nightwish-bye bye beautiful (2008 wacken)

[Bossophile]

funny how everyone keeps arguiong over tarja and annete...THIS SONG IS ABOUT HOW TARJA WAS NOT PASSIOATE WITH THE MUSIC!!! LISTEN TO THE CHORUS!!! that being said, get over it people...shit happens, bands change, annete has amazing talent as did tarja, and while i have preference, i will not say to who, BECAUSE IM NOT A WHINEY BITCH ABOUT IT< I LOVE THE BAND REGARDLESS!!

[WireHedgehog]

Nightwish is not Tarja

Nightwish is Tuomas

[Feanor2345]

@WireHedgehog

Nightwish died 2005.

[WireHedgehog]

@Feanor2345 nope

[Feanor2345]

@WireHedgehog

YES

[rockyblacksmith]

@Feanor2345 That is basically an insult to Toumas, Emppu, Jukka and Marco.

You say they are worth nothing.

[satislikev]

R.I.P. NIGHTWISH!!!!!

[WireHedgehog]

@satislikev Nightwish is reborn with Imaginaerum!! Did you hear the Samples?

[catslayer314]

marco missed half the verse!

[jnocetti]

@catslayer314

he doesn't miss anything he must sing that way in live concerts... he has to breath man O_O

[catslayer314]

@jnocetti i know but i can sing that whole verse its still amazing tho

[dennit1221]

@catslayer314

he didnt miss anything... he do this in all live concerts :D

[loawdlahsdad]

i didn't really like tarja very much but like the songs annete sings

[arianatremenda560]

NOOOOOOOOO CON ESTA NENA NO SUENA MAS COMERCIAL LA BANDA

[TOTTW]

Will this song be on the new album? I dearly love it.

[111Tob111]

@TOTTW it is on the album "dark passion play" which has already been released ;)

[TOTTW]

@111Tob111 The instermental part at the beginning? Which song is it in? I have the album.

[meiessiah]

Said it before and I will say it again. How many years ago did the whole Tarja thing happen? As much as I love nightwish and prefer many of Tarja's songs with them over Annettes ... for gods sake...LET IT BLOODY WELL GO !!!!

[Avradizimir]

And this performance is fucking appalling.

[Avradizimir]

I know it's not her fault and she didn't write the song, but it really does ranckle having Anette prancing around singing about what a bitch Tarja is

[BDaDennis]

I think Jukka is the only one who played this song 100% right. But still... Rock on NW!!! :)

[MrHardrock1997]

anette is better as tarja:) rock on...

[CanibelCorpse]

Anette isnt even close to be compared with tarja

[RaioShii2021]

"It's not the tree that forsakes the flower, it's the flower that forsakes the tree" Such powerful words :) A flower may bloom for a moment but a tree last's forever!

[RaioShii2021]

live at Wacken! lawlz pun. :)

[lelonemetal]

Compare Anette with Tarja is like compare a good fast car with a Ferrari . . .

[Raz0r65]

lol this nightwish is for LAUGHS HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA

[AyreonsDimension]

@MariannaNightwishGr it would be ruled in my opinion

[Reirsari]

I love her belt xD

[NightDreamer88]

She would love to spank you with it.

[Reirsari]

@NightDreamer88 ._. tbh I would become lesb for her.

[NightDreamer88]

@Reirsari

tbh I would be thrilled to watch.

[Reirsari]

@NightDreamer88 hahahahah naughty

[thiemig14]

epic !!!

[ArcherDivinity]

NON SONO I NIGHTWISH!!! PUTTANATE...non è marco che canta

[bradhamerstrat]

i like the combination of female and male vocals it rocks

[badman2504]

she's a great singer...the guy.....nahh

[EndOfDeceive]

@badman2504 : Normally he's better than here. I guess he had a bad day or something like that.

