Im muslim, This is very sad. No innocents deserve to die. I wasnt aware of this so thank u AK and evryone else part of the video. When it comes to things like this, people should unite despite wat differences we have. I have alot of respect for sikhs
im sad to say that i never knew about the anti-sikh riots until i saw this video, thank you so much for making it, im now doing a little research on it so i can educate myself, thank you
ITS PRETTY FUCKED UP TO SEE INDIANS KILL OTHER INDIANS. US PUNJABIS ARE THE PROTECTORS OF INDIA...IF WE DID NOT EXIST....INDIA WOULD NEVER HAVE EXISTED.
why is it that this video isnt based on all religions who were there on that day? along with sikhs, hindus/muslims and other faiths were affected by the governments actions !
@lilkapz "hindus.." are affected? LOL..was the holiest Hindu mandir demolished? 60,000 disappeared? 10,000 men/women/children massacred in 72 hours a in capital city? i think not sir_i think not_why only our religion is covered? because there are only 25 million of us_most of the world doesn't know what a Sikh is let alone the injustices of 1984...its called AWARENESS_that's plenty of Hindu/Muslim videos out there too_you've come to 1 of 120,000,000 videos on youtube if you aren't aware
@jattboi88 sorry kid but you go on like Sikhism is a dying religion. just ten years ago there was only 19 million... now theres 25 million...
i think ya people are doing fine, stop whinging because hindus were enslaved for over 4 centuries.. plenty die everywherre, making awareness is one thing, but developing hatred for your neighbour is another
i speak as a person with brown skin, i dont understand why we create our own divisions in the world. its pathetic
other videos create an awareness, but since the majority that died on the tragic day you decided to discuss, others died to ALONG with sikhs...
they are worth a mention, ya videos seem narrow minded as if to say nobody but the sikhs that died at that moment were the only ones worth a corcern..
i know plenty of hindus and muslims from whats considered punjab on the map... you tryna tell me not a single paki or guju or hindu punjabi got shot either intentionally or on purpose...
@lilkapz never mentioned Sikhism was a dying religion_mentioned it was the world's least numerous_while we're Sikhs and we want to talk about issues affecting Sikhs_you and the rest of India can pretend to be one big happy family_ what you call whining, we call educating our younger generation_Sikhs dont whineeee_the body ridden bodies of O'dwyer, Indra Gandhi, and the many others who have oppressed us are sure proof of that, kid.
@jattboi88 you got a nerve with ya bullshit, you think by venting anger against the people who we're responsible for something that happened over 25 years ago will bring anyone back. If anything you grow and indulgence of hate against those you consider responsible.. deep down inside you and many like you - you think theres a particular band of people involved in some sick plot to rid the world of the 25 million strong Sikhs.. your fragile my child ;) carry on blood, and you are BLOOD
@lilkapz LOL its not gonna bring anyone back u cunt_but its important to hold people accountable for such dastardly action against innocent people, especially when some of these people are still running for political office . i dont hate anyone_no religion_no people_i just want justice served for those who lost everything_
@lilkapz LOL we aint one people_i dont believe in attributing animal features to gods lol_thats not hating_i just dont_"my child" LOL_although u might want to talk to your mother_i might owe you a few child support payments hahaha
@jattboi88 saying things like that shows ya true colour and understanding of life really is.. dont make this personal. its only humans liek you that segment us, cast us and place us to be one thing or another.
i cant lower myself to you, my mum taught me standards - maybe ask yours where you lost yours BROTHER.. lol though it burns you inside when a hindu/pakistani/iranian/chinese/russian/dominican etc call you one
disregard for other cultures and hatred towards your fellow man wont help you reach any level of wisdom or enlightenment but just a vision, as empty as you.
@lilkapz but i only hate hindus lol jokes_don't know man you came across as one of those india-centric cricket watching douchebags_if you didn't mean any offense then neither did i_my mom did teach me standards_she also taught me not to take shit off no one_but this conversation is gettin painful boring_so peaceee
@lilkapz you friggen Gandhian lol_the world doesn't work that way_i wish it did too but it doesn't_oppressive violence must be answered with violent resistance_if you don't believe that_that's fine_but dont discuss Sikhism or waste your time on Sikh videos then_because that is what we believe_we dont believe in injustice violence_Sikhism praises the act of violence when committed as an act of self-defense_and that's my religion_we're not hiding anything
@jattboi88 idiot, why say peace then if you dont mean to wish anyone that isn't sikh peace
your delirious. why say shit like gandhian? does it have anything to do with me.. nope.. just because you can't target to be something your against you'll act like an idiot to try an irritate people trying to teach your slow ass not to be ignorant.. instead you waffle about sikhs being warriors.. i know plenty about your culture, its shameful that you know fuck all about mine.
dont reply if your gonna act like your 5 lad.. shit like gandhian and other pointless dribble makes you look that way.. im sure you'll get support for it.. but are those people the kind you wanna be acknowledged by warrior?
PEACE, look it up in a dictionary since you dont even see fit to understand the definition, and if your mum taught you to be civil why do you speak like an animal?
@lilkapz haha dude i've used the same words you have ie "shit" "fuck"_okay let me get this right_you're not indian nor sikh_but do you have a life? why the fuck are you on this video? you've got people on here describing one of the most violent massacres post the holocaust_where men, women and children were set ablaze for being part of a certain religion, instead of condemning that, you come on here and start criticizing ppl tryna spread the word_how dare they raise awareness aye?
@lilkapz only had the allies said we want peace and hitler wouldve stopped right? haha you're a fucken clown man_you don't understand anything_prolly read a few things on Guru Nanak and claim to know Sikhism_you dont know our struggle_dont know the events leading up to 1984_yet you come on this video and act like the moral authority championing world peace like a fag_PEACE will come with JUSTICE_IM A MAN and sometimes i swear_doesn't make me any less human_u stereotyping fool
Am Sikh, what happened was bad, I lost family myself, but every religion has a few bad people that spread hatred, we cant let the riots stop Hindus and Sikhs from being peaceful.....
Every thing is true! SIKHS got dealt the death card by hindus trying to wipe out the sikhs!
The past is the past, and let it be, burt never forget what happened to us! Not everyone is bad, but there are a few bad eggs who can infulence the entire country into hating another religion! look what they done to the christians in Goa, everyone should have the right to practise whatever religion they what without fear!
