Nothing - from A Chorus Line

[OMScardinals]

I thought this was the real version of the song until u hit tht tried note and then i thought tht was a edited part so what i am trying to say is u can sing..... B U T try a little harder. Since youve had lessons i want you make another 1 with ur new voice!!!!!!!!!!!

[janiegirly07]

just for reference, this was over 4 years ago. I've changed.

[ducksongrules1234]

hey dont worry, this isn't half bad. Sure it is a little flat, but at least you CAN sing!!!

[alicebarton14]

I really don't understand why you're saying this sucks! I think it's great! You have a really good voice for musicals :) Keep it up!

[broadwaybaby1825]

hunny this is badddd. your flat alot. if i were you id get some voice lessons.

[janiegirly07]

@broadwaybaby1825 this was my first video on youtube, about three years ago. I've gotten lessons, and I realize that this is terrible.

trust me, I've improved lol

[janiegirly07]

I did this over two years ago, this was my first youtube video. I've improved.

[me254065]

you're under quite a few notes and you need to find the music to learn the exact rhythmic and pitch values. Do this and you'll do just fine.

[LastCallFirstShots]

Very pretty. You kinda remind me of Stephanie D'Abruzzo.

[janiegirly07]

Thank you :)

[pawpels]

really good except the weird flute thing.

[janiegirly07]

thanks and yeah, the instrumental was made by some random guy so it turned kind of weird.

[XxElmoGirlxX]

how did you download the instrumental?

[janiegirly07]

it exactly a year ago when I posted this...

[broadwaybaby4205]

You're really good :)

[Vivalajess101]

you are really good...but you sound a little shakey in some parts which really takes away from the rest of the song which is really good. you should consider voice lessons. they really help!

[janiegirly07]

well, I'm not just an alto. i can sing suprano songs too, I can only belt alto songs. wow, so many people commented on this... this is a really old recording, and my range is much wider now, so I'm better!

[therealyukino]

Wait, I just have two quick questions.

1. How is My New Philosophy an alto song? We ARE talking about the one from You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown, yeah?

2. You're supposed to suppress vibrato? This is the first I heard of any such thing. Vibrato is sought after in both musical theater and opera, so I don't get it :/

I'd love it if you could explain :)

[cookiesnmilksinger07]

Hi Janiegirly- back onto this name as the other one had technical difficulties.

[cookiesnmilksinger07]

thanks so much for the list of alto songs, I am an alto- mezzo soprano ( in head voice) supposedly and finding songs to sing are hard for me, you just made it easier. Please check out my uploads.

[janiegirly07]

thanks for the advice, I'll try to find more songs in my range, but it is hard to find good alto songs.  Thanks for watching though!

[Tentennekochan]

you were a little flat on some of it but otherwise it had a lot of good emotion! Nice Job!

[janiegirly07]

lol, um, its kinda complicated, but I say play around with your youtube account for a while, and that might change something, also just give it a little time. sometimes youtube has it off days. (p.s. more people see your vids when you make a video response to karaoke, if you use it of course)

[janiegirly07]

well, I don't know what you are using, but I'm using windows movie maker, and I create a title at the begginning, and then I make it thiry seconds long, and copy and paste it so it covers the video.

[janiegirly07]

its now on the left

[janiegirly07]

wow, i already responded to this... oh well here i go agian, the info to find the recording is now on the left, just click more. since it won't let me have links in comments. grr...

[songpidgeon]

Nice work here!! This is a fun song! Just a couple things... .43 was off key. 2.06 was maybe the mic u use making it funny. also it was a tad nasal. Other than that it was good.

I really liked the dialogue parts! good acting here.

kiss,

~*~Sarah~*~

p.s. - I think that i-tunes has a better version of this backing track for only 99 cents.... just a thought :-)

[pika50potter]

Cool!i like this song! And u have a neat channel! AAAAAAND your a good singer!=good vid!

[janiegirly07]

thank you, singing is my passion.

[pika50potter]

Hey thanx 4 the comments on my vid. You know, have you ever tried singing For Good from wicked. You'd be good.

[janiegirly07]

yes, in fact i'm going to be recording wicked sometime, i just have too much schoolwork going on to record at the mombent.

[pika50potter]

Get a CD or iTunes this time though. Don't do another MIDI. there recordings are pretty bad.

[SmileyFace4646]

who did this arrangement? it's kind of bad.

[janiegirly07]

Its a MIDI file, and not professionally done, so compared to the other MIDI songs I found, its pretty good.

[SmileyFace4646]

well I don't like it because it's way slower than the real song, it sounds better a half step up, and it's supposed to sound like a mid-70s broadway song and it sounds like a pop-disco song. trust me. i've heard this song ALOT.

[janiegirly07]

well, it was the best I could find at the moment, so if you found something better for me to use then I'd love to use it, but until that happy day that I get millions of free karaoke, this is the best I've got.

[SmileyFace4646]

well, I liked the way you said "Jesus Christ" it was funny. very dramatic.

[janiegirly07]

why thank you. dramatic is what I do.

[SmileyFace4646]

do you by any chance go to drama learning center? cuz I know someone who is named sarah, is about 14, knows this song, and is kind of funny and goes there.

[Francog23]

no offense, but when you ask for feedback, you are not always going to get compliments. not everyone will like your voice, so learn to take the negative feedback. but you are good, and have potential. be careful on your lower register thou.

[kiten2cat12345]

I've never heard this song before, but I like it! Great job!~Michelle

[janiegirly07]

thank you!