Most people think John has been the only main guitarist since the beginning, so somebody who knows who Hillel is, is presumably a proper fan. So you should atleast know about the Chilis chronology...I meen, COME ON, this song was written after Hillels death for fucksake. And to not be able to distinguish the difference between Hillel and John is pathetic really.
They should play this track now that Anthony has improved his vocal rance since then, I read that in some private rehearsal a friend requested them to play it, but Anthony refused, and I think that's because he feels insecure because it caused him troubles to reach the high notes in the past (like in this performance), the difference is that in this time was one of the singles and a staple in the setlist, nowadays is a very optional song.
@chilipeppers01 he complains to techs about the monitors in front of him, saying that it feels like a 5000 pound hummingbird is farting and shitting on his face with these monitors : ) i have the whole concert video, that's how i know it.
too many stupid people confuse hillel with john....1 easy way to check...look at the drummer....if its chad, then its john....but if its cliff/jack irons then its hillel!!!!!!
@srvfan42 John doesn´t like playing songs from Mother´s Milk anymore. He doesn´t like his guitar sound on this record. And now with Josh, I don´t think they will ever play these songs live :(
@GrimKage Yes, that is a shame. But that is my opinion, and I like Josh too, he is doing an awesome job. But John makes me scream like a little girl, Josh does not...
@KunioTaki That's not what I wrote. Don't you know how to read?! To clarify it for you, John makes ME scream like a little girl. I don't think John screams like a little girl when he sings, or talks for that matter.
If people get confused with John and Hillel, just look at the drummer. If it's Jack, then it's Hillel. If the drummer's Chad, then it's John. Damn these people are so damn stupid.
@CuteHotChiliPeppers if people get confused with john and hillel they should just figure out that john looks absolutely nothing like hillel. same with jack sherman.
@NyckMag cuz john doesnt like his work on mother's milk with the exception of higher ground and i dont know why they dont play anything from up lift mofo and down
the lyrics "if you see me getting high" means if you see me getting stoned, or in drugs or something like that? if its like that i think frusciante is the less indicated to sing that part :P i mean, he was in drugs in that times..
@carliarce its about heriorn and they all were doing heriorn at this time. Even after Slim died. They all werent clean till like 99 when by the way came out. John stopped like in 96 i think but jonas kept doing it for awhile.
Knock me down is a tribute for Hillel, it was written AFTER his death, so... indeed, John is the one playing in this video, he played and looked similar to hillel in that time though... anyway.... RHCP is the shit
I swear to fucking god you people! "Knock Me Down" was on their album Mother's milk that was released in 1989! hillel had already passed.. and if you are supposubly a RHCP fan then you should know the difference between John and Hillel!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
wait a minute, this can't be in 1990. Hillel Slovak died in 1988 but he is playing guitar in this video. after Hillel died the band hired John Frusciante.
um...this song was created after hillel died and was on the 1989 album Mother's Milk. John Frusciante played on that album. John Frusciante is playing in this video. This IS 1990.
@theloserific yes it was written for him, you're right. I was just saying that it was written FOR him, not BY him. John Frusciante plays on it, and is the one playing guitar in this video. I was just trying to clear up any confusion because some people think that it's Hillel in the vid.
@hailtheheelz Yeah it's great that you clearify that. I see many differences between them, although I still think they look a lot like each other. Both are legends and great musicians.
@badlikebart I swear to fucking god you people! "Knock Me Down" was on their album Mother's milk that was released in 1989! hillel had already passed.. and if you are supposubly a RHCP fan then you should know the difference between John and Hillel!
just because josh klingoffer is in the band now doesnt mean they r ganna be like the one hot minute era again. josh is a way better musician than dave.
yeah i agree with Sambtbass.....ya see the thing is they havent wrote a completely decent album since Blood Sugar. John has just got too dominant in the writing process and their albums have just been getting mellower and mellower. Iam hoping they will find the funk again and bring back a harder edge to their music. So although I love John for what he did for the band iam now glad hes gone or the band would of only got worse and faded out.