@MrRickyjcolon you live in a fantasy of hatred against hindus.. im shocked at some of the comments on this video
this is a powerful tool fuelling minds with very disturbing thoughts. please wake up to the real world and think outside the box for a second. with the level of corruption and twisted individuals running the entire world you choose to concentrate on one top until it drives you crazy with hatred to the point where you hurt someone innocent yourself. wake up!
break all divisions as no sikh, hindu or muslim has a right to any land but all land should be for all humans to use. nothing determines the right to border land to one kind of people..
We need to forget about the past and make a brighter future for India where Sikh and Hindu's can both live in peace. Yes whatever happened in 1984 wasn't right but dwelling on the past isn't going to do much then to separate and build more tension between Hindus and Sikhs.
This video could not have been better and I can not explain how much I appreciate the message being sent out. It broke my heart to watch those clips. You guys are doing the right thing.
Whats sad is that the Indian General was sikh, Kuldip Singh Brar, how could this coward attack his own people. Some indian army soldiers were also sikh...how can this ppl live with themselves. Great video.
Screw this corrupt government! As a Muslim I dearly love my Sikh and Hindu brothers! Its the corrupt capitalist system which is trying to separate us!
tuhano aethe kisi da support nahi milega, giving support to some of the khalistanis or islamist or in future god forbids if it happens they would also support any hindu terrorists. They are against India and not helping any religion. Waise v jedi country bani hi ik religion te hove ona nu secularism da ki pata.meinu ta aena pataa hai ki appan hindustani pela haan fer asi hindu sikh muslim isai haan. Jai hind, and still proud to have indian and punjabi blood in me.
Yaaro im a hindu and sikh both..As my dad is a hindu and mom a sikh. I feel very bad looking at this video or others on same topic. But remind you that, it wasnt the sikhs who died neither was it hindus. It was humanity which died in my country. I dont live in India but India lives in me. Meinu hun v aapne desh te pura fakr hai. Meinu ae v pataa hai ki mein ya mere baaki hindu sikh dost, sab mil jul k rehne haan.Haanji pakistanio just get out of here.
not 84 but 80s were dark spot in history of punjab and India.....BOth sides were equally at falt u cant do shit bout it now ...all but try to avoid the deaths that happned.
thatz really shit broo i agree lot of sikh died in that tragedy i am a sikh as well but now let every 1 live in peace . dnt make a difference between hindu and sikh .. just forget it about that ....there nothing we can do about past ,the only thing we can do just make ur future good as much u can ..thanks
@wass786 because it took place in a "democratic" country. the indian government did and has made a tremendous effort to conceal the events of 1984 that put them in a bad light.
@gorasikh5340 wow I'm not indian you might be able to tell, but i seriously thought this stuff only happens in pakistan where my great grandparents are from not in india one of the worlds biggest economies. poor souls rip
You left out a really serious point in the making of this video. You left out that these attacks were a act of revenge on the Sikhs. The Hindus were very upset that a group of 2 Sikhs had assassinated Indian Prime Minister Indra Ghandhi because they opposed her military actions against the Sikh people. I am not justifying the brutal killings, it was wrong and should not have happened. Now my question, how can you ask for justice from killings that were a result of an in just act?
@MrPuffyism Your statement, I believe, contains the answer to your question. A group of TWO Sikhs assassinated Mrs. Gandhi, for desecrating one the holiest shrines of the Sikhs. The Hindus retaliated by murdering (savagely too, I might add) COUNTLESS, INNOCENT Sikhs for what Satwant and Beant Singh did. Just? I think not.
Remarkable video... Love it but all the people taking sides r the kind of people who caused that in 84... Please just learn from our mistakes n rebuild the world... We don't always get second chances... Im Punjabi n Im proud but i have nothing against other races n religions... Just cause SOME Hindus did that bk then doesn't mean everyone approved.
I'm glad you guys took the time to make a video bringing up the topic. I'm Punjabi (granted, from Pakistan), grew up in the U.S., and I'd never hear of these 1984 events. Just getting the knowledge out there is a really good thing.
The Khalistan movement is stronger overseas than in India. Reason 1980s-90s huge emigration of Sikhs..Indian Sikhs have evolved. India (Under 1984 admin) was responsible for human rights violations.. but so were the Sikh fundamental groups. I feel these videos don't do a good job in illustrating the events of 1984. You see this with a lot of these Youtubers. Cultural attitudes and personal beliefs provide strong biases. Please take the academic approach to the events of 1984.
There will be justice - God is above time and space - and He is the final Judge of us all. May Heaven preserve all Sikhs, true seekers after truth and justice, and worshippers of the True Name.
Why the fuck are you all fighting they made this video for us to stop and take 2 seconds out of our lives to remember. Don't fight this was made for us to come together
@1991jasdeep i'd think most of the dislikes were at the beginning when the stories are being explained.. i felt disgusted, and i wanted to "dislike" - i couldn't "like" the video out of respect for those who died.
@lau131528 explain why you sikhs needed guns, grenades, rocket launcher and other weapons? in your religion you are entitled to carry a kerpan/sword for protection, that is all. why do you need such deadly weapons? clearly you were participating in a terrorist movement supported by porkshitstan. so drop the act for we all know 1984 was dreadful.bhinderwala fucked you up and then people in Delhi fucked you up
What in the world are you talking about? Why we needed guns, grenades, rocket launchers and other weapons? Elaborate please. Even if a group of Sikhs had all the weapons listed above, the whole Sikh community didn't ever deserve the injustices that went on in 1984.
@desi8jaath i dont want to argue but maybe go to a gurdawara and learn from the beging about the maybe about our firstguru in religion and just saying if u r a hindu my guru gave his head to save ur religion and how about this u think if someone's army came and fucken litterly tryed to capture ur faiths leader or someone ur people think is right and ur temple could get
distroy a veryholy place wouldnt u fuckin protect it and i believe bhinderwala is not a terrorist ok so screw off
@desi8jaath also think whatever u want cuz there were people who were slaterd that day and some people who died protecting one man and they deserv to be remeberd
blame the govt, not the hindus, the employees werent all hindus, they even were muslims, hindus, compelled to do it, please dont make any racist comments.
its all the hindus..their the ones always making trouble..they think their so above everyone else..smh sheesh... oh and do sikhs have shaheeds too?? i know about us muslims...but im guessing that u mean shaheeds as in martyrs...people who die because of injustice or who die for a cause>> right?
