Added: 8 months ago
From: wtofficial
Views: 1,070,041
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (2,472)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Thumbs up if you love Within Temptation.

    Just kidding. WT is the best regardless of whether or not you give a fuck.

  • Nicee this song is named after me :D I feel ever so special! I surprisingly like this song, it's unusual of me to think so but I do. I think I might be sad enough to listen so many times I'll know it!

  • Is this poor pop-music? What a shame...

  • @kennedeee If you think this is pop, you have NO idea what music is. Sorry, but, try again.

  • i´m sorry. I really love within temptation, they are my favourite, but i think this song was their BIGGEST mistake in life :D its really a handfull of bullshit

    sorry again

  • The new album is not pop! Listen IRON, IN THE MIDDLE OF THE NIGHT, A DEMON'sFATE, MURDER .....

  • She could sing the obituaries to me and I'd think it was hot!!!!

  • Jesus Christ, what happened to old WT?

    I'm usually listening to Tarja and Epica, sometimes giving a try WT, but i'm not fan or smth. Today i got here...

    But this is... joke? i liked few old ones, seems she's turning into commercial trash :<

    Money money money... stronger than music genre so different than others?

  • @TehTroj If something sells better its because it fits better the wishes from those who pays to keep the band producing. "Commercial trash" is a misleading concept. If it's trash, why people would buy it? It's only people's taste, which is subjective and beyond judgement. Even though we firmly believe Bieber's fans have serious lack of intelligence.

    But "money"? 'Tis weird comming from a Tarja's fan. She was the one leaving NW because money, inspired by her manager.

  • @TehTroj I don't share your views of the "new WT" but I feel a simillar feeling with Rammstein. I really hated their new musics and even didn't watch their rare show here in Brazil cuz of the awful setlist.

    But if they're making more money, good for them. I don't like it, I don't buy it, simple as that. Money is like a real-time vote, you can't be upset because people don't agree with you.

    IMHO you should be thankful they at least produce something you enjoy in the past.

    Bieber never did it.

  • @SturmFuhrerx

    Well... no one knows for real what happened to Tarja and NW, but simple fact you can check by yourself is their music shops. Tarja in her official webshop have about 20 things, where as far as I remember 7 are CDs. Looking into NW shop we can buy simply everything we want, it brings them much more money. I don't care if they make more money or not, I'm even happy because of that, but when money takes control it's getting more and more pathetic.

  • @SturmFuhrerx I don't know further about rammstein, since I listen to them occasionally (i like some songs very much, just have never been interesting more about them) But look at KoRn. They used to make music they liked, but their last album, as they said, is completely different genre, since they wanted to make more money. And I felt really disappointed hearing that, looking at their old CDs on my desk. Usually when artists think more about money, their music is getting worse.

  • @SturmFuhrerx The best proof is old NW: their first album, oceanborn, was a pure epicness, which u could listen to all time, when they got popular(very popular to be honest) in their next albums we could find some songs that were made just to fill the empty space, to make it possible to release next CD, and sell it as soon as it's possible. Damn, it's hard to explain everything. I just want to ensure you I'm very thankful for artists' work, i always buy albums :P

  • I listen to WT since their very first album and i think they still make some of the best music ive ever heard. dont argue, enjoy....this song has a message, thats what counts. who cares about music style, either u like the song or u dont...and i personally love their new album!

  • OK, there's something I don't understand. If the song is called "Sinead", which is an Irish name pronounced "Shin AID", why is the song about someone named "Sugar"?

    I'm totally amazed that Within Temptation writes such incredible lyrics in English even though that's each members second or third (or fourth!) language. I can't write lyrics that good and I've been speaking English for years longer than anyone in Within Temptation. Is this just one little isolated, accidental mistake?

  • People say this is pop... if this is pop, then what is justin beiber, madonna, lady gaga, Katy perry, rihanna~~~???

