Vintage Lady Gaga Live at NYU - Captivated & Electric Kiss

[Katie098987]

Her voice sounds so beautiful! Its strong and powerful yet delicate at all the right times.

[amberma1217]

please listen to my music!

[jorgotaci]

5:11 :)

[CipotaxLoca]

she looks way better like this |:

[LittlemonseR242]

i. cried. so. hard. i. almosed. passed. out. it was so worth it :D

[TAYTAYshotu]

I wonder if she would actually play these songs now that she is "lady gaga"

[Katie098987]

@TAYTAYshotu She sings part of Captivated at a Monster Ball show. Youtube it.

[musicallyinclined100]

fucking stefani germanatta is enough man!!! i love this

[jorgotaci]

5:46 <3

[BuayDreamingOutLoud]

does anyone else find it sad that for Stefani Germanotta's talent to be recognized, she had to portray herself as "Lady GaGa" because our toxic culture thrives off of shock value? sign of the times...

[Davidsonary123]

That girl, she can blow. Hahaha :D

[laurasniffle]

ehm Tell me your fantasies

[lord262]

awwwsome! 

[fluffybunny360]

she's gorgeous

[SugarTDaGoalie]

Hahaha. "Norah Jones look out"??? GaGa more than eclipsed her!!!

[EvanLeeCharlotte]

Espectacular, Ademas Se ve Divina !! Re Linda & Wooo Que Buena Voz !! Te Amo Dios Mio I Lov U !! So So Much !! Shes Amazing !!1 A Perfect Star !

[BexLittleMonster1996]

5:47 onwards is just breath taking! I'm in such awe of her! I love you Gaga! xxxx

[BexLittleMonster1996]

If only everyone was just half as nice as she is the world would be a much better place! xxxx

[WordsXHurtX]

<3



[jeagaga]

bueno ahi esta para los IDIOTAS q dicen q no tiene talento!!!..Im Captivated ♪

[DrZoidberg15]

So she was a regular talented singer/songwriter (I'll give her that she's very talented) who found that there's no market for a regular piano playing girl so she created this oddball persona in order to sell records and it really worked apparently. All this does though is prove that she's really just a character. Not to take anything away from her because it was really smart of her to do that but she's not real is all I'm saying

[jonasklj]

@DrZoidberg15 she has actually stated multiple times that Gaga is theater and nothing more. I'm just glad that she is not like everyone else ;)

[josemagus]

@DrZoidberg15 Gaga's reality is way beyond your puny imagination.

[Stefani77777]

We started love her .. and we'll keep loving her <3

[RidaJK]

oh Luc...i don't get him!! HOW COULD HE LOOSE HER??

[Smokeherbs718215]

she look sooo good

[frymonster24]

wow she is REALLY talented, very impressed.

[roberto41494]

Straight up talent

[charliiegermanotta]

es impresionante su voz, en verdad es hermosa!!

desde siempre una esepcional ARTISTA

XO

[sethduhnke]

A star is Born

[MrBambiKills]

She is so fucking hot and amazing....so inspiring for me.

...check out my channel plz for cool music by me ;) *paws up*

[creepypeach]

@TheRealDumbNiggas :) i agree

[TheRealDumbNiggas]

How can people say that she is not like this anymore? When I watch this clip, all I see is a shy girl, with an inner Monster ready to come out. She was amazing, is amazing, and will always be amazing.

Of course people who can't relate to her and just blindly judge everything are going to say she's shit now. But it's not true. If she always sang like this on the radio, who would pay to go to her concerts to hear the exact same thing? There are acoustic/radio versions of songs for a reason.

[200Late]

Norah Jones look out!

[ajshing07]

What other pop artists have this much talent?

none

[anooseholay]

Its performances like this that the people who say she has no talent really need to see.

[bkeels002]

@anooseholay Shame she doesnt use it anymore. Whatever nonsense shes putting out now doesnt do her justice.

[gilmour0009]

Is that Amy Winehouse?

[iisKiTTlEsii]

@gilmour0009 she actually bleached her hair blonde because everyone kept confusing her for amy..lol just saying

[koolperson818]

@gilmour0009 No. That's Lady Gaga.

[felinefury3000]

My goodness is she great on the piano thank god we still have an artist like this

[PhelpsTwinsLuver]

Ooh, I really like that second song...too bad she had to go and ruin herself

[ForeverTeamFelton]

@annemakeuptutorials She did went to college..major in dancing,singing,and performing arts... :)

[omgitsrachie77]

i love how she's wearing no shoes when now, she wears so many different pairs of shoes(;

[chia1123]

I like the current and the old Gaga. Both are real. She is too good looking here. I like her bizarre costume, too. She is a great singer; that all matters.

