Added: 2 months ago
From: BBC
Views: 96,058
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (225)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • well done bbc, good adaptation but you should read the book

  • this is sick... and sad. i can't believe people, who want a faithful partner, would enjoy watching this trash.

  • @servantrose TRASH???!!!! your comment is completely ignorant. the story is about desire and forbidden love. Isabelle is abused by her husband & she's in a very unhappy marriage which she feels trapped in, and Stephen is someone who understands her and who will let her escape and feel loved.. I mean i don't want to even begin to explain the whole concept to you because you are clearly too stupid to understand -_- The story doesn't influence pp to do the same type of behaviour -____-

  • @Lyarellen lol... sure.

  • I sincerely hope that PBS is picking this up and quickly please??????

  • where can i watch it? :<

  • @allyandlarry No you're not ;) the only reason I watched the trailer was to see him

  • surely I'm not the only one who'll watch this because of Richard Madden

  • he mots her keith lemon would be proud

  • i saw this live on stage with ben barnes as the leading man at the comedy theatre and it was a great play. this should be interesting.

  • Read this book and it was fascinating. I am glad BBC made a drama out of it. :D

  • music: speech debelle - sun dog (f#cking masterpiece!!!)

  • Can't say I was in love with Great Expectations, this was far far more favourable in my opinion. The second part to Birdsong in particular was fantastic. Reminded me of Occupation too - another great war themed (modern) feature the Beeb made.

  • This mini series was absolutely INCREDIBLE. Please go watch if you haven't done so already! The BBC are really good at making these!

  • I want to watch this so badly. Why is it not on iPlayer??? :'(

  • i love eddie redmanye<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<3<<3h­e's gorgous and the book is amazing the tv series was exellent watch it! by the way the soundtrack is nicholas hooper i think

    eddie redmaynexxxxx<3

  • I don't understand all the hype! does it even have a plot?

  • @WetPurplePaint Yes! Of course it does. If you haven't watched it, I don't want to spoil it for you - but this mini series has a well developed plot! The relationships relate to real life easily, and the romance isn't too overwhelming. Friendship and bravery are portrayed excellently throughout the two episodes, and the main couple is hot. What more could you want?

  • How I managed to get through the first 40 minutes of this 1st episode of 'Birdsong', I'll never know. I didn't care much for the lead characters, Stephen and Isabelle as they left me cold. All they did was to stare at each other without speaking. I had some trouble trying to hear the French actress's English dication when she spoke. I found the war scene which some soldier gets his guts blown apart particularly gruesome so that was enough for me.

    I didn't watch the 2nd episode.

  • When you can see it outside the UK.?

  • Trailer looks very good. I've seen love stories combined with war many other times, but this trailer gave me chilling. Very curious!

    

  • does anyone know where to hear the soundtrack on piano. it was really lovely!!

  • This was AMAZING! i cried my eyes out!!! :D

  • Comment removed

  • just finished episode 2 totally awesome cried my heart out

  • The music in the episodes is an original score by Nicolas Hooper

  • simply beautiful

  • i cryed so much at the end of this film when the german was like 'the war is over' tears of happiness is always best :')

  • was sceptical about this because the book is one of the most outstanding pieces of literature ever written, but this adaptation lives up to the novel's reputation. Eddie Redmayne is the perfect actor to play Stephen Wraysford, exactly how i imagined him to be. credit must go to the BBC for following the novel almost to the letter.

  • Just finished part 2- it is sooooo good! Very emotional stuff

  • What song is played in this advert?

  • I have to say i loved this mini series well two parter really! I never read the book but i loved the TB programme so weeet! <3

  • I think that the BBC's origional british dramas are definatley under celebrated. They are all brilliant pieces of work :) like Sherlock and Great Expectations. Id rather watch these than Hollywood movies!!!

  • Omg jut watched the final episode made me cry the whole way through it : '( Eddie redmayne is such a beautiful actor !

  • Does anyone know hwo wrote the classical piece of music in the series, that keeps popping up? It was played in the last scene right at the end (in particular)

  • "There is nothing more than to love and be loved"- so true

  • :O That was my face when I realised Isabelle in Birdsong is also Fleur Delacour in Harry Potter. Also, Clémence Poésy has flawless English and speaks it with such a good accent!