@rokstar48 We ll see bro, we ll see... But I dont agree about John, that he was too dominant and they lost they funky-style because of him, its not true! They had to, every band must to be comercialized a bit, album after album... Anyway, iam hoping too they ll find they old-style, thats could only one positive thing about John´s quit...
yeah it won't but it could be a good thing. they might go back to more funky stuff like this. if you look at john's recent solo stuff it's quite mellow so with a new guitarist we may get more funk. fingers crossed. there's no denying that john was AMAZING before he quite the first time though.
no its definatley Jack Sherman there first guitarist. Just kidding he was fired before Hilell came back a second time...half you people are plain dumb (the people who dont think its John F.)
God dammit people don't know anything about John Frusciante. Thats John this song wasn't even written when Hillel was alive. Also Chad wasn't in the band until a few months after John joined.
This song is overrated, have never heard this on a radio before, they deserve more recognision for songs from before Blood Sugar Sex Magik. I love that riff at the start :D
the best... rhcp forever... they make the best music.. <3 :)))))
Kristi7Noel 2 weeks ago
so much energy! I love the end where they're all singing together
Protains 2 weeks ago
sorry anthony for saying this, in this song [or in this version at least] your vocals irritate me so fuckin much. And it's bad but love this song
sick0304 1 month ago
thats a fucking lot of people there
roundabout145 2 months ago
@badlikebart
Most people think John has been the only main guitarist since the beginning, so somebody who knows who Hillel is, is presumably a proper fan. So you should atleast know about the Chilis chronology...I meen, COME ON, this song was written after Hillels death for fucksake. And to not be able to distinguish the difference between Hillel and John is pathetic really.
zXeCLiPzeXz 4 months ago
@zXeCLiPzeXz John did Mother`s Milk
schwba 2 months ago
"This is a lovesong" -3
lele634 4 months ago
is the tempo slowed down? its seems a lil slow
KransefaWoW 5 months ago
John has make up on...
ProfCake0licious 5 months ago
They should play this track now that Anthony has improved his vocal rance since then, I read that in some private rehearsal a friend requested them to play it, but Anthony refused, and I think that's because he feels insecure because it caused him troubles to reach the high notes in the past (like in this performance), the difference is that in this time was one of the singles and a staple in the setlist, nowadays is a very optional song.
DMusta1ne 6 months ago
i wonder if any one followed his instructions literally in the mid to late 90's when he had his relapse
jesusitsant 7 months ago
SO GOOD SONG!
vivi125 7 months ago
I kindof wanted to hear want anthony wanted to say
TheAlmostGod888 7 months ago
John with a Gibson? John with anything else but his Fender Strat or Telly?!
Do! Not! Want!
dvt1393 7 months ago
@dvt1393 Yeah, this Gibson sounds too aggressively for me.
Lolest1 7 months ago
@dvt1393 Check Fortune Faded or Readymade ;)
gOnStrat 7 months ago
So exciting on stage!
ExpertDude13 7 months ago
Why dont they play this song anymore? :C its so good
Laimonel 7 months ago 2
@Laimonel Anthony has trouble hitting the notes :/ you can tell in this video
DrCake11 6 months ago
@DrCake11 Ahh, it's sad. The recorded version is one my most favorite songs of their.
Laimonel 6 months ago
they should rescue this song for the next gigs
pedrocarlosleite 7 months ago 14
I feel that you felt Anthony.. You're the best for me..My friend
Knock me down too!!
fleaR2D2 7 months ago
inside (inside)
kroper13 7 months ago
"Si me ves volviéndome poderoso , si me ves siendo altruísta, derríbame, porque no soy mejor que la vida" Antonio Kiedies, 1990
Zco4cuerdas 8 months ago
Yeah it has to be Frusciante, but I got to admit he's changed so much over years that I can understand confusion ;)
bergjasper 8 months ago
I LOVE THE FRUSCIANTE'S OVERDRIVEN!!!
kaplanjoedudugames 9 months ago
yup..its John...
