Talk: The Path to Unity (The example of Imam Jafar ul Sadeq (ra))

[MaIcoImZieI]

In order to achieve unity between Sunni and Shia, both have to compromise, or one has to completely dissolve itself. That is the only way. I meet many people who want Islamic unity, but are not willing to compromise their views.

[SvenskMuslim]

It was a wonderful lecture and q&a mashaAllah.

[scorpion32]

why dont we just all call ourselves muslims and unite under the banner of La ilaha ilallah

[Notgoingnowhere]

@mujtahid2006 I suggest you take a look at their aqeedah before talking about unity my friend

[yadgar266]

great speech, i like and respect brother Abdullah, thank you brother Sayed Nakhshwani for this unity call...may Allh enlighten all the truth seekers..insha'Allah

[TheGuevarist]

This great brother- Thank you for this video

Inshallah all Muslims (Sunna and Shia) Unite

We are all Brothers and sisters

we should respect each other NOT fight

[karimqaiser]

Goddamn look at the flimsy justifications they have for calling us Kaffir, yet they count Abu Sufian and Muawiya as Sahabas, of all people. And narrate hadith from them, which is preposterous.

Imam Ali(as) said;

"If ignorance was given form and all my enemies could be brought before me, I would kill ignorance first"

The Ummah has really gone down the toilet in this day and age, because most people are irrational dudes like SurahTahaForever.

[SurahTaHaForever]

may Allah azza wa jal keep us firmly upon the Sunna and the Jama'ah, ameen.

[SurahTaHaForever]

..and worst of all who believe that the Qur'an we have is corrupted. The Sunni 'Ulema all throughout history are unanimous that the Shi'a are the most astray of all people, and their 'aqidah is kufr. It is not an accepted "madhab" of Islam. I feel bad for the laymen among them who are ignorant and who are deceived by their "marjas". The ignorant Shia who do not have a clue what is in their books, I will unite with and show my love. But the real Shias who know their beliefs and hide them..

[SurahTaHaForever]

brother Abdullah, how can we unite with a people who believe that most of the Companions became kaffir, who hate and curse the mother of believers, who believe that the two men buried next to Allah's Messenger are criminals and the worst of creation whom the mahdi will crucify, who believe that you can have sex with a girl for 10 minutes and its considered a valid marriage and mustahhab, who love a man who allows sexual abuse to children..

[12imams]

great video.. and if any brother have questions on shia muslims.. please ask and i will answer from the koran, hadith and logic where possible.. please all sunni and shia be logical!

[GSGFlash]

And answer me this, who exactly are you to label believers who believe in oneness of Allah swt, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) as the final messenger of Allah, and the Quran as the final revelation as kafirs? Since when did Allah swt ordain you as a judge of whether a believer is kafir or not? You are absolutely nothing in front of the Quran and I'd suggest you respect your place.

Brother AllahsCreation, I wouldn't bother responding to him as he's not worth your time.

[GSGFlash]

But cursing them does not mean they consider them kafirs.

And I've met far more Sunnis, almost all of them as void of intellect as you, who cling to the title "Sunni" than Shias who cling to the title "Shia".

Only an ignorant would compare Ahmadiyyas to Shias. If I remember correctly, it was Shia clerics who outed Ahmadiyyas as kafirs because Ahmadiyyas, unlike Shias, do not believe in the Prophet (PBUH) as the last messenger.

[GSGFlash]

quickfixyz, honestly you aren`t worth any decent`s person time. Some Shias may curse Omar and Abu Bakr, but most don`t care about them, and AFAIK cursing Omar and Abu Bakr will not make you a non-Muslim considering that they were not infallible or divine, and following them is not prescribed mandatory by the Quran. The Shias that curse bibi Aisha are in the wrong as she's the mother of all believers, just like the prophet`s other wives, and if Ali forgave her, then everyone else must as well.

[GSGFlash]

quickfixyz please don't be such an ignoramus, everyone knows that Shias don't treat the 12 Imams on the level of Allah swt or the prophet, and suggesting that they do is just pure idiotic, you're not gonna fool anyone here with that rubbish. Shias and Sunnis are both Muslims, both believe in the oneness of Allah swt, Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) as his last messenger and the holy Quran as the final revelation, only Allah has the right to declare people as kafirs, not some no-namer on Youtube.

[AllahsCreation]

GSGFlash well said..

may Allah reward you..