[amymonty03]

I think she should bring Electric Kiss out a s a single!!! Amazing!!! This video just shows everyone that Lady GaGa has always been talented :-)

[chris76328]

Who could unlike this?

[chris76328]

@lexistar1001 thts no normal girl thts gaga

[chris76328]

Love u gaga

[thonyXDifyy]

WOW

[lexistar1001]

wow...no other words can describe the talent this girl has. love, love, love:]

[xxstormxangelxx]

beautiful performance, i love her. this is pure talent.

[laurma4325]

god she was soo good back then. this is beautiful, pure with no synth crap or any autotune

[banshee1965]

Beautiful Music !

[mizzkayleaa]

does she look like a tranny? i dont think so shes just beautiful get over it

[lobstery7]

Those people got to go to a Gaga concert before the tickets were priced 100$ or more...I'm jealous.

[koolperson818]

She was "that girl" to them, because they probably didn't know her name. Well, if they didn't then, THEY DO NOW.

"that girl" became a POP SUPERSTAR.

[mrsanabellecat]

she is wearing cloths :O

[xISoulReaperIx]

For all you people who say "if only she was like this" She made a transformation. She started out like this but always wanted to be on the top of the charts. She always wanted to be a star and now she is. She's the same exact person <3

[Gigigirl01]

They had no fuckin idea that she's gonna be one of the biggest superstars back then...

[ianianvong]

modonna look out, gaga over the top

[T3Dy16]

So she used ti be normal, cool.

[TheonHafet300]

Fucking sell-out.

[lobstery7]

@TheonHafet300 No...Just because someone is mainstream doesn't mean they sell out. Unless if by sell-out, you mean sell out concerts, then yes, Gaga is a sell-out.

[TheonHafet300]

@lobstery7 She is so FUCKING AMAZING here. I hate the fact that she changed. I'll take the bluesy/soulful, normal-dressed, normal-hair, non-makeup, classic piano playing Stephanie over that overrated rip-off of a product that she is now. Her voice even sounds better here! But I guess if that route is the only way to make millions... if that's what's important to her, I guess. I don't like Lady Gaga, but I do like Stephanie Germanotta. People are so much better when they're normal. -_-

[josemagus]

@TheonHafet300 Normal people are boring - kind of like you.

[TheonHafet300]

@josemagus So you're supporting the overproduced manufactured route she took? That's the same as saying you support Justin Bieber.

[lobstery7]

@TheonHafet300 Stefani and Gaga are the same person. The Stefani you see here is only "normal" because she is afraid to be herself. Gaga said multiple times that she was always to afraid to wear what she wanted and act how she wanted because she was insecure, but that went away when she became famous. Watch her performance of Speechless live. Or her duet with Tony Bennett "The Lady is A Tramp". I prefer modern Gaga to this Stefani any day. She's real, funny, honest, different, and exciting.

[TAYTAYshotu]

@TheonHafet300 I totally agree. But to tell you the truth I think the whole "lady gaga" act is actually hurting her as a person behind the scenes.*shrugs*

[NathanIcon]

If only she was still like this.

[aleslocchi1982]

0H my G0SH! Famous Lady Gaga Getting H0t Sex with BoyFriend now at Gaga003.thrill.to Have a Seat and watch link!

[TheKsenchy]

amazing!!!!!!

[HappyHooker83]

I love her facial features. She is beautiful AND she can F..K'ING SING!!!

[Texmurphy51]

No Autotune needed as with lots of other performers today

[hellohamstermilan]

This is also a book about gaga, of her biography. She sings so good huh! love GAGA! (LL)

xxxx

[LThinhhateJTBB]

she is Lady Gaga now...

[paco29681]

i want people to take away from this that she has the ability to write wonderful lyrics and that all her songs have the same passion behind it. she's not some rapper looking to make as much money as possible, she's an artist.

[pjlaner]

I wish Lady Gaga were doing this kind of music rather than her techno pop stuff. I really like this kind of music and her voice is perfect for it as well. But maybe she wouldn't have been what she is today if she continued with this style. Who knows though?

[KingKrabb999]

She's so... normal.

[singertwirler]

A GAGA WITHOUT HEELS!

[harace123]

That's not Lady GaGa, that's Stefanie Germanotta <3

[sincerelymaybe]

I teared a bit right when she started singing. What the hell is going on here ? She's so beautiful. I am so happy to see these performances !

And I live in New York ..

to think that I could've gone to college with her ..

becoming best friends ..

but she's just five years older than me ..

It's okay ..

It's okay.

[MakeIdol]

This litterally makes me cry that she doesn't sing like this now because of demand. I mean this is soooo much freakin better that the new GaGa stuff. This takes much more talent than any of her new stuff. I mean Cartman on South Park can do Poker Face just as well as her.

[FieldTaker]

If they only knew.....

