I love poetry and I love this poem more than any other. I feel this is truly the most moving interpretation I've ever seen/heard of "When you are old". I don't just praise without really good cause, I have to feel it deeply ! Both her facial expressions AND the emotions in her reading voice capture what I believe Yeats intended. This is the art of poetry and while her recital may look easy, if she didn't feel it deep down inside, it would be obvious. A painting with words !!
Thank you , you read it well, without affectation and with feeling.
The poem is a very free adaptation of the French poem : ''Sonnet à Hélène' ' by Pierre de Ronsard. Both tell of unrequited love. Unrequited love is a pound of flesh carved out of one's breast but this flesh wrenched out of one's breast has produced some of the world's greatest poetry. Maud Gonne was a tragic page in Yeats' life. Read '' The Circus animals' desertion'' carefully. There is a clue there everyone has missed.
Wow... that was the most amazing read. This is the first W. B. Yates poem I have heard read aloud and it was a real treat. Your reading was beautiful, eloquent, and done with such feeling that your love of poetry shone through it.
@nordicsky I am a little surprised that the only commentary here is so cloyingly doting, and that this particularly amateurish rendering escapes sensible criticism. The reading of this great poem comes naturally for those who can grasp its tragic pathos, where alliterative and rhythmic elements emerge spontaneously. This reader doesn’t seem to get it ... rather she comes across as some teen-aged prissy high school student more fascinated with the sound of her own voice than anything else.
Regarding Loreena McKennitt, since you mentioned you had some cd's from the 90's, I thought you would have to get Nights from the Alhambra. I was mistaken when I said She Moved Thru the Fair was Yeats, but that song is on this cd which also has dvd. It was my first of hers and I was instantly hooked. Just thought you might want to check it out. Thanks for your response to my earliler post.
Its interesting to hear Yeats readings of his own poems, recorded in the 1930s, which have been posted here on YouTube. He reads them almost like a mystical incantation, with great emphasis on the rhythm. As he put it It gave me a devil of a lot of trouble to get my poems into verse and that is why I will not read them as if they were prose.
Long marriages are a testment to sheer endurance, more than anything else, Nannygoatj,as you probably know!
But you're very welcome. Your delivery of this lovely poem was beautiful.
And what a sweet romantic you are.
NonInflatable 9 months ago
I wrote this lovely poem down in pencil and gave it to my wife before our wedding.
And here we are, 32 years later, still married, and she still has the scrap of paper.
Whoever you are, you delivered the poem beautifully, and you made that last magic line sail through the sky! Well done.
NonInflatable 9 months ago
@NonInflatable What a testament to lasting love! Thank you for letting me know. And thank you for the kind comment.
nannygoatj 9 months ago
BRAVO !
I love poetry and I love this poem more than any other. I feel this is truly the most moving interpretation I've ever seen/heard of "When you are old". I don't just praise without really good cause, I have to feel it deeply ! Both her facial expressions AND the emotions in her reading voice capture what I believe Yeats intended. This is the art of poetry and while her recital may look easy, if she didn't feel it deep down inside, it would be obvious. A painting with words !!
windbronze 9 months ago
One of the finest readings of this poem I have ever heard. Thank you!
silvermaneman 1 year ago
Thank you , you read it well, without affectation and with feeling.
The poem is a very free adaptation of the French poem : ''Sonnet à Hélène' ' by Pierre de Ronsard. Both tell of unrequited love. Unrequited love is a pound of flesh carved out of one's breast but this flesh wrenched out of one's breast has produced some of the world's greatest poetry. Maud Gonne was a tragic page in Yeats' life. Read '' The Circus animals' desertion'' carefully. There is a clue there everyone has missed.
daddio7777777 1 year ago
Wow... that was the most amazing read. This is the first W. B. Yates poem I have heard read aloud and it was a real treat. Your reading was beautiful, eloquent, and done with such feeling that your love of poetry shone through it.
Thanks for posting this
Life is good
Kind regards, Peter
nordicsky 2 years ago
@nordicsky I am a little surprised that the only commentary here is so cloyingly doting, and that this particularly amateurish rendering escapes sensible criticism. The reading of this great poem comes naturally for those who can grasp its tragic pathos, where alliterative and rhythmic elements emerge spontaneously. This reader doesn’t seem to get it ... rather she comes across as some teen-aged prissy high school student more fascinated with the sound of her own voice than anything else.
waywardtycoon 1 year ago
Regarding Loreena McKennitt, since you mentioned you had some cd's from the 90's, I thought you would have to get Nights from the Alhambra. I was mistaken when I said She Moved Thru the Fair was Yeats, but that song is on this cd which also has dvd. It was my first of hers and I was instantly hooked. Just thought you might want to check it out. Thanks for your response to my earliler post.
violetsky0036 2 years ago
i love when beautiful women read poetry
imitator777 2 years ago
Yeats is the best.
MarxBakuninMe 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
A fine rendition of a beautiful poem, thank you.
Its interesting to hear Yeats readings of his own poems, recorded in the 1930s, which have been posted here on YouTube. He reads them almost like a mystical incantation, with great emphasis on the rhythm. As he put it It gave me a devil of a lot of trouble to get my poems into verse and that is why I will not read them as if they were prose.
Fellwander 3 years ago
Comment removed
Fellwander 3 years ago
Great delivery 5*
DavidRandallCurtis 3 years ago
hey nancy , very good !!!! Cheers !
christophe76382 3 years ago