This song was made for Siobhan's voice, it suited her simplistic sounding, youthful voice. It just sounds bad for the others to cover it. XD Amelle's is too scratchy, Keisha has too much power in her voice and Heidi, well has that bombshell thing that isn't suited.
I think, it's acutally not bad with Keisha in the lead. Keisha did not have her own parts at overload, she only was the background singer then. I think Mutya also could have done the lead, but not Heidi and all the more not Amelle. Hearing this Song by Jade, Amelle and Heidi would also been very strange. But I think that most likely Jade could do the lead in this though (but still, I never ever want to hear this from 4.0).
I hate how keisha took siobhan's part. I think maybe heidi should've gotten it. I mean, she did replace siobhan. Keisha has her own part since she was in the original group when they released this. So it in my opinion keisha should sing her part, heidi should sing siobhan's part, and amelle should sing mutya's. Then again, nobody can really replace siobhan.
Im starting to see what you mean. I dont think anybody can do the vocals... i'm sry but i dont like how amelle sings mutya's parts. Amelle sings her parts good, but not mutya's. And heidi... i dont think she'd sound that good. So i guess keisha's the best choice.
haha, yea, heidi's got really high vocals, i don't think she could hit the notes siobhan could hit. so it made sense to have someone else with a lower tone be able to seen it.
I don't think Heidi could have really pulled of Siobhan's part in this song. Heidi is a soprano, therefore she typically sings the really high parts of songs. However, I do get what you're saying. I really like 3.0's version of "Overload".
Plus don't you think it would look super weird of Heidi and Amelle sang this song on lead? Because in the original Keisha doesn't have much solo parts, she's basically doing backup...
This song was made for Siobhan's voice, it suited her simplistic sounding, youthful voice. It just sounds bad for the others to cover it. XD Amelle's is too scratchy, Keisha has too much power in her voice and Heidi, well has that bombshell thing that isn't suited.
KayceeSparks 1 month ago
Ugh.. Heidi's screechy voice goes right through me! She's so shit!!!
simon2k4 3 months ago
I think, it's acutally not bad with Keisha in the lead. Keisha did not have her own parts at overload, she only was the background singer then. I think Mutya also could have done the lead, but not Heidi and all the more not Amelle. Hearing this Song by Jade, Amelle and Heidi would also been very strange. But I think that most likely Jade could do the lead in this though (but still, I never ever want to hear this from 4.0).
maritta2504 6 months ago
I hate how keisha took siobhan's part. I think maybe heidi should've gotten it. I mean, she did replace siobhan. Keisha has her own part since she was in the original group when they released this. So it in my opinion keisha should sing her part, heidi should sing siobhan's part, and amelle should sing mutya's. Then again, nobody can really replace siobhan.
oboefan 3 years ago 12
Keisha deserves to sing the lead vocals. Sh'e the only original member left.
yohan16 3 years ago 4
Im starting to see what you mean. I dont think anybody can do the vocals... i'm sry but i dont like how amelle sings mutya's parts. Amelle sings her parts good, but not mutya's. And heidi... i dont think she'd sound that good. So i guess keisha's the best choice.
oboefan 3 years ago 5
haha, yea, heidi's got really high vocals, i don't think she could hit the notes siobhan could hit. so it made sense to have someone else with a lower tone be able to seen it.
hangshimkim 2 years ago 2
yh i aggree wif u
XxsugababesfanxX 3 years ago 2
@yohan16 lol not anymore
jakedogz 2 years ago
@jakedogz low blow...lol
bibby445 2 years ago
Heidi admitted she didnt good in this when she joined in 2002 and they started to sing this
defekt8 2 years ago
Comment removed
maritta2504 2 years ago
siobhan is the best..
IcelandHorse6000 2 years ago
I don't think Heidi could have really pulled of Siobhan's part in this song. Heidi is a soprano, therefore she typically sings the really high parts of songs. However, I do get what you're saying. I really like 3.0's version of "Overload".
hangshimkim 2 years ago
Plus don't you think it would look super weird of Heidi and Amelle sang this song on lead? Because in the original Keisha doesn't have much solo parts, she's basically doing backup...
hangshimkim 2 years ago