I saw this rebroadcast last night on FOX news and I thought it was just a hilarious farce. There were several people who were obviously planted in the audience to discredit the Health Reform Bill: The polish doctor, the square-jawed Psychiatrist and the Ophthalmologist to name a few.
I feel sorry for the med students who were ridiculed for being "naive" just for questioning the false premises brought up by Beck and the plants.
Plus, Glenn Beck's incoherent rantings make no sense at all.
Glenn Beck should never be taken seriously. He's a clown for the entertainment of emasculated conservatives, who feel less impotent listening to his offensive nonsense. The outrage civil & rational people feel makes for good publicity & ratings
Fox news makes a lot of money from this latter day 'Mad Prophet' (for those of you who've seen the 1976 movie 'Network') Just look at the youtube hit counter
Those in power don't take him seriously and neither should you
Yes, that's called spin, but that doesn't change the fact that the original house AND senate versions of the bills contained those wordings that have since been removed or simply altered due to scrutiny.
Just to be fair , Fox news should also have a panel for those who went bankruptcy even with insurance, and those who were out of job and can't afford insurance.Doctors are making way too much money from typical average American and of course they are anti public health care fearing they will make less
These are real doctors, not those actors Obama had at the white house. What am i saying? Obama is an actor himself. He is on TV everyday playing president, because we know he dont know what the hell hes doing.
I like how the objections to Universal Health Care are centered around Poland's system, instead of the many more successful systems, like France, Germany, UK, Israel, etc. Instead of making trying to make ideological jabs at Universal systems when they see obscure examples of perceived downsides, they should take a more balanced look, as in acknowledge how much better these systems are than our system and see what lessons we can learn. They are not perfect, but they obviously do something right
Dr. McKalip is the same idiot circulating racist photos. Also Glenn Beck is a cancer of ignorance spreading misinformation only to benefit himself and create ratings.
Need to stop this "news" network from poisoning people with bad information and claiming that what they report are "facts". We live in a country where unfortunately people don't take the time to research for themselves and buy into whatever the goof ball (in this case Glenn Beck) spews out. Read people! Do serious research.
I'm from poland and the first polish doctor here is 100% right, my aunt is also a doctor studied in poland and came here because it was so bad in Poland.
You need to stop supporting shit that you know nothing about. Get a clue and stop being blinded by socialist ideology
Poland is ranked lower than us on the WHO rankings, so nobody is saying their health care system is better than ours. So in that case, lets look at all the industrialized countries, who all happen to have Universal coverage, that are ranked higher than us. Don't just attack "Socialized" medicine based on one country, so stop opposing shit you know nothing about. Get a clue and stop being blinded by right-wing ideology
So you criticize me for pointing t to countries with socialized med that are ranked lower than US but you yourself want to point to countries with socialized med that are ranked higher and make the argument that soc med is better. Do you not see the hypocrisy ? and Poland is not just one example, there are others.
I suggest reading on how the ranking is done(5 categories) and why it makes US look worse than rest when in reality it's opposite .google "WHO health care rankings explained"
You missed the point entirely, im saying instead of saying socialized medicine is bad based on one example, and i'd like to see what other examples you are talking about that are so much worse than our own system, im saying we should take lessons from systems that do perform better than ours on many, sometimes all, counts. And im separating "socialized" med with systems that achieve universal coverage, b/c there is more than one way to do this, hence the "lessons" we can take
Lol. You gotta be kidding MR GB. This is not a freaking a fourm. The respondents has so many legitimate concerns, but you twist their concerns to propagate your own agenda......come'on.
im a democrat but wow glenn beck is right this healthcare plan by the government sounds terrible and look at all these doctors telling us whats going to happen
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I don't even support glenn beck or one side or the other but this is an extremely valid debate from all sides. The people who blindly cast this off because "it's glenn beck" and "it's against our saviour, his holiest president obama" are just ignorant to the facts and use invalid points such as "it's not obamacare" to try to get their point across without providing real debate. If I call an orange and apple it doesn't change the fact that it's still an orange.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
People can call this obamacare all they want and that doesn't invalidate their argument. glenn beck and the doctors even SAY it's congress doing it, the problem is it's obama who has gone around the country blatantly lying and claiming this is THE ANSWER as is everything his holiness obama says. You people need to wake up and listen to all sides of the arguments on all issues instead of just listening to one side. The sheep will be led by one herder and the truly free will think for themselves.
yes, very ironic when you say straw-man argument when you make such a blanket statement such as "wow the irony" with no backing or rendering any support at all for such a statement. You're no different than all the chan kiddies who troll the internet and say "fucktard" rather than provide for a rational debate and merely attack people versus their statements.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Lest we forget, it was OBAMA who said we needed to stop debating the bailouts, stop arguing, and simply PASS IT while he KNEW it only benefited the already-rich bankers/wall street goons/companies. Now he is saying "let us handle YOUR LIVES (that's what healthcare is all about... duh...) and just PASS THIS NOW". Obama voted for the war, for more money time and time again, he forced everyone to pass the bailout and now this. Obama has been wrong, is wrong, and will always be wrong in all issues.