@desi8jaath WOOOOWWW.....if u knew anything..ud know that "shaheed" is an arabic word..and if im not mistaken the sikh religion has no apparent link to any arabs or arabic..though islam does..the main language of islam in arabic..so yeah WE do have shaheeds...and no need for name calling.. the apparent "incest" happens in ur society aswell..have a FINE day :D
It ws indra Gandhi who did it.....Fuck these politicians !!! Muslim-hindu riots ,Sikh-hindu riots...only bcs of this gandhi family n other culprits !!
I never have hated a hindu ... what I hate is INJUSTICE .. and INDIA really PAID good tribute to Guru´s and Those shaheed who died against mughals and britishers by giving CRIMINALS high positions in their PARLIMENT. This is the justice of INDIA :)
@desi8jaath I made your momma swallow my jizz whilst ur sister sucked on by balls u fagget muthafucka.. where abouts do u live? cuz i know if i came up to ur hindu homo ass u wuld shit yoself cuz all u pussy hindus the same bitch.. front on fb... bet u a puff in real life... tell u what tho, i would cum inside laxmi if that consoles the fact that ur all ugly fuckers
@desi8jaath I made your momma swallow my jizz whilst ur sister sucked on by balls u fagget muthafucka.. where abouts do u live? cuz i know if i came up to ur hindu homo ass u wuld shit yoself cuz all u pussy hindus the same bitch.. front on fb... bet u a puff in real life... tell u what tho, i would cum inside laxmi if that consoles the fact that ur all ugly fuckers
i agree with wtv happend in 1984 wasnt something that shud've happend but in this video hindus are being showed as we were the only one who killed...but ppl from both sides were killed... lot of hindus were killed too.. i think lot of ppl dnt even know wat happend & are making disgusting comments at each others religion.we belong to one country India and we shud stick together...remember countries like Pak & China want us to be divided...
@Silentstriker2288 Indeed and anyone who is of decent mind will know that. There are two sides of a coin. It was never the construed Hindu = Evil, Sikh = Good, that some quarters try desperately hard to portray.
@Silentstriker2288 i really are we from one country then why NO justice has been given tills today ... If we really are from one country then why ARE killers sitting on top positions in Indian Parliment.... if we really are from one country then why DO sikhs gurus and warriors called Hindu/Muslim and not SIKHs? ...... Are we really from one country ... ???
@grudingOyster u can think wtv u like i wont argue with u...i have no problem with Sikhs and Im Hindu...i have lots of Sikh friends and we get along fine..our PM is a Sikh and i have great respect for him...u need to change ur thinking....hatred wont help...we need to be united...long live India!
@grudingOyster have a fucking cry about it douchebag! "killers sitting in top positions in parliament" take another look at the parliament dickface! your daddy manmohan is the fucking PRIME MINISTER! the top-most position. he's a sikh, why doesnt he bring "justice". I know why, because there is NO justice to be brought! nothing happened! you motherfuckers became terrorists and our awesome army raped you filthy hairy dirty sikhs! :D
@desi8jaath Reading your comments... I know you ARE AN ASSHOLE ... it does matter how clamly I will talk 2 you, you will still rape anyone ... with anyone I mean your OWN MOTHER AND SiSTER too ... Now from onwards every comment you write will be about HOW I GAVE A METALROD IN YOUR FAMILIES ASS :) ... come on start writing HOW @grudingOyster GAVE METAL ROD IN @desi8jaath FAMILIES ASS
@desi8jaath well, first of all, one sikh position in the indian government cant really do anything, even if he wanted to bring justice he couldnt. you think the other HINDU politics would agree to that? And second of all, OUR fucking army is mostly made up of sikhs, dumb ass. and obviously the army beat them becouse there was probably 5X more army troops than your so called "terrorists". third of all, sikhs arent dirty, the cleanest city in india is Chandigarh dumbass,thats in punjab
Why dont all u hindus and sikhs respect each other fuckkk getting annoying i cant say alot either bz im muslim and we muslims fight with hindus to freekin annoyed
what's wrong with you all !? seriously ! cursing each other wont settle what happen before. im a sikh and i scream out loud that justice hasn't been served, but by cursing each other nothing is going to happen. WE ARE ALL FROM ONE FKN COUNTRY AND THAT IS INDIA! NO MATTER WHAT RELIGION WE COME FROM, WE ALL ARE INDIANS! AND WE WILL ALWAYS BE! so stop being so fkn immature and stand up for what's right.
u r not a human.. if this video does not gives you goosebumps.. we will avenge them, we will break the silence.. nd we wont never ever forget chauraasi (84)
why are you all fight, one of the reason we should remember is so we see what hate can cause, don't fight because of something that has already past if you continue to fight over the mistakes of the past you will in one way or another repeat the mistakes. So stop fight and forget your hate and remember what it will lead to.
@awesomeali786 thousands of Hindus were dragged out of buses, their homes and showered with AK 47 bullets, even kids and old were not spared that's disgusting.
EVERY single swear word,discrimination against one other has a consiquence.even on this internet.who are you people to judge others baised on religion.now i have come to realization that the genecide had to happen in order for something to consequently take place after.you cant control this.if you take ANGER,FEAR+ HATERED OUT of ur heart you CAN THEN CHANGE OTHERS.THIS IS KALYUG..save youre sould from the demon.may knowledge and wisdom be blessed upon you.
@amitkriit bindranwala supported the progangda which was given to him by congress. breaking india? tell me if im wrong arnt there hindu states which demand a independent hindu state? manipur, tamil nadu, , nagaland. punjab never demanded a separate nation, but a soverign state ! and, more sikhs died in punjab thn hindus, several thousand went missing . you guys got your 'justice' by butchering people on the streets and when it came to our justic , the govt gave us a so called commission ?
@jassitiwana according to Human Rights Watch, 85% of all those killed in Militant violence were Hindus. Tell me what was the fault of those men women and children who were dragged out of their homes and buses and then showered with AK 47 bullets just because they were Hindus? I am just saying that both sides were at fault, and ur community is not completely innocent. Gurdaspur district which was Hindu-majority is now Sikh majority, thanks to large scale massacres and migration.
