Added: 3 years ago
From: Lior420
Views: 68,855
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (869)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • assuming from your name u o weed :X

  • i am the maker of this video. i see that many people like it. thank you for your comments. I got guitar hero 4 after i made this and it was ok. the drums are great though. i also got rock band 2, beattles, and greenday. I am soon going to preorder dj hero 2. i have guitar hero 5, i also got guitar hero van halen free with it. it is a lot like aerosmith with the format. overALL guitar hero is a better franchise. but rockband has more music. dont forget to tell everyone you know about this video.

  • Uh, learn to spell. " cymbols, sepretly, awsome, custimize, doesnt and tranfer." Those are all the words you spelled wrong. Take a trip back to Language Arts class.

  • Let's have a different argument instead of the same one over and over again:

    Is Guitar Hero and Rock Band better on the PS3 or 360?

  • the drums in rock band are kinda disappointing,only 4 notes..

    the drums in GHWT are way way better and nicer,thats why i prefer these.

  • OMG. ROCK BAND IS BETTER! IT ALWAYS WAS SINCE IT WAS BORN! GHWT copied the drums and vocals. Who cares if you can create songs on GHWT? It will always sound like a damn NES (not that I have anything against it. I like the NES). Rock Band is easier because it was made for families. It has a lot of DLC and GHWT has songs that I don't even know! "L'via L'viaquez"!? I'm not spanish! "Monsoon"? Tokio Hotel is emo! Where is all the Journey!? AC/DC!? Grateful Dead!?

  • @greenorange75 Ur mother

  • @MrAppelde33 No rlly.

  • i had guitar for a couple of months and i let everybody play it and then the drums fuckin broke i played rock band b4 its ok but the drums on gh4 kind of suck but guitar hero is still better

  • i have both. rock band is hella better. i play real drums and i like rockband drums way better cuz the charts are more realistic

  • @cashmerestaten i'm sorry....do you not use cymbals in real life?

  • @TheSithOverlord666 no shit you use cymbals in real life im just saying that the actual charts are so much more realistic

  • i like rb2

  • i like rock band helllllla lot better.

  • my friend's GHWT drum cymbals broke three times. i prefer RB because instraments look WAY better than GHWT. i played my friend's GHWT and i didn't like it as much as RB. plus, RB has more songs.anyone disagree?

  • Course it happens cause rockband is easier and the guitar and drums are way different i hate both gh drums and rockband notes on them. I swang too hard my stick from gh and broke it. But a friend of mine couldnt play gh even he played expert on rockband

  • i prefer the guitar hero 4 drum kit because there's more notes to hit but break very easy im on my 4th drum kit but the songs on gh4 r better

  • Comment removed

  • guitar hero is way more fun... and the instruments are cooler and plus i just hate the way rock band looks...it reminds me to much of a fag punk band

  • 1020 songs on RB YEAAAAAAAAAAA

  • guitar hero world tour 4 ever!

  • I tried to reply to someones comment saying that halo is a total over rated shit on a disk

  • no this is a fact that world tour is only better for charater creator but rock band beat ghwt to the punch for songs and rb has over 1,000 songs out for download now so rock band you can really get your moneys worth but if you are a gh fan then stick with it but rb is still better

  • 200th rate 5*

  • id go wit RockBand the graphics r btr plus the drums work better plus the guitar works way better...THOUGH FOR SONGS GHWT ALL THE WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • how is that even possible? half the notes you play with a rock band set don't even register. any note you play correctly on a ghwt set gets registered. and being a drummer for 4+ years i'd have to say that the ghwt drums are more realistic too. just a thought

  • except my GHWT drums' green pad started to crap out after about 4 months, and my RB2 drums are working well after about 4 months, and i know drummers, and they say that the RB2 drums are probably the best stock kit you can buy that aren't ions

  • thats their opinion

  • and your's isn't?

  • @TSpikeProductions they're freaking loud though

  • the loudness is fine for me, they seem to have more rebound on the pads to me, but i haven't used my GHWT set in 8 months, give or take

  • GHWT!!!!

  • obviously, GHWT

  • halo sucks. this video was a terrible slideshow.

  • go back to the dumster u came from

  • guitar hero may have fewer songs than rockband but at least there good songs.

  • alder500 you are right who cares the guitar hero songs are a thousand times better than RB2

  • Ugh, fucking Blink 182, oh well

    I say even though rockband did the whole band first, i would still go with guitar...but out of this concept, real instrument obviously beat all, but Gh and rockband seem real fun, no joke! lol

  • GH FTW!

