Good job on this. I think you are close to getting it work. Try sanding the rod down a bit. I think you have it fit too tight.you want your o-ring to for the seal not the piston rod. Keep trying. Maybe you could do a follow up video.I made one but used man made materials so it was a little easier to get to work. Check out my video to see it work.
Sean Dont give up Mate. I made a few and its hard work to get it just right.I also have one i bought and it doesnt work everytime either.It all must be just right and its easier said than done.Good try though Sean. If you would like a few tips send me a line or 2 be glad to help.
Looks nice to me I have a feeling with some work you could make that work. One person mentioned that it may not slide easy enough I think he may be right. I would try removing more material closer up to the Handel leave it the same size on the end. Also some fire pistons have a slot as well as the hole to put the char cloth in. Last thing I can think of which you didn't specify. Did you actually use real chat cloth. Some people say even the best fire piston won't work without good char cloth.
Sean, welcome to my world. I made a fire piston as well and i had the same outcome, not enough compression. i am not quite sure what the secret is but it's definitely frustrating, especially the amount of effort and time that goes into it.
Overall, great video as always. Keep up the great videos!
Sure was a valid attempt. It would have been cool if it had worked. The piston looked a little tight too, maybe that slowed the piston action down just enough to prevent fire???
Nice try. Have you thought about looking for a straight piece of wood for the piston that doesn't need to be shaped? Then you could size your hole accordingly. When you drill your hole, it should be uniform to begin with, once you start trying to shape it any further you're introducing imperfections. Most of the piston should slide easily, except at the tip where you need something to make a good seal. Perhaps a waxed string or ring of rubber?
your a great guy you no mate, i don't normally comment that much, but every time i see one of your vids you are always helping people out, that are not in the fortunate position to buy things, like the free give away you have done, its very nice of you, just wish there were more people like you in the world, wouldn't it be a great place.
I hope this helps,drill the hole for the tinder hole seal it with finger nail polish so it won't burn ,sand down the rod to fit in the piston because the o-ring makes the seal and for the o-ring itself use a pipe cutter to make the cut lines trim a little with your knife then use a long thin piece of sand paper to sand out for the o-ring groove. I use Chap Stick (a waxy lip balm) to lube my o-ring also you may need to sand the inside of the piston to make it smooth for a tight fit.
Too bad it didn't work, extra care is needed with the ring piece and it's a good idea to lube your shaft very well before pumping, particularly when your wood is as big as that. All in all I'm impressed, it looks firm and solid, and could take quite a beating. We all have to start somewhere, but remember it's not always size that matters, technique counts for a lot.
Good job on this. I think you are close to getting it work. Try sanding the rod down a bit. I think you have it fit too tight.you want your o-ring to for the seal not the piston rod. Keep trying. Maybe you could do a follow up video.I made one but used man made materials so it was a little easier to get to work. Check out my video to see it work.
crazywhitedog78 1 month ago
Sean Dont give up Mate. I made a few and its hard work to get it just right.I also have one i bought and it doesnt work everytime either.It all must be just right and its easier said than done.Good try though Sean. If you would like a few tips send me a line or 2 be glad to help.
SilentWolf1966 2 months ago
wow good job unlucky with the seal = )
dannywood22 4 months ago
Looks nice to me I have a feeling with some work you could make that work. One person mentioned that it may not slide easy enough I think he may be right. I would try removing more material closer up to the Handel leave it the same size on the end. Also some fire pistons have a slot as well as the hole to put the char cloth in. Last thing I can think of which you didn't specify. Did you actually use real chat cloth. Some people say even the best fire piston won't work without good char cloth.
kdoubleg 6 months ago
maybe a young osage tree?
lordraveneyeofra 7 months ago
WOW... u mate have done a very execellent job!! A++++
TheNZrepper 10 months ago
Well done.Atleast you tried.
Sandy
g0vqw 11 months ago
sorry, but volume still too low after a whole year.
btsseeker 1 year ago
great vid and good try good luck next time
cslr11 1 year ago
Sean, welcome to my world. I made a fire piston as well and i had the same outcome, not enough compression. i am not quite sure what the secret is but it's definitely frustrating, especially the amount of effort and time that goes into it.
