Jim- I enjoyed this so much! It reminded me of my days a long time ago - as a choir boy in Grace Episcopal Church in Utica, NY (1954-58). The video was reminiscent of my winters in Utica, but your voice and the arrangement topped everything else. I look forward to hearing more of your wonderful voice.
I really enjoyed this. I'm something of a traditionalist when it comes to carols (my own "In the Bleak Midwinter video is of the organ accompaniment), but this has a wonderful feel. Five stars, added to favourites.
I just stumbled upon this after I had uploaded my own version. Wow, that's very different from mine - and it's amazingly beautiful. What a lovely warm and spacious mix. Very well done!
Truly beautiful. Your song inspired me to convince our choir director and singers to go with the Holst version of "Bleak Midwinter" rather than the Harold Darke arrangement. Your videos are interesting both visually and aurally.
Perhaps you could post a video response to my video "My favorite Christmas Carol. What's yours?" here in Youtube. We're collecting people's favorite carols from all over the world to celebrate this Christmas time with everyone!
A fellow Oswego County resident here. Thanks for sharing this wonderful song and video.
KickinShadows 1 year ago
@KickinShadows Thanks for the comment! Did you get hit by the lake effect last night? Here in Fulton we got hammered!
carrolly2k 1 year ago
Comment removed
KickinShadows 1 year ago
Lovely Voice, beautiful arrangement.
HerGreenEyesSee 1 year ago
Thanks!
carrolly2k 1 year ago
Jim- I enjoyed this so much! It reminded me of my days a long time ago - as a choir boy in Grace Episcopal Church in Utica, NY (1954-58). The video was reminiscent of my winters in Utica, but your voice and the arrangement topped everything else. I look forward to hearing more of your wonderful voice.
Twolfe38 2 years ago
Thank you for your kind comments!
carrolly2k 2 years ago
I really enjoyed this. I'm something of a traditionalist when it comes to carols (my own "In the Bleak Midwinter video is of the organ accompaniment), but this has a wonderful feel. Five stars, added to favourites.
posaune16 2 years ago
Thank you Nicholas!
carrolly2k 2 years ago
I just stumbled upon this after I had uploaded my own version. Wow, that's very different from mine - and it's amazingly beautiful. What a lovely warm and spacious mix. Very well done!
AndreSeifertMusic 2 years ago
Thanks Andre!
carrolly2k 2 years ago
Jim You have a Nice Voice and thats a great Song. What area are you from?
I have winter outdoors scenes of the Schenectady NY area at schenectadyvideos.
schenectadyvideos 3 years ago
Thanks! I live in the Oswego County area of Upstate NY!
carrolly2k 3 years ago
This is brilliant :) congrats on it. You've got the style exactly right and your voice is amazing. Thanks for posting :) x
PlanetPrincess1 3 years ago
thank you for this it's beautiful. Have a lovely Christmas
fletcherc1 3 years ago
Thanks and a Merry Christmas to you!
carrolly2k 3 years ago
Beautiful and very moving renndition and arrangement of this classic carol.
macbarclay 3 years ago
Thank you.
carrolly2k 3 years ago
Beautiful voice and wonderful style!
rattypajamas 3 years ago
Thanks!
carrolly2k 3 years ago
Beautiful voice and wonderful style!
rattypajamas 3 years ago
This is an awesome video...and you're so talented!!!!!!!!
mewmewvaly 4 years ago
Thank you so much!
carrolly2k 4 years ago
Thoroughly enjoyed this. Thanks for uploading it. Would happily buy this if you recorded this as a single.
chrisopenuni 4 years ago
Thanks for your kind comments.
carrolly2k 4 years ago
THANK YOU. Lovely! Truly Lovely
homousios 4 years ago
Thanks!
carrolly2k 4 years ago
Truly beautiful. Your song inspired me to convince our choir director and singers to go with the Holst version of "Bleak Midwinter" rather than the Harold Darke arrangement. Your videos are interesting both visually and aurally.
lawsonbob 4 years ago
Love it! My favorite Christmas carol too. Thanks so much for such a sweet version, and I love your videos.
julesv307 4 years ago
Thanks again!
carrolly2k 4 years ago
What a wonderful winterscape! Your personlization of the Holst melody, lovely... wonderful variations... love your voice!
reallyharried 4 years ago
Enjoyed your song & video so much we sent it as a Christmas card to our daughter in Maine to cheer up her bleak winter there.
jerrymussgnug 4 years ago
Thanks! Looks like we are going to have a white Chistmas this year. Hope your family has a wonderful holiday! Peace.
carrolly2k 4 years ago
Beautiful carol-words and music-thanks.
waynebrighton 4 years ago
So sweet...
What a beautiful song, thanks for the video response, thanks for sharing it with everyone.
Have a good Christmas time!
Linuxica 4 years ago
Thanks for inviting me to post and for your comments. Merry Christmas to you!
carrolly2k 4 years ago
Great!
Perhaps you could post a video response to my video "My favorite Christmas Carol. What's yours?" here in Youtube. We're collecting people's favorite carols from all over the world to celebrate this Christmas time with everyone!
Merry Christmas!
Linuxica 4 years ago