[EllaRoseX]

shittest day and ths just made it all better

[lewys258]

I can't get enough I this

[tabliduppten1973]

0H my G0SH! Laddy Gaga Puts his vagina in Her boyfriend cock now at GagaGa1.sail.to D0n't miss it out! Check it!

[Dana5760]

@tabliduppten1973 that made no fuckin sense

[ArthurHammerr]

She proves that you don't need a persona to be talented.

[ArthurHammerr]

Why would anyone every throw her in a garbage bin? Seriously.

[hjestrella]

@ArthurHammerr yeah!! now they wish it never happened ! :)

[SkeletalKitty]

Watched this after reading her/a book about her life.

I have so much more respect for than I did before.

[dansMAX]

shes so beautiful!

[PresObama2012]

I wish I went to college with her!!

[annemakeuptutorials]

@PresObama2012 she never went to college did she ?

[PreciousePink16]

she rocks!!

[painkillaz100]

i cant believe that was 6 fucking years ago :O

[beenzmasa]

Gaga was 19 old

[stnvsxdqforever]

How old was Lady Gaga then?

[Freistaat1918]

Back then: Singing really good, good songs and looking pretty (!) yet earning avarage money. Now: Still not singing bad, but her talent goes down in avarage pop songs that get raped to death by marketing and record companies; looking like a fucking alien; earning millions. Srsly, world, what the fuck is wrong with you?

[josemagus]

@Freistaat1918 You.

[prisRdrz]

2 years later she changed the world with her lips!

[LifeSucks13100]

If this were tumblr I soo would have posted that ovaries exploding thing.

[Gaga7055]

i love you :)

[TheNilnehri]

at 6.38 lady gaga's first monsters.

[lobstery7]

My sister insists Gaga can't sing, so I played this song and minimized the window. She said she liked it. If only people would take the time to listen to her live music.

[TheNeeuqnozama]

What a voice!! Glad to say I'm living in the prime of Gaga.. I don't think people get that she's only been out for less than 4 yrs really an has broken records an just done shit that artist who have been around just couldn't-

[italia10588]

Wish she was still like this instead of the trendy hype bullshit. I'd actually like her. She used to be quite an attractive girl.

[BlackJesusLOVESGaga]

she sorta looks like angelina from jersey shore. from her profile view in this video

[lobstery7]

@BlackJesusLOVESGaga No. Angelina looks like her :3

[BlackJesusLOVESGaga]

@lobstery7 yea sorry my mistake lol

[lobstery7]

For the longest time I thought talent like this was trapped in the past generations. Gaga is the only reason I don't totally hate modern pop.

[coolstass1]

I promise, I will kill anyone who says she's not telanted!

[twilightfanno11]

She's so talented, Love u so much Gaga! <3

This song made me cry..... <3

Mama u are amazing ,

[ukpkmkk]

This was her first performance/

[TheInsignificantFly]

^^ Tom Riddle before Voldermort

[vanessaxt]

@McKayBabyXx Yeah, is perfect like that!

[mocatz187]

I wonder if she was an anti-American communist back then like she is now?

[ukpkmkk]

@mocatz187 i dont remember her telling everyone they should get the same paychecks as everyone else.

[mocatz187]

@ukpkmkk Very few communists promote communism on it's merits but rather lye about it. Lady Gaga keeps close company with a lot of self admitted marxists like Slavoj Zizek and she supports communist political candidates as well as attacks the sovereignty of the United States on a regular bases. Communism wouldn't get very far if the truth were told about it. Instead, the idea of a "fair" system is promoted.

[lobstery7]

@mocatz187 All of that is complete BS. Besides, Gaga loves New York and all of her American qualities. You have to stop reading BS sources and start getting on with fact.

[mocatz187]

@lobstery7 NyTimes is a bullshit source? ABC News? Maybe your just jaded and in love.

[lobstery7]

@mocatz187 I would love for you to give me a source where Gaga says she is an anti American communist.

[mocatz187]

@lobstery7 I never said that was a quote of hers you stupid fuck. I gave the sources, read between the lines. Besides having close association with admiited marxists (NyTimes). She denounced deportation of an illegal that was a gang member and arrested for dealing drugs (attack on our sovereignty), and she denounced it at one of her west coast concerts through a dedication. That was picked up by all the networks while you were under a rock.

[lobstery7]

@mocatz187 By sources I mean links, and none of this was proven. And just because she doesn't agree with the government at times doesn't mean she's a Communist. Watch your language, by the way.

[mocatz187]

@lobstery7 I was wrong. I stated it was the NyTimes but instead it was the NyPost:

nypost.com/p/pagesix/marxist_m­use_befriends_gaga_v3XXqED29kG­oAf5bvJKPuM

[lobstery7]

@mocatz187 I think you entered the link wrong because that one doesn't exist.