  • @TranceAnton there are many kinds of pop you know...this one is disco-pop

  • @TranceAnton

    They all are shit-pop-

  • @TranceAnton Smartest comment so far. I don't know. Sometimes I think these guys just wanna make some ado. It's like:

    "I'm a isolated excluded loser who is proud of hearing a good band none ever heard of. Then I can say to others "I understand of music, you don't. I'm better then you" and actually convince then with a sample of good WT music. But now they got more than 4 fans and they aren't losers like me. Damn, WT turned into shit pop".

    I have a strong feeling this is why they whine so much.

  • Je trouve vraiment dommage qu'ils aient changé de style, je préférais quand ils faisaient du métal symphonic. Leurs meilleurs albums restent Mother earth, The Heart of Everything et The Silent force.

    Dommage.

  • saudades quando era doom metal, 'enter' = melhor de todos os tempos. , depois do mother earth ficou horrivel a banda

  • Why has the drummer got his face covered?

  • Какая хуета, бля, вы ебаные американцы все равно нихуя не поймете че я написал)

  • om te huilen

  • Her singing definitely improved but the style of this song is weird O.o

  • @AvaManchester It's just a try at a new style. I think it worked, though that's not a popular opinion judging by the top comments.

  • Can we please stop focusing on categorizing this band! Either you like it, or you don't. Either praise it or critique it for what it is and not be so damn worried about what your friends are going to think of you for listening to this song.

  • @OriginofDisorderI totally go with you, it's no good offending the bad and talking in a bad way about the members because you don't like their new music way, I know that's totally ubnacceptable. but what makes me pissed about WT is this non-stoppable hiding of unwanted comments, like they can accept only the good critic and praise.

  • Disco Music + Distortion Guitars is still Disco Music; nice try but in my opinion this song is the lowest point in a pretty good album.

  • A very nice Pop Song :)

  • Within Temptation have never been metal anyway. Bands like Nightwish and Epica are a lot heavier

  • @MrWaaaaaaagh "enter" and "the dance" album are 100% symphonic gothic metal.."mother earth" "silent force" and "heart of everything" are symphonic metal/rock (very very symphonic,with an orchestra of 80 people).. "the unforgiving" some song are pop/rock,but the others are a powerful symphonic rock :)

    (sorry for my english but i'am italian)

  • @marco95664ever giustissimo :D

  • Who cares if their new stuff is different? It's good. Is it just me or has the entire music world evolved into a bunch of criticising people who look for the worst in every band's efforts. It's the same with Metallica, people need to leave them alone.

  • The song is good, but the video looks like it should belong to a pop artist. The song itself is good, I like it. But this is a commercial video, as stated by @tchickish . I don't know what you guys were thinking, but this style doesn't suite you.

  • I hate videos wider than 16:9 >.<

  • What does "Sinead" mean?

  • @yryj100 I wonder the same...

  • @TheRosskopf I looked it up: it's just the name of a girl. That's why: "Oh, Sinead, come break away with me!" and, "You(Sinead) and I(Sharon) can, I know."

    Eric

  • @yryj100 Cool! Thanks for letting me know. Kindly answer :)

  • Gotta LOVE all these losers telling WT how to make a video, and what songs they should perform. I know, why don't you all WRITE YOUR OWN SONGS, and show them how to do it? Otherwise, STFU, and go listen to something else.

  • @tomdabom007 in case you don't know, youtube gives the chance to comment on the videos in order to say our point of view weather it's positive or negative. What you said is really funny, I wonder how old are you and you are so narrow-minded. The fact that we cannot write songs doesn't prevent us from judging a song according to our personal view. You say STFU, at least we say our opinion about the video and the song, we don't comment to attack other people like you do. So you STFU.

  • The worst song ever made by WT.

    Seriously.

    This song is TOO MUCH pop. Too much. 

  • @punk5273 are u kidding me?

