Added: 3 years ago
From: meeshell384
Views: 8,257
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (138)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • great atmosphere!

  • I love youre videos!!!

  • @FraPoppet Thank you very much!

  • This was ... amazing. I'm afraid there are no other words to describe it. Admittedly, when it said 'Innocence' I was thinking Avril Lavigne, by Evanescence is so much better that the confusion didn't bother me at all! But it looked totally realistic all the way through!

  • @pelahnar4 It's been a really long time since I've gotten a comment on this video. Which is fine since it's so old. So I was really surprised to find this comment. I'm really glad that after all this time, it still feels realistic. Thank you very much!

  • Omg I loved this! Plus Evanescence is always a good choice but man was that awesome!!

  • @Britfan06 Thank you very much!

  • Great video!

  • What was the name of the song in this vid??

    I lovedthe vid by the way it was great!!

  • @innocentlittleerin It's Fields of Innocence, by Evanescence (if you still care)

  • In my opinion the video was good in the beginning but it started to get a little redundant and at the end it was not the epic fight ending I would've liked it too be. You were very good with transiitions and video transparecy it's just that the emotion didn't flow. 3.5/5

    I'm still yet to visit your other videos though. I'm going to see if you have any other AU that you've made with your talent. :3

  • ArcanaLightHalfLycan - It's actually nice to get a comment that isn't entirely positive but provides constructive criticism such as this one. And I agree with you. But it's also a really old video, and one of my first AUs. And I'm proud of it for what it is - even without the epic battle you were hoping for. Sorry. Only so much footage I had to work with at the time. ;D

  • Your video is amazing! Totally seamless, loved the whole thing, keep up the good work!!

  • Moonlight1130 - Thank you so much! This video is so old, but I'm happy to hear people are still enjoying it. :D

  • wow this is awesome <33

    one question what does AU mean? sry i know stupid guestion :-/

  • MyRainyTwilight - Thank you very much!

    AU = alternate universe.

  • That was amazing!

    You really deserved to win that contest! :D

    I've been looking for a vid with this song for ages, and I finally found one, and this is the best vid I've watched in a while :D

    5 stars, favorite, subscribe and add to playlist :)

  • SweetEmmaWatson - Aw, wow! Thank you so much! I'm really glad you enjoyed it so much since you were looking for a vid to this song for a while. :D

  • No problem ;D

  • Amazing! Brilliant editing! Fantastic storyline! 5 million stars if i could!

  • Stine4me - Thank you very much!

  • great video.

  • shygirl7 - Thank you!

  • Wow. Amazing.

  • thisonesforthegirls5 - Thanks a lot!

  • this really is an awesome story

    great song choice for it . i felt bad for hermione whlle watchin 5* &faved =D

  • UndiscoveredLove33 - Thank you very much!

  • amazing, really. i like it because it makes me think, not just feel.

  • bruty16 - Aw wow. That's a really nice thing for you to say. Thank you!

  • you're welcome!

  • That was REALLY good!

  • mizzrocks13 - Thanks a lot!

  • Great job !! Loved it !!!!

  • nattie5991 - Thank you so much!

  • you are very welcome!!

  • GREAT!

    I LOVE IT

  • pirateprinessqueen - THANK YOU! :D

  • Wow, I can't believe you came up with suck an original/awesome story!! This video is proof of how much you rock!xD

  • rgqf - Aw, thank you! This was my first major AU, so I'm really glad its originality still holds up. :D

  • hey

    is the song by evanescence??

    i like the video :P

  • storiegalxxoc - Thanks! And yes it is.

  • I applaud you for your creativity in the storyline and awesome editing!

  • avat15 - Thank you very much!

  • How can I Start. I never thought of Hermione being the Chosen One - but it totally fits with her courageous and loyal, trusting and defiante personality. I can't believe you made such an amazing video from what little footage of such imagination there was from the potter films. it was never implicated that hermione was the chosen one in the series, of course it's harry so its unbelievable what you did. What program did you use??? AMAZING, keep making more, you're really really talented,

  • rachyrae015 - This is such an amazing comment. I'm really happy that you like the video that much. And yes. It was annoying to make at times due to the lack of footage that would imply this was the actual story. Haha.

    I use Sony Vegas 8 Pro.

