@sheri226 No, he failed to take me to court and my video was reinstated. He says he will file a DMCA on me again but so far has not yet done so. If he does I will just do a counter notice again and we will do this dance until he gets bored.
My version of the video has Finally been DMCA'd. I hope his account burns for this. The countter notice is filled out. He just doesn't want people to know about what happened with LisaErinBrown
@HappyCabbie When I uploaded it I knew what would happen. The only bummer is the inability to upload videos longer than 15 minutes as I've only just started using that feature. IMO his account should be terminated followed by a lifetime ban. He only went viral thanks to the Gregory's remixing his double rainbow video anyways!!
Bear us obviously an idiot! No court would agree to hear his case because no laws were broken. Just because he disagrees with a law, doesn't make him right, it makes him stupid!
I do wish there were a more clear stance on what is considered fair use.
I always enjoy discussing with you, and privately messaged you in the recent past inquiring your opinion on fair use and the use of clips from movies and movie trailers in movie reviews on here. I often see movie reviewers use movie clips and trailers in their videos and often wondered why some people like you mentioned Nostalgia critic get in trouble for it while so many others do not. There needs to be a standard.
@Absolutesublime1 The standard is essentially this. Some media companies will file DMCAs on any content they find, such as people like Viacom. Others consider it free advertising. Others still may not have found all of the infringing material.
Fair use by definition can not have a clear standard, as it is ultimately determined in a court of law on a case by case basis.
Which is exactly why I said there needs to be a clear standard instead of wasting the courts time on a lot of these cases that are just that; a waste of time and money.
If there were clearer guidelines in effect it would save a lot of people from making videos regarding the subject ;). They should ratify fair use, for instance having percentages of used material pursuant to video length and other such limitations as mentioned by the University of Maryland.
@Absolutesublime1 TheMaskedAnalyst made a great point. In cases like the movie Cloverfield, the whole point of the movie was about what the monster looked like. It was concealed until the very end. Leaking out the final end of the movie when the monster was revealed could have been ruled infringing even if it was a few seconds.
For an interesting Supreme Court decision on this concept look up
YouTube really needs to add a link explaining some basics on that form. They way it is written assumes a certain amount of knowledge of which people are actually largely ignorant. Ah, lawyers - such wonderfully understandable language - NOT!
@MyContext Actually if you scroll down to copyright at the bottom of this page, youtube has a very detailed copyright education center. Everything you need to know about copyright and fair use is right there.
Trying to explain things to someone who has trouble with the concept of rainbows... That wasn't a zit, that was a result of you banging your head against your desk.
Hey HC how do I appeal a YouTube ToS violation? I uploaded the video HungryBear was trying to censor and as soon as it uploaded it was took down due to a ToS violation. I tried the help pages but a lot of it is out of date. Thanx
He wants to be the first one to take this to The Supreme Court, huh? He's obviously never heard of Larry Flynt! Excellent blog HC, unfortunately some people just don't get it... 'it' being REALITY!
@sheri226 actually wasn't the Larry Flint case about parody, as in its mocking of Falwell. Lenz vs Universal Music is a great case to review on fair use.
Looky at all the people who don't care. Of course if someone abused copyright law to keep them from speaking there minds they wouldn't be very happy. That is what a false DMCA is in a nutshell. Abusing copyright law to silence other opinions.
@bobbybob3680 I do not care what he does. So long as he is not abusing the DMCA and putting other people's youtube channels at risk I have no beef with him.
The things he says about Lisa, and the Videos She supposedly saved, are quite wild, especially about the erotic nature of the supposed videos. Whether that is true or not is up for Lisa to know. If they are not, Lisa may have a case against him. Is that Libel or Slander?
white knighting a bit? cant play with turtles, cant look at teen feet, cant work for BC, cant DMCA. whats next, cant beat the wife? whats left for a guy to do for fun then?
Im going to stay out this for today. Im too pissed off to get into it. I'll end up pissing everybody else the fuck off and making the bullshit in to a moutain of fucking bullshit. Bear just pisses me off, hell he blocked me for critisizing him. and I wasnt even being a dick about it! GOD FUCKIN' DAMMIT!
@HappyCabbie This bear charater seems like a nice guy, but these DMCA's are geting too out of hand. I say just let people say what they want about you and let them look like the fools.
Are you going to do a follow up video on this?
sheri226 5 months ago
@sheri226 No, he failed to take me to court and my video was reinstated. He says he will file a DMCA on me again but so far has not yet done so. If he does I will just do a counter notice again and we will do this dance until he gets bored.