  • The British writer/director has done what I have been screaming for British filmmakers to do. Like their European siblings, work with the silence. Much can be conveyed and each second of the shot need not be interrupted with the spoken word. It makes for compelling, beautiful, storytelling. And the chemistry, between the actors truly exquisite.

  • I really liked this! I was looking forward to it so much and although it doesn't touch the book (which is still the most amazing piece of literature I have come across yet) it was worth the wait and I think they have done what they could with it because the book is so full of detail and other scenes :) xxx

  • they've butchered the book

  • Clemence <3

  • oh hai fleur delacour!

  • This is amazing. I love the BBC..and Eddie!

  • when is this on?

  • Amazing. Now that Sherlock is over, this has just saved me from my boredom!

  • The book is amazing. The tv drama does it justice.

  • @dorothy2295 He doesn't die !

  • I am sad this was not about the Grateful Dead

  • Mediocre.

    The best BBC drama in recent times was the first series of the BBC/HBO show Rome.

    I

  • this was amazing, very tempted to read the book now!

  • @mattevangreen

    Haven't seen the TV show yet, myself.

    But the book was incredible. Heart-wrenching. I cried for the first time in years.

  • I hate british shows/movies. But BBC is BRILLIANT

  • whats the song in this called ????

  • @332squadron Speech Debelle- Sundog

  • @bigradart can you listen to the song anywhere? I heard teh album will be released in two weeks, is the only available single studio backpack rap?

  • cool drama

  • what's the point of watching this if you know if he's going to die?

  • she wasn't in 28 days later! unless you're getting mixed up with Imogen Poots from 28 weeks later. but yes, this drama was excellent. i can't wait for the next episode.

  • truely a masterpeice

  • OMG I so want to see it but these movies are never released in France!!!!!

  • In the First episode - does anyone know the name of the song played in the credits? It's so beautiful ^^

  • whats the music from 0.50 called?

  • Oh Sunday nights are the best start of with call the midwife then lie back and watch this. Last week it was Sherlock with the gorgous Benedict Cumberbatch and now Eddie Redmayne, trouble is you now you have to be at work on Monday Morning.

  • @TheWhiterose1603 You re so right. I like all the shows you mentioned. I actually ordered dvd´s of sherlock because it has stopped and can´t miss it. Also enjoy midwife a lot.

  • love the novel! will watch this! :D

  • Watched the first episode of this last night. It's really good. I've only read Charlotte Gray from Faulks and wasn't all that take with it but this really has me hooked. Whoop! looking forward to the concluding part.

  • does anyone know when it it actually playing on bbc??

  • one more arthurian love triangle and i will never watch anything british again

  • And when will it make it to the US?

  • @integral I read it airs in April

  • The book is outstanding. One of the best books I have ever read.

  • @sergeantfan3 agreed, i cldnt put the book down when i read it!!! such an amazing story. cant wait to watch this tv production

  • @cokkiedoey Except that Downton is ITV ! They are good tho, Pride and Prejudice will always be one of my all time favourites

  • Comment removed

  • @cokkiedoey you do realise that Downton is an ITV drama and not a BBC one right?

  • @cokkiedoey Yes they are... i do have to point out that Downton Abbey is an ITV drama. nevertheless, British period serials are really awesome.

  • @cokkiedoey Downton Abbey is on ITV. Awkward.

  • Comment removed

  • @JoanaLND Oh yer hahaha AWKWARD...:P

  • @cokkiedoey and small island :)

  • @cokkiedoey Awkward moment when Downton Abbey isn't a BBC drama

  • @cokkiedoey

    'Fraid not, pal.

    HBO in America has been wiping the floor with the rest of the world's television for some time now.

  • i hope they will air this in canada!! 

  • Comment removed

  • Hope they don't ruin the novel...Like Spielberg ruined War Horse :(

  • @MunthTime what the hell are you talking about? Spielberg didn't ruin it at all. It was very powerful like the book

  • @rumpusdog1 ok

  • @rumpusdog1 A lot of people have suggested that Warhorse the film was overly sentimental, the characters not well drawn and not as effective as the book. So, I would suggest you that opinions and views are what these things are all about.

  • @THthefirst ok, well I honestly don't give a damn about these things. I enjoyed the movie as much as the book

  • @rumpusdog1 If you don't give a damn, why bother to post twice?