  • did you have to buy that ? lol, awe thanks, and you're welcome

  • rachyrae015 - Well.. I should have. Haha. But it's really expensive.

    Try searching regrefulsorrows in Google, and you should find a website that offers a download.

  • omg this video is amazing! I love it , hermione has always been my favourite and the way you have put this together is awesome :D And its quite emotional and it realy makes you feel what she was " feeling" lol amazing work keep it up x

  • bubblesthecat08 - That's exactly what I was going for. So I'm really glad you liked it that much. Thank you!

  • This may just be a continuation of what everyone has already said, but I'll say it anyway--truly brilliant vid, great editing; especially the part where she looks at her reflection. Keep up the great work.

  • lizwiz010 - Thank you very much. I may have read it before, but it certainly never gets old hearing it. So thanks for the comment. :D

  • Even i have thought of hermione as the chosen one. I love ur imagination!...

  • michelle7282 - Thanks! My imagination tends to run away with me at times. Hehe. ;D

  • I mean, I know I've already commented on this, but I can't stop watching it. Honestly, possibly my favorite video ever. Such a beautiful capture of raw emotion from Hermione. I mean, just wow.

  • tasha02c - Well, I'm really am just so happy that you've not gotten sick of watching this, and you felt the need to comment again. That really just means so much. Thank you.

  • whoa dude this is hackin awesome ure editing is beyond great and i subscribed to you

  • emmettsgirl10123 - Thank you very much!

  • this is amazing! Can't wait to see more of your vids.

    lol the story should have turned out this way :P 5* fav + subscribtion!!

  • Sibzlipz - Thank you so much! That's such a confidence booster!

    And thanks again for the subscription!

  • I would welcome this as canon.

    The ending was quick, with Hermione's defeat of Voldemort. I think it was beautifully poignant enough as Hermione's realization and confrontation of Dumbledore. However, the bursting in of Voldemort was very realistic. This was wonderful. Another fabulous job.

  • tasha02c - Thank you very much.

    I do agree that the fight scene was quick, but there's only so much you can do with the clips. Maybe the next movie will grant me some more footage to work with. ;D

  • Mir gefällt die Idee und auch was du denkst ...:) Ich wünschte es wäre so...! Ich liebe Hermione auch dasVideo ist toll aber leider geällt mir der Song nicht aber man kann ja nicht jedem alles recht machen

  • amazing!

  • HoratioCaineFan - Thanks!

  • wo this is AWESOME! :D x

  • SkinnyBee0x - Thank you!

  • Its Okk :) x

  • Chelle I lvoe this vid of your's. Awesome :)

  • IBothersSnape - Haha. I know you do. ;D

  • That was so good!

  • I really love this. While I am very picky about AUs, I really like this one. It's not very realistic, but it's still really great.

    The effects are done beautifully, as well as the manips. Congrats on first place, you earned it!

  • Its wizards, wands, and Lord Voldemort, and your talking about realistic?

  • Realistic for the Harry Potter canon...Not realistic in real life.

  • wow, I didn't expect you'd use the Evanescence song, and as I realized, I felt like hey, I've got to see this!:)

    and wow, you really did a great job with this. Your manipulations were at some points breathtakingly amazing, and you showed just awesomely the difference between the young Hermione's "innocence", and this older one's sadness. You just made everything clear in the vid, the storyline was easily recognizable.

    so WOW again, great job!=)))

  • mse63 - Thank you very much.  I really try to make everything flow and seem clear. So I'm glad you thought it was. :D

  • Yay!! Voldie's dead! Nice editing, it sure looks pretty realistic.

  • I love this, the song is perfect, it firsts the plot RIGHT ON! <3 The only thing I found a tad quickened was the show down with Voldemort, you should have made it a tad longer, but am not complaining..I could never do better, you beat me with your editing skills. <3<3<3<3 FAVS THIS 100,000,000,000 AND ***** STARS AM SO GLAD YOU WON!

  • PFXProductions - Haha. Thank you very much! :D

  • Simply amazing!!!

    Well done!

  • WOW!! This was absolutely amazing. Excellent maniping and placement of clips, and the idea is very original and interesting. You are brilliant at telling a story with the clips, something many people find hard or simply can't do at all. I also liked the small hint of Harry/Hermione at the end, and that it's pretty much left open to interpretation. Very well done and congratulations on winning, you definitely deserved it.

