Added: 5 years ago
From: haciyatmaz
Views: 6,771,513
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (12,164)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Avirl does a pretty good job but Dylans is the best. :)

  • Of course Dylan original song from the movie is the best. But from the covers Wyclef Jean's is the best.

  • Axl rose is more... drugged! i prefer when the singer uses drugz!

  • Suscribe my channel pleaseee!

  • Suscribe my channel pleaseee! 

  • Suscribe my channel pleaseee!

  • Suscribe my channel pleaseee!

  • i agree i like avrils voice too

  • Who cares who's version is best - isn't it better to see the message here - war is nearly always a disaster and the war in Iraq was super shameful. As someone said, this is a terrific song no matter who sings it

  • It's just plain stupid to say one verison is better than another, they'll all good, in the words of John Lennon "A good song is a good song, and a good song will be a good song 100 years from now" So respect other's taste in music whatever it may be, how hard is that right? And So much respect goes to Avril for bringing good old music to a new Generation that needs it the most!!

    Peace and Love!! :)

  • ♥ every version is the best ♥

  • Awfulll terribly awful...disgraceful for the original song..nice voice bt keep it for ur girly songs sis..

  • to hear & cry ♥

  • god, i miss her when she was like this :(

  • 1 Bob Dylan (original version)

    .

    .

    .

    996 Axl cover

    999 Avril Lavigne cover

  • @SteppenwolfDark and whose covers were 2-995. )

  • bellissima!

  • MA CHE è STA MERDA?

  • Wow love it

  • ESTA CANCION ES DE LOS GUNS AND ROSES no es de esa .l.

  • @28grizel  Es un cover todos saben eso.....GENIO respeta!!!

  • como olvidar esta cansion de avril :) creci escuchandote ,avril forever ññ

  • That tune is definitely stunning!

    

  • She can suck on Axl's balls!! GnR foreva! \m/

  • proves she is just not a teeny b any more show feeling and that she can sing love this

  • I'm a fan of Bob Dylan but I prefer Avril Lavigne's version... In my opinion it's better than Axl Rose's. I think it's because of the vocal. I really like her voice.

  • @ThePajoh When gnr makes a cover come with 2 guitar solo and major changes :) Although this cover is just a simple one, that anybody can do it :) So Gnr better then avril lavigne

    Gnr vs A.L. 1-0

  • This song is originally by guns n roses

  • knocking on heavens door? That's old! I ring the doorbell and run.

  • woww i love more avril when i sawthis video iss all about the palestinian

  • That melody is definitely great!

  • I do really like this version of the song, much softer than the Guns n Roses version (which I also like btw). I think they create quite different moods so maybe it is difficult to say which is actually better.

    So I recorded my own version of the song, you can check it out at my channel.

  • Linda De +

  • yes but his trow out that song its free song like ritmen blous

  • Third best version of this song after Bob Dylan (The Grand Master) and Kurt Cobain.

  • Guns N' Roses are better!!!

  • one m0:00re time

  • UNA ZANAHORIA

  • avril is the most wonderful woman in the world for me!

    i love her with all my heart, forever. <3

    From, the Netherlands

  • Hey avrillavgnekline if you love her so munch than how come you don't know how to spell name it is avril lavigne not lavgne

  • Such a simple song, but it says so much. And Guns and Roses version is NOT the best, as much as I love them, and neither is Avril's, as much as I respect her. Dylan's is and always will be the best. But this is a cracking cover. Merry Christmas

  • @jwmulvay1 yeah, that's your opinion. BUT since I'm an Avril Lavigne BIG fan, I'll have to say that Avril's version is THE BEST!!!!! that's all.. Cheerios~

  • @moffattes I didnt mean to say that I dont love this version because I do. Avril has such a pure and honest voice. Ciao

  • @jwmulvay1

    Guns N' Roses version is the best!

  • This might not be the best cover, but i love this style of music for her, it's lush. <3

  • i like the original the best by Bob Dylan ALTHOUGH i also like GN'R's version too

  • "Please Avril, i'm so hungry and i can't get an education because i have to look after my mother..."

    "Shut up, and listen to me sing..."

  • Awww...

  • i love avril she is the best she will always be she gave me the courage to tell my best friend about my crush on my crush

  • avril doesn't have much soul when singing and she doesn't sing as high as axl...axl beats her!! :D

  • @MetalForWelfare Music isn't about beating each other.

  • She sounds better than guns and roses

  • @wrestlemania157 There a better intro with the Guns N' Roses one. There are guitar solos and Axl Rose's voice is better ;)

  • 0:01 damned spot click here!