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • I retreated into deep within myself, all because people were laughing

  • Comment removed

  • whoever was laughing forced me into a sense of deep distress

  • Whoever laughed in journeys end, you ruined it you tits

  • @tobylax so true! some uneducated plebs at the lowry showing in manchester laughed through EVERYTHING. obviously didnt understand

  • this isn't really how i expected it but never mind

  • I cannot explain absolute love of this book, I get shivers every time I see this trailer and if it even comes close to the book then it will be a work of art. I thank the person who chose for my English class to study this book because it is one of the most heart string pulling pieces of writing I have ever met and at the end of it I just wanted to meet Stephen!!! :) I CAN'T WAIT FOR SUNDAY!!! x

  • WHEN?!!!???!??!???

    

  • I bloody hope it sticks true as possible to the novel

  • I saw this on stage with Ben Barnes as Stephen Wraysford (Eddie REdmayne's character) and it is such an amazing book!!!! I cannot recommend it more!!!! Such perfect casting as well!

  • For all those wondering, and there seem to be a few. The trailer uses 1 track. its call 'Sun Dog' by Speech Debelle

  • need to know what the song is at the start? please anyone!

  • @03wychaidar The track is 'Sun Dog' by Speech Debelle from the album Freedom of Speech

  • @03wychaidar SunDog- Speech Debelle Albums out 13 February

  • Clemence Poesy is so beautiful! <3

  • Looks shit, hope it's not.

  • This looks like the best thing in the world

  • Does anyone know the name of the music in this video that starts at the beginning?

  • @JTfro123 Sundog- Speech Debelle Album Freedom of Speech released 13th February

  • Love the book, hope this show does it justice

  • Such a fantastic novel. I hope this series does it justice.

  • Looks brilliant! wish they'd released it earlier though, I had an AS exam on it yesterday!

  • Does anyone know what's the name of the song playing from 0.52?

  • @blackbird9393 Sundog- Speech Debelle Album Freedom of Speech released 13th February

  • @darkangelazure Thank you! :)

  • They should have kept Stephens moustache. It adds to his eccentricity.

  • I am really looking forward to this, and am trying very, very hard to watch it with an open mind ... but to me, there could never be anyone other than Ben Barnes to play Stephen Wraysford. And I have to say that Clemence Poesy looks ridiculously young to play Isobel, she looks younger than Stephen, instead of at least a decade older. Nevertheless, I am hoping that at least with the TV version we should get the whole book portrayed on the screen.

  • Saw a special screening at BAFTA. Well meaning, but so predictable and soooooooo slow. Full of long lingering "I can't speak" close-ups. Every scene is approached with the same delayed, cautious pace. Beautiful to look at, but the leads are dull, and there was very little to intrigue this viewer to watch the rest.

  • guess they arent following the whole structure of the novel- but elizabeth and robert's story is not as exciting as Stephen and Isabelle's

  • Wow doing this in A-Level English Literature suddenly makes life better, cheero boys!

  • @CrazyPeepsx Haha same here! Quite funny reading the red room scenes aloud when there's only one dude in the class :L Brilliant book! Are you doing Journey's End or How To Kill a Mockingbird as your play? :P I'm doing J.E :)

  • @Nikirockztar there's only 2 in mine and 1 actually likes it and remembers the page number too XD and yes I've finished Journey's End, we went as a collective A-Level group to Wolverhampton to see Journey's End at their theater it was sensational, we all were almost in tears at the end it hit home for sure :)

  • @CrazyPeepsx haha so lucky! We went to go and see JE in Manchester :P It was rather amusing to say the least xD. But it was sooo good! I think the actors who played Stanhope, Raleigh and Trotter had it dead right, they were the best :D But when you went did they pronounce Raleigh as "RAW-LEIGH"? Because our teachers have been saying it as Raleigh, like the bike XD. Got so confused xDDD.

  • @Nikirockztar nice, and I quite liked the man who played Stanhope he was the best for me, Raleigh was good too and Trotter was so funny and yeah they were dead on, and my teacher pronounces Raleigh as 'rally' and i say it however XD, they did come to my theatre where I live and a friend offered me a ticket free of charge to go and see it, i don't know why I didn't accept but i don't regret not accepting it, once was enough i got all the messages, plus i can sympathise

  • @Nikirockztar it's not supposed to be amusing, and quite frankly the audience members who laughed throughout the play, ruined the performance. Thanks for that

  • @TheProjectJustice Did I say that I physically laughed? No, I did not. I was ACTUALLY referring to the fact about how funny the amusing parts of the play were. Because R.C Sherriff did intend for there to be some humour. It was hailed as one of the most realistic war plays, you seriously think that they didn't have a small joke in the trenches? They may have been soldiers, but they were still men! Don't judge me because you read into my comment wrong. Cheers.