[badman2504]

@EndOfDeceive fair enough, I've seen more live videos now, and I agree, bad day at the office

[Taxi5751]

die kann net singen

they are fucking bad

the man isnt able to sing

sie singen sehr schlecht treffen keinen einzigen ton^^

[lulalely]

@Taxi5751 labalabalabalaba

[varo0na1]

esos nightwish ya no me gustan

[mau571]

sad

[dumbcow1]

Marco.....wow.. @.@ you are a beast ...like DAMN

[MommiesLittleZombie]

No, no it's not the same Nightwish. Tarja is gone. Anette is here. If you don't like it, then don't support them anymore. Don't watch their vids. Yes, we all know. Tarja was an amazing singer, but she's gone now. Can you please get over your hissy fits and accept that Anette has replaced her? She's a great singer. She's just different that the way Tarja sounded. So no, it's not the same old Nightwish. So don't come here expecting the exact same old sound.

[LSUbleauxs14]

@MommiesLittleZombie Tarja may be a better singer, but Annette is great and hotter. Great vs Great and hot? Hmmmmm

[MommiesLittleZombie]

@LSUbleauxs14 Oh, Don't get me wrong. I agree with you 100%. I was just iffed at how people will litter Nightwish vids with their petty arguments about which one is better.

[mikeman42986]

@MommiesLittleZombie in my minde iam a f an of both.they have very distinct voices and bring something totaly different to nightwish

]

[DonarsSeidr]

@MommiesLittleZombie  "...great singer..." ?? Where ??, not in this Video!

[Rina19961]

What is this?:))) Even her song can't sing good live?? And what is whit Marco's voice? Sound too stupid. "That" is not Nightwish ...not true Nightwish.

[Lastwagen1000]

Sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo­oooooo Geilllllllllllllllllllllllllll­llllllllllllllllllllllllllllll­llllllllllllllllllllllllll

[GreenDay1981]

I can understand why this song is worse live than on the album. It'd be tough for Marco to simulate his part live. I just don't get why he cuts out some of the words. It's not like it's too fast for him to sing.

[hyl14nn1gh7]

@GreenDay1981 I think it may be a little much to sing in one breath while playing bass and well, being up on that stage.

[skumpik666]

3:19 wtf is she doin'?=))))

[Winterhe4rt]

@skumpik666 dancin like mojo on lsd xD

[AyreonsDimension]

no tarja and marco losing his voice is the end

[Kaldranga]

I liked the studio one a shitton better. This one kinda sucks, with all due respect of course.

[darkcarolineriddle]

This is the first video live where Anette really sings like in the studio. xD I love marco's voice, but I didn't like how he sang here.

[dimezakkrandy]

@darkcarolineriddle I think his mic was just up too loud.

[supereend666]

@albiinoankka

still this issnt the same nightwish anymore

[chadpretimusic]

@supereend666 yeah, right

[YaoiKat]

@supereend666 until Tarja will not come back Nightwish will never be the same....

[zomgt3hpoison]

Do want.

[mihaTHELYRICSMAKER]

wtf was that

it sounds like crap

that song sucks live...

[mihaTHELYRICSMAKER]

wtf was that

it sounds like crap

[lowrides99]

wow they sound like crap live.

[bokuroker]

i like how annete sings, but she fails at whispering

[supereend666]

... this issn't nightwish anymore

rip nightwish

[EINEWIEALASKA]

too bad that marco wasn't in a good shape that day because anette was really good :)

[1IronMaiden123]

i think it would be better, if guitarist would do the backing vovals and the female singer would sing the main vocals-just my opinion :D

[deadtotheworld00]

@1IronMaiden123 trust me man, marco is the right person for this

[diaphanoux]

wtf is this!??.. sounds horrible!!.. nightwish no more!!..

[estuans1]

get back tarja we miss you

[mcrkiller93]

Oddly, voice of emmpu fuckin sucked, performance in general sucked a big one

[Astapabol]

MrMarcoisgod You are right,but Tarja is better than Anette.I like i anette a lot,but i like Tarja more than Anette,because the music of nightwish is syphonic metal,it isn't so good to play power metal.