  • why are people talking about halo 3 !!! this is about gh vs rb u idiots.. go watch a galo 3 vid if u wanna be nerds

  • Put a better song than that fagget song

  • get a life and learn how to spell

  • MCR, I understand Eastern Finnish(which is hard 2 understand and i live in finland) better than ur typing cuz u use this stupid typing style u undrstnd?

  • HAHAHA!!!!!! that is so true

  • youre only mad cuz you suk playin any of these games. Plus im in a band 2 but i still like these games. if u gonna make comments about us who like rb n gh but u hate it, wtf r u doin watchin da video? N yea im not on da charts, but i can still talk, so stop bein a in da closet music game fan.

  • can you translate that to english? i have trouble deciphering it

  • rockband 2 ftw fags!

  • GHWT FTW STUPID FAGET

  • Someones got some anger management.

  • Nerd. go to school

  • i can just sing so i dont how you others say but singing is much better in rock band than gh...but everybody should play the game he wants.

    by the way gh 5 and tb rb suck both

  • rockband has breakneck speed....>.>

    do research idiot

  • Gh was here first and we'll stay here forever!!!!!!!!

    Rok band has gay songs, GH has kick ass songs.

    Who would want to play yeayeayeahs maps in rock band where u got Van Halen's hot for teacher on GH?

    Better clothes cooler characters and a song creator, fuk 500 songs ill make myown. Thats how u save money. Hands down GH wins, (doesnt mean i dont like RB1+2 cuz i got both games. Theyre both fun to play)

  • iron maiden and judas priest make gay songs now do they?

  • Rock Band 2 is better then Guitar Hero World Tour, however, this year, Guitar Hero 5 is better then the Beatles Rock Band. Just my opinion..

  • i dont see why ppl r arguing over which game is better. they're both great games. stop arguing and just hav fun. thats wat games were made for

  • rock band is better than gh

    more songs, rock band network better than this fucki*g ghtunes with crappy sounds on tracks (MIDI)

    charts don't suck on RB

    instrument are better too !

  • @DevilRinuX guitar hero is alot harder though

  • @DevilRinuX pfft the guitar sucks ass on RB! the fucking strum button doesnt regester unless you friggin hammer it

  • i like both but gh has better strum timing if u play gh guitar u wont be able to play rbwith out takeing a week to learin it

  • yah i agree with u i couldnt use the rb guitar but i like the rb drums better but only if ur playing them with gh =]

  • G H wins

  • rockband sucks! GH all the way!

  • I agree!

  • !!!

  • what sucks about rock band? the 1000+ songs by the end of 2009, rock band network, for bands who just want to get their music out there, compatibility with every game in the series? what does guitar hero have? a crap MIDI creator, a setlist with only about 20 good songs, laughable DLC, and getting a new game every 3 months?

  • ROCKBAND sucks the little notes on it are hard there to freaking little they just had to copy guitar hero and change a little bit cuz there retards

  • can't see how the notes are too small, they are ffine for me, unless you are blind or something

    and harmonix(makers of RB) made the first 2 guitar hero games, along with rock the 80's, until activision bought out red octane, thus getting the rights to milk guitar for all its worth, harmonix created the guitar game as we know now, and activision is just using HMX's creation to make as musch money as possible

  • rockband still sucks gh all the way im not a nerd who researches this stuff rockband ftl

  • how does rock band suck though? the note size is a moot point, since the GH notes aren't much bigger

    and calling someone a nerd online doesn't mean much

  • apparently calling ppl nerd is a big deal or u wouldn't of said it didnt mean much u wud of just left it alone rockband just sucks cuz they coppied GH and the notes look mentally retarted

  • but how could they possibly copy something they created?

    if you're gonna be a fanboy, at least learn the history

  • they didnt create it the first game out ever was GH 1 and im a fanboy i guess?!?! and im not a nerd i dont like to learn

  • the first game was GH1, and harmonix DID create it

    and yes, you are a fanboy, and have fun finding a job if you don't like learning

  • i have plenty of jobs nerd. GH better than rockband that final.

  • i bet you do, seeing as you have been replying to every one of my comments

    its fine to have an opinion, but at least get valid reasons

  • i win thats final

  • how, may i ask, do you win?

    inb4 i just do

  • cuz im smart.

  • is that because you can't spell "because"?

  • i dun like to work hard and spell right idc

  • i bet, since the educated tend to spell correctly, and typically like to work, i'd say you aren't

  • i win its over im done idc care bout u ne more

  • ok, glad to have wasted your time

  • thanks go to school now halo 3 ftw

  • lolwut @ halo 3

  • halo 3 is awsome

  • ODST was better

  • halo 1 and 2 were the only good halo games.