"And hold fast, all of you together, to the Rope of Allâh (i.e. this Qur'ân), and be not divided among yourselves Q.3:105

"Verily, those who divide their religion and break up into sects (all kinds of religious sects), you (O Muhammad SAW) have no concern in them in the least. Their affair is only with Allâh, Who then will tell them what they used to do."Q.6:159

[quickfixyz]

ask any shia to stop labelling themselvs as shia, and be just muslims as allah(swt) in quran called . they will never give up the label shia.

where as a sunni will happily give up the label sunni to be just muslim. now u know who follows allah (swt).

[AllahsCreation]

ok brother, keep it up & point fingers, i was only trying to warn you for your own sake, Allah will question you about this

sellam to all the muslim no matter who you are, Allah said stick together & thats the most important thing

MUSLIMS UNITE

[AllahsCreation]

@quickfixyz

The believers are brothers, so make peace between your brothers and have fear of Allah so that hopefully you will gain mercy. (Surat Al-Hujurat: 10)

[12imams]

wow.. so both are wrong and one is willing to stop the wrong one day.. but still does wrong.. does that make him better..?hhmm!

now, as as for shia, its actually a word from the koran if you have read it...

as for names, shia and sunni.. do u even know what they mean..? seriously brother.. u not doing your intelect any justice!

[quickfixyz]

Here comes another shia , with conditioned answer like ,"" did u know brother the word"shia" is in the quran, but he will never tell u what is the meaning of the word "shia" is. and in what reference the word "shia" is in the quran...... we gone thru this before, we wont change you nor you can change us muslims.

To u shia is ur religion shiasm and to us muslims our religion islam... let there be peace,

now this same "peaceful" shia will start abusing. i know them.

[12imams]

brother, so i tell you the meaning of the word.. then what..? what do u do then.. noting keep debating and accusing..

as for abusive shia, god will judge them, but u dont judge shia islam as a whole.. and no such thing as shiism same way no such thing as sunnism..!

shia: the followers of:

sunni: the way of:

[demnati2007]

salam bro, Bro your wrong.

Shia means a group.

and the quran does mention shia quite a few times, but never in a good way.

it says wala tafarakuna wala takunu shia.

transalated means and do no split and do not become shia. I take it to mean do not be in a group.

[12imams]

salams.. same way u find negative ones, u find positive...

"And most surely Abraham was among the Shia of him (i.e., Noah)" (Quran 37:83)

anyways, did u know the word SHIA was mentioned 12 times in the koran..? (ive been told)..

[3DeeFanatic]

Shia today has turned into a derogatory term thanks to you "Sunnis". The correct term for Shias are Muslims. They are Sunnis, their math'hab is called Ja'afari, named after Imam Ja'afar Assadeq. And yes we also use the term Shia of Imam Ali, just like you according to your own logic are a Shia to Abu Bakr and omar. But despite all that I've said we have to live with your ignorance.

[quickfixyz]

yeah ahmediyyas are not kufrs either rt? u shia are same as ahmediyyas,

[quickfixyz]

i dont understand , why shia want be with" us" muslims, when they curse our mother of all momeen, they curse sahabas, they worship allah and also believe 12 men have divine attribute of allah, they are waiting a naked man supposed to hidden in caves, to be their mahdi,we have nothing in common with shiasm or shia, we cannot be brothers in religion islam, they dont follow islam, shia follow shiasm., yeah we can be brothers in humanity and help each other .

[ajizbilal]

This guy is saying that "dont believe the propaganda about them". Either this guy is Shiah or he is a Jahil fool. If he had read even the basic books on Shiah beliefs, he would have realised that Islam and Shiaism are 2 different paths. These Shiah, I mean all of them, believe that we the Sunnis are worst kuffar than Yahud. It is due to this they are cursed by Allah beating themselves whenever they can. Would anyone with a sound mind do that? Shiahs please wake up and fear Allah, you may prosper

[ajizbilal]

May Allah guide this so called "Shaikh" Andalusi who didnt even recite the Sunni Khutba, I wonder why he changed his deen for thiese Shiah Kuffar. These people are probably laughing at his naivity. These people believe that the best of the best wrere the worst of people. They curse Aishah (in whose arms the Prophet passed away), Abu Bakr, Umar and Uthman (whose collected Quran they reject as incomplete). May Allah curse the Rafidah and those who sympathise with them, ameen.

[adzee909]

Ok i was in the wrong, I cant paint all of them under the same brush, but most of the stundents of knowledge from Saudi i ask them all say that some Shia call Abu bakr, Umar kafir. This statement angers me so so much, and they their master Khomeini said alot of other terrrible things about companions.

