Parvenu333 1 year ago
@Parvenu333 you are officially a musical idiot. they are a minimalist band. they blur the distinction between noise and music and that is truly unique... who fucking cares if the language is simple? it's powerful.
pugfuglychris 1 year ago 3
Comment removed
Parvenu333 1 year ago
Comment removed
Parvenu333 1 year ago
Comment removed
Parvenu333 1 year ago
@Parvenu333 wow, i'm a musician and im glad im not like this guy. shut the fuck up theory lesson kid. not very punk of you. noone talks about music like that, only school band fags and espicially not xiu xiu. noone gives a shit about your opinions. yes it is simple pop melodies. its how its done not what is done. please shut the fuck up and listen to the music. if anyone ever talked about my music the way this guy does with harmonic timbre & shit id have to probly smash a tube amp over his head
blasphomy 1 year ago
@Parvenu333
i respect that you want to question and discuss, that's important. but you have to know there's more to music than this math. art is heart, needn't be 'smart'.
FreeFiggyTree 11 months ago
@FreeFiggyTree I've fully concluded that all xiu xiu fans are just completely dominated by emotion and have no insight whatsoever into what I'm talking about, so I'm not talking about it anymore...
By the way, analysis isn't math. Analysis is a way of understanding the world through experiences, just like words are a way of categorizing ideas. Your little catchphrase there is cute, but completely misinformed I have to say. Louie Armstrong didn't wake up one day with the blues...
Parvenu333 11 months ago
@Parvenu333
ah, you're one of the ones who think that cos someone disagrees, the only possibility is that they don't understand. truth is, -you- don't understand. analyze your feelings. this music, simplistic though it certainly is, makes us feel great. probably -because- it's so simple.
FreeFiggyTree 11 months ago
You still haven't proven me wrong. Nobody I've seen on this board has been able to communicate with me on any level of theoretical terminology. You can tell me how the music makes you feel, and while I think it's great that you can connect with music, it's not at all what I'm talking about. I was trying to make a statement about the compositional qualities of the music, not whether I like or dislike it. You're listening, I'm listening and then analyzing; I have no interest in continuing this.
Parvenu333 11 months ago
@Parvenu333 blah blah blah gtfo ...... if you wanna discuss music with "theoretical terminology" get the fuck off youtube. i don't even know what this is about but i'm sure glad you're fucking leaving.
alekastar 10 months ago 2
@Parvenu333 shut the fuck up
jeridadams 1 year ago 2
FTW in most internet contexts stands for "For The Win," although obviously in this case it probably stands for something else. Bugger knows what.
Great band.
kbillysupersounds 1 year ago
fuck the what? i like what they're going for, but the last thing i need to hear is another overly angst ridden voice. it's annoying the way this guy sings.
indosaur 1 year ago
@indosaur you're an idiot. why even watch the video if you're just going to talk shit? jamie stewart has a beautifully emotive voice.
pugfuglychris 1 year ago
vomitshovel is such a Shwee face! <3 that!
Litjunky 1 year ago
a go board pops up!
NEDM1991 1 year ago
I believe it is Fuck The World ... but for some reason I prefer thinking it's Fuck The What ... What the Fuck backwards.
BillClintonn 1 year ago
kinda reminds me of Arthur Lee strangely
5bonfire 2 years ago
I think The Cure's influence comes through a little stronger on this on than most Xiu Xiu songs. But that's not to say it's in any way an imitation-- something I couldn't say for a lot of other bands. Xiu Xiu fills a special and unique niche in modern music, and I hope it stays that way.
Ntron933 2 years ago 8
Too late, they're already recording their metal album.
bigman1225 2 years ago 2
@Ntron933 To bad it didn't stay that way..
ColtonDSemer 3 months ago
I wonder what are those " gay " subjected books have to do with this song
Jackitreborn 2 years ago 2
@Jackitreborn idiot
zpac064 1 year ago
FUCK YEAH!!! wow this is amazing XIU XIU FTW shwee shwee!!! i <3 u guys srsly
VomitShovel 2 years ago 10
ya xiu xiu. For The Win
happidae 2 years ago 2
fuck the world is my guess
stairjump 2 years ago 2
shall i remind you that zach pennington learned everything from jamie stewart? fuck, i hate parenthitical girls... it made xiu xiu remind me of them...thus forever ruining the idea of xiu xiu
DakotaSlim23 2 years ago
Fuck The World
KillMePussycat 3 years ago 3
What the fuck? This doesn't sound like Slipknot at all!
bigman1225 3 years ago 3
hahahahah
ourvinylcollection 2 years ago 2
Too bad you were the only one to figure out I was kidding.
bigman1225 2 years ago 2
Yeah sheesh... people are thumbs-down crazy around here.
ourvinylcollection 2 years ago 2
omg...
2:22
rhymeswithgabriel 3 years ago
2:22
rhymeswithgabriel 3 years ago
Does anybody the name of the book in the video (from 1:13 to 1:26)?
lokehans 3 years ago
no but i would like to know to because it looks very beautiful
cujoenyo 3 years ago
the book is called "old french fairy tales" by the comtesse de segur.
if you google it, you can find copies online (but nothing is better like the real thing especially the antique editions)
kerblam 2 years ago
@kerblam Thanks for the info man
lokehans 1 year ago
Haha, you kind of have to wonder what the hell is going through Jamie's mind. He is either a misunderstood genius, or he is insane. I like to think the first one.
And what is with his new obsession with fruits and vegetables?
AlexanderLlamahausen 3 years ago 4
i like to think the second
giygas 3 years ago
There's a fine line there. :3 I tend to think both can exist within one person in harmony.
Vynnie 3 years ago
i tend to think you're a noob
zeppelin3345 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No, no, just no.
No.
lumfun123 2 years ago
is that a book given to jamie by matilda from poland? i think it isssss.
passenger1987 3 years ago
ha, this is such an anti-music video...I really don't know what to say except.."Yup, Xiu Xiu's still whacked out as usual..."
detlenes 3 years ago
I don't understand that. It has meaning and is beautiful. To me an "anti-music video" would have nothing or they just wouldn't bother themselves to make one.
letonelive 3 years ago
I see what you mean, I was just referring to how Xiu Xiu's videoes are all...Unconventional. Assumed definition of anti-music video = unconventional.
detlenes 3 years ago
Assumed by you, perhaps. I'm pretty sure the actual definition of "anti-music video" was established in 1987 when "Bastards of Young" first aired on MTV.
lastclearchance 3 years ago
=/
-shrug-
w/e
detlenes 3 years ago
an anti music video doesn't have any sound
1elfdeck 3 years ago
FTW FTW
stephenlikesvideos 3 years ago 4
Jamie Stewart has an odd, but hypnotic voice
carinalillithkell 3 years ago
PANDAPPLE
satyrinae 3 years ago
I love his kitties.
jacwee 3 years ago
Love it, love it.
QueenJuliana 3 years ago
They seem to be into fruit lately.
good video.
kaltech19 3 years ago
Refreshing :]
andrewXransom 3 years ago
xiu xiu makes great videos
oldhacks 3 years ago