  • Esta canción es caca de paloma pura. No puedo creer que WT haya cambiado tanto. El disco anterior era medianamente más comercial que los anteriores, pero aún así tenía buenas canciones, que conservaban la esencia de la banda. Esta cagada es pop. / This song is pure shit. Can't believe they changed so much. The heart of everything was commercial but still a good album with good songs. The essence of the band was somewhat kept. Now this song is pop, nothing of gothic or metal on it. RIP WT.

  • dude.....come on....!! WTF is this shit?

    how's possible that a band that was AWESOME is doing this crappy videos and songs?

    Its sad to see how one your beloved bands can become such a lame and pop-song kind of band....!! :/

  • @pdsegura26 aggggh I soooooooo agree with you!

  • still amazing!, keep on this wt!!^^

  • 400 birth control candidates?, how can you not love this group? Not only are they a great group they are awesomely nice in person too. Need more exposure in the US though.

  • I think the song and video she made with Armin Van Buuren was the final straw towards dance music O_o not that there's anything bad, but you can't use such a voice and a band for songs like this...

  • ....this is...soo...haahahahahaAHAHAHAH­A can't find the right words for it....it's just not the thing I used to like :)

  • I think the the video is awesome,.. except for the limp wrist action @ 1:23 that's lame looking. Other than that i like it, It fits the song. Sharon is stunning in her party clothes and make up.

    [but really., what was mr. director thinking when adding that limp wrist footage??]

  • Comment removed

  • select few hardcore dancers that continue partying even after the shooting O____O

  • Within Temptation have an economic crisis? .___.

  • the best voice on earth!!!

  • good song :)

  • the only bad thing I have to say about this is, the video... /I/ don't care for the video.. the song /I/ Like ♥

  • Yyeah ur right... within temptation is th best at everything

  • pop????

  • @muckelbomb not... better than pop anyway :D

  • 2:53 2:55 -- Sharon's doing a Kanye West.

  • Bleh. Not a fan of this album so far. Kinda disappoints me.

  • I like her hair down better. >.> But her make up is fantastic.

    Personally I think the audience would be thrashing metalheads, not a preppy danceclub. ;P Heheheh.

  • Not bad but not great either. I hate the culub concept of the video.

  • i did a cover, thumbs up if you like it

  • desde enter pasando por another day, pearl of light , see who i am, the truth breath of rose y todas las demas hasta llegar a sinead la calidad es la misma y el sentimiento tambien

    la escencia de WT no se ha perdido ahi sigue

  • Bands "change their style" because they change as people, diffrent things inspire them to write and they will have lived and understood more of thier life. The more time goes on the more the possibility of change is there as they grow as a person. Music is about freedom of expression and we all know better than to put it in a box and label it. Besides steriotypical pop dosent have that ammount of bass -.-

    They're amazing and insperational, no need for chritisisum or arguments !

  • @ImLostSomePlace Nope. They change because they make more money this style, because it's much more mainstream.

    It's money that makes them change. Nothing else but that.

  • esta canción es la reeehostia!!! dejaros ya de estilos y pollas técnicas, que es lo de menos, y daros la oportunidad de disfrutar la canción, quizás a muchos hasta os acaba gustando!! siempreee WT, seguid creando!!

  • Idk why people think they've changed their style. They're still the same Within Temptation they've always been! All their songs are unique in their own way. Some are heavy songs and some are more soothing songs. They don't really have just one style in my opinion...

  • @natigueto All of their other songs were variations of Symphonic Metal. This is a pop/trance style song.

    They have their own style, it's Symphonic Metal. The Unforgiving shows however they are making a move to be mainstream more, as other bands like Evanescence and My Chemical Romance have done too. They make a lot more money by being mainstream, because it's what the majority of the population buys. Money talks.

  • @TheHandgunhero

    sad but true...

  • @MrNw07 yeah metallica .. hahahaha

  • @TheHandgunhero That said, it's worth considering that if they make more money due to more people buying, well, they're making more people happier.