[GSGFlash]

Bro, obviously Saudi students will mislead you about Shias, they are wahabbis and they have an irrational hatred for not only Shias, but also Sunnis who don't believe in their ways, these people are the ones bankrolling the suicide bombers in Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan. I also haven't heard any Shia call Abu Bakr and Umar kafir. Ayatullah Khomeinei, who isn't the master of anyone since many Shias disagree with him, was for Shia/Sunni unity, so I doubt he would say anything to jeopardize that

[quickfixyz]

common , stop this lie or taqiyyah of making this statement " i havent see any shia calling abu bakr r.a, and omer r.a kafir, " u must be so dumb not to notice , every shia on you tube or any shia website curses them and u shia r so low u wont even leave prophets wife.

you" flash" so called shia uniter , playing P.R. games

politically you know, its better to be with muslims for u.

[adzee909]

"Wahhabi" why do you mock Allahs name. The Saudis are allies of the American government. Why would they be bankrolling suicide bombers?

You seem to have a Irrational hatred for your so called "wahhabis". May Allah guide us all. Ameen

[quickfixyz]

adzee, well u dont have to hate shia,

but they are not ur brothers and sisters in islam either.

They follow shiasm with allah and 12 imams having divine attributes of allah. WHICH IS NOT PROPAGANDA .

we muslims follow islam, and shia follow shiasm.

shiasm and islam are 2 different religions.

but we know shia will support us muslims over xtians and jews, we should also support them as required by general human kindness.

[2LoyAli]

may Allah bless you brother!! Barakallah feekh!

[XxXMusliimSouljaXxX]

salam alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakthu, i have a question...u are calling for unity with the shias how can we unite with them if they dont consider us muslim, according to them anyone who doesnt believe in Imāmah is not muslim its one of thier articles of faith, so how is it possible to unite with them?

[alfatourist]

Let us NOT unite with each other.

Let us all unite with the messenger' s personal 23 years experience in our hearts & minds, to please Allah, to earn rewards from Allah.

If we do so, we'll become part of a group that did the same.

The groups includes all sahaba at the time of the messenger's 23 years existence.

The sahaba includes who ever saw him as Muslim.

We know who saw him as Muslim includes Fatima r, Ayesha r, Ali r, Abu Bakr r, Othman, Omar r, Husain r, Hasan r & other sahabas.

[uuutube1]

"The Sahaba inclued whoever saw the Holy Prophet SAWW? .. So what about Abu Lahab?"

A true sahaba is one who is loyal to the Prophet SAW in his time and loyal to the Ahlul Bayt A.S after the Prophet SAW passes away..

[directdirect]

"sahaba" were companions of the prophet Mohammad (SAW) ......Abu Lahab was never a companion

[santacharlie]

Everything, everyone is dependent on Allah's mercy & power, even for salvation, including the messenger, let alone....

[santacharlie]

The bottom line is we do not believe anyone including the the messenger, let alone other, graves, imams, can answer our prayers.

Everyone is the slave of Allah, including the messenger, let alone ....

This is the basic difference between us & mushriks, that they think other than Allah, entities or humans have divine powers to answer their prayers.

Negation of divine authority possessed by anyone, but Allah, is the core message of Islam.

[alfatourist]

Islam came to knock down all shirk beliefs, where people think, expired people, idols, graves, so called godly people (with god sitting inside), can answer your prayers, or grant your wishes.

Allah is AL Qareeb & the sustainer, Allah is not inside objects, people, grave, or anything. Allah is closest to all in power, knowledge, closet to the jugular vein. Allah is incomparable. The existence of the entity of Allah cannot be compared to anything. Allahs is unique, The exclusive.

[Zamanabbas]

mashallah iv recomended dis vid to many brothers and sisters god willing more people will understand one another and not divide becuase that only leads an outsider to conquer ..!

[TurkBoy87a]

We all believe in Allah. We all read the same Quran. We all follow the same Prophet. And we all pray in the direction to Qaba. So i think there can`t be big differences between us. I am neither a sunni nor a shia. I`am just a Muslim...and everyone who says that he is a muslim is my brother.

[2LoyAli]

Mashallah!!!

[muslimpwincess21]

we have been divided so that we can be weak as a ummah.

[JanMuzelman]

Yazaak Allahu khayran brothers, keep up the good work.

