3:50 til the end, the singer just ruined everything he'd done to that point. He had been good up until then, what did his voice box blow out or something? Did the guitars around him blow out his ear drums and make him tone-deaf?
I don't know if I've ever heard such monotone, unpassionate singing in my life.
whats so wrong with criticism? we all know we wouldnt ever listen to this anyway. so why not talk shit? we dont have to do better to talk down upon people.
You know you're comment was written over a year ago but when I saw it something inside me died. You're breed of people is the kind that goes through the motions of society bitching about everything all the time instead of trying to contribute something.
Anyone who doesn't play an instrument or has never attempted to play this song has no right to put these guys down. I can play it well on guitar, but that's only because I've practiced and practiced. Anyone can learn each seperate instrument for this song and learn to play it well, but it's a hard song for a band to play together. I'm in a band and it's one of the hardest songs we've had to learn to play together.
Ya'll gettin some negativity,and i gotta agree with some of it...sorry, you just can never have Isaacs voice,and it does sound really outa tune. needs work...
I know! Everyone on youtube should have their own cameras and a recording studio to be able to record their own videos! Noone should be allowed to post any criticism since their opinion means nothing unless they are better than the person they are critical of. Next, I'm going to tell movie reviewers to stop being critical until they start directing their own movies
@buffduff18 By that logic, the only people who should have been able to criticize Bush were past presidents. Think about what your saying before you say it
@buffduff18 I have no problem with this band, they're fine, but what you said is flawed. You don't have to be better than someone, in order to riotously criticize them. It doesn't take a professional to tell that some a band isn't playing together, or on key. You don't need to be Van Gogh to tell that shit on a lightbulb isn't art.
I know it's sometimes hard to detect when reading something, but I was being sarcastic in my post. I figured my last sentence gave it away, but I guess there's always someone that doesn't get it.
Another problem could be where they are playing. When I was in my school band, in the auditorium the sound didn't travel right, and everything sounded compressed, and it was hard to make out the brass section.
The bass sounds like the amp is dipped in pudding and the higher notes are all out of tune. Good try tho. I agree with a lot of other comments, the vocals are really good. It doesn't sound the same with just one drummer. There are a lot of holes and the beat doesn't move enough.
the drummer was not even close i am sorry but that was not accurate at all on his part otherwise it was good. I suggest you either find a better drummer or have him learn it the way the band write it so it acctually sounds write. He screwed up your whole entire performance
Fuck these guys. I thought it was alright. It had it's faults, but it wasn't "fucking bad" or "ear splitting". It was good. Nice job guys.
iboneic13 1 month ago
c'mon guy it wasn't that bad!
DasBSERind 2 months ago
"hi my name is Craig and I'm here to show y'all how much I suck"
airsplat490 3 months ago
.......dudes..?
pepijnn7 3 months ago
the singer is actually decent but the bassists has no idea what the fuck is going on
Reyisfilms 4 months ago 2
I thought the singer did a really good job. Although the instruments needed a lot of work. It's still a lot better than I could do.
HenjoGamingHD 6 months ago
AHH MY EARS ARE BLEEDING!!
TheXXxShAnExXx 6 months ago
Minor mistakes, but who cares :) it was fun watching :D
Spinning23greens 7 months ago
nice cover, best one ive seen, everyone else who thinks otherwise.... suck it!
ameture1excitement 8 months ago
BADDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDBADDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
modestmouseman11 11 months ago
dear guitarist,
TUNER!!
esquirevancoleburge 1 year ago
if you wanna see a good cover watych this (i can't believe this has 10 000 views and mine has 400)
Mongomaniac94 1 year ago
3:50 til the end, the singer just ruined everything he'd done to that point. He had been good up until then, what did his voice box blow out or something? Did the guitars around him blow out his ear drums and make him tone-deaf?
I don't know if I've ever heard such monotone, unpassionate singing in my life.
BenderPicturesDeux 1 year ago
alright but the bass line was weird. would have been pretty cool if you featured trumpets in it to for the brass line
nicklol823 1 year ago
This is bloody awful!
LewisKiernan 1 year ago
srry but this is some ass
pomm100 1 year ago
whats so wrong with criticism? we all know we wouldnt ever listen to this anyway. so why not talk shit? we dont have to do better to talk down upon people.