Chris31095 10 months ago
@ChiefWiggum26 That's so sad.. Those were some of their best songs..:(
srvfan42 10 months ago 3
@srvfan42 yea to be honest i think he did his best guitar work on this album. the only album that comes near it is bssm
added23 8 months ago
@added23 Agreed... areed.
srvfan42 8 months ago
my lovely man is about hillel
aakelsey 10 months ago
fml i was not 20 or older here. i wasnt even born yet. 3:49 to the end Anthony's facee! <3333 ughh orgasmm
ksbrownie1 10 months ago
To all people who mix up Hillel and Frusciante, go get raped by slim shady.
clamNshaun 11 months ago 2
I really want to know what Kiedis Has to say after the song!!
chilipeppers01 11 months ago
@chilipeppers01 he complains to techs about the monitors in front of him, saying that it feels like a 5000 pound hummingbird is farting and shitting on his face with these monitors : ) i have the whole concert video, that's how i know it.
NoChrReq 8 months ago
too many stupid people confuse hillel with john....1 easy way to check...look at the drummer....if its chad, then its john....but if its cliff/jack irons then its hillel!!!!!!
123ada321 11 months ago
For people who think it's Hillel look at the tattoos.
Commiteee 11 months ago
@Commiteee For people who thinks it's hillel check out the year
BrunoDiaz97 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@BrunoDiaz97 For people who thinks it's hillel.... are not true fans of RHCP!!! xD LOL
87RepoMan 9 months ago
So much emotion in anthony's voice. Do they even play this song at shows anymore?
srvfan42 11 months ago
@srvfan42 John doesn´t like playing songs from Mother´s Milk anymore. He doesn´t like his guitar sound on this record. And now with Josh, I don´t think they will ever play these songs live :(
ChiefWiggum26 10 months ago
Of course its john, assholes
I66Mhz 1 year ago
he even says take it johnny in the clip or something of that description. duh?
rhino0909 1 year ago
are you stupid?!
give a shit on the pictues and listen to his voice?!
Nerds....
RippedPantsBand 1 year ago
i love anthonys voice in this clip! :D very angry very good!
TwistofLemon12 1 year ago
essa música é muito foda...
jaimealternados 1 year ago
Thats how John looked back then and its how Josh looks now...
GrimKage 1 year ago 26
@GrimKage ive always noticed that
rockypc24 2 months ago
@GrimKage Except that John was and still is way more sexy and handsome than Josh, in my opinion.
MillaXilla 2 months ago
@MillaXilla Seriously, even with Josh's sexy voice? Plus John lost his original teeth to heroin =/
GrimKage 2 months ago
@GrimKage Yes, that is a shame. But that is my opinion, and I like Josh too, he is doing an awesome job. But John makes me scream like a little girl, Josh does not...
MillaXilla 2 months ago
@MillaXilla Well lets give Josh a chance, I think he's gonna make some awesome music with RHCP in the future
GrimKage 1 month ago
@GrimKage Indeed! I can't wait. :D
MillaXilla 1 month ago
@MillaXilla No, Josh screams/sings like a girl, not John, just listen to John Frusciante - Omission.
KunioTaki 1 month ago
@KunioTaki That's not what I wrote. Don't you know how to read?! To clarify it for you, John makes ME scream like a little girl. I don't think John screams like a little girl when he sings, or talks for that matter.
MillaXilla 1 month ago
@rafamine1995
high on what? maybe weed
at this time anthony was clean after hilles death and started taking at dave navarro ( one hot minute ) periode
Bullet19881988 1 year ago
yeah this is definitely Slovak.... playing a song AK wrote about Slovak dying.
tripjams 1 year ago
THIS IS A LOVE SONG
HMSAdiBOSS79 1 year ago 3
FAR TOOO SLOOOWWWWWW
TheSicDominator 1 year ago
knock me dddownn lol...
they played it slower than the original song
ohad156 1 year ago
This is the only version where it sounds live
Jolamarajami 1 year ago
Lol @ The guy thinking Hillel's playing this song...
Touch up on your RHCP knowledge a bit.
To be fair, the younger Frusciante did KIND OF look like Slovak, but still... this song is about his death...