[QueenSarahz]

@ Abdulrahman101 as u can see this was a tafkeer productions, as u are a ignorant TAKFEERI plz go watch ur TAKfeer production favorites u ignorant fool

[muhammadalattas]

the problem with Shia is, they put words into Sayidina Ja'far AsSadiq's mouth..

hence many were tricked into converting to Shia bcos of this..

Sayidina Ja'far AsSadiq is innocent from any ridiculious claims made by the Shias in their books.

[muslimpwincess21]

how can u convert to shiasim when they are also muslims ??

its different opinions and if u do not agree with some things and think some individuals are doing wrong, leave it to allah. do not create a barrier, we need to unite, thats why we are so weak today we are unable to do anything for our oppressed brothers and sisters. "united we stand, divided we fall"

[Miniclip420]

you are right.

[ibnarab]

shias commit shirk and bid3ah so how can sunnis who dont unit with such impure poeple with impure beliefs??

[Sultanya86]

Please let Allah deal with that....

[ilov3fudg3]

the Ummah should not seperate themselves in this suni shia thing..

we are all follwers of the Prophet(Saw)

Quran:49-10

The believers are nothing else than brothers (in Islâmic religion). So make reconciliation between your brothers, and fear Allâh, that you may receive mercy.

[nadialejandra]

come on! christians are more impure and I see a lot of brothers doing conferences along with them.Besides that, not all shais believe in the same thing and that is up to Allah to judge. If u think they are wrong, as u are none to judge weather they are muslims or not, u still have obligation to them and u better guide them, dont dispise them.And be patient to them as Allah has been patient to u. Those with an stained heart wont enter jennah, regardless of their deeds and beliefs.

[Sultanya86]

Brothers and sisters please stop these non-sense some people are trying to study islam get information about islam..maybe decide to be muslim by writing things that are not certain is not helping....TALK ABOUT WHAT IS SAID IN THE QU'RAN NOT WHAT WAS SAID AFTER MUHAMMAD (S.A) DEATH..people are not interested about Shiias and Suunis...

[syed113]

Imam Ali and all the martyrs are alive as Quran clearly testifies, though they are not on the earth. So please do not treat them as dead. Allah states in Quran:

Think not of those who are martyred in the way of Allah as dead. Nay! They are living, finding their sustenance in the presence of

[syed113]

Its a true fact go look up and research .If you cant even understand meaning of ya Ali madad, how are you going understand Allah.

There is nothing to lie about. if this aint clear enough for you .I pray may allah guide you on the right path of haq .

[syed113]

Even our beloved prophet (a.s) asked for help when his life was in danger, also the Sahabas used to say "Ya Ali Madad" . If the prophet can ask for help from Ali, and sahabas .why then do you question us.

[directdirect]

Even if Muhammad (SAW) and the sahaba said Ya Ali Madad, that was at the time when Ali (RA) was alive. The point is you cannot make any prayer or ask for help from a dead person. Ask Allah for help, Ask Allah for everything

[elpilot80]

"Allah and his massenger and those who bring out alZakah when they are in Rokoo'a"

[Sultan1923]

"Raafidah" "Nawasib", I'm sick of hearing this sectarian garbage.

Sunnis and Shia are united, no matter how loud the sectarian dogs bark. We are one Ummah. Our only title should be Muslim. Nothing more.

Salam, great vid, and inshAllah, more men who will unite the Ummah like you shall come.

[faki49]

Very good speech with noble objective. Are you a full-time scholar bro? Sunnis-shias have to unite. Ahmedinajad prayed in sunni turkish mosque this year. And he is very strong shia. WE need to tie our countries together and hold the rope of Allah. Remove all the historically hateful narrations in our books about each other.

[N0stalgicWanderer]

God bless you for your work bro.

[12imams]

salams.. i love how some people just become scholars on shia islam as soon as they sign up to youtube...! please brothers and sisters. if you have questions about shia.. as a shia.. and im happy to answer and help where possible. with references..! salams.

[filistin4life]

Akhi you are basically throwing away the principles and ideology of the 4 schools of Islamic (sunni) thought. ALL scholars such as Shafiee, Hanbali, hanafi, Ibn Taymiyah, Ibn Al Qayim, etc ALL OF THEM CALL the RAWAFITH (rejectionist shiites) as Ahlel Bidah and they say it is Haram to unite with Ahlelbidah. Imam Malik: Once when asked about the Raafidi Shia, Imam Malik said; "Do not speak to them or narrate from them, for surely they are liars."

