Polish sabre vs katana training (Liszka vs Alan)

[misfit13091]

If the Katana makes contact with another sword it will chip or break. It was made for quick drawing not defending. Katana = overrated.

[TheBloodyBlackJackal]

@misfit13091 The only way it will chip during sword to sword contact is if you SMASHED THEM TOGETHER...

However, in this case BOTH would have to be hard metal, if one is not hard metal; it will get sliced into (not through, just into).

Its like a game of bloody knuckles, smash your knuckles together, and its painful as hell for the both of you. Smash your knuckles into the palm of the guys hand, and well... Sucks for the other guy...

[RealSlavicPoland]

bokkeny ;d

[averit]

Szkoda, że jakość taka słaba. Macie możliwość nakręcenia czegoś więcej w lepszej jakości? Mało jest na youtube takich filmów. Osobiście służę kataną lub bokkenem ;)

[LiskowicStudios]

@averit nakrecimy nakrecimy. katane i szable lubie tak samo. trzeba wiedziec tylko jakie styl walki naklada ograniczenia a jakie daje korzysci i mozna pokonac kazdego :) np. walka nozownika z wlocznikiem jezeli nozownik pokona dystans wlocznik ma przejebane...i na odwrot. podobnie z kazda bronią

[snkhuong]

dont know about saber, but that's not how to use the katana

[MrBoneStripper98]

ok lets get someone that knows how to use a katana first. no speed, no balance. no controll. for the katana guy

[yellowbird1800man]

polish saber pwns xD

[born2lol]

The truth is that katana is a sword with reputation built by myths and anime shows. Hussar sabre beats it in every category ... well maybe not in the number of fanboys. I know I was a weeaboo in past ;)

[francescoyaftehmihan]

@born2lol .... every sword is lethal, depends how you use it. However I didn't see in this video someone that know how to use a katana....... mah

[LiskowicStudios]

@francescoyaftehmihan he uses european sword techniques. It was called "katana" because he uses bokken. still i agree with you about that every sword is leathal. if someone knows perfectly how tu use combat knife he/she will be great oponent against everyone. *high five*

[TheBloodyBlackJackal]

@born2lol "The truth is that katana is a sword with reputation built by myths and anime shows."

The truth is, jealous western hillbillies tend to make up just as bad anti-katana myths... "Hussar sabre beats it in every category" Really, and what categories do those happen to be?

[VaoPL]

Nagrywane chyba kapciem...

[KrwawyLeon]

kompletna amatorka. nazwijcie to poprawnie, typ z kijem vs typ z kijem.

[szmesz]

Interesting video. I think katana has not too much chance against sabre becouse of a simple reason. Katana is a two handed sword which means it has shorter attack and and defend area than the one handed sabre.

[kadzit]

@szmesz but you have to admit that two-handed weapons gives more deadly atacks XD. i personally prefer sabre. everybody has his own beloved weapon ^^

[szmesz]

@kadzit True. If you can earn your opponent. :-)

From an other wiewpoint saber is basically a sword which was used from horseback. These circumstances are turn the balance to the saber's side again. Just try to imagine how deadly that attack what a razor sharped saber can give with 60km/h speed... :-)

[kadzit]

@szmesz thats true and polish winnged hussars sabre had that beautifull handle XD which makes almost imposible to lost your weapon XD

[jinnd319]

@kadzit personally I think Indian weapons are the best (tulwar and such) but I have never seen this sabre before today. I do like killij style blades and blades that can be used with ferocity.

[YuriPRIME]

@kadzit Not realy my friend :P it takes just 2 centimeter of depth cut to slice any important vain in body. Sabre does it to 3 cm katana even to 8... but as you pierced the vein it makes no difference. Katana demands more force for atack that is needlesly overpowered... it's like exploding a snail with a granate, while astep on it with a boot makes the same stuff done.

[LiskowicStudios]

@YuriPRIME Not really my friend ^^ Polish sabre curvy level allowed to do really deep cuts (no problem with chopping hand off)

Katana has more straight blade

[YuriPRIME]

@LiskowicStudios Yeah, if you had a chance and time to slice that deeply, but if you look at bones of victims found by archeologists on battlefields it very often proves that the cuts were rather shallow, quick, delt in chaotic way, still enaugh to kill someone :P

[LiskowicStudios]

@YuriPRIME good point but we forrgot one thing SABER was created as Cavalery weapon. During horse charge it was not suprise when opponent lost half of his head body etc. During fight on feet saber fighters were trained to cut at the vital points (so deep cuts were not needed at all) When your opponent use two handed weapons he/she uncovers that vital points much often than other saber fighter. On the other hand attack with two handed sword etc may easily break the block of saber rapier etc.

[LiskowicStudios]

@YuriPRIME so final conclusion is that. No metter what weapon your opponent use...result of the duel depends from a FIGHTER not WEAPON. If you understand advantages and disadvantages of your weapon and you are able to use that knowledge during duel...you will be victorious ^^

[YuriPRIME]

@LiskowicStudios That is true ^^ but you know if I just think of a Winged Hussar charge against Japanese horseriders I can't help to wonder not who will win, but why japanese haven't retreated during first few minutes of the struggle ^^

[LiskowicStudios]

@YuriPRIME Winnged Hussars were simply the best XD

[TheBloodyBlackJackal]

@YuriPRIME "I just think of a Winged Hussar charge against Japanese horseriders I can't help to wonder not who will win, but why japanese haven't retreated during first few minutes of the struggle"

I don't know about that, if it were just cavalry vs cavalry, the Japanese would feign retreat and arrow down most of the Hussar before the actual battle begun.