D4N13Lf00 1 year ago
@D4N13Lf00
You know you're comment was written over a year ago but when I saw it something inside me died. You're breed of people is the kind that goes through the motions of society bitching about everything all the time instead of trying to contribute something.
aznbacon321 7 months ago
@aznbacon321 It's been a whole year i don't even remember this video lol but i have to say i agree with you. (but im actually afraid to click Play)
D4N13Lf00 7 months ago
hey pretty good.,especially the singer.,
i know what its like to play imn a place lke this.,.,so the sound may not be the greates.,.,but if yu listen closely.,its great.,
HowardFineAndHoward 1 year ago
Anyone who doesn't play an instrument or has never attempted to play this song has no right to put these guys down. I can play it well on guitar, but that's only because I've practiced and practiced. Anyone can learn each seperate instrument for this song and learn to play it well, but it's a hard song for a band to play together. I'm in a band and it's one of the hardest songs we've had to learn to play together.
ryannorris1 1 year ago 2
@ryannorris1 then u need to be better musucians.. its not that hard.
bearsafetyus 1 year ago
this is pretty bad dude. it seemed like every key was off by a fret :(
Guercinator 1 year ago
hang yourself.
andimhisfriendjesus 1 year ago
ive heard worse,,,,,but brutal ending
brix04 1 year ago
FAIL!!!!!!!
chrismoss420 1 year ago
lol, bass had no idea what was going on.
logorogo1 2 years ago
♥
Nikirainbowkins 2 years ago
Dear god...
FlucifuX2 2 years ago
Ya'll gettin some negativity,and i gotta agree with some of it...sorry, you just can never have Isaacs voice,and it does sound really outa tune. needs work...
Volcom0570 2 years ago
this is fucking bad sorry to say
ARCFIDEO 2 years ago 25
@ARCFIDEO i agree, but i think the vocals are spot on
SuperGuy344 1 year ago
@ARCFIDEO Not as bad, there's even a worse cover of this song.
Eblanc 11 months ago
@Eblanc where may I find this?
Lockjaw95 8 months ago
@Lockjaw95 Just goo look it up on youtube search. ModestMouse Cover
Eblanc 8 months ago
Damnn that was good!
Saon187 2 years ago 3
wanted to cut my ears off at some parts
eliedru 2 years ago
Im convinced that i should cut my ears off. Bass guitar is too loud, lead guitar is too low, any1 in the band own a tuner???
imjohnandyouare 2 years ago
Out of tune compared to the original, but taking that out of context, I think it all sounds great!
Pixelbuddy 2 years ago
Seems very out of tune :D good singing
abluefuzz 2 years ago 2
great singing for the verses, but u need to sing the chorus a little heavier. Good job though!
CHDRBOB 2 years ago
woah dude you sing exactly like him...
wwjoeyd 2 years ago
good singer playing, but it seems out of tune
MrSimpson 2 years ago
A for effort!
aznbwong 2 years ago 5
Go kraig!!!
mygreentamberine1409 2 years ago 6
Fantastic effort! The vocalist surprised me with his ability to actually sing the song!
xPythox 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
thanks for ruining this.. I mean.. at least have the instruments in tune..
Tylerg12345 2 years ago
i find it pathetic how the people who talk shit, have no vids of their own dashboard cover to back their ass's up O.o
r0k37m4N 2 years ago 8
I know! Everyone on youtube should have their own cameras and a recording studio to be able to record their own videos! Noone should be allowed to post any criticism since their opinion means nothing unless they are better than the person they are critical of. Next, I'm going to tell movie reviewers to stop being critical until they start directing their own movies
buffduff18 2 years ago 13
Thats just stupid?