And it's not "Obamacare" you fucktards, it's "Congresscare", because it was congress that wrote the bill. Though at the same time, there are 6 lobbyists for every 1 congressperson trying to get in on the bill. Conservatives need to get mad at lobbyists, not Obama. Obama can't do shit if congress and the lobbyists keep getting in the way.
Fuck David McKalip and his racist fans. This was the guy caught circulating racist photoshops of Obama disguised as a witch doctor. People who support this man are vile scum that need to be quaranteened.
Nearly all medical association, medical student associations, nurses association and nurse student associations have endorsed Health Care Reform. The only medically related people that endorse Glenn Backs are people in nursing homes were they don't have other option than Fox news and the Arkham asylum patients
Why is Glenn Beck, who, some might be saying, raped and murdered a 12 year old girl in 1990 given a show on Fox?
Now I have no proof that Glenn Beck raped and murdered a girl in 1990, and I am quite sure that where I read that Glenn Beck might have raped and murdered a young girl in 1990 was labelled as a "parody" site.
Still, as long as this question hangs over Glenn Beck's head, (he hasn't denied it!) should anyone watch his show?
"Dr. David McKalip, the Tea Party movement anti-anti-reform activist who was caught circulating a racist email with a photo of loincloth wearing President Obama in the guise of a witch-doctor.
After we publicized the email, McKalip apologized, later said he was withdrawing from the public debate over health care and felt compelled to resign as the head of the local medical association."
Now hes back in support of the insurance industry. Really smart and dedicated.
That's a shame. I'll never understand how people can be so narrow-minded - the guy is a neurosurgeon which implies intelligence, but I suppose intelligence doesn't necessarily imply reason or wisdom.
Thanks for the heads up - I wasn't aware of that.
Hating Obama is like a religion for these people. Facts and evidence are irrelevent, Obama is evil personified to them. Attempting to persuade them is pointless.
I saw this rebroadcast last night on FOX news and I thought it was just a hilarious farce. There were several people who were obviously planted in the audience to discredit the Health Reform Bill: The polish doctor, the square-jawed Psychiatrist and the Ophthalmologist to name a few.
I feel sorry for the med students who were ridiculed for being "naive" just for questioning the false premises brought up by Beck and the plants.
Plus, Glenn Beck's incoherent rantings make no sense at all.
OriginalCinnamom 2 years ago
Who said anything about sarah palin in any of this?
Way to not provide any valid debate at all and attack sarah palin who has nothing to do with anything and has ceded any applicable power.
Way to keep making internet comments look stupid.
emptycorp 2 years ago
Glenn Beck should never be taken seriously. He's a clown for the entertainment of emasculated conservatives, who feel less impotent listening to his offensive nonsense. The outrage civil & rational people feel makes for good publicity & ratings
Fox news makes a lot of money from this latter day 'Mad Prophet' (for those of you who've seen the 1976 movie 'Network') Just look at the youtube hit counter
Those in power don't take him seriously and neither should you
Ignore him and he will go away
twinturbine 2 years ago
Yes, that's called spin, but that doesn't change the fact that the original house AND senate versions of the bills contained those wordings that have since been removed or simply altered due to scrutiny.
emptycorp 2 years ago
Just to be fair , Fox news should also have a panel for those who went bankruptcy even with insurance, and those who were out of job and can't afford insurance.Doctors are making way too much money from typical average American and of course they are anti public health care fearing they will make less
hatefailure 2 years ago
@ 13:52 David McKalip was on National TV for a racist e-mail that put Obama as an African witch Doctor.
onlyrey 2 years ago
Beck makes me ashamed to be human.
S3N909 2 years ago
These are real doctors, not those actors Obama had at the white house. What am i saying? Obama is an actor himself. He is on TV everyday playing president, because we know he dont know what the hell hes doing.
bigdogsdontbark 2 years ago
The doctors are making an excellent point. They are saying that they can not be trusted to do their jobs when it comes to care versus costs.