171 dislikes are from Hindus
manu703 14 hours ago
IT WAS INDRA GANDHI ATTACK NOT BY ""HINDUS""....THEY LOVE US THEY R NOT KILLERS....STOP SHOWING THESE RACISTS.....WE R SAME..WE R INDIAN.
simran6023 1 week ago
IT WAS AN INDRA GANDHI ATTACK....NOT BY HINDU'S ...STOP SHOWING THESE RACISTS...HINDUS LOVE US...HINDUS ARE'NT KILLERS!!!
simran6023 1 week ago
SCREW INDIRA GHANDI !! SOME WOMEN GOT RA**ED CUZ OF GHANDI
HyperAndAwesome 1 week ago
Im muslim, This is very sad. No innocents deserve to die. I wasnt aware of this so thank u AK and evryone else part of the video. When it comes to things like this, people should unite despite wat differences we have. I have alot of respect for sikhs
rb2489 1 week ago
sikhs like us shoudnt get treated like that
fantasy11121 1 week ago
One word: Amazing!..........keep up the great work. Finally the educated youth taking up the challenge where our (the older) generation failed.
chamkila911 2 weeks ago
The thing I HATE about this video, is that it's all true..
TheAR1128 2 weeks ago in playlist More videos from AKakaAmazing 2
the thing i like about this video is that it is all true
MrTejbir21 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
171 People don't have a heart!!
ShailesHezky 3 weeks ago
Im a muslim, neva knew about these anti sikh riots till i saw this video, thanks for upload,
. Got loads of respect for sikhs !!!!!
n786j 3 weeks ago 5
Amazing u r doing the great job... M from BC n m with u guys in this noble cause... Keep it up
harsimranranu 3 weeks ago
im sad to say that i never knew about the anti-sikh riots until i saw this video, thank you so much for making it, im now doing a little research on it so i can educate myself, thank you
pr1y 1 month ago in playlist More videos from AKakaAmazing
OMG MY BIRTHDAY IS JUNE 25TH AND IM SIKH
starkaran25 1 month ago
GOOSEBUMPS !!!!
ishranjitsingh 1 month ago
Both sides were affected guys....
jahajboeing 1 month ago
Fuck u thedragon967 violence is nvr da.answer an dats all u care bout
CarlosSpicyweiner52 1 month ago
ITS PRETTY FUCKED UP TO SEE INDIANS KILL OTHER INDIANS. US PUNJABIS ARE THE PROTECTORS OF INDIA...IF WE DID NOT EXIST....INDIA WOULD NEVER HAVE EXISTED.
TheDragon967 1 month ago
I think AK should've disabled comments..... Great vid tho.
keslerovechkin6895 1 month ago
why is it that this video isnt based on all religions who were there on that day? along with sikhs, hindus/muslims and other faiths were affected by the governments actions !
lilkapz 1 month ago
@lilkapz "hindus.." are affected? LOL..was the holiest Hindu mandir demolished? 60,000 disappeared? 10,000 men/women/children massacred in 72 hours a in capital city? i think not sir_i think not_why only our religion is covered? because there are only 25 million of us_most of the world doesn't know what a Sikh is let alone the injustices of 1984...its called AWARENESS_that's plenty of Hindu/Muslim videos out there too_you've come to 1 of 120,000,000 videos on youtube if you aren't aware
jattboi88 1 month ago
@jattboi88 sorry kid but you go on like Sikhism is a dying religion. just ten years ago there was only 19 million... now theres 25 million...
i think ya people are doing fine, stop whinging because hindus were enslaved for over 4 centuries.. plenty die everywherre, making awareness is one thing, but developing hatred for your neighbour is another
i speak as a person with brown skin, i dont understand why we create our own divisions in the world. its pathetic
lilkapz 1 month ago
other videos create an awareness, but since the majority that died on the tragic day you decided to discuss, others died to ALONG with sikhs...
they are worth a mention, ya videos seem narrow minded as if to say nobody but the sikhs that died at that moment were the only ones worth a corcern..
i know plenty of hindus and muslims from whats considered punjab on the map... you tryna tell me not a single paki or guju or hindu punjabi got shot either intentionally or on purpose...
lilkapz 1 month ago
@lilkapz unintentionally*
lilkapz 1 month ago
@lilkapz never mentioned Sikhism was a dying religion_mentioned it was the world's least numerous_while we're Sikhs and we want to talk about issues affecting Sikhs_you and the rest of India can pretend to be one big happy family_ what you call whining, we call educating our younger generation_Sikhs dont whineeee_the body ridden bodies of O'dwyer, Indra Gandhi, and the many others who have oppressed us are sure proof of that, kid.
jattboi88 1 month ago
@jattboi88 you got a nerve with ya bullshit, you think by venting anger against the people who we're responsible for something that happened over 25 years ago will bring anyone back. If anything you grow and indulgence of hate against those you consider responsible.. deep down inside you and many like you - you think theres a particular band of people involved in some sick plot to rid the world of the 25 million strong Sikhs.. your fragile my child ;) carry on blood, and you are BLOOD
lilkapz 1 month ago
inspite of all thats said and done, we all are one people.
lilkapz 1 month ago
@lilkapz LOL its not gonna bring anyone back u cunt_but its important to hold people accountable for such dastardly action against innocent people, especially when some of these people are still running for political office . i dont hate anyone_no religion_no people_i just want justice served for those who lost everything_
jattboi88 1 month ago
@lilkapz LOL we aint one people_i dont believe in attributing animal features to gods lol_thats not hating_i just dont_"my child" LOL_although u might want to talk to your mother_i might owe you a few child support payments hahaha
jattboi88 1 month ago
@jattboi88 saying things like that shows ya true colour and understanding of life really is.. dont make this personal. its only humans liek you that segment us, cast us and place us to be one thing or another.
i cant lower myself to you, my mum taught me standards - maybe ask yours where you lost yours BROTHER.. lol though it burns you inside when a hindu/pakistani/iranian/chinese/russian/dominican etc call you one
PEACE BROTHER. =P
lilkapz 1 month ago
disregard for other cultures and hatred towards your fellow man wont help you reach any level of wisdom or enlightenment but just a vision, as empty as you.
lilkapz 1 month ago
@lilkapz but i only hate hindus lol jokes_don't know man you came across as one of those india-centric cricket watching douchebags_if you didn't mean any offense then neither did i_my mom did teach me standards_she also taught me not to take shit off no one_but this conversation is gettin painful boring_so peaceee
jattboi88 1 month ago
@jattboi88 i watch cricket, something i enjoy with my pops. doesnt mean you can establish whether or not im an idiot because of it
i support zambia not that its relevant anyway. dont say peace for the sake of it, else its another meaningless expression given to one another.
