张学友-2004.活出生命Live演唱会-23.[情人]

[mygoodness12548]

我喜歡張學友唱的~~

[fuiundownwm]

i like jacky chung but his new songs is just sucks he should just do conerts from his ealry 80's to mid 90's

[ozalice96]

@fuiundownwm I don't think you really like Jacky because you can't even get his surname right! Do you actually own his latest album 'Private Corner' before you said his new songs suck? I have the album and I think the songs are quite nice! I am more inclined to think that his jazz songs are out of your league. Maybe you have neither the maturity nor the musical depth to appreciate them! Too bad!

[eminem2642]

還是歌神唱得好聽....

[Weedguy83]

沒什麼好比較~just respect

[0919rico]

家駒和學友都是香港的傳奇 , 有必要比較嗎? 同時 , 留言時 , 請專重死者。

[bbufo234]

on9 黃家駒唱張學友D歌 一樣冇FEEL !

[DevilZEnka]

@bbufo234 唔好將on9同家駒放埋一齊!!!!

[hweizh0n9]

太好听了

[totororororo]

嘉義聽到著手歌就想起你了。

[anna101059]

學友唱得不錯,但家駒有把歌的詞義唱出來,家駒的版本多了一份滄­桑不羈的味道.還是真正打動我的心...

[ariyip0608]

不會有人比家駒唱情人唱得好,也不會有人比張學友唱吻別唱得好.

就是這麼簡單.



[kinglhk]

我覺得張學友演繹得此曲十分完美。beyond那個版本比較簡約­，沒有太多修飾，或許對當時的情人一曲已經先入為主的人會喜歡b­eyond的版本多些。但是兩者不能比的理由，是beyond當­時錄製的年代並沒有如此出色的配樂陣容。學友這個版本是混合了對­beyond 的懷念之情，即使演奏演唱效果超越beyond，也十分正常，因­為好歌就是需要這樣傳頌下去，宣傳不斷超越自我的精神（beyo­nd）。

[wongdaman]

@kinglhk

抱歉,不認同,一個mv版,一個live版,好難比較.

但我都係中意家駒版,原因係首歌係佢寫,只有佢先懂得演譯出當中­神(水).

[sonson3701]

不好意思 沒有攻擊的意思...詞忘太多了吧...

很好聽...但是FEEL 不到...純個人意見 沒有任何比較...

[stiafro]

Different feel... but still good.

[naotarokoji]

I like Kakui's version better.

[jesmine222]

很喜欢张学友在这首歌中尾音的处理，有一点点beyond的味道­，又不完全一样。

[Visa1368]

The thing that places Jacky Cheung from good singer to a great singer and total Legend is his (voice) range and the different style of songs he can sings. This 2004 concert shows he can cover all types of singer (voice/range) and their songs. I cannot think of any other singer would able to do this!!!

[gg1314]

我從家駒中聽到一點悲涼的淒滄

但亦從學友中感受激昂的感慨

一首好歌,兩個好歌手

[cooliemomoyoyo]

LOL HI

[chingching2011]

家駒唱情人是唱得很溫柔的, 學友唱得比較肉緊,學友唱得這首歌,預了人們會將佢跟家駒比較,­ 我想佢練這首歌,都落足心機練, 因原唱者非一般當紅歌手, 更是曾經批評過自己的猛人

[Nateibu]

我相信家駒冇死到ge 話, 冇人會話佢无人能及

張學友只係冇唱到家駒ge feel, 但係佢唱到屬於自己ge"情人", 好明顯技巧,情感 都勝過家駒ge MV版

[goshogun]

@Nateibu 首個本身唔係情歌,係家駒寫比佢既歌迷既.

所以學友唔會唱到家駒既feel,各有千秋,但原唱最好始終

[loveuwai916]

又家駒, 你地悶唔悶 , 尊重死去GE人 , 唔代表一定要經常提起佢 , 一首歌由唔同人去演繹當然有唔同GE感情啦 , 你地中意家駒GE版本, 唔代表學友唔夠佢好. 盲目.