Overall, great video as always. Keep up the great videos!
Back2DaBasix 1 year ago
Nice work Sean, I'm sure after a few more attempts you'll have it working perfectly.
Mike.
WeaponCollector 1 year ago
Sure was a valid attempt. It would have been cool if it had worked. The piston looked a little tight too, maybe that slowed the piston action down just enough to prevent fire???
Woodenarrows 1 year ago
Nice try. Have you thought about looking for a straight piece of wood for the piston that doesn't need to be shaped? Then you could size your hole accordingly. When you drill your hole, it should be uniform to begin with, once you start trying to shape it any further you're introducing imperfections. Most of the piston should slide easily, except at the tip where you need something to make a good seal. Perhaps a waxed string or ring of rubber?
rulrich45 1 year ago
Didnt they grease it with animal fat to seal it and make the plunge faster?
canadianbushman 1 year ago
Really nice video. Great thought too.
It's a shame it didn't work in the end, but it was definitely worth a go. Keep up the good videos mate!
jonthedoors 1 year ago
Good video, I bet you'll get it working. I'm interested in seeing one of these homemade, if you get working please share that. Thanks!
mwig50 1 year ago
@StrykingHawk
I think I didn;t get the dowel as straight as it could be.
seanmulhall 1 year ago
your a great guy you no mate, i don't normally comment that much, but every time i see one of your vids you are always helping people out, that are not in the fortunate position to buy things, like the free give away you have done, its very nice of you, just wish there were more people like you in the world, wouldn't it be a great place.
lucklee1 1 year ago 11
@lucklee1
Thank you for your kind comments. It very much appreciated.
seanmulhall 1 year ago
+++++
Snicke22 1 year ago
very nice...
hinckleypoland 1 year ago
looks like wood from a blossoming cherry tree
ledaczepplindc 1 year ago
@ledaczepplindc
Thank you. As I said I was unsure.
seanmulhall 1 year ago
Homemade MagLite Torch Fire Piston
watch?v=-djD2n2YSv0
Prepare2Survive 1 year ago
I hope this helps,drill the hole for the tinder hole seal it with finger nail polish so it won't burn ,sand down the rod to fit in the piston because the o-ring makes the seal and for the o-ring itself use a pipe cutter to make the cut lines trim a little with your knife then use a long thin piece of sand paper to sand out for the o-ring groove. I use Chap Stick (a waxy lip balm) to lube my o-ring also you may need to sand the inside of the piston to make it smooth for a tight fit.
CZBOHUNK 1 year ago
@CZBOHUNK
Thanks. I'll try your tips for the next one I make. Trust assured you'll get the credit if it works.
seanmulhall 1 year ago
if you try something and you fall on your face,atleast you are still moveing forward...
12fitzgerald 1 year ago
Too bad it didn't work, extra care is needed with the ring piece and it's a good idea to lube your shaft very well before pumping, particularly when your wood is as big as that. All in all I'm impressed, it looks firm and solid, and could take quite a beating. We all have to start somewhere, but remember it's not always size that matters, technique counts for a lot.
PeterGratrex 1 year ago
totally agree, it's only a mistake if you don't learn from it. Nice effort though mate and I learned from it, so cheers for sharing.
kobudo4 1 year ago
"IF AT FIRST YOU DON'T SUCCEED, TRY, TRY AGAIN. Don't give up too easily; persistence pays off in the end. Good Luck.
jenn011754 1 year ago
excellent attempt hopefully the next one will turn out better.
unrulyierulli1 1 year ago
nice work ive been thinking of making one of these. just a sugestion, but how about getting a peace of dowl for the plunger?
hobo31009 1 year ago
this is pretty cool for a first attempt
longltran 1 year ago
Nice tutorial for making a fire piston. Too bad it did not work, perhaps the plunger was too tight. Good try.
Trailtraveller 1 year ago
@Trailtraveller
I agree. It wasn't straight enough.
seanmulhall 1 year ago
sad :(
but thanks for the video :)
thumbs up
scavenski 1 year ago