  • jaeeton - What I love about this comment is that you told me exactly what you liked about this and what I did well on. Thank you so much!

  • I must agree with everyone! You call this a vid? WRONG. This is a freakin' piece of art!!!

    Who doesn't like this should have their breains checked. I mean, this is simply a gorgeous AU, wonderful vid and an extremely touching story. It's something, let's say 90 % of the people wouldn't be able to create... cause those feelings weren't fake.

    Absolutely bloody gorgeous!!!

  • Minttushka - Oh. My. Goodness. At first I was like "Oh no!" when I saw the first part of your comment. Haha. But I'm truly touched by what you just said. Thank you so much.

  • Sorry it took so long, but I just looked at the results.

    I'm so proud of you, Michelle. This masterpiece was worthy of nothing but 1st place. You truly deserve this. Again, great job.

  • MikeyT0601 - Wow.  Thank you. I actually was pretty shocked when I saw that I won first. There were a lot of really good entries in my category. I'm glad to see that you had faith though. Haha. ;D

  • excuse me but:

    was that video AMAZING or WHAT?!

    flippen' heck girl that must have taken you FOREVER!!!

  • aandcod - Haha. Thank you!

  • I like your little advertisement at the start:)

    Love the video!

  • RadcliffeWatson - Oh my intro? Thanks! :D

  • I faved this a while ago and here I am, AGAIN, to watch it. I thought I commented already, oops! This video is amazing.. the plotline is so unique! Excellent job! You have a new subscriber. =]

  • chappscj3 - Thank you very much for rewatching this, and now telling me that you love it. :D

    And thanks again for subscribing!

  • congrats on winning HO.

  • CheckeredRedHearts - Are you allowed to call me HO (I feel that that's Rachel's trademark name)?

    But thanks SKANK. Olives you!

  • I came to rewatch this video and was suprised that I hadn't already commented it. Its fantastic and so so so original. The editing and manips are flawless, but hey thats what I expect from your vids, and great song choice. I feel that this is exactly how Hermione would react if this is what happened- I always think you capture Hermione and her feelings perfectly. Great vid

  • Clowie88 - Well thank you very much! I really appreciate you watching this again and taking the time to tell me how much you like it.

  • I know I've commented on this before but I haven't watched it in ages!

    I LOVE this vid, It's so beautiful, your editing is amazing!!!!!

    LOVE

  • IBothersSnape - And again... Thanks! :D

  • S'all good lol

    :)

  • Wonderful!! I absolutely loved the concept and your editing was just, my goodness!! You made very good use of your choice of clips to carry the story. Heck! You could strip the music and the video would still make sense because it just flowed so wonderfully. Great job!

  • ninazera - Wow. I love this comment. I'm so happy that you think the story still would have been good without the song. Thank you so much!

  • it is cool idea.i luv it alot.the song is great.i love evanescence alot.

  • emmafangemini - Thank you very much!

  • I loved it that for once, Hermione was the hero!! I loved it! Job well done!!! I absolutely love it!!! I just can't stop watching it!!!!!!

  • hermionelover656 - I love the idea of Hermione being the hero. Thank you so much for this comment!

  • This simply tremendous video. Very very much original. I love it so that simply there would be no words what to state. You so telented ;)

  • xxXAliveHeart27Xxx - Thank you so much. Such nice words to hear (I mean... read ;D).

  • This is really really really good!

    There are no words to describe the editing-- it's beyond amazing!

    Wonderful effects! This is fantastic! Keep up the stunning work! :)

    5/5 and added to favourites!

    xoxo

    [Nicole]

  • NicholesSpellbook - This is really the best kind of comment to get. Thank you so much!

  • No problem! :)

  • Oh my goodness, I'm seriously speechless right now. That was so amazingly brillant and beautiful plus the storyline was so creative and gosh the editing was fantastic! Definitely going to my favs :D

  • SilverLilly88 - Wow. This is such a nice comment to get. Thank you very much! :D

  • you're michelle too? nice to meet you!

    I browsed through some friends' channels and found you! and found that you are a GREAT vidder!

    wish you so much luck with the contest hun, coz you deserve all those great compliments for such an amazing video!

    to think something like this up was BRILLIANT :D

    --- michelle

  • swtchell - YAY another Michelle! :D

    And wow... Thank you so much! I know I say this a lot to people, but it does so mean so much to hear it.