[mocatz187]

@lobstery7 Google corrupts the text. There is a saying amongst programmers that there is no such thing as plain text. The attributes follow and corrupt. If you Google "marxist muse befriends gaga nypost" you will find it at the top.

[lobstery7]

@mocatz187 There is nothing in there that even remotely suggests she's a Communist. So she supports a strike, and happens to be friends with someone. One of my friends smokes, so I must smoke too, right? No. That's not how it works.

[mocatz187]

@lobstery7 If you think donating time to a cause that will eventually lead to people losing rights is no big deal then nothing is a big deal to you. She is using celebrity status to put forth a political agenda. Judging by all the time you spend on this video talking to all kinds of different people it must be to hard for you to think in between all of your masturbation episodes you engage in. You need to get a life dude. I know it must be hard to not have a girlfriend and allbut damn

[lobstery7]

@mocatz187 Everything could eventually lead to someone losing rights. Nothing Lady Gaga does is Communist and you have to learn what a Communist is. I don't masturbate and I have a girlfriend, now quit being an immature ignorant child and start making up insults about my life that aren't even true just because you know you are wrong and you can't think of anything intelligent to back up your argument.

[mocatz187]

@lobstery7 I know plenty of what a communist is. Does your girlfriend know about your gaga obsession? If she does than she must be a straight up loser like you. In your eyes absolutely nothing is evidence or backing an argument up. with you anything goes ANYTHING! Your channel shows nothing but star struck ignorance. You are a fool and you are why America is fucked up. Go watch dancing with the stars you loser.

[lobstery7]

@mocatz187 Apparently you don't. You don't even know me, so you can't validify any of your insults against me. You haven't given evidence. Giving something that could be interpreted many different ways is not giving evidence. Plus, I don't even live in America. And Dancing With the Stars sucks.

[lobstery7]

@mocatz187 My intelligence>Yours

[lobstery7]

@mocatz187 She isn't.

[mocatz187]

@lobstery7 Oh yes, she is. read my comment to ukpkmkk below.

[yesimgreek]

anyone who tells me that she can't sing clearly needs to have their ears checked

[Adler36]

She LIVES music, art and love. <3

[Noelle314]

AMAZING. i love her hair this way too :)

[zombie5151]

love her so much

[marcoma103]

YEA I WAS A MONSTER BEFORE SHE WAS BORN! lol

;) I knew she would always be famous

[crazy4corbinbleux]

a bit chubby

[dragonlordx25]

@crazy4corbinbleux why would you point that out?

[crazy4corbinbleux]

@dragonlordx25 because its VERY noticeable? That's the first thing that came to my head when I saw her. And Gaga even said it herself, before she got her big break she had to loose 15 more pounds and she's glad they told her to.

[titanicology]

@MrsAprilsunshine I knew it. :)

[TheNoreLios]

I love her so much <3

[CandiceMusic13]

Gaga is still an amazing artist,now and then. Check her born this way acapella, her speechless performances. She STILL sings like this,when its just raw,her and a piano. Now shes more eccentric and pulls off these huge fashion stunts. But shes incredibly talented and nothing can hide her.

[meghan6121]

I love her so so so much.

[NervelandisMind]

She turn bad. She were so fabulous. I wondering one thing : What happened to her for change like that.

[SuperSeonghoon]

@NervelandisMind money and fame

[ilikepizza161]

i think she turned 18 or may be nineteen and skipped all the other ages and turned 37 she looks ugly now.

[ilikepizza161]

wyf happened

[Callm3chad]

it seems like she never changed her style of song

[Lebdood]

Lady GaGa is her creation. It's even more real than her actual name because it was her creation. It is the lie that is much more honest because she created it.

If you only listen to her singles and then watch these random clips from the past you'll never actually understand what Lady GaGa stands for.

How about you watch the acoustic versions of the music some of you refer to as "trash" and you'll see that her "real self" is still there.

It's the best of both worlds. Pop and Piano.

[meghan6121]

"look out Norah Jones."

Look out EVERYBODY.

[Lagrangianification]

She was born this way

[siamouno7]

Haha 'norah jones look out' look at her now, cant even be compared to her lol

[LittleMonsterMan93]

She's no different in this video than she is now. She's still writing her music, and expressing herself. Truly listen to the music and the lyrics and you can hear it. It's just that now she has the support and the money to do it the way she always dreamed of.

[yaeltru]

She's so talented, either way. I don't think she's better this way or that way, she's just amazing both ways. In her albums she has up-beat songs and songs like this, the thing is that songs like this less succeed than the up-beat songs. I love Lady Gaga so much, and I think this video shows to all the haters that she has pure talent and she actually knows what she's doing in the music industry.

[eslgurucalif]

This adolescent seems so much more grown up than the person we see now. Often people are who they really are at 19.

[TheInsignificantFly]

@eslgurucalif That makes no fucking sense at all.