[elpilot80]

U and ur muthafukaz are the liars. "and who is more unjust than who made up on allah lying or rejected the truth..". the truth is Alla requiers u to think instead of "do not speak to them..surely.." which ur dead Qyiim and Waha told u. allah taked me "..allah and his massenger and The Ones Who Believed.." and The Ones Who Believed sounds clear and determining The Ones Who Believed instead of making it up to ur small head. ".. who is more unjust.."

[filistin4life]

Good Aklaq, mashAllah. Typical shiite manners, if you had the Sunnah you would not speak so ignorantly.

[elpilot80]

yes this is wat u can say and similars faggy. "ignorant", "typical" and repeated same empty meaningless shit is wat u say. sunnat is not someone u represent neither know everything about. wats up with ur head not being a lil usefull, wondering around aquising niggaz and stereotyping others i fuck u up if i get a graba u pussy ass. u r the Time Waste.

[courseworkdue]

Proof you didn't watch the video.

watch it from 1:08:00 onwards, he explains those quotes.

[arashbd1990]

What a beautiful video...... I fully agree with it!

I have a Hanafi sunni father, a sufi mother and I am a twelver Shia,which is the Maddhab of my great grandparents; my younger sister has started off as a Hanafi Sunni.All of my family chose their own beliefs and although we dont agree on issues at the end of the day we believe in the same God, Prophet and religion

A garden with many kinds of flowers is much more beautiful than a garden with only one kind. Ummah needs diversity

Allaho akbar

[Zulfiqarr]

MashaAllah! This is what we should do! Unity!

[RoqayahChamseddine]

MashaAllah I cannot believe I did not watch this before :)

[shubzi]

lol,in ur intro, they started chanting, and it looks as if you wernt expecting that - actually its quite bait!

Ur still at speakers corner rite?

[ArabianLover81]

if this unity requires us ( the sunnis )to accept Ali as the first Caliph then sorry we dont need this unity..

[mujtahid2006]

er, brother, who said we (ahl ul Sunnah) need to accept Ali (ra) as first caliph? Unity requires we only accept the brother who holds a different opinion, not the opinion itself. Let us agree to disagree with our shia brothers, and march in one line together against the plots and plans of the kufar in Muslim lands.

[shubzi]

*good

[shubzi]

Keep up the ggod work dude!

[mujtahid2006]

whats so funny brother? :)

[shubzi]

Your expression man! ;)

[mujtahid2006]

I thought you were talking about the point I was making lol!

[abusheee]

brilliant speech. and its such a shame to read some of the comments that STILL argue about hadith books. they forget about the spirit and vibrancy of islam and choose to make uneducated judgments on points of history that will never be solved.

[americanmuslimgirl]

Ya Sheikh Abdullah, can you tell me, when you transliterate from Arabic to English, do you do so phonetically or letter by letter? Just curious! JazakAllahkhair

[mujtahid2006]

Both, depending upon what the people can understand.

[FarhadBa]

Mashallah, what an informative talk. It was the most useful hour i spend on the net this week.Thank you very much. Brother Mujtahid, i was wandering if you can make that pamphlet (about different schools of thought) accessible online.

[Wahidullah180]

great video mujtahid, Allah bless u. shia and sunni unity Allah Akbar!

turkmeniraqi4life, u are so ignorant about the shia, how can u believe what the murtads says about the shia? that they believe that sahaba was kafir and the quran is changed, istaghfirullah!

[Wahidullah180]

no khomeyni hasn't said anything like that, istaghfirullah u dont even know the shia school of thought

[Wahidullah180]

my marjas are taqlid of imam khomayni, i have read their books, and nobody says that the quran isnt completed , istaghfirullah!

[Wahidullah180]

KASHFUL ASRAR is a book in urdu, its lies about khomeyni, come to iraan and ask any marja or shia muslim.

[Wahidullah180]

haha bro u dont know anything about the followers of ahl al bayt, al kafi isnt the most famous or important hadith book for us, its nahj al balagha. btw al kafi has many fabrications added, the wrote in what ever hadith was found, read in ur own bukhari and muslim when omar calls the prophet(s) deluded. and u still call these books sahih? the only book that is sahih is the holy Quran!

