I really thought they covered this beautifully, but I hated their debut album. I guess I was expecting more of the same, but I'm not slamming anyone's taste if they do enjoy them. We're all different.
@gahooth think of it as paying dues. Respect. It's the Beatles man.. Its not about making it your own...
But on the flip i totally understand what your getting at...I supose in the end, it's just fun. and they've got all the time in the world to fuck with their own songs, so why fuck with something that's near perfect? its a fucking relief to just play something thats al layed out for you and sounds great. hence classical music.
@gabitangerine think it's hard to rerecord something in better quality years later and make it sound better? It's the same beat same composition same dynamic and same chord progression... only difference is that they didn't write it, and this version sucks.
@BukkakeNation It's not the same, there are clearly differences, I mean I can tell this song is not from 1966 if I hear it...when a song is really good it doesn't have to be very different from the original, plus this song was made for a soundtrack for I am Sam so they should be close to the beatles style.Anyway I think this version is better than the original.
Brilliant cover by a brilliant band! such a shame they are so underated...unfortunatly most people listen to a band only if that band is appreciated by media, critics, charts etc....such a shame we let those things to influence our minds, anyway, the good part is that such underated bands have only true fans, not bunch of wannabes who know one song and claim to be fans.
@RandomMan023 Haha.. you knockin' on commas man? Commas are cool bruh lol. Na I believe its just how I had visualized it in like my mind dude and also I was faded!!!! Really fuckin' faded. I have no clue how i was able to piece all of that shit out like that lol
Awesome but the Bass fills should have been revised. One of the better Beatles Cover I've heard through the years :) Beats that Jonas Brothers cover of Hello Goodbye xD
@weenerwallet It's a cover of the Beatles song "I'm Only Sleeping", and The Kinks are a bad version of The Beatles. And this is a bad cover. So there's your connection.
@pirategirl30985 Congratulations on making the stupidest YouTube comment I've read today. There isn't any point answering your claim that the Kinks were a bad version of the Beatles. It's like saying a roll of quarters is a bad imitation of snow falling from the sky---just an idiotic and wrong statement an intelligent person can't even begin to answer.
Whats with people wanting covers to be "exact"? If you want to hear the Beatles version of a song then put on a Beatles CD. Who wants a band who does songs exactly the same as other bands. I cant think of anything more boring.
@tjnuge - you are probably very right about that. A lot of people on here seem to think the cover was too "happy" but I thought it was just about right.
@beatlesrutles Agreed. I think it has a "new age" flavor while still keeping the song's structure in tact. I still listen to it now and again. A real good cover.
@CalumKenny You're right, but when it comes to songs such as this one which have distinct tones and sounds and whatnot, changing it too much would probably make it sound less than desirable.
@MegaMacTV A cover is not supossed to be a copy of a song, that is just too fucking bored, a cover is supossed to be a song in the style of the band that cover the song
@tzukishiro Not necessarily. Like I said to the fellow below, when it comes to the caliber of Beatles tunes, certain bands' styles and genres make the songs too different and not at all how they were meant to be. In short, most major mixes sound like utter trash, and that not being said just because I am a Beatlemaniac. Bands can cover them all they like, but when they, say, finger-paint on the Mona Lisa or any other timeless art, it ruins the song's feel and point.
@tzukishiro That is one possibility of covering a song and many people do it. Some do it good when they rearrange it, some make songs worse. Close covers which sound similar and tribute the song/band seem to do them more justice while at the same time adding the fresh and different sound of the band covering it. Take this song for example, it sounds close the original, but you can tell it's The Vines' putting their twist (pardon the pun) on it, lol. :P
I really thought they covered this beautifully, but I hated their debut album. I guess I was expecting more of the same, but I'm not slamming anyone's taste if they do enjoy them. We're all different.
JulesAndVincent54 2 weeks ago
@JulesAndVincent54 If you like this kind of stuff, I think you will like more their album Winning Days. The Vines are versatille .
gabitangerine 1 week ago
@gabitangerine Thanks my friend. I'll check that out.
JulesAndVincent54 1 week ago
this band is good... love this cover
intouchsuvas 3 weeks ago
Cool song
lovegarbage1 1 month ago
@gahooth think of it as paying dues. Respect. It's the Beatles man.. Its not about making it your own...
But on the flip i totally understand what your getting at...I supose in the end, it's just fun. and they've got all the time in the world to fuck with their own songs, so why fuck with something that's near perfect? its a fucking relief to just play something thats al layed out for you and sounds great. hence classical music.
lladanscott 2 months ago
Craig is the new John Lennon !!!
GrungeIsNotDead13 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@gabitangerine think it's hard to rerecord something in better quality years later and make it sound better? It's the same beat same composition same dynamic and same chord progression... only difference is that they didn't write it, and this version sucks.