The Mongols hit Poland hard, and the Japanese have all the same tricks and more...

[thx1103n]

@szmesz i dissagree, as a person who has done kendo and single handed sword for years i.e. vikingr, sabre etc a proper katana could quite easily be used with 1 hand. also this persons kendo is terrible. usinf proper technique a good kendoka could win, so could the sabre mind u. now if a shield was involved my $ would be on the sword and shield. but to make conclusions from this video considering their techniques r amateur at best is just silly.

[countnickoli]

@szmesz that isnt true its the skill behind the weapon

[TheBloodyBlackJackal]

@szmesz A katana is designed for 2 handed, but believe me; it is just as effective when used 1 handed, if just slightly more tiring...

Using a weapon 2 handed gives you more power, and more control; if it becomes a binding match, you'd best use both hands...

[szmesz]

@TheBloodyBlackJackal

I absolutely agree about the katana is a deadly, sword of course.

I just say your oportunities of moving are more "limited" if you use both hands.

No offense to the katana, I respect the katana especially if it used by a person who know how to use it. :) I saw some bato do cuts. These were wonderful. If you cant control properly your katana, than it wont cut.

I training with saber till 3 years, but never tried cut yet. Watching katana cuts can be very instructive for me.

[TheBloodyBlackJackal]

@szmesz Actually your movements are not limited... Your range is limited, however using your weapon 2 handed gives you also sorts of control, for positions and strikes that you wouldn't normally be able to do with 1 hand... Also, its not like it takes anything to mix it up, and do 1 handed strikes along with 2 handed ones.

[TheBloodyBlackJackal]

@szmesz Anyways, the range limit is actually not that much... Probably not much more then an inch. The Katana has an extra long handle specifically so that you have leverage and range...

[budzas]

Zawsze byłem ciekawy jak by wyglądał pojedynek szabla vs katana.

Kciuk w górę !

[gothic223]

dno ___

[kadzit]

@gothic223 dno to cie robiło

[Szarllej]

@kadzit i like panecakes

[Noxvind]

Hm. Powiem tylko tyle. Niejednokrotnie przeprowadzano testy i walki z uzyciem obu rodzaji broni. Zawsze wygrywala szabla. Dlaczego? Jest wiele czynnikow.

Na youtube jest pelno filmow. Wystarczy poszukac.

Pozdrawiam.

[kadzit]

@GotMan911 nie powiedziałbym...owszem zaangazowanie dwoch rak daje mniej swobody a stopien jej zagiecia nie pozwala na wiele sztuczek..ale smiga w powietrzu i z dwor rak idzie wyprowadzac niezwykle silne ciosy ^^

kazda bron jest dobra..wystarczy dobrac ja do siebie

[copypacercopypacer]

@kadzit hey next time u should put a cutlass vs a katana or two cutlasses and two katanas vs each other. that would be awsome and would so make me put thumbs up and al least make alot of people suscribe

[copypacercopypacer]

which is better

[jediknight2694]

Good fencing! But that didn't look like katana technique, still you guys know what your doing

[kadzit]

thank you.. its quite old video XD soon i will upload better ones

[copypacercopypacer]

@kadzit what do you think would break if they actually hit each other, a sabre or a katana and both were same quality

[kadzit]

@copypacercopypacer there blades were this same quality... you see sabre in poland was used in all wars so they had to made the best sabre in europe. try to see how looks "Szabla husarska"

[copypacercopypacer]

@kadzit no i'm me what happen if a katana hit a sabre and they both were same quality or if and if a sabre hit a katana and sabre had better quality?

[kadzit]

@copypacercopypacer probably any of them will break, but if they were bad quality ...well probably katana would break sabre because f you are useing 2 hands your hits are ussually stronger.

[kadzit]

@copypacercopypacer well in my opinion katana would break first, because sabre (polish sabre) was more flexible

[copypacercopypacer]

@kadzit what about a foil or a katana. sorry for these questions but I LUV SWORDS ^-^

[kadzit]

@copypacercopypacer its ok XD

i think Foil would be broken. you jus have to hit it with sabre very strong.

foils wer not created to block. Katana would break foil much easier because katanas or longswords atack are strong <fighter is useing 2 hands at all)

[kadzit]

stary film..... ale koles jest nastawiony na europejskie poltoraki... slowo katana wystepuje w tytule bo uzywa bokkena

[scumimpaler]

Szkoda, że szablista jest taki pasywny. Szabelka przede wszystkim dużo oszukuje :) Jestem pewien, że realnie samuraj by był pokaleczony.

[kadzit]

szablista jest po wypadku i ma problemy z lewa nogą... zauwaz jak szeroko musi rozstawiac nogi aby go nie bolała.... Ponadto jeszcze się uczę ale wiem że idzie ku dobremu XD. Owszem zgadzam się ze samuraj byłby pokaleczony ale trzeba tez przyznac ze cięcie z obu rąk wyprowadzone ma siłę przebicia... A Alan ( Samuraj) potrafi przypierdzielic i do tego technicznie... . PS. dzieki za uwagę, będę wiedział co poprawiac jak mi ten problem z nogą przejdzie

[scumimpaler]

To jeszcze dorzucę, że walcząc jedną ręką jesteś do przodu mogąc ciąć z nadgarstka w pół taktu. Trzymanie broni oburącz więcej odbiera niż daje :)

[kadzit]

jak złapię trroche wprawy to na pewno dojde i do tego XD ...

[kadzit]

chamsie komenty będą kasowane... można emocje wyrażać grzeczniej... z poważaniem autor XD