Added: 5 years ago
From: Christabel13
Views: 127,676
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (320)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I like so much Tuomas but Tarja choose Marcelo and he looks a good person. I don´t know if Tarja will come back one day to Nightwish, I hope so but he has to apologize about quik her out because he was too bad with her. She can´t ask to come back. On other way, she´s going too much well alone. The truth is that everybody wants the Tarja´s voice back to Nightwish...

  • Hey,i was reading ttromance.It´s fantastic.=)

    Oh,and the video,too.=)

  • This video is amazing!

    Congrats! ^^

    We all want Tarja back :(

  • isn't that Ironic??? A video related to Nightwish and a song that is played on it is from Within Temptation...great song though :p

  • Did you know why Traja was fired? D:

    Tuomas wanted it... And he probably had a reason.

    Unfortunatly, yes, she'll not coming back D:

  • tarja have the best voice i never heard

  • when Tarja was in nightwish, Toumas's songs were full of love, now are full of sadness...I feel so

  • Wooow... so cute... Is difficult that something makes me cry, but how can I dont cry with this??

    Really.. I dont have any problem with Annette (she likes me too), and their style [NW] still be amazing (only to say 1 adjetive) ... but with Tarja all the glory came alive....

    But just the memories can heal us

    Anyway, Tarja was a reckless child....

    Why Lord?, Why?!

  • bye bye diva...

  • Thumbs Up if you want Tarja back in Nightwish!!!!!

  • Classic !

  • Why does that man (?is it Tuomas?) has so sad face, at the times you see his close up?

  • ur long roks tarja the godess

  • @Jurie0 Tarja is great ????,

    U was on her concert in Vizivice (Czech Cepublic) and I was borred of her. I hoped that she will play some more songs from Nightwish but she sings only two from them.She sings 75 minutes and in to 60th minute I was absolutely bored, but after that I could hear some notes from ´´Beauty of the Beast ´´and I a started to feel great. After this song she sings ´´Forever yours´´ .Nightwish is going to be great from now on , but Tarja will go down really fast.....

  • What the hell is with the nightwish "bye bye" with the 5 girls???

  • our farewell by within temptation

  • tuomas is so handsome

  • can anyone tell me what is the name of the song? it's so beautiful and it makes me cry...

  • Name of the song is 'I want to die' by mortal love

  • @ckfunconi: Dax Johnson - Beloved

  • @Christabel13 "Our Farewell" by Within Temptation (Mother Earth CD)

  • Come to think of it, isn't kind of cruel that Toumas dismissed Tarja AFTER the concert "End of an Era", talk about greedy and opportunist >__>

  • actually, tarja had planned to leave nightwish after the tour anyway... that's why they named it end of an era... but i honestly thing that nightwish screwed up when she left, especially by hiring anette... ick...

  • NICE, it makes me cry.

    Nightwish will not be the same without our beauty Tarja.

    ;_; lol

  • i love it !good job 5*****!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • An angel is irreplaceable!

  • I love Tarja and I love Anette, but mainly I love Nightwish!!!

  • I consider Nightwish a new band now so I can listen to them....

  • anette is great, but tarja was best x(

  • nightwish really needs tarja

  • I agree 100 %

  • why? anette is a great singer too, maybe she's different, but she's amazing too..

    and it's good to have a change sometimes..

  • yeaaaah it does :(

  • Nunca lograre entender como Tuomas llego a echar a Tarja de su banda, de su vida, de esta forma, todavia no acepto el hecho de ke Tarja se hubiera ido tan derepente

    The world needs Singers like u, Tarja and Players lake u, Tuomas. You are exelents, but both together are perfect. . . I MISS U OLD NIGHTWISH!!!!!!!!

  • Tú no entiendes porque no pasabas 24 horas con ellos :).

  • xDDD

  • Tarja come back, we need you.

  • @erwin191990

    So true! Tarja is missed here :(.

  • tarja miss you come pliezz back

  • Tarja come back , the new singer song false

  • Tarja come back!!;(

    I miss you Tarja and old era Nightwish ;((

    I cry .....

    :(

    COme Back!!!!

  • This is not Within Temptation's "Our Farewell".

  • guys pls tell me ,where this melody comes from ?