Reviwers Tell us whats worth watching,, just because Its hard to make a movie, it doesent mean i wanna see it?
primeus70 2 years ago
@buffduff18 By that logic, the only people who should have been able to criticize Bush were past presidents. Think about what your saying before you say it
alexs1422 1 year ago
@alexs1422 I know it's hard to detect sarcasm when you're reading something, but really? You couldn't sense it the slightest?
buffduff18 1 year ago
@buffduff18 I have no problem with this band, they're fine, but what you said is flawed. You don't have to be better than someone, in order to riotously criticize them. It doesn't take a professional to tell that some a band isn't playing together, or on key. You don't need to be Van Gogh to tell that shit on a lightbulb isn't art.
keysmasterivory1994 1 year ago
@keysmasterivory1994
I know it's sometimes hard to detect when reading something, but I was being sarcastic in my post. I figured my last sentence gave it away, but I guess there's always someone that doesn't get it.
buffduff18 1 year ago
upland womens club
BazBallFReak 2 years ago
Another problem could be where they are playing. When I was in my school band, in the auditorium the sound didn't travel right, and everything sounded compressed, and it was hard to make out the brass section.
dradfromthebu 3 years ago 2
yeah u gota point
wen sound bounces off certain walls, it interferes with the sound that is emitting.
it brings a muffled sound.
instruments played fine...but base was to heavy
SquireAlmighty 3 years ago 2
Good vocals, guitar and base sounded out of tune, but whoever is singing is really talented.
dradfromthebu 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
YOU SUCK BIG HAIRY BALLS
Sauske98 3 years ago
Guys you haven´t thought about that the recording maybe is bad? This is a hard song to play! Good job guys i mean it! :)
Mack3e 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this fucked up a great song... good job
twj008 3 years ago
bass is out of tune
or bent out of tune
its tough to tell
ghett0fabu1as 3 years ago
is this at the upland womens club?
Branflakes126 3 years ago 2
The bass sounds like the amp is dipped in pudding and the higher notes are all out of tune. Good try tho. I agree with a lot of other comments, the vocals are really good. It doesn't sound the same with just one drummer. There are a lot of holes and the beat doesn't move enough.
peleman24 3 years ago 2
this is painful kids, sorry.
mabryzealand 3 years ago
yea kids, what the grown-up said, because this guy is a badass, why can't you be like this guy.
eurotyrent 3 years ago
fucking kill yourselfs u couldnt be ne worse
LancerDeeks 3 years ago
o_0 EPIC FAIL WAY TO KILL MY FAVORITE SONG
PoletheismyQueen 3 years ago
this sucked overall. sorry.
nickconfidental 3 years ago
god damn the drummer sucks. good vocals though. pretty close to the original guy.
odensfury 3 years ago
you're an idiot
nickconfidental 3 years ago
The bass sounds like a tuba!!!
needs to be tuned.
someday49 3 years ago 2
Bass too loud. Vocals were excellent cept not loud enough.
retrodrood 3 years ago
This has got to be the only YouTube Cover i've ever seen with great vocals. Keep it up man.
LJRO 3 years ago 2
The bassist is SO out of tune. Well played though.
ElWeasle 3 years ago
the drummer was not even close i am sorry but that was not accurate at all on his part otherwise it was good. I suggest you either find a better drummer or have him learn it the way the band write it so it acctually sounds write. He screwed up your whole entire performance
dgkshreder4 3 years ago
i don't know if it's just me, but i think the bassist is off key. It might just be the video. I don't know. But hey it sounds awesome!
MavMedic81 3 years ago
Toooooooooo Fasssssssst. But Awesome!
xIgnoreMe 3 years ago 2
Great brock impersonation. not many people can get the voice right.
BVisionProductions 3 years ago 4
yeah i agree. good job.
tibsnow 3 years ago 3
Yeah, the singer is really good.
Mctwist1 3 years ago 4
Really good singer.
OnlyHighWhenDriving 3 years ago 4
Kraig rocks.
Nocturno91 3 years ago
les paul crazy man just awesome
whathehellasian 3 years ago
great job
Nypimp365 3 years ago
wow its like the real thing!!! I thought it was really modest mouse for a sec. :D good Job
jackhammer698243 3 years ago 3
Finally, someone that sings this correctly, or at least really close to it.
buffduff18 3 years ago 3
haha i like your these guys are awesome comment.
but you guys are good. nice cover
c2m51 3 years ago
i thing the bass is wrong... at least thats how it sounds
maciekomis 3 years ago 2
these guys r freakin awesome
thedmutz 3 years ago
@thedmutz u r so right!!!!!!
kai5558545 8 months ago
hey guys i love this song the band is awsome hope to hear more songs soon and ones that i like oh and the vocals were awsome!!!! see ya!!!!!
mandytapia 3 years ago