SamariaTV 2 years ago
Amazing that people actually take seriously anything Glenn Beck has to say about health care.
But then, it IS Fox News after all....
"If God puts a little tap back there ..." LOL.
SteveAndIdiAmin 2 years ago
I like how the objections to Universal Health Care are centered around Poland's system, instead of the many more successful systems, like France, Germany, UK, Israel, etc. Instead of making trying to make ideological jabs at Universal systems when they see obscure examples of perceived downsides, they should take a more balanced look, as in acknowledge how much better these systems are than our system and see what lessons we can learn. They are not perfect, but they obviously do something right
hokeypokey03 2 years ago 2
Dr. McKalip is the same idiot circulating racist photos. Also Glenn Beck is a cancer of ignorance spreading misinformation only to benefit himself and create ratings.
Need to stop this "news" network from poisoning people with bad information and claiming that what they report are "facts". We live in a country where unfortunately people don't take the time to research for themselves and buy into whatever the goof ball (in this case Glenn Beck) spews out. Read people! Do serious research.
DeVstatrOmga 2 years ago 2
13:49 lul
thefirstnotquitegone 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Fox news poll.............
:|
KlumzyAngel 2 years ago
health insurance should be for catastrophic purposes only, not a monthly service of doctor visits.
czargwar 2 years ago 3
I'm from poland and the first polish doctor here is 100% right, my aunt is also a doctor studied in poland and came here because it was so bad in Poland.
You need to stop supporting shit that you know nothing about. Get a clue and stop being blinded by socialist ideology
czargwar 2 years ago
Thats cause poland fuckin sucks. try spain, Germany or france, not some polak failed try at life.
WrxSti04 2 years ago
why
czargwar 2 years ago
Poland is ranked lower than us on the WHO rankings, so nobody is saying their health care system is better than ours. So in that case, lets look at all the industrialized countries, who all happen to have Universal coverage, that are ranked higher than us. Don't just attack "Socialized" medicine based on one country, so stop opposing shit you know nothing about. Get a clue and stop being blinded by right-wing ideology
hokeypokey03 2 years ago
So you criticize me for pointing t to countries with socialized med that are ranked lower than US but you yourself want to point to countries with socialized med that are ranked higher and make the argument that soc med is better. Do you not see the hypocrisy ? and Poland is not just one example, there are others.
I suggest reading on how the ranking is done(5 categories) and why it makes US look worse than rest when in reality it's opposite .google "WHO health care rankings explained"
czargwar 2 years ago
You missed the point entirely, im saying instead of saying socialized medicine is bad based on one example, and i'd like to see what other examples you are talking about that are so much worse than our own system, im saying we should take lessons from systems that do perform better than ours on many, sometimes all, counts. And im separating "socialized" med with systems that achieve universal coverage, b/c there is more than one way to do this, hence the "lessons" we can take
hokeypokey03 2 years ago
hokey, you're arguing with the dining room table....
jedgeco 2 years ago
Lol. You gotta be kidding MR GB. This is not a freaking a fourm. The respondents has so many legitimate concerns, but you twist their concerns to propagate your own agenda......come'on.
avo7007 2 years ago 2
im a democrat but wow glenn beck is right this healthcare plan by the government sounds terrible and look at all these doctors telling us whats going to happen
ProtossX 2 years ago
haha ur must not be a democrat if u think glenn beck is ever right
hokeypokey03 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I don't even support glenn beck or one side or the other but this is an extremely valid debate from all sides. The people who blindly cast this off because "it's glenn beck" and "it's against our saviour, his holiest president obama" are just ignorant to the facts and use invalid points such as "it's not obamacare" to try to get their point across without providing real debate. If I call an orange and apple it doesn't change the fact that it's still an orange.
emptycorp 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
People can call this obamacare all they want and that doesn't invalidate their argument. glenn beck and the doctors even SAY it's congress doing it, the problem is it's obama who has gone around the country blatantly lying and claiming this is THE ANSWER as is everything his holiness obama says. You people need to wake up and listen to all sides of the arguments on all issues instead of just listening to one side. The sheep will be led by one herder and the truly free will think for themselves.
emptycorp 2 years ago
wow the irony
hokeypokey03 2 years ago
yes, very ironic when you say straw-man argument when you make such a blanket statement such as "wow the irony" with no backing or rendering any support at all for such a statement. You're no different than all the chan kiddies who troll the internet and say "fucktard" rather than provide for a rational debate and merely attack people versus their statements.