  • It says the song is Our Farewell by WT

  • I think we all miss Tarja. But they are never going to be a real band again. There was a reason why she left the band.

  • Exacly! This is so true.

  • Hmm.... I still think they would have been a good pair... ^^

    No.. NW with Tarja was fantastic and NW with Anette is just good. I think it isn't NW anymore... it's something dirfferent, but it's still very good.

    No one is able to be as good as Tarja... and Tuomas did the right things... He created a new band. With a new stile and a new good singer...

  • anette debe ser hechada de nightwish, no tiene nada que hacer ahi. la banda tiene que seguir con marcus como cantante.

  • hola no se escribir muy bien en ingles,pero segun mis fuentes anette esta atrvezando momentos muy duros con nightwish,anette tubo que contratar a un mannager por culpa de los integrantes de la banda...nightwish no esta bien,ni tampoco es un cuento de hadas como decia tuomas...anette esta luchando para ser oida y respetada,yo no aprecio mucho a anette pero realmente la voy a apoyar en todo!

  • dónde oiste eso? o_o yo no he escuchado nada al respecto.... :-O

  • it's about writing and playing what you feel. The band is happy with Anette, so let them be. Tuomas had said he didn't want another Tarja, he wanted another singer to sing what he was writing and Anette was their choice. So as a NW fan I support them, although I still feel something more special listening to the old era. Anette should't be compared to Tarja because they're different types of singers. So anyone who just wants to insult others should go fuck themselves or something... NW forever!

  • amen *

  • the band has to be able to express their music on stage and if Tarja was changing cause of her husband's fault and it was causing problems in the band then the best thing to do was to let her go, Tuomas gives everything he has to NW and NW was more important to him then his feelings for her, they would've been great together, but the heart can't always be controled. Still the new NW, even though a different style, is still expressing what they feel, it's not about being stuck to a certain genre

  • I agree that the old NW was a very unique band, they had their own place in the music world, Tarja's voice was what made their songs so special, Tuomas' songwriting was made with all his feelings and emotions "All of my songs can only be composed of the greatest of pains, every single verse can only be born from the greatest of wishes, I wish I had one more night to live"

  • aah.

    i miss tarja soo much. :(

    she is the best. forever.

    ....

  • tarja turunen go back to Nightwish.

  • ;(

    Come back Tarja

  • aahh....nice song...love Within Temptation!!!

  • nice video..

    i miss the tarja Era :(

  • Great work Christabel13 !!!!

  • Wow,this really made my day. As much as I'm going through drama,this smoothed it...I missed them together...did anyone hear about Anette leaving the stage in Brazil?

  • Oo What happened?

  • she left stage due to the fog smoke. Heh...real professional.

  • No, no I checked than. Many said its cuz she has some personal problem and they say it's about her son :(

  • Wasn't it because people were shouting for Tarja? Thats what i heard. I feel so sorry for her, she is having a rough time..

  • tuomas said that it was because people was screaming for tarja and giving her the finger

  • it was cuz people we're being asses to her and she was having problems with her son

  • yeah she left the stage

  • Ah... This is so beautiful. I almost made me cry :')

    Without Tarja, Nigthwish's new stuff... sucks.

  • very well done <3

    im loving it

  • Great job ;) made my day

    He is amazing

  • omg! this vid is so sad my heart dropped just hearing the music!

  • Un preciosoo videeooo!!

    Is a beautiful videeo! Really i almost cry! wuah well bye

  • 3:25 I love her dress

  • Me too *__*

  • I MISS U TARJA :(

  • Sharon and Tarja - Queens of metal music

  • I love Tarja Turunen, but i like nw too. It will never be the same again but what can we do?

  • OMG! i Love Tarja and Tuomas, and I Love this song!!!

  • Tuomas still

    makes amasing music so Nightwish is still worth to hear. And after several listening to the new Album I realised that its another masterpiece.

  • nightwish is bad without thequeen tarjaturunen

  • nightwish..........never will be the same

  • Well, her voice might be replaceble, but she's a star and a diva that will be almost impossible to replace.

  • little cheesy :P 5*! good job!

  • i'm crying

  • Perfect....