BistroMcSex 1 year ago
mothers milk and BSSM r the best albums
dovlaBass 1 year ago 2
they should start playing this song live too its really great, they should switch this up instead me and my friends
sheptropremix 1 year ago
for my daughtas and their joint motha from anotha brotha aka joint sista from anotha mista! anthony kiedis used to be sooo hot!
nejakuchen 1 year ago
ho ho first tateoo
0wn3d17 1 year ago
i love the early years where anthony cant sing :D it matches perfectly with this fuckin funk songs from that time
FreaKKinG1996 1 year ago
It's ironic ... John write this song against the drugs :P
eykey89 1 year ago
@eykey89 its not talkin about high like a drug high, its talkin about being better than other people or higher above them
Masterreese1 1 year ago
If people get confused with John and Hillel, just look at the drummer. If it's Jack, then it's Hillel. If the drummer's Chad, then it's John. Damn these people are so damn stupid.
CuteHotChiliPeppers 1 year ago
@CuteHotChiliPeppers if people get confused with john and hillel they should just figure out that john looks absolutely nothing like hillel. same with jack sherman.
ledzeppelin4485 1 year ago
@ledzeppelin4485 That is true but some people are just either stupid or blind.
CuteHotChiliPeppers 1 year ago
@CuteHotChiliPeppers very true
ledzeppelin4485 1 year ago
i love the studio version of this song, but this SUCKS. faith no more were leagues ahead of this band. patton can actually sing aswell.
1zv 1 year ago
Why they don't play these years songs anymore?
NyckMag 1 year ago 3
@NyckMag cuz john doesnt like his work on mother's milk with the exception of higher ground and i dont know why they dont play anything from up lift mofo and down
fender714 1 year ago
man i love this song but they murdered it on this take - pretty slow and loose, still prob hadn't played in years, brushin out some cobwebs
gimmeshelter72 1 year ago
@gimmeshelter72 i agree, anthony sounds horrible in this version. sounds like he has a huge loogie in his throat or something.
sharkark 1 year ago
course its john. the song is about hillel and their love and missing him basically
06scorr 1 year ago
is that rly john on guitar???
ternalator 1 year ago
fuck 20 years ago
HolyLaguna13 1 year ago
WHAT WAS HE GOING TO SAY?
haza942 1 year ago
the lyrics "if you see me getting high" means if you see me getting stoned, or in drugs or something like that? if its like that i think frusciante is the less indicated to sing that part :P i mean, he was in drugs in that times..
carliarce 1 year ago
@carliarce its about heriorn and they all were doing heriorn at this time. Even after Slim died. They all werent clean till like 99 when by the way came out. John stopped like in 96 i think but jonas kept doing it for awhile.
ChicagoEnoughSaid 1 year ago
This must be John
Knock Me Down is a song by Anthony to Hillel, 'cause he loves him so much. And at the beginnig Anthony says, that this song is a love song.
"I want you back, but I get real. Can you hear my falling tears, making rain where you lay." From the original long version.
And the song was recorded in 1989, on Mother's Milk, an other reason why this can't be Hillel.
ChadSmithFanFinn 1 year ago
Ive read in Kiedis' book that its a 1st song written by John for RHCP
pashtettRB 1 year ago
Damn my favorite part! 3:17
mseerob 1 year ago
Knock me down is a tribute for Hillel, it was written AFTER his death, so... indeed, John is the one playing in this video, he played and looked similar to hillel in that time though... anyway.... RHCP is the shit
bloodsugarcrazy3 1 year ago
I swear to fucking god you people! "Knock Me Down" was on their album Mother's milk that was released in 1989! hillel had already passed.. and if you are supposubly a RHCP fan then you should know the difference between John and Hillel!
LexiTheRetard 1 year ago
thats definetly john, this from mothers milk.
Tom070994 1 year ago
you can see just where they evolved, so many musical movements that evolved and stayed, like some of chad's fills and john's signatures
guineapigsheep 1 year ago
It is John Frusciante. Hillel Slovak was already dead in 1990.