peace.
lilkapz 1 month ago
@lilkapz you friggen Gandhian lol_the world doesn't work that way_i wish it did too but it doesn't_oppressive violence must be answered with violent resistance_if you don't believe that_that's fine_but dont discuss Sikhism or waste your time on Sikh videos then_because that is what we believe_we dont believe in injustice violence_Sikhism praises the act of violence when committed as an act of self-defense_and that's my religion_we're not hiding anything
jattboi88 1 month ago
@jattboi88 idiot, why say peace then if you dont mean to wish anyone that isn't sikh peace
your delirious. why say shit like gandhian? does it have anything to do with me.. nope.. just because you can't target to be something your against you'll act like an idiot to try an irritate people trying to teach your slow ass not to be ignorant.. instead you waffle about sikhs being warriors.. i know plenty about your culture, its shameful that you know fuck all about mine.
lilkapz 1 month ago
@jattboi
dont reply if your gonna act like your 5 lad.. shit like gandhian and other pointless dribble makes you look that way.. im sure you'll get support for it.. but are those people the kind you wanna be acknowledged by warrior?
PEACE, look it up in a dictionary since you dont even see fit to understand the definition, and if your mum taught you to be civil why do you speak like an animal?
lilkapz 1 month ago
@lilkapz haha dude i've used the same words you have ie "shit" "fuck"_okay let me get this right_you're not indian nor sikh_but do you have a life? why the fuck are you on this video? you've got people on here describing one of the most violent massacres post the holocaust_where men, women and children were set ablaze for being part of a certain religion, instead of condemning that, you come on here and start criticizing ppl tryna spread the word_how dare they raise awareness aye?
jattboi88 1 month ago
@lilkapz only had the allies said we want peace and hitler wouldve stopped right? haha you're a fucken clown man_you don't understand anything_prolly read a few things on Guru Nanak and claim to know Sikhism_you dont know our struggle_dont know the events leading up to 1984_yet you come on this video and act like the moral authority championing world peace like a fag_PEACE will come with JUSTICE_IM A MAN and sometimes i swear_doesn't make me any less human_u stereotyping fool
jattboi88 1 month ago
AWESOME BUT......it wouldn't have hurt if it was memorized O.o
asdfghjklasdfghjk35 1 month ago
Am Sikh, what happened was bad, I lost family myself, but every religion has a few bad people that spread hatred, we cant let the riots stop Hindus and Sikhs from being peaceful.....
Consecotaleophobias 1 month ago
did anyone else shiver and feel there hairs stand up, thank you aka and everyone else in the video!
GrimeGFX 1 month ago
i am proud to be a Sikh !!!!!!!!!!!
MrTejbir21 1 month ago 24
@MrTejbir21 yes yes soo proud i'll die 4 my faith
xJ1nd4K4urx 3 weeks ago
Every thing is true! SIKHS got dealt the death card by hindus trying to wipe out the sikhs!
The past is the past, and let it be, burt never forget what happened to us! Not everyone is bad, but there are a few bad eggs who can infulence the entire country into hating another religion! look what they done to the christians in Goa, everyone should have the right to practise whatever religion they what without fear!
MrRickyjcolon 1 month ago
@MrRickyjcolon you live in a fantasy of hatred against hindus.. im shocked at some of the comments on this video
this is a powerful tool fuelling minds with very disturbing thoughts. please wake up to the real world and think outside the box for a second. with the level of corruption and twisted individuals running the entire world you choose to concentrate on one top until it drives you crazy with hatred to the point where you hurt someone innocent yourself. wake up!
lilkapz 1 month ago
JO BOOOOLLLLEEE SOOOOO NIHAAAAAAALLLLLLLLLLLLLL!!!!
SAT SRI AKAAAAAAALLLLL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! <3
Pakistan was smart for taking the land for themselves... WE SHOULD HAVE DONE THE SAME!!!! OH WELL ....WE ALREADY CONQUERED THE WORLD!!!
MrJawl 1 month ago
@MrJawl dividing the land does not make us free
break all divisions as no sikh, hindu or muslim has a right to any land but all land should be for all humans to use. nothing determines the right to border land to one kind of people..
you fool
lilkapz 1 month ago
We need to forget about the past and make a brighter future for India where Sikh and Hindu's can both live in peace. Yes whatever happened in 1984 wasn't right but dwelling on the past isn't going to do much then to separate and build more tension between Hindus and Sikhs.
krazzy415 1 month ago
i started crying
deepak1231837 2 months ago
This video could not have been better and I can not explain how much I appreciate the message being sent out. It broke my heart to watch those clips. You guys are doing the right thing.
PotterMyLife 2 months ago
This video was made to keep peace between hindus and sikhs. Cant we just stop fighting?
IndianMaharaja27 2 months ago
Whats sad is that the Indian General was sikh, Kuldip Singh Brar, how could this coward attack his own people. Some indian army soldiers were also sikh...how can this ppl live with themselves. Great video.
TonyBby 2 months ago
nob hed
MrAdilafsar 2 months ago
is it me or wen i see just regin face i start laughin
galaxysonu 2 months ago
Screw this corrupt government! As a Muslim I dearly love my Sikh and Hindu brothers! Its the corrupt capitalist system which is trying to separate us!
Pharmentist 2 months ago
tuhano aethe kisi da support nahi milega, giving support to some of the khalistanis or islamist or in future god forbids if it happens they would also support any hindu terrorists. They are against India and not helping any religion. Waise v jedi country bani hi ik religion te hove ona nu secularism da ki pata.meinu ta aena pataa hai ki appan hindustani pela haan fer asi hindu sikh muslim isai haan. Jai hind, and still proud to have indian and punjabi blood in me.
hellowmates 2 months ago
Yaaro im a hindu and sikh both..As my dad is a hindu and mom a sikh. I feel very bad looking at this video or others on same topic. But remind you that, it wasnt the sikhs who died neither was it hindus. It was humanity which died in my country. I dont live in India but India lives in me. Meinu hun v aapne desh te pura fakr hai. Meinu ae v pataa hai ki mein ya mere baaki hindu sikh dost, sab mil jul k rehne haan.Haanji pakistanio just get out of here.
hellowmates 2 months ago
I feel sad now and its christmas day but its true.