  • BellaMasonCullen-I loved it,it almost made me cry a couple a times.

  • its so sad by the way i had a vid about new nightwish and had to take it off cause it was 2 offensive i just what 2 say sorry to the people i offended

    and tuomas looks like my bff chad its scarry

  • then ur bff is hot! lol

  • anette tiene buena voz pero no para cantar con nigthwish, extraño tanto a tarja ¡¡¡ pero aun asi sigo apoyandolos ¡¡

  • My honest oppinion is that EVERY1 that says Anette sux, Sux themselves. Anette is a GREAT singer and she can give Nightwish alot in the next few years. She cant sing Tarjas songs cause they are not made for her and opera is not her style. Jeez guys. give her a break and Love Nightwish nomatter what happens. Cheers and harmony from Denmark. Btw this video is awesome :)

  • "love nw nomatter what hapens!"

    why? does nw love us? nw never cared about the fans when it changed the style with 180 degrees!

  • Im sorry but thats just bull to say. <.< If u are a true fan of NW then even though they changed singer u hould give them a chance to get up again.

  • I am a fan and i gived them a chance to get up but it will never be the same without Trja :(

  • there a band not a product of commerce.

    fuck the fans.

    as a band you do what you feel is to be rigth.

    not what the fans migth want.

    no offence but the fans have to live with it.

    not the other way around

  • we are living with it, but not buying anything from the new stuff....

  • look i dont like the new girl either.

    if it was up to me i whould let marco do or the singing or find a new opera vocalist to join them again.

    Bet not my choice..

  • I respect that. But I think, that the band has lost its magic without Tarja

  • aaaaaaaaaaaala! no puedo creer que esta cancion me haya hecho llorar:(

  • I write in my language:ANNETTE VAI A CAGARE

  • Oh I love this song sooooo much! And it's so sad:(:(:( beautiful!

  • Look whats done is done, i agree that i prefer tarja..but i havent really given annette a chance...however..all things MUST change..but look at tarja now...shes got her own thing going now...and shes got no restraints...she can only go higher with her beautiful voice...

  • Pourquoi mettre une chanson de Within Temptation sur une vidéo de Nigtwish ???

  • Anette really sucks!She is not that bad, but she sucks for Nightwish..!

    they need Tarja to be as majestic as before...

  • tarja we miss you. anette sux.

  • You're right, we do miss Tarja. Or at least I do.

  • this song made me cry! :(

    i love tuomas and tarja! :)

  • cudowne cudne piękne! xD koooocham i uwielbiam!

    * , * omężę się z Tuo kiedyś! Zbaczycie!xDDD

  • So I noticed something... apparently they booted Tarja cus she wasn't warm enough? Ever watch Anette in an interview? She's very tense and up tight unless she's being spoken to, even then... Tarja smiles often, and seems so much more alive then some doll when being interviewed. Also, on stage. Yeah, Anette dances around, but Tarja actually waved to the audiance, smiled, waved her hands to encite their excitement, ect. ::Shrugs:: Just something I've noticed.

    -Lochness

  • They let Tarja go b/c her focus on the reason for wanting to make music changed, (according to what I understand from Toumas's "open letter"). Apparently she said at one point that she didn't need Nightwish...I think the tenseness you're seeing w/Anette is usually present when the interview switches from English to Finnish - I know I'd be a little bit tense too - you wouldn't know what they were saying...that and she's under a _lot_ of pressure, etc etc....anyhooo - great video :)

  • I see that only in interviewa in Suomi. Anette does not speak the language, it is not surprising for her to get a little tense because she doesn't know what the other people are talking about. In many interviewa she actually "saved" Tuomas from answering unwanted questions.

  • yeah Tarja totally owned the stage! You don't have to jump around on stage to be a great performer. In fact, it makes it all seem fake for me sometimes. Classical singers aren't meant to jump around too much on stage anyways cause it would mess with their breathing. <3 tarja

  • sweet and beautiful video!tarja 4 ever...sweet memories for ever...

  • so funny you used this song the other day i heard this song and my first thought was nightwish...good job!

  • Very well-put together. touching.

  • Within Temptation - Our Farewell ... live version is amasing! :-)

  • his mike was wack!

  • tarja you are the best !!!