  • this is such a painful song whenever l lısten thıs feel in my side excellent good job avril always wıth u

  • Is this song about WWII because it says "Mama take this badge off of me"?

  • @AvrilAwesomeness It's about Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid. "Mama" in this case is a wife or girlfriend, which is generally how Dylan used the term. This song is originally by Bob Dylan (a far superior version as well, I might add.)

  • that schould be illegal ,can't she write her own songs

  • Guys! Really, if the other versions are so much better, then go watch them and don't bother with commenting because no one cares and we're still going to listen to this song and love it no matter what you jerks say. And like a lot of other people say, it is a very beautiful song and the meaning is still the same no matter what person sings it.

    Thanks for reading!! <3

    Don't forget to check out my channel!!

  • i love avril so much

  • Wow Avril's voice Impressed me

  • I prefer the original but this is ok

  • Garbage

  • I can't believe GnR signed off on for this garbage!

  • @jakswold GnR didn't write it. Dylan did.

  • axl rose version is best

  • @juniorkofull Ok so it may be better, but Avril made a damn good cover? She obviously liked the song so she covered it.

  • @WeAreParamoreAlways Definitively not prefiermo thousand times the cover of axl rose

  • @juniorkofull i strongly disagree bob dylan ftw

  • @xombsqaudgaming Ok this one well pro for my this better of axl rose

  • @juniorkofull the version of Knocking on Heaven's Door is of BOB DYLAN!

  • @NurSalsano Perfectly what I say is that the version of axl rose is the best

  • @juniorkofull slsh version

  • I love Avril Levigne's music, but I have to agree that GnR's version is still the best. Never was much for Bob Dylan so I guess she comes in second.

  • guys if guns n roses is so much better then dont bother with commenting go and listen to them, no one cares... i prefer this one, but i dont go and dislike their version, its such a beautiful song:) a lot of its covers are great, and the meaning is the same, so i dont see any logic in disliking them

  • Awee ... i hve felt like i was knocking on heavens door at one point ... </3

  • i want to say something poetic or smart, but all i can really say is that when i listened to this song it made me cry, and honestly its the words that count, not who sounds better singing it, or how good the music is. so keep you dumb comments to yourself.

  • this haz touched my heart <3

  • Good version, better than Guns n roses. This song only touches me in her voice.

  • kurwa. Już myślałem ,że nie ma nic gorszego od tych amerykańskich dzieci ... JA PIERDOLE

  • avril lavigne version is a big shit...bob dylan and Guns N Roses version is better

  • @pedrocury29 wonderful voice, anyway

  • @macyhatelove it really touched my heart...wow <3

  • she adds something so sincere, only a girl could do... I luv it

  • does anyone ever think about whats going on on the other side of the world? do you ever think of someone other than yourself? there are children being forced to shoot their own family, children being raped and left to fend for themselves, people living in ditches, babies being beaten to death & children are dying of starvation. getting your phone or video games taken away isn't the end of the world. repost to show you care.

  • @erslandmorgan The thing is we can't choose to think about everyone else all the time, we have to think about ourselves as well.

    If we have a problem we shouldn't ignore it because others suffers worse than us. What we can do is help those who do suffer more but we can't just ignore our own issues anyways.

    You yourself always comes first because if not then you won't be helping others anyways.

  • I don´t understand this: everybody says Yesterday´s the most covered song in the history, but I have heard LOTS of covers of this song but none from Yesterday. By the way, this is the 1st female cover of Knocking on Heaven´s door that I´ve heard and IT´S GREAT =)

  • i never thought she was the girl who did this cover of Guns n' Roses, amazing voice!

  • does anyone ever think about whats going on on the other side of the world? do you ever think of someone other than yourself? there are children being forced to shoot their own family, children being raped and left to fend for themselves, people living in ditches, babies being beaten to death & children are dying of starvation. getting your phone or video games taken away isn't the end of the world. repost to show you care.

  • such a voice...

    such a meaning....

    such a beautiful song...

    <3

    Avril .. we are all trying to knock on heaven's door..

  • i bet no one can tell me the orginal band that sang this

  • @blink182lollove Blink 182 duhhh! lol

  • @blink182lollove If by "band" you mean Bob Dylan, then you are right

  • @SebtheOne lol i thought it was guns n roses at first but i looked it up on google and it said bob dylan

  • uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuu

  • ihate that music

  • Avril teaches us to move on fix something in the past get rid of bad memories bed yourself and don't give a damn just like p!nk AVRIL LAVIGNE FOREVER

  • @KittyKat46111 Bob Dylan did that, this is a cover.