  • @Nikirockztar So then, you didnt physically laugh? Oh fair enough XDDDDDDDDD do you therefore agree that the idiots laughing throughout the play were laughing at the wrong moments and got it all wrong?

  • @xanderburchill Nah, did I heck, was an amazing play!! :O At the Manchester one, hardly anyone laughed where it wasn't appropriate, so I wouldn't know. But in general I agree with the statement that if something is not intended to be comedic, then it should not be laughed at. Especially considering that this is war literature/playwriting and not a comedy sketch :P

  • @CrazyPeepsx lucky bugger

  • I'm so glad he doesn't have a mustache in this like he does in the book

  • I was at the BAFTA screening of this last night and they confirmed that the first episode/part of this will air on BBC1 on the 22nd January (next Sunday). No confirmation of when the second part will be on.

  • Can't wait for Birdsong! Amazing book <3

  • @CravingNoMercy Ch yeah! ;) :L Whatever are you doing here old bean? :L :L

  • @Nikirockztar Well I dare say you're frightfully keen on following me son!

  • @CravingNoMercy Moi? Follow? :L oh dear xDDD. Well, at least we frightfully eager for its release! Bring on the 22nd? :L :L I see no Weir? o.o or did I just miss him in all the excitement?Wonder if Mrs Morgan will let us watch it....xDDDD

  • @Nikirockztar Whether she does or not, rest assured we shall be on it like a Model T Ford bonnet 0=)

  • have waited so long for this trailer!

    Eddie and Clemence look soooo perfect together! xx

  • I heard it was on the BBC in January so on the 1st I went looking for it on my planner and found out it had been on 9am that morning - who is even awake at 9 on New Years Day to watch anything?! Devastated I missed it!

  • When does it come out?

  • I am far too excited for this. AGH!

  • what is song?/

  • @lewdjaws Sun Dog-Speech Debelle

  • @lewdjaws Sundog- Speech Debelle Album Freedom of Speech released 13th February

  • Why I can´t see BBC in Spain??? I only want to say Congratulation to UK for their series. Sorry for my bad english.

  • does anyone know when this is being broadcast on bbc, date wise in uk?

  • Literally finished reading this today when I saw this advertised, really excited!!

  • Two of my favourite actors! Think I will read this soon.

  • WATCH MY VERSION ON MY CHANNEL :D

  • "There is nothing more sir, to love and be loved"

  • Was such a powerful book, full of every emotion you could imagine. If anyone's capable of bringing it to life, its the BBC.

  • @adamh9312

    I'd give it to HBO myself.

  • Cannot wait!!!

  • A great book to read

  • Eddie&Clemence= best couple EVER (+Eddie's deep voice!!!)

    sooo excited for this!!!!!!

  • Fleur!!!!

  • I have read this book 3 times and on each occasion it has bought me to tears, so well researched and written I only hope that this adaptation will truly do it justice.

  • Still don't think the book was that great and this looks like another boring bbc period drama version of it.

  • fucking yesssss this looks so good!!

  • Looks like they cut a lot out of it. Like the bit with Germans and the parts set in the 1990s.

  • Comment removed

  • oh I'm going to weep, aren't I?

  • Looks good, don't think it's one for me but I know that some of my family will enjoy it : )

  • And I was like, Fleur Delacour?

  • Eddie is ok, but... where is Richard Madden?! :-/ It is a mysterious man.

  • The BBC are clearly keen for me to pass A-level English literature. Cheers!

  • @RKTheMauritian That's what I was thinking... It would save reading the book !

  • @RKTheMauritian What do you think of the book? My English teacher suggested I read it and, being 13, I'm finding it slightly more advanced than I thought I would.

  • @lajones98 I'd recommend it really. It's not a hard read; and being 13, it will help you in the future when you come to study novels/plays. 100% recommended.

  • @RKTheMauritian Thanks. It was Part One with all the love elements I found difficult and slightly boring. I'm quite enjoying it now though.

  • @lajones98 Really? I thought part one was good. Part two's got more action and is more lively! Part 3's fairly dull, but important to the novel.