[leorocker28]

tarja is the best

[Tesmer666]

2:56 Tuomas looks amazing !!!

[brNNNbrNNN]

Hey, her live performance is not bad!

Even really good!

[Astapabol]

bye bye beautiful we shood say in Tarja!It was a big mistake to take Annete...

[MrMarcoisgod]

@Astapabol best thing that ever happend to night wish was anettes .shes a beautiful person inside and out.shes a good singer so please lay off.i dont know how old you but pretend that you are in a relation with a person and you give it every thing you got,but your other is not by doing stupid stuff.it gets so bad you get so depresed you dont care if you live and die.thats my feeling i think tuomas had writing poet and the pendulum.tuomas saw his dream of nightwish falling apart because of greed.

[TheRiCkJaMeS182]

disaponted... nightwish sounded so awsome on cd, but live they don't sound as good, they don't do anything than stand there and play, mabey walk around, booooring

[fumfulapenguin]

@zephranna01 in Germany

[carlosxtinajlo]

no puedo creer como la gente dice q con anette es mas industrial?..... jajajajja si con tarja comenzo crecio..!! se suponia debia morir pero?... ACASO CON TARJA NO FUE Q SE DIERON TAMBIEN A CONOCER?!.. jajaja q risa.. ACEPTO q la era de tarja termino PERO NO PUEDEN DECIR ESO..

[skumpik666]

With Anette they are more industrial. Tarja's voice were 'adressated' to another kind of people, people that know what is music for real. Music in made for pleasure, not for fans and money! So I guess Tarja was better. Anette is tallentated and has a beautiful voice, but not for Tarja's songs. This song is great :D.

[Himynameistorres]

@skumpik666

-Have you ever heard the album "once" -Do you know the reasons why Tarja's got kicked out?

then you can tell me who is interested in the money. ;)

[asterionmetal]

@skumpik666 I hear a lot of celtic music and female singers have voices like Anette, so her voice is perfect for epic music AND for real music as you want to call it

[SilmeBetty]

There's nothing better than the moment when Jukka first hits the drums in the beginning of a song (:

[andreasosfp100]

@SilmeBetty  etsi!!!

[dasaintsman5121]

@SilmeBetty iagree 100% thunder from the heavens

[mattyguitar22]

@SilmeBetty i'm going to see them live on this tour for the first time ever! imagine, that moment but in real life, being there....

[bryn44]

With Anette, they were able to merge different styles and expariment more in my opinion. look how diverse DPP is.

[MrSavagevvv]

Anette has a good voice in the studio but SUCKS live

[mvcs1]

The new nightwish is different from the old nightwish, especially the style. So please stop saying which one is better.

[bombelek128]

tylko kurwa mi tu nie przeklinaj

[krzysiektr6]

co to kurwa za midi jest?

[1Richter1]

Tarja we miss you!

[1Richter1]

Instrumentals are awesome, vocals are - S#@T!!! -. Anette and Marco sing as if they needed air.

[emirhasa]

Marco's voice is less awesome without the back vocals singing

[Mercifulangelica]

YAY JUKKA!! the only reason I would go to a nightwish Concert since Tarja left.

[BryceIbanez17]

4:44 lol

[ZEROYOKO91]

@BryceIbanez17 DUDE HARDCORE!!!!!

[megadethcob666]

2:16 - 2:27 Ride the lightning Drumms xD

[greendayfen4e]

@megadethcob666 hah true

[celicniopanak]

i'm total fan on nightwish,but this sucks...

where the fuck is tarjaaaaaaaaaaa,LOVE her singing.......they are singing lik pop stars !!! emppu total can pass

[kickpit]

@celicniopanak If you were a fan, you would have known that she is no longer in the band. Great job, great band!

[theantarex]

Es curioso ver como una banda que te encanto se va al carajo, este tema es bueno, pero en estudio, en vivo adolecen de su vocalista que sin lugar a dudas es como el efecto Iron Maiden sin bruce de vocal, algo asi pasa con Nightwish, la banda que me gusto simplemente ya no existe...