BukkakeNation 3 months ago
Whats the point of covering if you do it the same
BukkakeNation 3 months ago
@BukkakeNation It's not the same, there are clearly differences, I mean I can tell this song is not from 1966 if I hear it...when a song is really good it doesn't have to be very different from the original, plus this song was made for a soundtrack for I am Sam so they should be close to the beatles style.Anyway I think this version is better than the original.
gabitangerine 3 months ago
Comment removed
BukkakeNation 3 months ago
john is not dead, just this sleeping
freemasones 3 months ago
Brilliant cover by a brilliant band! such a shame they are so underated...unfortunatly most people listen to a band only if that band is appreciated by media, critics, charts etc....such a shame we let those things to influence our minds, anyway, the good part is that such underated bands have only true fans, not bunch of wannabes who know one song and claim to be fans.
gabitangerine 4 months ago
loved this! i am sam soundtrack
Ezkillin29 4 months ago
this is a great cover!
i must say i just realized that ... ive never heard a beatles song done better than the beatles! Does anyone agree or have seen the opposite?
drasteek 5 months ago
best Beatles cover I ear
o0musiic0o 5 months ago
great cover!
the1020302000 5 months ago
good one :)
fujiwarataku 6 months ago
very good cover nothing beats the original though
CanKuman8 6 months ago 3
THE VINES (L)
16Niikki 6 months ago
Best Beatles cover EVER!!
lfcstevenlfc 6 months ago
Better than most covers
GrisGrisOnUrDoorStep 6 months ago
Music Mastery, John Lennon + Vines = Perfection
stevefromchicago 8 months ago
best beatles cover has to be Sublime doin Daytripper....imo
elhefe112875 8 months ago
Nice cover but the beatles is obviously the best Beatles4eva XD
zaroz01 9 months ago
Awesome cover!!!!! :D
xCheezyNoodlesx 9 months ago
beatles and you are good!
beatlessuper21 9 months ago
There are very rarely Beatles covers this good.
TheGhFan 9 months ago 17
that's a solid cover i have to say!
MRTAYLORWALL 10 months ago
Yeah, be productive for god sake. Do cocaine.
soitgoess5 10 months ago 2
This is my song!!!!!! definitely love it!!!1
Jenn131088 10 months ago
waitingforsleepingfeeling_____"
michhh183 11 months ago
When you're high this song has such a deeper meaning.
xThatOneNurdx 11 months ago
@xThatOneNurdx ... I suggest you stay high. That's an excellent condition for anyone unwilling to participate in life...LOL
TheSgt1035 11 months ago
@TheSgt1035 :) lol
xThatOneNurdx 11 months ago
did anyone else think the picture was moving?
Bassist3545 11 months ago
@Bassist3545 Holy shit, yeah me!
Daimyo20 10 months ago
(Y)
ivigonchy 11 months ago
the best cover of this song of the Beatles
steya8 11 months ago 2
Very good coover.
brazdamnit 1 year ago 2
¡Vayaa! JAjajaja está buenaaaa.
flyfuzz 1 year ago
i love this coverrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr :$
kin1600 1 year ago
Really love this cover
VicRattlehead79 1 year ago 3
definately a band, that can truly cover a great song, such as this....
CrayzMark 1 year ago
@CrayzMark Lol Whats, with the, commas? xD
RandomMan023 1 year ago
@RandomMan023 Haha.. you knockin' on commas man? Commas are cool bruh lol. Na I believe its just how I had visualized it in like my mind dude and also I was faded!!!! Really fuckin' faded. I have no clue how i was able to piece all of that shit out like that lol
CrayzMark 1 year ago
fucking awesome cover
iamthewalrus3012 1 year ago
THE VINES
ClubDominoEnglish 1 year ago
Ah 'I am Sam' is an amazing movie with great covers. ;D the movie made me cry though D:
naruthenarcicist 1 year ago
Awesome but the Bass fills should have been revised. One of the better Beatles Cover I've heard through the years :) Beats that Jonas Brothers cover of Hello Goodbye xD
YousefHaddad90 1 year ago
@YousefHaddad90 thats because the jonas brothers suck wang
32stevo 1 year ago
this has a bit of the kinks eihh??
weenerwallet 1 year ago
@weenerwallet It's a cover of the Beatles song "I'm Only Sleeping", and The Kinks are a bad version of The Beatles. And this is a bad cover. So there's your connection.
pirategirl30985 1 year ago
@pirategirl30985 lol I know its a beatles song, and yeah. it sounds like a kinks song
weenerwallet 1 year ago
@pirategirl30985 aah estas bien pirata tu !
como te atreves The kinks son igual de buenos que the Beatles r.r
y este cover rulea !!!
Blindfold64 1 year ago
@pirategirl30985 Congratulations on making the stupidest YouTube comment I've read today. There isn't any point answering your claim that the Kinks were a bad version of the Beatles. It's like saying a roll of quarters is a bad imitation of snow falling from the sky---just an idiotic and wrong statement an intelligent person can't even begin to answer.
SlappyFrankenstein 1 year ago
@pirategirl30985 Oh, and by the way, "I Love Lucy" isn't a movie. Oops.
SlappyFrankenstein 1 year ago
Z z Z z Z z Z z Z z Z z . .. . . . .
bahaysapureza 1 year ago 2
Whats with people wanting covers to be "exact"? If you want to hear the Beatles version of a song then put on a Beatles CD. Who wants a band who does songs exactly the same as other bands. I cant think of anything more boring.