cnpanesar98 2 months ago
Comment removed
alteejm 2 months ago
its going to 28 years since 1984 but no justice for Sikhs. ABSOLUTE NO JUSTICE.none at all.
and now still with that many Sikhs died no justice
MsJoto33 2 months ago
not 84 but 80s were dark spot in history of punjab and India.....BOth sides were equally at falt u cant do shit bout it now ...all but try to avoid the deaths that happned.
tanujarora45 2 months ago
thatz really shit broo i agree lot of sikh died in that tragedy i am a sikh as well but now let every 1 live in peace . dnt make a difference between hindu and sikh .. just forget it about that ....there nothing we can do about past ,the only thing we can do just make ur future good as much u can ..thanks
deep096deep 2 months ago
woooow! this stuff is deep, how come its not publicised more?
wass786 2 months ago
@wass786 because it took place in a "democratic" country. the indian government did and has made a tremendous effort to conceal the events of 1984 that put them in a bad light.
gorasikh5340 2 months ago
@gorasikh5340 wow I'm not indian you might be able to tell, but i seriously thought this stuff only happens in pakistan where my great grandparents are from not in india one of the worlds biggest economies. poor souls rip
wass786 2 months ago
You left out a really serious point in the making of this video. You left out that these attacks were a act of revenge on the Sikhs. The Hindus were very upset that a group of 2 Sikhs had assassinated Indian Prime Minister Indra Ghandhi because they opposed her military actions against the Sikh people. I am not justifying the brutal killings, it was wrong and should not have happened. Now my question, how can you ask for justice from killings that were a result of an in just act?
MrPuffyism 2 months ago 7
Comment removed
alteejm 2 months ago
@MrPuffyism Your statement, I believe, contains the answer to your question. A group of TWO Sikhs assassinated Mrs. Gandhi, for desecrating one the holiest shrines of the Sikhs. The Hindus retaliated by murdering (savagely too, I might add) COUNTLESS, INNOCENT Sikhs for what Satwant and Beant Singh did. Just? I think not.
Spideramun 2 weeks ago
@MrPuffyism fucku... if u dnt know the facts don't talk shit .. .. now that's a justice to ur fucktard comment
harman6681 1 week ago
@MrPuffyism A group of 2 SIKHS (JUST TWO?!). Yet they had to take it out on all of us.
JHEEEEEEEEZ 2 days ago
Remarkable video... Love it but all the people taking sides r the kind of people who caused that in 84... Please just learn from our mistakes n rebuild the world... We don't always get second chances... Im Punjabi n Im proud but i have nothing against other races n religions... Just cause SOME Hindus did that bk then doesn't mean everyone approved.
dipinjit 3 months ago
respect to sardar and sardarni in video but dislike hair cutted people in video
jassgrewal1111 3 months ago
@jassgrewal1111 im bald so i guess im gonna burn in hell
lilkapz 1 month ago
respect
angad287 3 months ago
Are you ppl having some organization of yours in India helping the suffered Sikh families in their fight for justice, would really like to help.
jpsingh159 3 months ago
what happen on 1984
taimuraadin 3 months ago
@taimuraadin sikh holocaust 1984 look it up
XXsunnyproductionsXX 2 months ago
NEVER EVER FORGET 84
freakoid7 3 months ago
Never forget 84
prabjeetmaan 3 months ago
PEACE
PoojaMissan 3 months ago in playlist More videos from AKakaAmazing
Comment removed
vishifishi01 3 months ago in playlist More videos from AKakaAmazing
We support u. But dont forget Babri Masjid too
imranasifchaudhry 3 months ago
I'm glad you guys took the time to make a video bringing up the topic. I'm Punjabi (granted, from Pakistan), grew up in the U.S., and I'd never hear of these 1984 events. Just getting the knowledge out there is a really good thing.
zinniakhan92 3 months ago 44
LONG LIVE KHALISTAAN
1SUPERGOGS 3 months ago
IM PROUD TO HAVE MY USERNAME ..Hindufags
hindufags 3 months ago
The Khalistan movement is stronger overseas than in India. Reason 1980s-90s huge emigration of Sikhs..Indian Sikhs have evolved. India (Under 1984 admin) was responsible for human rights violations.. but so were the Sikh fundamental groups. I feel these videos don't do a good job in illustrating the events of 1984. You see this with a lot of these Youtubers. Cultural attitudes and personal beliefs provide strong biases. Please take the academic approach to the events of 1984.
Alpinex105 3 months ago
There will be justice - God is above time and space - and He is the final Judge of us all. May Heaven preserve all Sikhs, true seekers after truth and justice, and worshippers of the True Name.
72Yonatan 3 months ago
this is amazing ...... very touching !
the1mightygod 3 months ago
Why the fuck are you all fighting they made this video for us to stop and take 2 seconds out of our lives to remember. Don't fight this was made for us to come together
party101ist 3 months ago
thats a sick instrumental! can i has?
fofox21 3 months ago
FUCK YOU, HEARTLESS DISLIKERS !!!!
1991jasdeep 4 months ago 44
@1991jasdeep i know right dumbshits
SupaPandaPus 1 month ago
@1991jasdeep HOLY SHIT MY NAME IS JASDEEP but i spell it jasdip but it is prounced the same lol
MutiPlayer09 1 month ago in playlist More videos from AKakaAmazing
@1991jasdeep i'd think most of the dislikes were at the beginning when the stories are being explained.. i felt disgusted, and i wanted to "dislike" - i couldn't "like" the video out of respect for those who died.
gb9514 1 month ago
this is complete bullshit the government used hindus for a cover up
footbalfrk25 4 months ago
EVERYBODY SHUT UP AND EXPLAIN TO ME WHAT IS GOING ON!!!