  • omg its awesome!! well done hunn x

  • SkinnyBee0x - Thank you very much! :D

  • its ok x :P

  • JoAnne couldn't of written it better herself. I feel that this is how it would of happened if this was that actually storyline. Amazing job on keeping true to the characters. Bravo!!!!

  • MikeyT0601 - Oh my goodness! I love comments like this because you're not just saying you liked it. You're saying exactly what I wanted to hear. I really did try to make this realistic and stick to the characters' actual qualities. So thank you very much for saying that.

  • Wow.

    this was really great!

    I love the idea, its so orginal!

    Great editing too!

    thanks for joining mine and tiki's contest!

  • SpiritedPegasus - That really means a lot! I'm really excited to see the results! :D

    And no problem! Tiki's the one who told me about it, so how could I not enter?

  • GAH! this is probably the 20th time I've watched this...it's *AMAZING*! I can't stop!

    so, I have another question...how did you make the screen look "dirty" sorta...is it picture that you turned down or something else?

  • Komischer - Haha! That really means a lot that you've watched this so much. *dances*

    And I'll send you another message. I literally just walked in the door though, so give me a few minutes to get myself settled. :D

  • Good luck in the contest ^_^ I entered too for fun, but I don't think my vid stands a chance against this one, ahaha.

  • ShanaBaby00 - Once again, I swore I replied to this. YT hates me.

    You're too nice, hun! Good luck to you, too! :D

  • i love this video i tso cool

  • Wow!!

    It's a fantastic storyline. Why shouldn't she be the Chosen One? I thought you did it brilliantly with the conversation between Hermione and Dumbledore.

    Also I'm suprised no one thought of the Voldemort-DA scene before. Very original!

  • jennyloughman - The DA/Voldie thing didn't come to me at all until I was getting ready to put his death scene together.

    Thanks so much for the positive feedback! :D

  • WoW. This was really FANTASTIK. You idea "Hermione was "The Chosen One" VERy original.I very much like to observe video with an interesting and original plot, and this such. Thanks for this video.I have such chils in finnaly scene:DYou Really have shown those Hermione`s emotions which have conceived. It is made very talently and originally.Well I can tell still. There are no words.AMASOME.

    P.S.Sorry for such big and emotional coment :D

  • Sapfirchik - That's really just so nice to hear! Thank you very much!

  • I've already told you how much I admire this one, but I shall do so again. lol Bravo. Just awesome. Love the beginning manipulation and the music. Very chilling and very entertaining to watch. Thanks so much for entering our contest! :)

  • TikiTyler9 - It really doesn't get old having people tell you how much they enjoyed watching a video of your's. So I appreciate you telling me again. ;D

    And as for entering... how could I not? Seriously. It's a fantastic idea for a contest!

  • wow that was amazing!  seriously! i loved it, you did a fantastic job.

  • shalzi17 - That means a lot. Thank you! :D

  • I know I've commented so many times about this vid but I really LOVE it!

  • IBothersSnape - *blush*

    Thanks for commenting again! I really am just so happy that you like the video this much. :D

  • Tis just an awesome vid TBH ;)

  • este video esta muy bueno, la musica ni que decir, sinceramente muy buen trabajo.

    te mereces *****

  • SPmeybi - I don't understand much of what you said.. But I think I got the jist of it. ;D

    Muchos gracias!

  • This was absolutly AMAZING!!no,it's beyond amazing(i can't find words good enough).Such a great storyline,and the editing and the manips were fantastic(it must take ages to make them)=)

    i want to give 10*(darn yt,why's there only 5??why??)

  • kiraly12 - 10 stars?! Stupid yt! Haha. Thank you very much!  It really does mean a lot.

  • You're welcome!it was really fantastic!:D

  • OMFG Michelle!!! that was prob one of the best AUs I've seen! ::claps:: and LOL, yes, this thime you killed who you were supposed to kil :lol:

  • siriusblackbabe - Haha! I'm glad you approve of who I murdered this time. Thanks hun! :D

  • Wow, amazing job!! Great storyline.