  • i just HATE the rb strum pad..

  • both

  • i like gh guiter, rb2 drums and rock band games (but gh5 will pwn rb beatles)

  • WTF sources : google?????

  • GH4 is better than rock band 2 it sucks and its easy 2 play GH games r harder than rock band games

  • compare any GHWT guitar song to a song like thrasher, or even visions

  • Yeah, but GH is basically only for people who like to take it up to the highest point of their limits. Also, if you're at the party playing GHWT, that would me you would stay on it for a LONG time. The only reason why RB is "easy", because Rock Band is considered a "party" game. Case closed.

  • i like gh4

  • ROCK BAND WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • RB2 guitar is better. i generally prefer RB cus its easier to use, but i like guitar hero's song list. it's a pretty even thing.

  • I agree. I like the RB2 guitar over the GH:WT guitar.

  • so.. wich one is winner?

  • okay all this stuff about ghwt drums still breaking is bs, yes when the drums first came out they were defective and the gh ppl admitted it but ghwt is an awesome game and my drums work PERFECTLY!!!!!! even when my friends bang the crap out of them =}

  • dude, same here, mine are great, my friends don't bang the crap out of em tho lol and idk but im stuck on the idea that (like rock band, yes rock band messed up too on their first attempt) the drums were just really faulty and ppl bought it right away, and they bought a faulty drumset. Come 2-3 months later, they tweaked the sets and fixed 'em a little bit and made em better, and I think thats what happened to me :D

  • yep, and how can ppl say the ghwt guitars are too big? u have to have like 4 inch arms for it to be too big

  • Guitar hero guitars necks are usually like.... an inch and a half, at the most... and that's pretty thick, i could be off on my guessed measurement, but that is probably what people are talking about.

  • o, well if your cant reach that then ur probably pretty young so u probably shouldnt be playing the game.....but i guess if i is too long or big u can always use the Xplorer from guitar hero 1 - 3

  • no dude, im 18 years old.... its not too big or anything, i'm just saying the guitar hero guitars were thicker in the neck. whereas rockbands first guitar was pretty much scale. lol

  • so which one is better???

  • To me the guitars are very difficult to choose, personally i dont like the design of WT because of the huge size,and Rpck Band 2 well i just dont like it i used it and well i would enjoy if they minimalized the guitar size to a little bit above the GH3 size.

  • GH needs some godsmack

  • i no seriousley

  • people like seriously, both of the games are awesome in their own way and have some not so good thing about them so stfu about it =/. i like GH because it gives you more of a challenge than RB and i like RB because of the music and DLC. now personally i like the GH intruments better but thats just me. and i have both of the games so all i really have to say that they're both awesome =)

  • why is RB not challenging? have you not seen the guitar charts for songs like thrasher and the solo for ride the lightning, even vocals can be hard in that game

  • i have rb2 for wii and have some dlc does ghwt have disturbed or green day even maroon 5 rb2 all the way

  • GHWT song creator was a failed concept.

    Singing in GHWT was BS. You can't get 100%.

    My GHWT drumset came broken out of the box. The red pad doesn't register.

    I used to like GH games, it just seems that lately they just got greedy. In 2009 they came/are coming with:

    GH Metallica

    GH Smash Hits

    GH 5

    GH Van Halen

    GH On Tour Modern Hits

    They are rushing the games making them low quality.

  • They might be good if each game has their own unique development team. But they won't cos they're dicks. :(

    On Tour Modern Hits sounds like a fail concept. Now you can play new pop shit in a game. Joy.

  • seriously biggest blow was smash hits they just ran out of ideas so they made a game with songs they already used lol

  • wrong.low quality??? GH Metallica is teh most awesome game ive ever played\!

  • well i think that rock band rocks because of the songs and the guitar is very cool in guitar hero w t the drums is very nice but the guitar is kind of weird and the songs are like creepy

    so i think that ROCK BAND RULEEEEEEEEEEZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

  • ghwt sucks balls. why on earth would you like something like that. the drums cymbals broke off while playing byob. rb2 is way better. the set is nice guitar is ok and it is challenging. think byob is hard, try playing visions or battery on any instrument.

  • i have xbox 360 and rockand 1 and gh:wt and rock band 1 is waaaaaaaaaaaaay better than gh:wt, firstly the downloadable songs are 0-160 microsoft points but in gh:wt they're up to something like 440 microsoft points, and most of the gh:wt songs are to slow paced.