47474747z 4 months ago
@lau131528 explain why you sikhs needed guns, grenades, rocket launcher and other weapons? in your religion you are entitled to carry a kerpan/sword for protection, that is all. why do you need such deadly weapons? clearly you were participating in a terrorist movement supported by porkshitstan. so drop the act for we all know 1984 was dreadful.bhinderwala fucked you up and then people in Delhi fucked you up
desi8jaath 4 months ago
@desi8jaath
What in the world are you talking about? Why we needed guns, grenades, rocket launchers and other weapons? Elaborate please. Even if a group of Sikhs had all the weapons listed above, the whole Sikh community didn't ever deserve the injustices that went on in 1984.
karenk321 3 months ago
@desi8jaath i dont want to argue but maybe go to a gurdawara and learn from the beging about the maybe about our firstguru in religion and just saying if u r a hindu my guru gave his head to save ur religion and how about this u think if someone's army came and fucken litterly tryed to capture ur faiths leader or someone ur people think is right and ur temple could get
distroy a veryholy place wouldnt u fuckin protect it and i believe bhinderwala is not a terrorist ok so screw off
lau131528 2 weeks ago
@desi8jaath also think whatever u want cuz there were people who were slaterd that day and some people who died protecting one man and they deserv to be remeberd
lau131528 2 weeks ago
blame the govt, not the hindus, the employees werent all hindus, they even were muslims, hindus, compelled to do it, please dont make any racist comments.
vishaal143 4 months ago
this made me cry...
kjaswin1988 4 months ago
@kjaswin1988 looking at yourself in the mirror would make you cry too..asshole
desi8jaath 4 months ago
@desi8jaath anger management? your time wld probably be better spent banging your head against the wall =)
kjaswin1988 4 months ago
what are they talking about
47474747z 4 months ago
@47474747z they are just talking shit..its nothing important. making a big deal out of nothing.
desi8jaath 4 months ago
Today is 31st October 2011
27 Years Of Injustice..
NEVER FORGET 1984!
navkiran1000 4 months ago
its all the hindus..their the ones always making trouble..they think their so above everyone else..smh sheesh... oh and do sikhs have shaheeds too?? i know about us muslims...but im guessing that u mean shaheeds as in martyrs...people who die because of injustice or who die for a cause>> right?
yusaraahmed25 4 months ago
@yusaraahmed25 what shaheeds are you motherfucking incest muslims talking about? you have suicide bombers not shaheeds!
desi8jaath 4 months ago
@desi8jaath WOOOOWWW.....if u knew anything..ud know that "shaheed" is an arabic word..and if im not mistaken the sikh religion has no apparent link to any arabs or arabic..though islam does..the main language of islam in arabic..so yeah WE do have shaheeds...and no need for name calling.. the apparent "incest" happens in ur society aswell..have a FINE day :D
yusaraahmed25 4 months ago
what exaclty is going on?
StunningHijabi 4 months ago
It ws indra Gandhi who did it.....Fuck these politicians !!! Muslim-hindu riots ,Sikh-hindu riots...only bcs of this gandhi family n other culprits !!
RKay777 4 months ago
who ever disliked this has no heart and can go smd
the23boss23 4 months ago
fuckin hindu's
ImaSingh 4 months ago
I never have hated a hindu ... what I hate is INJUSTICE .. and INDIA really PAID good tribute to Guru´s and Those shaheed who died against mughals and britishers by giving CRIMINALS high positions in their PARLIMENT. This is the justice of INDIA :)
grudingOyster 4 months ago
The ones who disliked are the ones who are ignorant.
XcOoKiExMoNsTa0X 4 months ago
Damn. This gave me chills and got me tearing up..
paneet24 4 months ago
KHALISTAN ZINDABAD
pernellwhitaker1 4 months ago
@pernellwhitaker1 i will fuck your mother and sister simultaneously while i make you and your father watch :D
desi8jaath 4 months ago
@desi8jaath I made your momma swallow my jizz whilst ur sister sucked on by balls u fagget muthafucka.. where abouts do u live? cuz i know if i came up to ur hindu homo ass u wuld shit yoself cuz all u pussy hindus the same bitch.. front on fb... bet u a puff in real life... tell u what tho, i would cum inside laxmi if that consoles the fact that ur all ugly fuckers
pernellwhitaker1 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@desi8jaath I made your momma swallow my jizz whilst ur sister sucked on by balls u fagget muthafucka.. where abouts do u live? cuz i know if i came up to ur hindu homo ass u wuld shit yoself cuz all u pussy hindus the same bitch.. front on fb... bet u a puff in real life... tell u what tho, i would cum inside laxmi if that consoles the fact that ur all ugly fuckers
pernellwhitaker1 3 months ago
:(
Rajvir0444 4 months ago
BREAK THE SILENCE!!!
hindufags 4 months ago
its so awkward to see jusreign serious :))
pinkberryglee 4 months ago
i agree with wtv happend in 1984 wasnt something that shud've happend but in this video hindus are being showed as we were the only one who killed...but ppl from both sides were killed... lot of hindus were killed too.. i think lot of ppl dnt even know wat happend & are making disgusting comments at each others religion.we belong to one country India and we shud stick together...remember countries like Pak & China want us to be divided...
Silentstriker2288 5 months ago
@Silentstriker2288 Indeed and anyone who is of decent mind will know that. There are two sides of a coin. It was never the construed Hindu = Evil, Sikh = Good, that some quarters try desperately hard to portray.
kumarsa108 4 months ago
@Silentstriker2288 i really are we from one country then why NO justice has been given tills today ... If we really are from one country then why ARE killers sitting on top positions in Indian Parliment.... if we really are from one country then why DO sikhs gurus and warriors called Hindu/Muslim and not SIKHs? ...... Are we really from one country ... ???
grudingOyster 4 months ago
@grudingOyster u can think wtv u like i wont argue with u...i have no problem with Sikhs and Im Hindu...i have lots of Sikh friends and we get along fine..our PM is a Sikh and i have great respect for him...u need to change ur thinking....hatred wont help...we need to be united...long live India!
Silentstriker2288 4 months ago
@grudingOyster have a fucking cry about it douchebag! "killers sitting in top positions in parliament" take another look at the parliament dickface! your daddy manmohan is the fucking PRIME MINISTER! the top-most position. he's a sikh, why doesnt he bring "justice". I know why, because there is NO justice to be brought! nothing happened! you motherfuckers became terrorists and our awesome army raped you filthy hairy dirty sikhs! :D
desi8jaath 4 months ago
@desi8jaath Reading your comments... I know you ARE AN ASSHOLE ... it does matter how clamly I will talk 2 you, you will still rape anyone ... with anyone I mean your OWN MOTHER AND SiSTER too ... Now from onwards every comment you write will be about HOW I GAVE A METALROD IN YOUR FAMILIES ASS :) ... come on start writing HOW @grudingOyster GAVE METAL ROD IN @desi8jaath FAMILIES ASS
grudingOyster 4 months ago
@desi8jaath well, first of all, one sikh position in the indian government cant really do anything, even if he wanted to bring justice he couldnt. you think the other HINDU politics would agree to that? And second of all, OUR fucking army is mostly made up of sikhs, dumb ass. and obviously the army beat them becouse there was probably 5X more army troops than your so called "terrorists". third of all, sikhs arent dirty, the cleanest city in india is Chandigarh dumbass,thats in punjab
kabirthepunjabi 3 months ago
BREAK THE SILENCE !!
simmukhosla 5 months ago 6
Why dont all u hindus and sikhs respect each other fuckkk getting annoying i cant say alot either bz im muslim and we muslims fight with hindus to freekin annoyed
2pkjs1351 5 months ago 2
@2pkjs1351 Most of us do thank you very much. Youtube is not representative. It gives the marginal views of respective communities a voice.
kumarsa108 4 months ago
i'm shivering.