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
@HappyCabbie That's great news! You should add an update in the description or an annotation letting people know!
sheri226 5 months ago
The bear just wants some happycabbie.
gravekeepersven 5 months ago
My version of the video has Finally been DMCA'd. I hope his account burns for this. The countter notice is filled out. He just doesn't want people to know about what happened with LisaErinBrown
19822andy 5 months ago
@19822andy sorry to hear you got a DMCA
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
@HappyCabbie When I uploaded it I knew what would happen. The only bummer is the inability to upload videos longer than 15 minutes as I've only just started using that feature. IMO his account should be terminated followed by a lifetime ban. He only went viral thanks to the Gregory's remixing his double rainbow video anyways!!
19822andy 5 months ago
drama queens.glad you are milking views off this. enjoy your $2.
liliavilladotcom 5 months ago
@liliavilladotcom there is no drama in this video
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
you forgat to hide the claim number in the reply (you edited it out on top, but not in the inner msg).
eyallev 5 months ago
@eyallev oops, oh well. Promise me you won't stalk me #LOL
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
@HappyCabbie np, you're not my type anyway ....
eyallev 5 months ago
Bear us obviously an idiot! No court would agree to hear his case because no laws were broken. Just because he disagrees with a law, doesn't make him right, it makes him stupid!
kmfocht 5 months ago
@kmfocht Well even clueless people are entitled to their day in court.
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
i just watched this and let me tell you i was laughing my ass off sounds more like he needs to get a life lol
dungeonmaster600 5 months ago
@dungeonmaster600 thanks for watching
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
@LeavingOnAJet I did, about 30 minutes ago. It also floated.
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
@HappyCabbie LOL, you make me smile. you also thought i called you stupid on another video but i didn't mean that.
marcarmstrong88 5 months ago
@SuperThoughtPolice reading is good
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
I do wish there were a more clear stance on what is considered fair use.
I always enjoy discussing with you, and privately messaged you in the recent past inquiring your opinion on fair use and the use of clips from movies and movie trailers in movie reviews on here. I often see movie reviewers use movie clips and trailers in their videos and often wondered why some people like you mentioned Nostalgia critic get in trouble for it while so many others do not. There needs to be a standard.
Absolutesublime1 5 months ago
@Absolutesublime1 The standard is essentially this. Some media companies will file DMCAs on any content they find, such as people like Viacom. Others consider it free advertising. Others still may not have found all of the infringing material.
Fair use by definition can not have a clear standard, as it is ultimately determined in a court of law on a case by case basis.
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
@HappyCabbie
Which is exactly why I said there needs to be a clear standard instead of wasting the courts time on a lot of these cases that are just that; a waste of time and money.
If there were clearer guidelines in effect it would save a lot of people from making videos regarding the subject ;). They should ratify fair use, for instance having percentages of used material pursuant to video length and other such limitations as mentioned by the University of Maryland.
Absolutesublime1 5 months ago
@Absolutesublime1 TheMaskedAnalyst made a great point. In cases like the movie Cloverfield, the whole point of the movie was about what the monster looked like. It was concealed until the very end. Leaking out the final end of the movie when the monster was revealed could have been ruled infringing even if it was a few seconds.
For an interesting Supreme Court decision on this concept look up
Harper & Row v. Nation Enterprises
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
I'm not sure, but I'm somehow tempted to use part of his DMCA video. For some reason, I want to make him come to Pittsburgh to try and sue me.
theninjasoulreaper 5 months ago
@theninjasoulreaper #LOL
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
Just stop caring about that idiot, dude. Just report him or something. He is obviously just fucking with you.
blackoutworm 5 months ago
@blackoutworm I don't think he is screwing with me, I think he just doesn't understand what he is doing. My videos are aimed at trying to help him.
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
I saw that image you posted on Twitter.
And I like how he says "I don't believe in fair use"
It doesn't matter if he believes in Fair Use or not. Anyone's videos can still, legally, be used within Fair Use.
AlexChris617 5 months ago
@AlexChris617 You can use it so long as it meets the four points of the fair use test.
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
Happycabbie are you going to submit a counter notification?
PaintedTearz 5 months ago
@PaintedTearz already did
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
OMG can he get disciplined for this?
TammyFlores1 5 months ago
@TammyFlores1 eventually he will if he is not careful
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
Bear disappoints me.
Katfellow 5 months ago
@Katfellow he will eventually learn
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
YouTube really needs to add a link explaining some basics on that form. They way it is written assumes a certain amount of knowledge of which people are actually largely ignorant. Ah, lawyers - such wonderfully understandable language - NOT!