  • Que tristeeeeeeee

    =/

    saudades

  • All these idiots out there picking any insignificant thing wrong about Tarja just to diss her, she never helped with song arrangements so she's selfish, did jukka? does that make him selfish! They must think there being good dissing Tarja, but the first person to defend Tarja would be Toumas he would not want to see people dissing Tarja even with there differences. People chattin bollox when they no NOTHING. The new NW aint bad but it jus does not compare, its such a shame she's gone.

  • Nightwish is even with Annette excellent and they have more fans than once with Tarja. I've just seen their concert in Prague, which was marvelous experience, that can't be compared to the music Tarja's doing now on her own. There ruled friendly atmosphere among musicians on stage, which I have never felt in Tarja's era.

    Please understand, that if Tarja had stayed with Nightwish, it would have meant slow destruction of Nightwish.

    Tuomas knew well what he had to do to keep Nightwish alive.

  • are they married??

  • someone asked that same question, and he said: "one wrong word here and i'm going to end up in the tabloids again. let's just say that we had a personal relationship without anything romantic"

    Tarja herself is married to Marcelo Cabuli.

    Tuomas prefers to keep that information to himself, though he is not married.

  • no.

  • oooooooooohhhhhhhhh..i'm crying..this is so beautiful...

  • ;;___;;

  • LOL nO hOPEFULLY sHE iS aLIVE!!

  • please tell me that se isnt dead

  • She isn't dead. She was fired from Nightwish in 2005.

  • ohhhh thank god

  • its a song from within temptation right...nice song selection for the video.

    very cool!

  • Tarja.... where are you?

  • so sad!! :(

  • we miss you Tarja ...

  • beautiful video :)

  • Together dose two ARE Nightwish

  • Nah.. need Marco too

  • ha did you know that marco came into band later then tarja and tuomas?

  • At first,Tuomas played the bass too...See their first Album-Angels fall first. Tuomas isn't there.

  • Tuomas didn't play the bass... That was Emppu... Tuomas only touched the keyboard and he sings on te album angels fall first and he was there... He wrote the whole album angels fall first. Just lettin' you know.

  • Lol this is disgusting. How can you imagine band with 2 people in it?! Just like some sports team, the band can't be built on 2 people.

    I'm sorry but I totaly dissagree with you.

  • What about White Stripes lmao

  • There are a lot of duet bands

  • Actually there are bands which are built of 2 persons and even only ONE person(Pain for example) and they sound very well...

  • Isn't Nine Inch Nails also a one person band? xD;

  • Beautiful!!!...I loved it, very tender!!

  • ya i rly wish she didnt marry her manager, ever since that she got greedy, rly do think she is an amazing singer, loves her in Nightwish

  • geez we all know who sings our farewell... it's just that this song goes with the situation... think before you talk whisperingwidow

  • read the discription smart one.

  • So beautiful ! Miss Tarja in nightwish.

  • So beautiful. I wish it was still Tarja and Tuomas in just one beautiful band NIGHTWISH.

  • Me too :(

  • Esta cancion es de Whitin Temtation, no la canta Tarja, aunque me gustaria escuchar una version cantada por ella.

  • Tarja's voice is in-fucking-credible... Nightwish is lost without her...

  • sharon has a beautiful voice; but no comparison to tarja's opera voice of course! Tarja should teach sharon! They are both goddesses anyhow

  • uhm i dont think so some how

    sharon is a MILLION times better than tarja

  • Sharon's voice is amazing, even moreso than Tarja's because Sharon sings with passion, when she sings she generates the mixture of emotion and music together. Tarja expects everyone to kneel to her mediocre voice. Sharon is better, Liv Kristine is better,Loreena is better, Miriam Stockley is better.

  • i sorta disagree.. on passion issue.. i dont think Tarja nor Sharon sing it with passion.. but whatever !

  • ever dream live end of an era, then talk about tarja not having passion...

  • I disagree Tarja's voice is much uniquer and so beautiful I LOVE TARJA! (L)

  • I AGREE!

  • Tarja isn´t so good,like Sharon den Adel.Sharon has angel´s voice.And she is beatifull,too.And clever.Tarja hasn´t so soft voice.