TheSid786 5 months ago
STFU ALL OF YOU RASICT LIL SHITS CANT U JUST SIT BACK AND LISTEN TO WHAT THERE SAYIN
gwal31 5 months ago
@gwal31 fuck u comments are seen not heard dumbass
hindufags 5 months ago
IM MUSLIM BUT WHY DON'T U GUYS RESPECT EACH OTHER WHAT EVER FAITH U ARE. I MEAN WE'RE ALL THE SAME AT THE END OF THE DAY.
hammy78698 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
President of Pakistan teaching his children the spelling of Assassination*
* One ass behind another ass, behind that I, and behind me the whole nation.*
OurThoughtExactly 5 months ago
The chick is hot.
whydoiwearnexus 5 months ago
Scheiß Punjabi...!!!!
Dissmonger 5 months ago
sure hindus died as well people but the hindus asked for it, dont mess with the sikhs, we're a warrior race, we're not going down without a fight
genharmdog 5 months ago
what's wrong with you all !? seriously ! cursing each other wont settle what happen before. im a sikh and i scream out loud that justice hasn't been served, but by cursing each other nothing is going to happen. WE ARE ALL FROM ONE FKN COUNTRY AND THAT IS INDIA! NO MATTER WHAT RELIGION WE COME FROM, WE ALL ARE INDIANS! AND WE WILL ALWAYS BE! so stop being so fkn immature and stand up for what's right.
siimii02 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I am Young uprising artist who just wants his music to be heard by a lot of people
I mean you don't have to like but if you can spare a few seconds and just check
out my music and my channel I would be highly appreciative of that and also
please subscribe and help a young brown boy make his dreams come true and
also tell your friends family cousins neighbors just anyone you know to listen to
my music and help me to become a well liked rapper
TheMoking4 5 months ago
NEVER FORGET 1984 Proud Sikh =]
navkiran1000 5 months ago
u r not a human.. if this video does not gives you goosebumps.. we will avenge them, we will break the silence.. nd we wont never ever forget chauraasi (84)
roughplayer9 5 months ago
This actually made me cry a lil
aniebbe 5 months ago
why are you all fight, one of the reason we should remember is so we see what hate can cause, don't fight because of something that has already past if you continue to fight over the mistakes of the past you will in one way or another repeat the mistakes. So stop fight and forget your hate and remember what it will lead to.
TheIndianUser 6 months ago 4
@awesomeali786 thousands of Hindus were dragged out of buses, their homes and showered with AK 47 bullets, even kids and old were not spared that's disgusting.
amitkriit 6 months ago
i hope you all know.of all races this:
EVERY single swear word,discrimination against one other has a consiquence.even on this internet.who are you people to judge others baised on religion.now i have come to realization that the genecide had to happen in order for something to consequently take place after.you cant control this.if you take ANGER,FEAR+ HATERED OUT of ur heart you CAN THEN CHANGE OTHERS.THIS IS KALYUG..save youre sould from the demon.may knowledge and wisdom be blessed upon you.
foxyehfly 6 months ago
Jeounda rahoo yaaro never Forget 1984 ,,,, Break the silence
MrRockisback 6 months ago
wad da fuck
mir4510 6 months ago
muslim solidarity with my sikh brothers! i dont care what u have to say to me... so bring on the ignorant comments.
WTFaiq 6 months ago
@WTFaiq yeah losers united lol
amitkriit 6 months ago
@desi8jaath yesssss sirr
johhyboy12 6 months ago
Never forget 1984
johhyboy12 6 months ago
@johhyboy12 yeh never forget how the golden temple harbored terrorists.
desi8jaath 6 months ago
i beleive whoever did this had no relegion....
nharneet 6 months ago
Any one explain what was that?
glOock2 6 months ago
WHY WOULD PPL THUMBS Down this? Only haters would
hindufags 6 months ago
@hindufags was ur dad a fag? Is this why ur mother had to fuck every homeless guy on the street to have u?
amitkriit 6 months ago
@amitkriit shut the hell up shit hindu
HinduShit1 6 months ago
@HinduShit1 I bet ur mother is the best whore in her locality. How much does she charge to the ragheads?
amitkriit 6 months ago
@amitkriit was ur mom raped by homeless men sleeping on footpaths
shit hindu exposed
HinduShit1 6 months ago
@HinduShit1 are ur parents related?
amitkriit 6 months ago
@amitkriit bindranwala supported the progangda which was given to him by congress. breaking india? tell me if im wrong arnt there hindu states which demand a independent hindu state? manipur, tamil nadu, , nagaland. punjab never demanded a separate nation, but a soverign state ! and, more sikhs died in punjab thn hindus, several thousand went missing . you guys got your 'justice' by butchering people on the streets and when it came to our justic , the govt gave us a so called commission ?
jassitiwana 6 months ago
@jassitiwana according to Human Rights Watch, 85% of all those killed in Militant violence were Hindus. Tell me what was the fault of those men women and children who were dragged out of their homes and buses and then showered with AK 47 bullets just because they were Hindus? I am just saying that both sides were at fault, and ur community is not completely innocent. Gurdaspur district which was Hindu-majority is now Sikh majority, thanks to large scale massacres and migration.
amitkriit 6 months ago
@jassitiwana I say justice must be served to all victims, irrespective of their religion. This is the duty of the government.
amitkriit 6 months ago
@amitkriit No ur mom was u motherfukin bastard. Go fuck your brahmin dad u son of a bitch
hindufags 6 months ago 8
@hindufags do you still get your dinner from your mother's breasts?