蔡幸娟：水上人

[1bigwater]

現在華語女歌手，能把此金曲在現場唱至如此境界，蔡幸娟真是了不­起，讚。

[capo0122]

最完美的「水上人」版本除了這個外，就祇有台灣望春風的了，

但那位演唱人也就是八、九年的娟姐啊！



[miaulian08]

好像蔡幸娟才能把這首歌詮釋的好

[huixionglee]

乜野級數？ 亂噏一通。

[smartmiffy]

好聽好聽真好聽~

聽了還有安定心情的作用耶~真棒！

[smartmiffy]

每首老歌被阿娟一唱就好好聽哦~我一直在按重覆~ ^^

[summichalle1]

i am her one of her fans in HK.

[hotnewppl]

@summichalle1 香港娟迷加油 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[lovelove88881]

從小聽到大 對阿娟的歌有著濃濃的感情

[poetjdragon]

Miss Delphine Tsai sings this song in a superior manner. In my opinion, Miss Teresa Teng and Miss Delphine Tsai are the best among all female singers. But for this song, Miss Tsai obviously sings better than Miss Teng.

[rae6423212]

陶醉在每一串如波浪般的轉音裡，似在湖面上輕輕的擺盪著，聆聽著­．神遊著．．．

讚＋＋＋

[hotnewppl]

阿娟唱這首歌的時候有幾歲了?

[goingyourway101]

I agreed, she is much better than Teresa Teng.

[makingto]

@goingyourway101  級數相差太大,沒有感情

[yuedu618]

跟邓丽君当然有差。。听起来没有那么流畅。。

但已经很不简单了。。。

[hakumshing2006]

@yuedu618 如由鄧麗君唱這個key, 可能頂唔順。

[poetjdragon]

Excellent interpretation! Beautiful girl with angel's invoice, so sweet and tender.

[cheungal88]

She is just beautiful and her voice is so sweet! Wish she has more of her own original songs - she is so talented and such a wonderful singer!

[chunchangtw]

好聽 但沒有鄧麗君圓潤 輕柔

[phobekireisan]

yes..she sung very good,,,, but i dont think she is better than Teresa..listen to her breath thoroughtly..Teresa didt sing like so.

[hakumshing2006]

@phobekireisan TT 每次呼吸換氣的時候都會有意識地把咪高峰稍稍移開.

[candyagogo]

Yes, she did a higher key than Teresa!

[ajoe999]

只有她能把鄧麗君的演唱的最好 其她翻唱者真的都不如蔡幸娟

鄧麗君的版本帶有空靈的感覺

她们兩聲音我都很喜歡

[mm3271]

甜美的聲音，甜美的蔡幸娟。

[charles12231]

優美的旋律, 動人的歌聲, 完美的演譯, 難得的作品, 賞心悅目, 無可比擬!

[ajoe999]

嗓音像蜂蜜一樣

[cinderella0208]

good voice!! excellent singing!!!

[cinderella0208]

good ,excellent!!!!

[cloud7592]

聽了以後，還是覺得鄧麗君的聲音真的是獨一無二，後無來者~~小­鄧不愧是國寶！

[badboyblue99]

Tsai Shin Juan is known in Taiwan as Little Teresa. She is just about the only person who can sing Teresa's songs and sound good. And shes famous in her own right too.

[hopps47]

You are right, Very similar style to Teresa Teng

[kimcholon]

Teresa Teng's voice sung through a different person.

[yadnussyl]

蔡幸娟比鄧麗君唱的key 高一點。

[candyagogo]

They sing in the same key!

[yadnussyl]

Yeah, I think you're right.

[tdt1000]

不愧是天籟

[0101therock]

天籟的歌聲

[atnb678]

she is my dream girl, reminding me the song oriantal girl in the year of 1887

[leymennl]

1887?or 1987?

[iconiaam]

I love her version too , she is good, really good

[teresafan]

very good!

[vnkegve]

so cute!

[88122920]

She is one of my favourite singers. I heard her song when she was a teenager, she was once nick-named as Chinese Doll.

[Qian0108]

请问您是从哪首歌开始喜欢蔡幸娟的？

[mation200]

邓丽君的名曲~~~~

[timizhuofan1]

Wow! I never knew she was that good... We have a few cassettes at home of her but they aren't that clear and not so good... Now that I hear her sing on YouTube, I love her voice!!!

[warriorclaude]

she's fantastic

[porkai]

if ask me die for her...i think i will.

[timizhuofan1]

WOW... LOL...

[may4818]

太好了

[may4818]

只有蔡幸娟才能把这首歌唱到这样好.

[chinesepower1]

Teresa's one was much better ps: its not a difficult song to perform

[ajoe999]

嗯真的 除原唱鄧麗君 好像蔡幸娟才能把這首歌詮釋的好

[namiejames]

like that's possible......

[Sigmadelta123]

Don't mean to be disrespectful to Teresa Teng, but she is much better than Teresa Teng.

[TraderJoe1]

haha, better have your ear check.

[TigerSauce]

Don't mean to disrepectful to 蔡幸娟, but Yuquan Chen's version is much better :)

[hakumshing2006]

陳玉泉比她好? 不可能吧。

[ckw66]

@hakumshing2006 剛聽過陳小姐的版本，我也放心了。你說得沒錯，完全不可能！

[yadnussyl]

I totally agree with you.

[hakumshing2006]

@Sigmadelta123  You are absolutely right !

[Echmax]

好听!

[Qian0108]

我是她的歌迷

[liaihua]

amazing...her voice is very good, just like Teresa Teng

[fkxt5726]

her voice is so good, no wonder she is called 'little teresa teng'