  • Lovett18 - Thank you! :D

  • This was such an original storyline and your editing was really fantastic. It fit the song and the plot perfectly!  5/5 and faved =)

  • HBHO - This really means a lot. Thank you very much! :D

  • wow omg that was BRILLIANT. The editing is amazingly perfect and the song with this idea is superb. 5* and I subbed =]

  • xDeppObsessedx - Aww.. thank you so much!

    And thanks again for subbing!

  • u r so welcome!! :DD

  • This video is BEAUTIFUL.

    You deserve the Global honor hun ^_^

  • ShanaBaby00 - That really is so nice of you to say. I was in denial about for like 20 minutes, thinking there was something wrong or different about what people saw. Haha. But thank you so much! You always leave me such nice comments! :D

  • Well duh you always mnake such nice videos!

  • WOW!! 0______o

    This is absolutely INCREDIBLE!!

  • BabyAZY - Thank you so much! :D

  • COOL COOL COOL COOL <3

    very BRILLIANT :)

    5.5 and fav:D

  • maarlenee008 - THANKS! I appreciate it! :D

  • i love love and love the story line!!!!!!!!! its nsahahdkashdsdh amazing xDDD and the editing of the video : perfect

  • andreiaaa1214 - Thanks so much hun! :D

  • Wow hun this is gorgeous! the editing is soooo smooth and the plot is outstanding! I especially love how you flawlessly edited the battle between Mione and Voldamort it was incredable and seemless! and I'll say it again but the song aww I dont know how you do it you always seem to be able to find a song and vid it so perfectly that one would think it was ment to be that way and they always seem to tell the most amazing stories! you are so creative and talented and your effort shows its gorgeous!

  • ETJNM - I think this is one of my favorite comments from you. I really appreciate how you said that my songs and editing fit so nicely together because that's really my number one priority when it comes to vidding. I can never just pick a song because I like it. So that means so much that you would say that. *hugs*

  • wow, i've never seen that plotline used before, its so original and portrayed so beautifully, very well done hunn, i L-O-V-E it : )

  • SharShar071693 - That's so nice of you to say! Thanks!

  • OOOHH!

    You got more honors!!!

    How good am I? XD

  • JFresshhh - Yes, you did call that! ;D

  • OMG :o

    this is so awesome!

    great job!

    i love your videos :D

  • Katelicious125 - Thanks so much hun!

  • woah! that was awesome. more than awesome! you got a global honour! NO WAY! lucky!

    this video is amazing

  • namsmagical - Haha! Thanks Nomi! ;D

  • OMFG, U got a global!?!? I am sooo super proud of you! :D and of course OllieJuice is a tad jealous ;) *throws the juice out*

    Haha, u totally deserve it!

  • CheckeredRedHearts - Haha. Poor OllieJuice. It's not her fault she can't control her emotions...

    And thanks hun (especially for the explanation... I'm a little slow)!

  • Oh man! So stinkin' awesome! I just LOVED this! The editing in the beginng was FLAWLESS. So cool! This would actually be a great entry for a contest I'm hosting! I'll send you the details. I know this is already in a contest, but mine goes until Oct 18th, so feel free to enter it then! Or even a totally diff one, you're so talented!

  • TikiTyler9 - Thank you so much hun! And thanks for the info. I sent you a message about it already. :D

  • Amazing, this is so wonderful, unique, original, it's so perfect. It's going on my HQ Harry Potter list, 5 stars and i'm subscribing :)

  • misspansyparkinson - Wow.. Thank you so much!

    And thanks for subbing! :D

  • You're welcome, praise due where praise is due :D Or, at least, I think that's it...!

    Anyways, i'm off to check out your other videos :D

  • huuuniiie you got an GLOBAL honor! :DD

    #58 - Top Favorites (Today) - Film & Animation - Global

    i just had to tell you!! hahah

    congrats!! :D

  • Juliiaxx - Thank so much for letting me know! :D

  • Ohhhhh my god!!!! What an amazing editing! Never saw something like this! It is the best editing ever!!!!!

    5* + favourite

  • MeileRockt - Haha. I love all of you !!s

    Thank you very much! ;D

  • Wow I love this!! The story was such a brilliant idea and very original! I loved all the manips - firsy when Hermione was taking the prophecy, when she was looking through the mirror - it was all full off....geniusness!! 5* aand faved!