Nice blog post on the topic!
MyContext 5 months ago
@MyContext Actually if you scroll down to copyright at the bottom of this page, youtube has a very detailed copyright education center. Everything you need to know about copyright and fair use is right there.
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
Trying to explain things to someone who has trouble with the concept of rainbows... That wasn't a zit, that was a result of you banging your head against your desk.
MethodicalMadness 5 months ago
@MethodicalMadness #LOL
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
Hey HC how do I appeal a YouTube ToS violation? I uploaded the video HungryBear was trying to censor and as soon as it uploaded it was took down due to a ToS violation. I tried the help pages but a lot of it is out of date. Thanx
19822andy 5 months ago
@19822andy I already replied to this in PM, glad I was able to help
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
Meh. Let the process run its course and he'll soon hit that brick wall called "reality"
rozeboosje 5 months ago
@rozeboosje well said
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
He wants to be the first one to take this to The Supreme Court, huh? He's obviously never heard of Larry Flynt! Excellent blog HC, unfortunately some people just don't get it... 'it' being REALITY!
sheri226 5 months ago
@sheri226 actually wasn't the Larry Flint case about parody, as in its mocking of Falwell. Lenz vs Universal Music is a great case to review on fair use.
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
@LeavingOnAJet I do. Just a bit. But I do.
GumbaMasta 5 months ago
Looky at all the people who don't care. Of course if someone abused copyright law to keep them from speaking there minds they wouldn't be very happy. That is what a false DMCA is in a nutshell. Abusing copyright law to silence other opinions.
felinoid 5 months ago
@felinoid I know
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
why should you care what he does??
bobbybob3680 5 months ago
@bobbybob3680
Because he's being a dickbag to other youtubers.
ComradeAlpharius 5 months ago
@bobbybob3680 I do not care what he does. So long as he is not abusing the DMCA and putting other people's youtube channels at risk I have no beef with him.
HappyCabbie 5 months ago
He needs more than a lawyer to "step forward" to help him. There's also that pesky federal court filing fee (around 500 bucks).
realman1000000000000 6 months ago
Double Rainbow All The Way Across the Sky!
AdenCrockerTV 6 months ago
The things he says about Lisa, and the Videos She supposedly saved, are quite wild, especially about the erotic nature of the supposed videos. Whether that is true or not is up for Lisa to know. If they are not, Lisa may have a case against him. Is that Libel or Slander?
KiddsockTV 6 months ago
white knighting a bit? cant play with turtles, cant look at teen feet, cant work for BC, cant DMCA. whats next, cant beat the wife? whats left for a guy to do for fun then?
tom9152a 6 months ago
@tom9152a There's always room for Trolling :P
realman1000000000000 6 months ago
It'll never happen. He is "The One". There will be only ONE DMCA to rule them all.
MeanBlackDude 6 months ago
Hes a jackwagon!
quakertownjackass 6 months ago
Looks like YT's DMCA policy is finally getting some attention. Unfortunately it's because of justin beeber. Saw it on tv the other day.
hevyAccel 6 months ago
Hungrybear doesn't give a shit, he's willfully ignorant.
MalchikBlue 6 months ago
Im going to stay out this for today. Im too pissed off to get into it. I'll end up pissing everybody else the fuck off and making the bullshit in to a moutain of fucking bullshit. Bear just pisses me off, hell he blocked me for critisizing him. and I wasnt even being a dick about it! GOD FUCKIN' DAMMIT!
HappyIsFleeting 6 months ago
Holy crap Google is getting in on the Groupon craze?
startreking2007 6 months ago
i still don't get it. ????
lardo444 6 months ago
I like HungryBear he is like Corky only retard and also a pedophile. Go Bear!
happyjesus123 6 months ago
His response is putting his fingers in his ears and going "lalalalla i'm right you're wrong! lalalalala" lol
falulu209 6 months ago
Hi Happy.... you're fast ....:)
lilimax555 6 months ago
You brought out the Picard facepalm? This must be serious!
pamew 6 months ago
@pamew double facepalm
jsJavaScript 6 months ago
@pamew ''picard facepalm'' hehe make it so
dungeonmaster600 6 months ago
First 'like' fuck yeah!
alterbyme 6 months ago
First
HappyCabbie 6 months ago
@HappyCabbie This bear charater seems like a nice guy, but these DMCA's are geting too out of hand. I say just let people say what they want about you and let them look like the fools.
TheTryingman 5 months ago