Gahooth 1 year ago 13
I never heard a Beatles cover I really liked until this one.
beatlesrutles 1 year ago 5
@beatlesrutles it's because they didn't deviate from the original sound.
tjnuge 1 year ago
@tjnuge - you are probably very right about that. A lot of people on here seem to think the cover was too "happy" but I thought it was just about right.
beatlesrutles 1 year ago
@beatlesrutles Agreed. I think it has a "new age" flavor while still keeping the song's structure in tact. I still listen to it now and again. A real good cover.
MegaMacTV 1 year ago
bad, sounds almost cheerful. ruins the whole point of the song
niallo12 1 year ago
Classy.
Juleetron 1 year ago
Wow!! I'm an admin on a Beatles Parody page & I'm listening to covers from so many bands. The Vines are awesome!!
rockcandy15 1 year ago
Fuckin awesome tune!!! If anyone can cover The Beatles it's The Vines. (Yeah, yeah, and Oasis....)
chriskirby1985 1 year ago 2
@chriskirby1985 also elliott smith
rolisTV 1 year ago
@chriskirby1985 And Cocker.
LON009 1 year ago
good
Tommy17931 1 year ago
wow... great cover!!
i fucken love this song and well i wouldve been a little ticked if it was killed..
but i liked the cover! nice =]
tonyeschido07 1 year ago
i like the yawn
boonlid 1 year ago
Wow, most Beatles covers suck, but this one is really good.
badtown88 1 year ago 6
not as good as the beatles but still really good.
SlayerBlitz1337 1 year ago 5
the vines are massively influenced by the beatles so it's not surprising the similarity in sound.
just paying homage to their heroes.
ImpatientLime 2 years ago 4
this is a very good cover of a very good song....and who would want to rerecord the same song the same way? how retarded.
Trentstone121 2 years ago 4
not bad but gotta agree, beatles did it best. this one is more pop, but i like it! still beatles will never be overcomed =].
meANDmyRICE 2 years ago 4
awesome! nobody can do it like the beatles, however...wow! good job Vines!!
jegovernor 2 years ago 2
great cover
ADreamerDreams 2 years ago 59
This has been flagged as spam show
me encanta este tema es mejor q el orginal y eso q ue es uno de los mejores tema s de lennon
nicoconcordia2 2 years ago
bueno en verdad que es el mejor cover de the beatles que eh escuchado..
a the vines le queda perfecto.. no se, se que no se comparan con los beatles pero el sonido les asemeja un poco
steya8 2 years ago 2
this sounds exactly like.. the beatles. way to bring something new to the song
tunaleg 2 years ago
Not "exact", but at least they didn't mix it up too much. Very good recreation, I must admit.
MegaMacTV 2 years ago 37
@MegaMacTV Covers arent always supposed to be " exact "
CalumKenny 1 year ago
@CalumKenny You're right, but when it comes to songs such as this one which have distinct tones and sounds and whatnot, changing it too much would probably make it sound less than desirable.
MegaMacTV 1 year ago
@MegaMacTV A cover is not supossed to be a copy of a song, that is just too fucking bored, a cover is supossed to be a song in the style of the band that cover the song
tzukishiro 1 year ago
@tzukishiro Not necessarily. Like I said to the fellow below, when it comes to the caliber of Beatles tunes, certain bands' styles and genres make the songs too different and not at all how they were meant to be. In short, most major mixes sound like utter trash, and that not being said just because I am a Beatlemaniac. Bands can cover them all they like, but when they, say, finger-paint on the Mona Lisa or any other timeless art, it ruins the song's feel and point.
MegaMacTV 1 year ago
@MegaMacTV When you cover a song, you're making a new song, everything changes, obviously cuz then is your song
tzukishiro 1 year ago
@tzukishiro That is one possibility of covering a song and many people do it. Some do it good when they rearrange it, some make songs worse. Close covers which sound similar and tribute the song/band seem to do them more justice while at the same time adding the fresh and different sound of the band covering it. Take this song for example, it sounds close the original, but you can tell it's The Vines' putting their twist (pardon the pun) on it, lol. :P
MegaMacTV 1 year ago
@MegaMacTV It's best that it's not "exact", they did The Beatles some justice. I haven't found any other covers that I enjoy.
Jaguiar05 9 months ago
they really sound like the beatles jr. lol
madambuttahfly 2 years ago 6
yes it's right
you have the voice of tHe reason
steya8 2 years ago
yah. it's awesome. this is my favorite song from the vines. great cover. ^^
akopopoyme 2 years ago 3
muy bueno
snorlax95jfk 2 years ago 2
Sweet this is pretty darn good cover!! One of my fav Beatles songs too! Actually I loveeee the Anthology version much better lol.
0MountainGoat0 2 years ago
this is a really good cover
cousyrules 2 years ago 6
great song!!!
FooEgo13 2 years ago 6
flippin awesom
gooman989898 3 years ago 3