Bad singing by Anthony in this movie.
robu71830 1 year ago
if THAT is Hillel am I God! that truely John... sorry, but look once again, cuz that's NOT Hillel....
janeFRUSIE 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
wait a minute, this can't be in 1990. Hillel Slovak died in 1988 but he is playing guitar in this video. after Hillel died the band hired John Frusciante.
ps. great performance! :)
badlikebart 1 year ago
um...this song was created after hillel died and was on the 1989 album Mother's Milk. John Frusciante played on that album. John Frusciante is playing in this video. This IS 1990.
hailtheheelz 1 year ago 44
oh sorry, is that really John though? it looks like Hillel
badlikebart 1 year ago
@hailtheheelz Wasn't this song written for Hillel in the first place(becasue of his death)? May be wrong but that's what I thought. :/
theloserific 1 year ago 12
@theloserific yes it was written for him, you're right. I was just saying that it was written FOR him, not BY him. John Frusciante plays on it, and is the one playing guitar in this video. I was just trying to clear up any confusion because some people think that it's Hillel in the vid.
hailtheheelz 1 year ago 16
@hailtheheelz Yeah it's great that you clearify that. I see many differences between them, although I still think they look a lot like each other. Both are legends and great musicians.
WTSskillz 1 year ago
@hailtheheelz frusciante looks a lot like hillel here
ericcarr21 8 months ago
@theloserific Hillel Slovak -(April 13, 1962 – June 25, 1988) R I P my funky friend :)
daveyharsh 1 year ago
@hailtheheelz Pretty sure this is Josh.... Yep, defs Josh.
gsp227 4 months ago
@gsp227 Josh would have been a kid at this point in time haha
tigerkinglok 1 month ago
@badlikebart John does look a lot like Hillel, huh?
Mechz 1 year ago
@badlikebart I swear to fucking god you people! "Knock Me Down" was on their album Mother's milk that was released in 1989! hillel had already passed.. and if you are supposubly a RHCP fan then you should know the difference between John and Hillel!
LexiTheRetard 1 year ago
@badlikebart John Frusciante is playing here!
RHCPFreaklol 1 year ago
@badlikebart this song is a tribute to hillel's death
badfish350 1 year ago
@badlikebart Dude... It's John! They are pretty much like each other though.
WTSskillz 1 year ago
@badlikebart
What makes you think its Hillel? :P
RHCPThom 1 year ago
@badlikebart wow dude they released this song in 1989, after Hillel Slovack died
Billiejoesmithh 10 months ago
@badlikebart Fucking moron, that is John Frusciante playing!
PyrotechBrothers 8 months ago
@badlikebart are u sure man? xD
BRUTALDEATHn 5 months ago
Happy Birthday John Frusciante :)
DanPansza 2 years ago
@DanPansza who's definitly not there: hillel was not grave material yet.
rhythmcorp 1 year ago
? what?
DanPansza 1 year ago
just because josh klingoffer is in the band now doesnt mean they r ganna be like the one hot minute era again. josh is a way better musician than dave.
roadsidecoyotes83 2 years ago 3
the guitar here sounds as heavy as Navarro's. I don't know why people complain so much.
DonLduk 2 years ago 3
Maybe Flea'll start doing vocals again too :D
OutOfTheClosetProd 2 years ago 5
oh and can anyone tell me why they never play this song live anymore??
rokstar48 2 years ago 6
@rokstar48 because John never felt that the material on Mother's Milk was up to par w/anything following.
Although now that John is gone, maybe they'll start playing some of the earlier stuff again? Maybe that's the silver lining in all this...
OutOfTheClosetProd 2 years ago 2
@OutOfTheClosetProd yeah, and something off of one hot minute besides pea
bea5ToloG 2 years ago
yeah i agree with Sambtbass.....ya see the thing is they havent wrote a completely decent album since Blood Sugar. John has just got too dominant in the writing process and their albums have just been getting mellower and mellower. Iam hoping they will find the funk again and bring back a harder edge to their music. So although I love John for what he did for the band iam now glad hes gone or the band would of only got worse and faded out.
rokstar48 2 years ago
@rokstar48 We ll see bro, we ll see... But I dont agree about John, that he was too dominant and they lost they funky-style because of him, its not true! They had to, every band must to be comercialized a bit, album after album... Anyway, iam hoping too they ll find they old-style, thats could only one positive thing about John´s quit...
Havranek88 2 years ago
@Havranek88 thats what i was thinkin they might make itl probly be like one hot minuite i hope they go back to mothers milk style thatd be ever beter
garrydylanmarsh 2 years ago
is that a gibson????
corradobeerbroda 2 years ago
No - its Epiphone, or Stagg :D LOL! YEAH, Its LP black beauty - great guitar, i didnt know john used to play BB too...