[goshogun]

@loveuwai916 既然呢首係家駒既作品,其他人唱佢既歌拿黎同原唱者比較都好情有­可原. 冇話咩悶唔悶. 我只可以講學友唱既版本係佢既風格. 欣賞不同. 但有趣的是家駒生前曾公開批評過學友"男聲女腔",可能2人其實­關係麻麻,所以學友係呢段片開頭先講"可能大家都覺得我唔會唱呢­首歌" 純碎個人意見

[seahouse520]

@loveuwai916 咁思念死左既人,提得嗎?

[loveuwai916]

@seahouse520 你GET唔到我所講GE野GE重點,無需要回答

[chingching2011]

學友唱得非常之好, 但家駒唱出的獨特感情是沒人可勝過的,

6月了,很想念你

[wushengzhang168]

different taste, not bad tho

[yinevalai03]

他唱得好好呀 ! 讚呀 !

[ngkwokleung11]

家駒略勝一籌, 歌神也要比下去......

[foreverkarpos]

其實不明白為甚麼要時常比較。在我心中，家駒的音樂以經不再是音­樂那麼簡單，而是他自己本人。而每當別的歌者演譯他的音樂時，我­反而覺得是歌者對家駒的尊重，將家駒最好的，繼續與知音人分享。­再者，讓學友這種懂尊重和熱愛音樂的人唱，總比九唔撘八的人唱好­萬倍。Peace! :)

[ryankathy]

@foreverkarpos 說的好，只要是尊重音樂的人唱就好，學友絕對唱得好

[kmfung83]

i listen to this song more than 10000 times,and more than 100 version,this is the second touches voice i heard....after Ka kui........

[lotteboyhk]

@kmfung83 haha u serious? 10000 times???

[blisstan]

張學友是柔情的情人

家駒是很MAN的情人

[king0228]

个人比较喜欢黄家驹的版本~

[cakelovegigi]

@king0228

me too

[alex20101020]

另一種的味道:)

[chineserose1981]

呢首情人，记得有一晚，我行系街，慢慢响起呢首情人，回想起自己­多年的感情跌宕，两行泪流在面上。

[andrewdisplay]

为什么人总要去比谁唱的好谁唱的差？有必要吗？每个人的特点不一­样。人药懂得欣赏。他们唱的都很投入！

[suki923115]

@andrewdisplay 說得好.正是這樣.放進感情,投入去唱,能感動人就會好聽!

[scorpiogirl328]

I like Ka Kui's version more. Jacky is a good singer but his voice was not soft enough when he sung this song. Plus, Ka Kui wrote this song and he knew the true meaning of this song.

[scorpiogirl328]

@Jubakaye

Hey, this song was written by Wong Ka Kui and Ka Kui was the original singer.

[tianzi11]

Stop comparing... Kar Kui is the original singer, if Jacky is the original singer for this song, u probably think he is the best. Jacky is technically brilliant that's why some people focus on his technique than his emotions put into every song. Having said this, my point is Kar Kui is good and Jacky has a reason for being the Singing God. ^^

[ozalice96]

Kar Kui's version has more of a rock feel while Jacky's version sounds more

romantic. From a female's perspective, I prefer Jacky's version as it touches

me far more than Kar Kui's version. I actually became a bit teary at the end of

the song. On the other hand, I also shed a tear or two listening to Kar Kui's version but for a totally different reason. I am saddened that he's no longer with

us and I miss him!

[kenwong789456]

我覺得學友沒有家駒唱得那麼傳神



[MichaelTangBB]

我覺得學友唱得ok,但還是家駒唱得感人,反而我覺係背景音樂同­音響做得好好聽

[ray1443224]

張學友唱得較好

[turbobenx]

jacky cheung is the greatest singer of all times. So some of yall cock suckers can shut it.

This song is ka kui's signature song and not even his band member can sing as well as him for this song. But still, gotta give jacky's some credit.

[francosueho]

唱唱麻麻!



[larrainewong]

i can sing better then him in this song i loved beyond so much

[larrainewong]

who the heck eats a apple while singing

[Raiyne324]

@larrainewong ... its good for the throat

[larrainewong]

i wonder if 1 day he and beyond will join together while singing this beautiful song

[larrainewong]

i wonder when will a singer ever retired i guess no 1 will unless they are dead

[aocpang]

家駒口中的男人女腔是否張學友?