  • @TheHandgunhero bussines are bussines

  • @TheHandgunhero that is the sad real life

  • @TheHandgunhero Actually they are a combo of the following Melodic/Symphonic/Gothic Metal.

  • @TheHandgunhero Yeah, these bands are still mainstream cause ppl loved them for that reason, for their own style. Just like WT, before the Unforgiving. Αpparently, the money wasn't enough, so they threw the quality to make their music more accessible.

  • @PanosArvan But isn't that just YOUR opinion? I like bands who can evolve and change with time.

  • Comment removed

  • She has such a beautiful classic voice.

  • @SoSickOfYourFace indeed Sharon has a very beautiful and unique voice but she doesn't show it at all by singing such songs

  • @moonshinetears Except the Unforgiving vocals are much, much cleaner than any of the other vocals which are either a bit screechy or modified.

  • @Tr4y3r You should listen to their lives if you haven't where there's no modification and you'll understand what I am talking about. For example mother earth or ice queen! I miss her singing in high tone.. not many artists can do that and control their voice at the same time so well.

  • @moonshinetears I always thought she sounded too screechy in most of the earlier stuff, but each to their own.

  • So this is what WT has become. I am glad i gave up on them when they released their 3d album.

  • I love! the new Within Temptation, I stopped listening to them after i grew out of the whole emo stage but now they are in the genre I listen too :D love Within Temptation again!!

  • If a band want to change style,they should do it with another name..if WT sell albums with the name of "Within Temptation" people think of buying a metal album..or at least with the same style that characterizes the "Within Temptation".

    They certainly don't think to buy an almost Pop album..

    No,seriously,i know this can't be called "Pop",but compared with their original style it sound like it is..Anyway NOT what i expected buying their album!

    Understand me, this is only MY opinion...

  • @lucretiam I totally agree wih you.

  • I've got to try it's not over yet ,The signals of love have you left (TUNZ TUNZ TUNZ) My heart is bleeding just for you (TUNZ TUNZ TUNZ TUNZ) Bleeds for only you (TUNZ TUNZ TUNZ) And it hurts to know the truth (TUNZ TUNZ TUNZ TUNZ TUNZ)

    D:

  • quanto cazzo sei bella e brava! ti sposerei!!!!

  • @AvalonK8 anche io la/li adoro *W* peccato per i tunz tunz =/

  • ok excuses, when i said "this" is pop, i was referring to sinead and not the whole album. but of course the whole album too has nothing to do with gothic metal, neither symphonic metal. and yes, Sharon herself has recently said that they are a symphonic rock band. but i really don't see the reason why we should all argue about what this new style is.

  • i can't believe the actually have deleted the negative comments bout that video. why would the do that?

  • Commercial video.

  • Come break away with me..

  • @waterwavesandsand They have changed their style alot with the newer stuff, but her voice is still phenomenal and the song in general is amazing.

  • I like all of their music. It's their band, their music, and this is their newest album. I, for one, think it's awesome.

  • Cmon guys, it has WT elements in it... its a bit popish but still... a change is good, who knows what theyll learn from this... dont be filled with hatred..

  • like this video and like Sharon's voice...

  • you will not hear it on the radio if she did it old style, because thats how it goes. If you don't have something new , you will not get puplicity. And WT will never die !!!! they made a piece of culture.

  • So much hate. This is far from pop. And just listen to her voice. <3

  • You're listening to a quality song thats what...now, i've bought tons of albums last year, and saw loads of gigs, and have to say that THIS album was the best album of last year..BY FUCKING MILES..there's not one bad song on the album..simply a perfect rock/pop album, and WT's best album by far.

  • @WASPS1867 Definitely NOT the best! I loved enter, mother earth and etc. Those were the best!! More vocal experimentation, atmospheric sounds and less mainstream/commercial elements. I don't like new within temptation at all!! All their talent was used to make these mainstream poppy songs in an album which seems like an attempt to make money and not real art!

  • @LukeSWalker well said my friend, well said.