[Wahidullah180]

haha, the book is called sahih bukhari, not sahih hadith bukhari. what u talking about?

well take care bro, and please dont judge me as i will not judge u. leave that to Allah (swt)

[MuslimByChoice]

look bro what's important is to follow the sunnah of the prophet

[nassernasa]

Alkafi isnt the most Authentic book, and this is quoted by Shia Scholars, here is some of the quotes regardin the Quran from Shia Books

We read in Al-Mesael al-Sarawya by Sheikh Mufid, page 78:

No doubt that what is between the two covers of the Quran, all of it is the word and revelation of Allah, there is nothing from mans words in it

[nassernasa]

and even more quotes

We read in Ahdath al-Istiftaat al-Aqedia by Sayed Sistani, page 454:

The Quran that exists in our hands is the same that was revealed upon Allah's messenger (s) without addition nor loss

[MuslimahForever]

as salam alaikum brother abdullah :) this was very informative and interesting, jazakallah khair

[mujtahid2006]

Imam Nawawi for example was Ashari (and he was a great shafi!!). The Ash`ari methodology of Imaam an-Nawawi RH was to negate direction from Allah, interpreting the Attributes in certain instances to mean Power, Favour and other things (Sharh Sahih Muslim. V. 5, pp. 24-26; ), that Allah has no bodily or corporeal form (V. 17, pp. 177-178), that Allah did not have literal hands (V. 17, pp. 127-133) and that Allah does not literally come down from the sky.

[TurkmenIRAQI4LIFE]

@mujtahid2006 I like your videos and I like it also that you want unity between Muslims!!

As for uniting with Shias... there are two kind of shias... the Rafidha one, who curse all Sahaba and say Quran is changed (like Khomeini) are Kuffar according to all 4 Imams of AhlulSunnah... as for the other Shias, they are Muslims (but deviant muslims)...

Fee Aman ALLAH

[prodigiouschild72]

no one on this planet has the right to call whoever deviant regardless of what path they follow, choose your words carefully, if Abdullah here is doing a cause to help the unity of muslims who are you to turn and say its deviant or anyone else for that matter if someone is helping the situation why are you belittling it, you should pray for this to happen and for the others to get hikma shame on you

[mujtahid2006]

Yes, but no Shia would say this - in fact, Shia Ulama declare anyone who believes the Quran has been changed, is a kaffir.

[prodigiouschild72]

the shias and i put in quote "have never stated the quran to be changed anyone who says this is not on the true path and shouldn't be labelled as muslim" khomeini never said the quran was chaned he said that when Imam Mehdi will come he will bring with him the word, people misconstrued this.

[elpilot80]

salm brother.

muslims are united under allah and his massenger but some chose to stop there and vague islam with "sunah of prophet" or hadeeth as in bible and turah of Eassa and Mossa. union is when u, i, him and they do wat we could following allah. Allah is not gonna come to ur door neither send u an undying massenger to keep getting u back on track whenever u prefer ur desire over right or truth.

[elpilot80]

Allah is not gonna leave u without a guide who u can ask about islam when u need, I would copmlain justice i immagine. other words, how would allah judje u if u were cut off the requiered knowledge while others had access to his massenger alive and reachable.

[elpilot80]

It wouldnt either be justice to have you assigned less duties just cuz u were born in adifferent centuary with internet and shit. Alla in Quran will always mention and remind u of the Leadership concept. its connected to allah being the creator god.

[elpilot80]

Allah's massenger is his connection to earth, and the knowledgable chosen disiple or imam who u trust is the most knowledgable of islam on the planet that u can reach if u needed. which is ur leader and only scale and nobody else as a First place, naturally, u trust he is the most Knowledgable on earth.

[elpilot80]

different leaders is not separation neither an only one leader would be a uniting. also, i keep my mind thinking and fighting to be true and stay true :-) too much to write bro. i hope some or all of this is usefull or enjoying to think of. wassalam alaikum wa rahmatullah.

[profit1]

bro i heard that imam maliki prayed without his hands becuase his right arm was hurt so he didnt like to use his left arm to pray so for that time he prayed with no arms i might be wrong allah knows best please can you research and clarify for me baraka la feekum

[stingray2525]

bro, it doesn't matter what you believe is true, as long as mujtahid believes the way imam maliki was praying to be the ultimate truth then he shall do it accordingly. no one has the right to judge others what is more acceptable in the eyes of the Lord in the ways to worshiping him. let HIM be the judge of that

[profit1]

no disrespect bro im not judging the broher im actually asking advice lol that is not haram is it?

[mujtahid2006]

Salam alaikum bro 'profit'. As I mentioned in my talk, someone approached Imam Malik and said "I bring you a hadith to pray hands folded", Imam Malik responded "You bring me one hadith, but I have thousands of the scholars of Madina who practice the Sunna [of hands folded] of their forefather from the time of the Prophet (saw)" The story of Maliks hands being hurt is made up. Besides, would his student of been unintelligent as to not know why he prayed with his hands by his side - I think not.