Havranek88 2 years ago 2
no i can see by the headstock that its a gibson...
ilr111 2 years ago 4
And what i am saying? It was really stupit question, of course its Gibson!!!
Havranek88 2 years ago 4
it's a gibson les paul yeah (:
5ek1tor 1 year ago
chad hasn't changed a big
birdieboy91 2 years ago
woah, first time seeing chad like that...
JasonCFunk 2 years ago
fruscianteeeeeeeeee..never be the same without him :-[
paulrosscz 2 years ago 14
yeah it won't but it could be a good thing. they might go back to more funky stuff like this. if you look at john's recent solo stuff it's quite mellow so with a new guitarist we may get more funk. fingers crossed. there's no denying that john was AMAZING before he quite the first time though.
SamBTBass 2 years ago 2
no its definatley Jack Sherman there first guitarist. Just kidding he was fired before Hilell came back a second time...half you people are plain dumb (the people who dont think its John F.)
getoffwelfare 2 years ago 5
ye haha. jack sherman, their geek guitarist...
fildeps 2 years ago
It's definitely John Frusciante!
pattypeppers4ever 2 years ago 37
this is the most beautiful touching punk rock song ive ever heard
sheptropremix 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I don't think this is John
earydog 2 years ago
It is John, hes got the Octopus Tattoo
FruscianteII 2 years ago 9
it is John
hailtheheelz 2 years ago 9
Its john ,, cause slovak died in 1988
carliarce 2 years ago 6
God dammit people don't know anything about John Frusciante. Thats John this song wasn't even written when Hillel was alive. Also Chad wasn't in the band until a few months after John joined.
mikolene97 2 years ago 49
In fact, this song is in part a tribute to hillel...
SantiRedOx1 2 years ago 7
Thats more proof :]
mikolene97 2 years ago
it is 10000000%
paulpogues 2 years ago
Its young Johnny. lol
RHCPFreaklol 2 years ago 3
@RHCPFreaklol Wow, that is an old comment.
RHCPFreaklolNEW 1 year ago
wow, john with a les paul =]
imman033190 2 years ago 2
its a 'love song' about Hillel. .
RHCP for life
bjorkica5678A 2 years ago
Flea is god!
bassistfromholland 2 years ago
This is the period where John started not carrying about the band and hating being in the bad.. how sad :(
vivi125 2 years ago
i dont think it is that started after bssm released in 1991 and this is in 1990
hillelslovakrip 2 years ago
oh yea your right
vivi125 2 years ago
it's so lonely when you don't even know yourself, and that's right Johnny!
NoChrReq 2 years ago 3
Woops, I mean this song is underated. Please get rid of my -1.
jpdidit 2 years ago
Happy Birthday Anthony!!!
RedHotLove21 2 years ago 4
ahhhhh to slow!!!!
bostonkid828 2 years ago
This song is overrated, have never heard this on a radio before, they deserve more recognision for songs from before Blood Sugar Sex Magik. I love that riff at the start :D
jpdidit 2 years ago
Im sure you mean underrated?
InvisibleShoeLaces 2 years ago 6
is this the concert where pearl jam did play too?? or is it 92?
AsurorusA 2 years ago
man, the title says it all (1990)
shawnzorf 2 years ago
lol read carefully yo
im thinking if PJ does 90 or 92 with rhcp..not vice versa
AsurorusA 2 years ago
No, its the same festival but this is 1990 and pearl jam played 1992 i think.
pimhond 2 years ago
okay thanks yo
AsurorusA 2 years ago
flea has always had the best pants of the band
thetrevorchannel 2 years ago 2
If you love RHCP you should read Scar Tissue...
barbaracevasco 2 years ago 3
haha johnny playing a les paul who woulda thought it?
ColdGreenChili 2 years ago
They made this song after Mr. Slovak died, very good song my favorite from Mother's Milk.
kornflekes 2 years ago 2
rip hillel
hayleeep 2 years ago
thats john you know
genius7000 2 years ago
WOW! Great1 *****
funkyAviationpunk 2 years ago
top 10 songs of the chilis, so sensitive!!
LaGulaDelNorte 2 years ago 3
why cant they make songs like this anymore
their new songs are good
but their old songs were great
Burgio92 2 years ago 9