  • uhh I think rock band drums are better espically since I have both games and I was playing GTWT one day and the whole thing just fell apart

  • I prefer Guitar hero world tour :)

  • I think Gh is more advanced than rockband =D but rockband has really

    nice music ^^ but i think Gh became a bit more famous because of the drumset and

    Gh metallica so uumm... i prefer gh just cause it's a bit faster and stuff ^^

  • RB has over 700 DLC songs now.

  • ROCK BAND!

  • Rockband Rock;-)

    GHWT Suck;-(

  • their both good

  • I actually enjoy both games and i hate people fighting over which is better!!!

  • my pick

    gh world tour drums- win

    rockband guitar- win

    rb and gh mic- same

  • why did u make guitar hero world our gameplay look gay.

  • I like them both the same

  • overall i think the mic is good for rock band. but guitar is a no brainer definily guitar hero. the drums tho i say is a dead tie. only cause rock bands drums are more duriable besides the foot pedal. and while guitar hero u have cymbols, there quiet. and stronger foot pedal. but there not that durible mine broke in 2 days i didnt even hit that hard either

  • This might be the shittiest and most biased video I've ever seen.

  • rockband improved guitar hero because guitar hero only had guitars RB had drums, guitar, bass, and microphone=RB>GH until GH copied RB and made world tour so they both copied each other!!!! ROCK BAND IS BETTER!!

  • idiot its a different game from the same creators.

    theres even gonna be a band hero game..

    it said so on the gh website...

    even though there is allready a band in gh and in rb

    does that mean that band hero copied them both?

    think before you reply

  • rock band creators created gh1 gh2 gh rock the 80s then gave it to neversoft not sure exactly but i think they sold it to them then neversoft created gh3 gha ghwt ghm oh and also the ds gh games

  • GH is the best an RB SUCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i totally agree

  • I think GHWT gives you the rocker experience. But thats my opinion.

    PS. Why would you care?

  • i agree with you on that Taytay

  • gh world tour wins by 5 miles when rockband is going full speed.

  • I both think they are very good games but i like rock band 2 a little better i feel like rb2 is more realistic but thats just my opinion

  • I TOTALLY agree with you.but i like GH:WT better because i've had giutar hero since the first one came out.I like BOTH games alot though

  • guitar hero world tour kiks rock bands dariair

  • The real winner is neither of them.

    Guitar Hero: Metallica is the best!!!

  • obviously this guy is all for GHWT probobly cuz he has it and it costs more. and its funny because he dosnt even talk about rock band its all about RB2 so this video is kind of pathetic. I only got half way through and completely lost interest.

  • rock band is awesome!!!!!!!!!!

  • GHWT!

  • GHWT owns the rb2!!! go gh go go go!!!

  • i have guitar hero world tour full band pack for the wii but am getting an xbox 360 for my birthday and will get the rock band 2 guitar bundle for it. i live in the uk btw.

  • Rock band 2 Wins Big time

  • Rockband has a better soundtrack than Guitar hero

  • add me on rockband2

  • The GH guitar is more heavy that makes is realistic but the rock band one looks more realistic... Rockband haves a nice premium drumkit but cost to much so thats a fail. GH Wins!

  • ADD MY ON GUITAR HERO WORLD TOUR FOR THE Wii! MY FRIENDCODE IS: 120457314319

  • for my opinion i kinda liked world tour better.

    the songs and the controls for the guitar was better for me i find.

    but hey don't give me thumbs down, this is just an opinion.

  • instrumets: Rock Band 2

    Music and Notes: GHWT

    Graphics: Rock Band 2

    And Songs:GHWT

    Rock Band customize drum kit it´s LOL :)

  • but the normal gh drums are bettter than rb 'cause ION are better but soooo much expensive...

    i didn't play rb but i think both have their good and bad things...i have ghwt so sure i say ghwt is better for me but rb is a nice game,too

  • Rock Band is a n00b's Guitar Hero, that's why its so popular.

  • I don't know why people gives you thumbs down you're completely right

  • They're just pissed of because they know it's true.

  • wow thats the first not one sided video of this that ive seen. completely fair on both ends! awsome vid for that. i go with guitar hero and always will cant wait for smash hits to come out. i tried rock band but ehhh can never get used to thoose freakin squares lol

  • rock band and gh are great but at last gh wins!!!

  • youre right!

  • I like rock band 2

  • ghwt DA BST GAME 2009

  • wow... have you played it?