[profit1]

jazakala khair for that bro

[profit1]

by the way i see you brothers in speakers corner i have never went thier before what time do u guys usually go their if u still go their???

[profit1]

i also wanted to ask bro i see u brothers going speakers corner i never went their b4 what time do u guys usually go since i would like to se the dawa??

[mujtahid2006]

ok, that is his opinion- so what? I could quote many Ashari scholars from maliki and shafi backgrounds, would their quotes carry any weight? Why not submit textual evidences to me, if you wish to refute the majority ahl ul Sunnah school of ashariyya.

[narasum]

i'm referring to suicide bombers

[narasum]

i've been trying to understand how a person can commit a suicide when Islam blatantly forbids such practice. d'you think your 42:51 can be used to justify their actions?

[iLoveKagome23]

mujtahid2006= amazing brother. MUSHALLAH! may Allah reward you.

[ArabianLover81]

I'd love to see an islamic seminar between Sunnis and Ahmadis, and between Sunnis and durze .. if you do accept shia as muslims then why do we ignore the rest (Ahmadis, Durze and Ismaelis)

[lostprophet786]

"if you do accept shia as muslims then why do we ignore the rest (Ahmadis, Durze and Ismaelis)"

Why do you classify Shias, Ahmadis, Druze and Ismaelis in the same category?

Surely anyone with the most basic of knowledge on this issue regarding creeds would know that the differences between the above mentioned School of Thoughts is monumental.

[ArabianLover81]

Why do I classify Shia, Ahmadis and Durze in the same category because they all are SECTS !!

[ArabianLover81]

the shiite creed is totally different than the sunni creed, for example you allow mutta and Rajaa, Durze believes in the concept of reincarnation , all these concepts are rejected in Sunni islam..so lets keep it that way .. if we are gonna accept shia as muslims then we MUST accept Ahmadis ( with their false beliefs ), Durze, Ismaelis and Nusairis, so brother Mujtahid I hope you make another seminars to durze and Nusairis next time ..

[mujtahid2006]

Simple reason: I only do unity seminars with Muslims.

Shias, sunnis and most Sufis are part of the religion of Islam, and constitute schools of it.

Ahmedis, druze and ismaelis are not even schools of thoughts, they are separate religions! fahamta? :)

[ArabianLover81]

Shiaism is a sect NOT a school of thought can you practice mutta for example no as a sunni you cant because its haram according to the four schools of thoughts (mathabs)..Do you believe in the concept of Rajaa, again the answer is NO, therefore its not a school of thought you cant follow its teachings, if you have no intentions to accept ahamdis and durze as muslims then I recommend you to take down this video

[mujtahid2006]

Ibn Hazm believed you can practice Mut'a - he was Sunni and a highly regarded Sunni scholar, though he did not follow the four schools of thought, he was dhahiri.

The Four schools of thought do not equal ALL of Islam or the Islamic Ummah. Show me an evidence to say that Islam has only four schools and that their names are....

as for Rajaa, I strongly disagree with it, but it does not render one a kafir - you have to prove to me it does.

[ArabianLover81]

Whoever believes that "Imams" would return to avenge their own deaths by killing their murdrers before Qiyyamah (the day of judgment) is a kafir .. and out of islam..period

[mujtahid2006]

Proof?? Show where that belief (which I disagree with btw), contradicts core Muslim aqeedah - show me, or I recommend you take down your comment (i.e. allow me to :) ).

[prodigiouschild72]

I reccommend you think twice before using fingers to keyboard as you obviously don't understand one word what was trying to be portrayed in this video...

its about unity of muslims regardless of what school of thoyght you follow and bear in mind Imam Jafar Saadiq was the teacher of both Imam Malik and Imam Hanafi where the first two schools of thought originated from

[ArabianLover81]

LOL@ unity, a unity with the " nawasibs", killers of Hussain and Fatima, dont flatter yourself there will be no unity with any DEVIANT sect..and if " brother Mujtahid " decided to have seminar with shia, it still proves NOTHING I rather take fatwaa on who is muslim and who is not from Sheikh Al Qaradi than this " convert "

[mujtahid2006]

All the first Muslims were converts brother. You should seek further knowledge brother before you formulate your 'opinions'.

[2LoyAli]

astagfirallah, how dare you talk in disrespect about this brother just because he is a 'convert' ? It is about his sincere faith and his knowledge of Islam. Were Ammar, Hamza, Abu Dharr, Salman, Jafar, Bilal, and other Muslims and Sahaba not converts? Say tawba bro! wa salam

[lostprophet786]

Fantastic speech. It's ashame I couldn't attend that evening, would have loved to.