emptycorp 2 years ago
i actually don't remember what i said wow the irony too since u've been voted down so many times that ur response is hidden
hokeypokey03 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Lest we forget, it was OBAMA who said we needed to stop debating the bailouts, stop arguing, and simply PASS IT while he KNEW it only benefited the already-rich bankers/wall street goons/companies. Now he is saying "let us handle YOUR LIVES (that's what healthcare is all about... duh...) and just PASS THIS NOW". Obama voted for the war, for more money time and time again, he forced everyone to pass the bailout and now this. Obama has been wrong, is wrong, and will always be wrong in all issues.
emptycorp 2 years ago
but it does confirm that it's not an apple, which is what ur trying to attack. Basic straw-man argument
hokeypokey03 2 years ago
I bet Kim Jung Il would love to kidnap Beck so that he could make propaganda tapes for him.
kdwormy 2 years ago 2
And it's not "Obamacare" you fucktards, it's "Congresscare", because it was congress that wrote the bill. Though at the same time, there are 6 lobbyists for every 1 congressperson trying to get in on the bill. Conservatives need to get mad at lobbyists, not Obama. Obama can't do shit if congress and the lobbyists keep getting in the way.
the2989 2 years ago 4
Glenn Beck is a disease that corrupts the minds of gullable idiots.
the2989 2 years ago 10
Fuck David McKalip and his racist fans. This was the guy caught circulating racist photoshops of Obama disguised as a witch doctor. People who support this man are vile scum that need to be quaranteened.
the2989 2 years ago 5
Nearly all medical association, medical student associations, nurses association and nurse student associations have endorsed Health Care Reform. The only medically related people that endorse Glenn Backs are people in nursing homes were they don't have other option than Fox news and the Arkham asylum patients
frigoria 2 years ago 4
This presentation brought to you by Cigna, Aetna, and the guy who makes $107,000 AN HOUR at United Health.
JustsayinAgain 2 years ago 7
Why is Glenn Beck, who, some might be saying, raped and murdered a 12 year old girl in 1990 given a show on Fox?
Now I have no proof that Glenn Beck raped and murdered a girl in 1990, and I am quite sure that where I read that Glenn Beck might have raped and murdered a young girl in 1990 was labelled as a "parody" site.
Still, as long as this question hangs over Glenn Beck's head, (he hasn't denied it!) should anyone watch his show?
Mumon7 2 years ago 8
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Good video
Dr. David McKalip is a smart an dedicated guy - if you're interested he wrote an excellent article about health care here:
campaignforliberty. com/article. php?view=217
cmstyz 2 years ago
From TPM:
"Dr. David McKalip, the Tea Party movement anti-anti-reform activist who was caught circulating a racist email with a photo of loincloth wearing President Obama in the guise of a witch-doctor.
After we publicized the email, McKalip apologized, later said he was withdrawing from the public debate over health care and felt compelled to resign as the head of the local medical association."
Now hes back in support of the insurance industry. Really smart and dedicated.
foodope 2 years ago 5
That's a shame. I'll never understand how people can be so narrow-minded - the guy is a neurosurgeon which implies intelligence, but I suppose intelligence doesn't necessarily imply reason or wisdom.
Thanks for the heads up - I wasn't aware of that.
cmstyz 2 years ago 2
This is a great show - one of the only ones I was able to watch until the end!
toknow07 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Its good to hear what the doctors say.
If they wont like Obama healthcare - we wont be #1 in quality healthcare anymore
toknow07 2 years ago
Hating Obama is like a religion for these people. Facts and evidence are irrelevent, Obama is evil personified to them. Attempting to persuade them is pointless.
rangerthree 2 years ago 13
This comment has received too many negative votes show
rangerthree-
Your Probably from those who spent 8 Years fighting Bush - and now your in your 9th Year!!
toknow07 2 years ago
Which one of the doctors is the one that fucked up Glenn's anal surgery?
MidnightChimes 2 years ago 8
Dude that blonde girl in the first row is drop dead gorgeous
thecoolerstinger 2 years ago
...and she doesn't say a thing the whole time. :) How much you want to bet she was either planted or was told to sit there because she was hot?
Arsenal3077 2 years ago
Dude its fox, of course she was there b/c she was hot. This video doesnt do her justice i saw it on tv.
thecoolerstinger 2 years ago
I wonder how much the writers make...
CelicetheGreat 2 years ago 2
The public option which is being proposed is not tied to medicare/medicaid reimbursement rates.
Flirmy 2 years ago