  • @KittyKat46111 not avril, bob dylan teaches us....

  • ...if we saw what she meant for us to see, there would be no hateful comments. Look past Avril, and see the beauty of another child, woman, human, and the sadness of civilians stripped of their human rights and caught up in a nightmare... The lyrics are perfect...I love the video. See the man with peace sign on both hands? Intelligent humans have propensity for empathy...ignorance breeds fear which creates hate and distruction.

  • avri u love you

  • AVRIL LAVIGNE FOREVER

  • WONDERFUL

  • she has the same nose and the same hair of axl.... but not the same voice... but is no bad.

  • watch my awesome cover of this song :D

  • this seems a tutorial on how to ruin a classic song.

  • @BrenoDouglas1 And canyou tell me why? And don't come up with 'she can't sing' cuz she can...can someone like u please tell me what the hell did she do wrong!?

  • this sucks, thanks for ruining a classic

  • oh my god this is horrible.

  • did they film this with a calculator?

  • It's funny, she looks like AXLE ROSE!!!!!

  • stfu up people! this version has exactly the same lyrics as bob fucking dylans...people just hate this version because they hate avril. if she wasnt famous and if there werent any haters of pop, people would love this version too, and would praise the girl for her voice. people are just haters

  • @Mitsiooh Honestly like fuck, im not a fan. BUT she did Very Well..

    PPL Just Hating (N)

  • it takes an amazing person to do a video like this

    thumbs up if u agree

  • I miss the old avril

  • @Camielwoogieworld why? i mean, yes, she did have wonderful songs before, but now, SHE HAS BEAUTIFUL SONGS TO. Ok, so Wht The Hell , its not a very reasonable song,but so what? she sang, it to have fun, i mean, take Selena Gomez for an example, she sang beautiful songs and still does, and most of her songs are actually not all about love and crushes , she sang ' Magic ' 'Tell me something i dont know' annd ect. and all Selena Gomez, And Avril have BEAUTIFUL songs. God Bless Them xx

  • This is really not bad. Its simple, but, avril have an awesome voice. I ain't gotta talk about guns'n'roses, just because you can't compare Avril to Axl or Guns. But she is an awesome vocal, my congrats :)

  • noooooooooooos q mardita essa música é do Guns N´Roses ao inves de gastar seu dinheiro Avril Lavigne comprando musicas contrate um compositor pra voce ...

  • @280rhian not GnR... Bob Dylan man

  • @The91Walrus é Guns man

  • @280rhian nao é bob dylan man

  • @280rhian composição é do bob dylan, mas a melhor interpretação (minha opinião) é do Guns

  • knock Knock on Evan's door ♪ haha Avril should've knocked on Evan's door and married him :) they make such a cute couple.

  • Avril, you've made My. Dylan extremely pleased with this version!

  • avril can sing all kind of songs!!!

  • better the guns n roses!

  • @trecoolcool ... no, but not bad

  • this is the first song that made me cry.love it

  • This was the times when Avril used to kick ass, damn I miss her rebellious teen period.. Cos I was passing through the same period :D

  • I prefer Guns' cover, but... this is better than I thought

    

  • @MrMervin173 wow really? Your lame it's her version of the song okay and how she decided to interpret it. This song's nice i like it!

  • LADIES AND GENTLEMAN:

    HOW DESTROY A AWSOME SONG:AVRIL LAVIGNE

    this is a fucking shit ¬¬

  • ESTA CANCION ES DE GUNS N´ ROSES ¬¬

  • @sangriento24000 No es de bob dylan

  • this song isnt even about war its about a dying cop

  • @captnghost8788 in england this song will always be about the dumblane massacre

  • ilove this song this for iraq

  • Love this version.

  • i like this version i also like Gun n roses and bob dylan the original all good i think its nice to hear variations of a song

  • too much sound effect!

  • RIP Gaddafi

  • First thought before watching: OH NO WTF WHAT HAS HAPENEND HERE!!!

    Half way through:not that bad

    End: WHY THE FUCK DID I LISTEN TO THIS SHIT I WISH I NEVER KNEW SHE EVEN DID IT!!!

  • @MrMervin173

    what the hell? is it because of the video u don't like it ?

  • @iwillmissu1234 no cause its shit thats why

  • We don't have TMF anymore,now have only the new crappy MTV.

  • Mama put my speaker in the ground

    I can't listen this shit anymore

  • absolutely love avrils version, just learnt it on guitar :)