JazakAllah.

[prodigiouschild72]

I wanted to leave you with something profound, something with intelligence but I realised sometimes simpler is better... a man need not know exactly where he is heading for destiny lies in the hands of Allah, but we all need someone to help enlighten the path in order to show us the way. May Allah continue to give you the strength to fight in the struggle and one day achieve what most of us muslims crave... the unity of muslim brothers and sisters aameen

[prodigiouschild72]

The muslim ummah have needed someone like you for a very long time...

there is a saying I once read

Your life lies before you like a path of driven snow, be careful how you tread it cause every step will show.

I truly believe your footing is where others should make their tracks, be they sunni or shia we can all learn something from unity and you've said it extremely well.

[saadb1990]

Thats funny Brither i beleive in Allah, i believe in the Qur'An and i beleiev in Muhammed(saw) yet you would call me a Kaffir??? why's that?? Did you read a book on the Ahmadiyya or research it yourself??

[mujtahid2006]

Funny? So you believe that there is No god except Allah and Muhammed (saw) is his LAST Prophet and FINAL Messenger eh? If so, then my apologies for calling you Qadianis kaffir...

[saadb1990]

No but show me where is says Muhammed(saw) is the final messanger, in a Hadith it is narrated that the Prophet(saw) said "I was Khatam-un Nabiyeen while Adam was still in his creation" (Ahmad) so if Muhammed(saw) was the 'LAST' prophet before Adam was even created then that means according to you Muhammed(saw) was the only true Prophet sent to this earth? Also the Shahada translation is "I bear witness there is no god but Allah & Muhammed(saw)is the messanger of Allah"not he was the last Prophet

[profit1]

"Muhammad is not the father of any of your men, but (he is) the Apostle of God, and the Seal of the Prophets: and God has full knowledge of all things 33:40.

[profit1]

"In My Ummah (Islamic Nation), there shall be born Thirty Grand Liars (Dajjals), each of whom will claim to be a prophet, But I am the Last Prophet; there is No Prophet after Me Abu Dawood Vol 2 p. 228; Tirmidhi Vol 2 p.45

[profit1]

Sa'd b. Abi Waqqas reported that Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) left 'Ali b. Abi Talib behind him (as he proceeded) to the expedition of Tabuk, whereupon he ('Ali) said: Allah's Messenger, are you leaving me behind amongst women 4nd children? Thereupon he (the Holy Prophet) said: Aren't you satisfied with being unto me what Aaron was unto Moses but with this exception that there would be no prophet after me. Sahih Muslim, Book 31, The Book Pertaining to the Merits of the Companions

[profit1]

if you want more prove that rasuallah was the last prophet let me know baraka la feekum

[profit1]

may allah guide you to islam inshallah (not saying it in a arragant way) but if you belive a prophet or messenger after rasulallah then you are a kaffir im sorry i hope you open your mind iunshallah

[americanmuslimgirl]

my jaw is wide open

you are an inspiration

thanks for always being willing to discuss

I hope we will have more chances in the future, inshallah

[pacifistearthling]

WOW i wasn't aware you were a sheikh (?)Masha'Allah, Alhamdulillah. May Allah bless you and all of us in abundance and give us the ability to be more tolerant and considerate of other muslims...ameen

much appreciate your efforts

Salaam~Peace x

[americanmuslimgirl]

jazakallah khair

[shiasoldier786]

i was there!

[mujtahid2006]

whats wrong with the classical (and majority) ahl ul sunnah school of aqeedah, al Ashariyya?

[xiaahmad]

Keep up the good work.

bro

[Halomaster7]

Thank you brother for the talk. InshaAllah this will lead to better discussions and unity between all the schools of thought of Islam.

[h3arty]

Wow, this was really fantastic, I learned a lot. You're an excellent speaker, an inspiration ^_^

[themanishere4]

Alhamdulillah beautiful

[floweriepot]

awesomeness defined!!

[cfrb]

Wow I didnt realize u were a shekh..when I think of shekh i imagine some old guys. I am not sure what it means but its great to see young guys like u with so much knowledge. normally

[nassernasa]

Sayed Ammar Nakshwani =D thanks bro for this.

Inshallah ppl will come together for unity, even though i have no doubt there will be some ignorant ppl spreading fitnah in the comment page.

and Barrak Allah Feek Bro!