  • @LukeSWalker Sorry dont agree..the WHOLE album is excellent..yes, the other albums are good, but not every song on each album is perfect..this is a perfect album..thats my opinion anyway..others will disagree..and these aren't mainstream poppy songs..if they were we'd be hearing them on radio etc..we we dont.

  • @LukeSWalker and sorry to go on...but the GREATEST BAND EVER..changed their style so many times, yet still managed to have the top selling album ever in the UK, be in the charts longer than any other band, and be in the top 5 selling artists of all time..and that band is QUEEN.

  • @WASPS1867 Topping the charts doesnt mean much. I'd rather within temptation not top charts and be like they were before. And these songs do play in the radio. Maybe you don;t hear it but they do...especially in europe. I still think WT is a good band but they aren't artistic and unique as before.

  • @LukeSWalker Define art. You can't because it's all a matter of perspective and personal preference.

  • what the FUCK am I watching?

    really?

    REALLY?

  • This song is very different from the rest of The Unforgiving, and the rest of the Within Temptations repertoire for that matter. I love the song as a one shot thing, but would be disappointed if WT change their style to match this song.

  • guys from band should have been agents or cops ,.. or just dispersed around the disco.Sharon should have been bartenderD..that would be , in my opinon, better spot.. this is a bit too stuffed:)

  • This is fucking sucks!! Within temptation died for me!! T_T

  • @Warrantsweetroses reserve your judgement until you hear the rest of the CD. This song is one of a kind.

  • This is fucking sucks!! Within temptation died for me!! T_T

  • <3 chicks with akimbo glocks :D

  • i have tickets :P

  • Sinéad is my mom's Irish name, her name is Jane. Funny because Sharon looks very similar to

    my mom too haha.

  • who is this ? it isnt Sinaed unless she got rid of moles and  different ears and went straight!

  • sad to see she went pop!

  • I like the song, like the change, but not the guns on the video...

  • Beretta vs dual Glocks? Just give up already, dude.

  • Nice

  • R.I.P. old Within Temptation :(

  • Sharon is starting to look old...

  • @joeymadexellent So...

  • @MultiOtherMe Im not saying its bad i love her new look.

  • wow, they have changed heaps. Is it me or have a lot of female singer metal bands changed their style recently? Evanescence, Nightwish... even Floor Jansen?

  • @waterwavesandsand that's not a pretty recent tendency

  • @waterwavesandsand Change isn't always bad. And Evanescence was gone for half a decade, of course they changed.

  • @waterwavesandsand Lacuna Coil too...

  • @waterwavesandsand Wow, looking at Wishmaster, Dark Passion Play, Fallen and The heart of everything to Imaginarum, The unforgiving and the other ones, it really has. Damn, I feel old.

  • the best song ever heard <3

  • 2:21 FANTOMAS :D

  • Everyone is entitled to their own opinion and thoughts. I love old Within Temptation, they are classic and wonderfully moody. I do have to say that I like this current album. It is different from their usual stuff but to me it still sounds like Within Temptation.

  • This is not WT  :(..

  • I'm not listening to WT for a long time, but I like them. Maybe they had an other music style, but I think it's okay when the music is good. I think not the music style makes a band special, the songs make it, when they are good and people like them. and everybody likes other music, so it's okay if one person says "the song is very nice" and an other person says "i don't like it"

    I really love this song! ♥

  • And I can't comprehend how they could agree with this change??? 'cause I don't belive it was their idea... Simply I do not belive... -.-

  • I'm little confused and I don't know how to express my feelings now... I really miss their old style - it was oryginal and awesome in my opinion. On the other hand, Sinead is nice song (I'm listening to very different kinds of music), but it doesn't fit them completely... When I heard it first time, I couldn't belive that is WT, but it was sure of course that is Sharon's voice... After all I hope they will come back to gotic metal 'cause that's what makes them so much special in my view

  • @inez3 Pretty sure they have stated in the past that they hated being pegged as 'gothic.'