[arieltheripper09]

@theantarex Para vos no existe!me vas a decir que el Dark Passion Play no existe??date por sordo, y acá Olzon cantó calcado al disco, aunque si desafinó Marco. Reconozco que da lugar tu comparación con Iron maiden porque Olzon no encaja en las canciones más antiguas, pero... que no existe?no me caen bien los exagerados.

[bacsek19]

ohh jesus... WTF is this shit? they are very bad and false in lve, you have to admire it

[Ann1405]

Marco best voice !!!!!!!

[oscarFeb17]

This is NW-Anette-Era...still poweful, still complex, still amazing. Tuomas and the guys found the way to merge the new singer...as for Tarja: bye bye beautiful!!!!

[roji556]

@oscarFeb17

The only reason Tarja left was because she was forced out by the record company and they wanted to sell "sex" with Anette instead.

[kiiuliiini]

@roji556 wtf its not true the reason why tarja "left" was because she was kicked from the band cause she was causing drama and didnt respect her fans, she was fighting with the band all the time! she went to the movies when they had a concert! She didnt even go to the band practises. Ive seen the letter they gave tarja that kicked her out, its in finnish so many people dont know about it but for gods sake dont say that they just want to sell sex with anette,fuck you! u r not a true fan!

[kiiuliiini]

@roji556 you are just a tarja fan, now old nw fan! if you were old nw fan, youd respect anette, because TUOMAS THE CREATER OF THIS AMAZING BAD CHOOSED ANETTE !!! So go fuck yourself please. :> greetings from finland you motherfucker

[roji556]

@kiiuliiini

Ah the finnish have always been guillible...and dumb. That's all that you know of, look at the Video of Bye Bye Beautiful and then look at ANY Tarja video. Anette is dressed in skimpy attire because the record company wanted to sell her body. That's obvious in the FIRST VIDEO THEY USED ANETTE IN, so research please beforehand. And not a true fan? I've been to EVERY concert that Nightwish has had with Tarja so please, more of a fan then you.

Oh and greetings from Sweden fucker.

[kiiuliiini]

@roji556 lol you dont even know in how many concerts i have been! And " And not a true fan? I've been to EVERY concert that Nightwish has had with Tarja so please, more of a fan then you." every concert that nightwish has had with tarja. you are a tarja fan xD and people from sweden are gay! you prove it. + anettes style is different than tarjas. GTFO

[fvalheim1]

annette rocks! but it seems the male voice is out off conditioning of his voice no offense but thats what i see

[IanasAnd]

Annete is 39 :S ? :O

[domiukas1]

@IanasAnd yup :)) Anette's birthdays was on june 21 :p shes 39 now.

[minotaur313]

@IanasAnd Yes, and I'd STILL fuck her!!!

[Ramzykh]

Nightwish is nothing without Taria Turunen

[emil9412]

@Ramzykh haha kinda funny u can't even spell her name :P

[BenioOwns]

@Ramzykh

gay _._

[mahrogmahrog]

Marco is the best:X:X.....amazing...awsome.­..cool

[BenioOwns]

@GoldenDream22

bullshit like you do not like to fuck

[dragoncraft12]

El vestuario de Anette

Como que se ve raro para estar en ese tipo de banda

:/ pequeña opinion

[tarjabeauty]

@dragoncraft12 x2

[shirlrita]

chale como hay gente q habla tan bien de ellos ahora si son una mierda en vivo con esa vocalista jajaja ni sus propias canciones con annete salieron bien ...

[benniponken]

Is this song dedicated to Tarja???

[moon1592]

@benniponken yeah... its was kind of disguised for a while lol

[boyan23maggot]

awesome.... Jukka is the best

[bonestorm99]

Marco's strugglin

[GloveMC]

@bonestorm99 Indeed, lmao

[bissa86]

hm.......nightwish, din pacate nu mai este ceea ce a fost, pina si in melodiile lor se observa acest lucru, parerea mea...........a fost mai bine inainte, cu Tarja Tuner.