[low787]

his voice is not soft enough

[KT1981100]

好似唱錯左喎...

[ichoiichoi]

好懷念家駒滄桑的聲音...

[forever2271]

Why he said most people thought he wouldn't sing this song?

[frank73u38]

是緣是情是童真<<<童真兩個字

家駒真係夠哂經典

[hpywtrftn]

開玩笑 .... 他是張學友

[hiant27]

ga kui n jacky the best singer....they can make every song a life......

[thxyoulove1999]

雖然沒的跟kakui比，但是還唱的不錯！

[tommyman2008]

真係唱得好好,可惜家駒唱先

[swallowpin]

家駒唱的比較有感覺

[Bobby0917]

如果張學友系Beyond中一員，簡直無敵

[yhchu1]

ok lar

[toanh88]

爱上了这首歌

[aqidanille]

学友唱得真好！！！

[Georgia523]

平心而論阿Paul03年個live唱得好聽d..

[chiyip617]

有淚 (有汗) 有付出  .........

[lotteboyhk]

HE made the song reli pop

too bad.

[jorvan6910]

不管你喜歡誰好 都比我們好 所以好好聽歌吧 大佬!!!

[98wongjf]

You're funny.  Thanks. I needed that laugh today.

[turbobenx]

because eason has a deeper voice which "good singer" doesnt really have. Eason cant be compare wit jacky cheung.

[wutangbeech]

The master

He would have really killed this song in his prime like 1999

still sounds amazing

when he sings a cover i feel bad for the original

[rainhk12]

lol where can i hear the 1999 version one?

[changalator]

um...the original is by Beyond, one of the greatest asian bands of all time, this is no way comparable to the original work.

[calvincalvin05]

超愛這歌!

[26698409]

佢唱有第2種feel~

各人唱 有各人自己風格

家駒有自己既feel 學友有佢自己對呢首歌既feel

[gantb]

jacky cheung is good..He brings a total new flavour to this great song!

[fung20072007]

點解學友佢話佢e首歌d人諗住佢唔會唱既?

[ewan4ever]

Sorry, no one sings Ka Kui's songs better than Ka Kui. No one!

[ahmarkhk]

歌神張學友唱很多歌也比原唱好聽極了

但家駒所作的曲 始終只有黃家駒才能唱到那種境界! 我愛家駒 懷念他..

[26698409]

立即諗起家駒~感人

[MrHanghang]

正....有令一種風味阿!!

[khandura]

好沧桑的味道

[hei398]

Ka Kui sings this song better

[wongjonny123456]

唱得不错，但我还是觉得家驹唱得最好。

尤其这首，家驹的演绎是经典， 无人能及。

[zuohuaisi]

@wongjonny123456  Totally agree ！！

[fatboon1020]

"!ka kui版 是 带 着 沧 伤 无 奈 感 ， 而 学 友 版 充 满 分 开 离 别 味 。 "正 "....

[deathrider2006]

I really like this cover. Jacky is by far the best at covering this song

[ayu1978]

Jacky's cover is nice but i found a better one, during the 別了家駒十五載...海闊天空音樂會 performed by 黃耀明. Sounds much more emotional and closer to the original.

[Yanamariel]

I still like this version better!

[JCLMLL]

noooo i would say 家驹is better

[deathrider2006]

Oops I meant anyone other than Ka Kui meaning all the cover versions of 情人. I've heard Ken Zhu do it, that kinda sucked

[babyqirl]

Although no one can ever compare to wong ka kui's version, Jackie's voice is also one in a million.

[a1234ddf]

u are so damn right !!!

[Yanamariel]

One in a million? I think it's one in a zillion LOL

[dgfpat]

LOL i agree with zillion

[ronwong05]

好歌~~

[calvinkahing2004]

nice crossover

[simontse1992]

別具風味

[jjtml]

very nice!!

[electronic1]

更能帶出這首歌的味道!

[tosexy4u2c]

sung so well with so much passion.

[candilover]

i love this song, this is probably one of the best canto song ever! love Jacky and Beyond!

[Yanamariel]

He is great, i love his hair here...thanks for uploading the whole concert...i have been looking for this for so long!

[999kk108]

一首好歌再配上一個歌神,真系絕配!!