    In any case, I like their new stuff the same as the old stuff, but I also don't pointlessly limit myself to extremely specific genres like it seems a lot of people do, or begrudge bands for trying to branch out and try different sounds. I trust that WT as music artists will keep putting out music I want to hear. When they stop, then I will have a problem.

  • @inez3

    To be honest, it was their own idea, they wanted to trie something different in all of their albums, if you listen they all through, you will notice that they aren't same kind of music at all, and to that "gothic metal, it's hardly gothic, it's more like symphonic metal, like they (WT) have stated. So I have to go with @Ashleymjy in this.

  • I miss Mother Earth style...

  • @DestructorOfMinds me too!!!!!!!!!!!! so much :(

  • Ook. Low quality music. The new cd is in my opinion extremely mediocre. I mean a band that made deceiver of fools or frozen makes this?

  • @heroesdrhouseaddict1 No offense but I like this, I think the problem is that they changed their style slightly, maybe not forever, I havn't heard the album, it could be forever, one album or just one song, but the thing is a lot of people wont like this style, it's not that this is worse than the other songs, it's just different, fair enough that you don't like it though. I do indeed prefere the older stuff but this is good too.

  • @heroesdrhouseaddict1 If you can't handle the awesomeness of the new album then good. What kind of fool wants a band to releases the exact same sounding album 6 or 7 times... why not just release one and then stop making music. You sir are a complete tool.

  • @barronation watch your mouth cause you are indirectly offending all of us who prefer their old style. And this is not about being narrow-minded cause they're simply NOT METAL BAMD AMYMORE, it's not about just changing let's say the sound of the album, they changed the whole band's philosophy.

    and to my mind 'the fools' you call are the ones who don't have the ability to judge a band's music objectively and love like EVERYTHING they do just because it's them.

  • @marshmallowyeeah

    ...and yet you just state you don't like their music because "they're simply NOT METAL BAMD AMYMORE". That's really being objective there, Ace.

    The album is different, get over it you moron.

  • @Zealot1011 look how rudely you talk..now I really wonder who the 'moron' is..O.o

  • @marshmallowyeeah No, it offends the people who ONLY prefer their old style and do nothing but complain about their new style. I love the way WT used to say but tbh I love how they sound now even more. The comment only offends people who want WT to release the exact same sounding album every time.

    Also WT were never a metal band to begin with, they were Gothic Metal and if you knew what that was you'd know they still are.

  • @barronation they were never a metal band, but they were gothic metal? lol like you say, it's not a cake, it's a cake with chocolate.. and what? you think this current style is gothic metal? ok, this is POP, but of course you need some musical education to know that. plus, WT themselves have said that they're not a gothic band.

  • @moonshinetears Oh I'm sorry I didn't realize that ONE song on the album defines what genre the band is. Have you even heard the rest of the album? I somehow don't think you have. Also what band tells fan's what their genre is? I can't make a screamo band and then say "We are a country music band". It's what you take from their music and most people define WT as Gothic Metal.

    Finally if WT said "We are not pop" you idiots wouldn't stop saying this is pop so yea GREAT point.

  • can I have her earring? :D

  • We wait anxiously in Mexico

  • wait, so people get shot and they just keep dancing like nothing happened? 0.o oh well, still the best song from the album, maybe their best overall. i hope they keep with the new direction.

  • Comment removed

  • whats with the drummer covering his face completely?

  • @missdoublesided They were having some... drummer disputes. They didn't know who the drummer of the band was going to be for the future, so for this music video and Faster, the director(s?) just decided to make the drummer anonymous.

  • que balada é essa??

  • Just excelent!! Perfect music. Thank you Sharon, you are an amzing singer.

  • 935,913 :( the best

  • super,yeri var:))

  • bald...bald....my eyes....!!!

    

  • @aditiyagaul Proud that I knew it was Spongebob without even thinking! ;)