[Hasohnir]

Hmmm this is probably one of my favourite songs, but Marco sounds much worse on live than he does in the studio :S Especially the "Bye bye beautiful" part sounds much weaker than in the studio

[JokerSpirit160]

pyro in the beginnings sweet

[lordithemaster]

anette's aaaa.. at 4:32 i think is too loud

[ThePenisman15]

3:12 O_O wtf...

[TheDespi23m]

anett so sweet and marco the best bassist

[TheDespi23m]

anette so hot sweet women and marco the best

[TheDafra]

VOLTA TARJA :s

[JEA21B]

This live sucked I have to say. both the band and the song are awesome but this one sucked. MY OPINION PPL, CHILL.

[lordifandk]

whats the deal with the very low guitar sound and way too high bass?

[cwooley77]

I agree, I cannot Stand Annette. She may sound decent on the cd, but she Slaughters their music live. They need Tarja Back to truly be nightwish. She was their Siren!!

[zpyna]

tarja is the best...ever!!!

[MrWildchild97]

This is not real Nightwish

[EatMe50000]

@MrWildchild97 This is Nightwish, i think you are confused about the singer? Targa was fired and a new lead singer is in nightiwish; Anette .

[uzumakiarual]

Hey i like it! sound like the most comercial song of NW, but i like the anette voice! so great to her that song!

[ragw33d]

i love how wacken film most of the sets

[SithBerserker1488]

This isnt in any way Better than the "End of an Era" Performance....

[GloveMC]

@SithBerserker1488 End Of An Era is End Of An Era, this sucks.

[ScooterCRO]

tayra4ever

[godinhomar]

bye bye your bitch.

Anette is terrible

[peguetas]

i liked the voice of anette

[TheDespi23m]

anette so sweet tarja noths sweet

[lordskelic]

Tuomas Owns All.

[3gk5]

omfg false SING!

[BluBolt09]

@3gk5 What do you mean, false sing?

[lordifandk]

@3gk5 what da fuck are you talking about? she sings very clear or are you just another of the anette hater or are you talking about marco?

[litlemadguitarist]

Poet and the Pendulum should be the first on the live setlist t be honest!

[Darknight1987]

awful voice, sry :X

[johannessssss]

Love it!

[xThevasilinax]

karalho velho anette canta d++ so fanzasso dela s2 =D

[SamvoltS]

may be she is hotter than Tarja...but Tarja sing thousand times better...and yeah sounds very soft...

[MrTenisMaster]

nightwish is sooo much better now....i love the way anette sings....and how she sounds live an everything...

[peguetas]

this song is perfect

[0llowain88]

Anette is a bitch >:(

[chechyveiraga]

NO........DEFINITIVAMENTE NO...!!

Nightwish se perdio totalmente cuando expulsaron a TARJA....eso no vale la pena oirlo...suenan orrible...!!...de verdad que que pesar que haan expulsado a tarja...ella era el triple de mejor que anette..!..y nightwish era el triple de mejor de lo que son ahora..!

[adr14ntr]

@chechyveiraga Si no vale la pena entnces para q te metes a ver un video que sabes q no t va a gustar??

Esta cancion es una de las mejores de Nightiwsh! Es extraordinaria... pero Tarja no es 3 vecesmejor que Annette es 10000000000 mejor pero aun asi Annette hace muy buen trabajo y la banda sigue siendo la mejor del mundo!

Nightwish forever!!

[dedlyduo1217]

tch...she makes nightwish too soft... i dont like it...

[rodrigolevel37]

great voice

[nimettka]

Oh my God... It's terrible.

[MegaTank88]

the sound is shit

[minerallover]

Marcos voice cracks at 3:12

[MGinGerFisHM]

keyboards and vocals flooded the rest...

[foxman123456789]

i think i like new nightwish compared to old nightwish