Added: 2 years ago
From: djanedee
Views: 355,572
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (241)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • xD re linda *-*!

  • ooohhh que boniiitaa!! es! :)

  • ♥why am i crying♥

    ♥i dont wanna cry♥

    ♥but the tears can't stop falling♥

  • have somebody notes for violin please? thanx

  • this song is nothing without James' aggressive, yet passionate and emotional voice and Kirk's amazing guitar solo.

  • @12JimmySmith James did the solo.

  • METALLICA RULES!!!!!!!!

    I hate covers of untouchable songs.

  • i love metallica but this is perfect and beautiful! Love this...represents lyrics better.

  • Haters will be haters, but this is a good cover by her

  • no habia un videoclip? no lo encuentro!! :(

  • La versión original de metallica es de diez!!! y la actual de Lucie silvas es espectacular, no desmerece una a la otra. Impresionante!!!

  • as metallicas biggest fan.....i fuckin love this and its awesome!!!! Nobody better disagree with me or else.....im fuckin warning u guys aaaagggghhhhh!!!

  • @dwano20 I agree. But what are you going do with the 39 people what have pressed on the dislike button?

  • Congratulations! You have accomplished something I thought was impossible:

    You are THE first person EVER to rape a song!

  • It aint bad... but there's only one solo T_T

  • esta canción ha marcado mi vida (;

  • somehow this song makes me remember the first Saw movie... , still I have to say I like Lucie's version way more than that of Metallica, but thats probably because I don't like rockish music.

  • I want to dance to this at my wedding...

  • Comment removed

  • The intro is so deep and better

  • The intro is so deep

  • Beautiful.

  • I actually like this version than metallica's version, it "feels" softer.

  • @MaartjeStuff

    Oh, and nice pictures in the vid C:

  • me encanta(L)!

  • Nice voice, nice version..lovely video!!

  • They should remove all of her bones, just for attempting to hitch on Metallicas succes

  • @all of those who have written beneath me...

    I couldn't agree more with BlackHawkGaming. the sentences 'All these words I don't just say' and 'all these words I just don't say' have very different meanings. Although I like the way the music is composed in this version.

  • I prefer the elevator version of the original, or the S&M one. :) But cred to the lady for doing a decent version.

    However; the original is for me the perfect "power ballad". It's pure perfection when it comes to building up a song, I love the lyrics, I love the sound and I absolutely adore the big finale of the original: James Hetfields solo. Others are entitled to their opinion, though.

  • @tottelott yes definitely. The Original US release version of the song was amazing, but the elevator version released on the UK release can't be compared due to its difference in feeling and atmosphere of the ambiance in the way its played. This version is alright, but it would have been better had she had sang the lyrics the way it was written: "All these words I don't Just Say" as opposed to "All these words I just don't say" =/ thats just me

  • @BlackHawkGaming ~ Yeah, that's just you. I guess you don't realize that songs are not always sung exactly, word for word, the way they were written, or first performed. Did you ever hear of "artistic interpretation"?

  • @edwardjames50 lol i get really ocd about stuff, don't get so serious man =)

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • i just love her voice so much.!

    i totally love these song and its lyrics.. can't tell that the original is better.

    her voice fits best to the lyrics - just my opinion.

  • i think that this son is so romantic!!!!!!! i know that you know that you dont love me. But I will continue trying that you say to me that if you love me, because that is like that

  • Ainsssssssssssssssss mi amor bonito ven, ven mi amor bonito, ven

  • Ainsssssssssssssssss mi amor bonito

  • We all know the original is better.. nobody can do Metallica like Metallica.. but she's got a good voice and I kinda like this girl version of the song.. this particular video, not so much.

  • I know a lot of you com ment about how the original version is better, but lucie's voice is gorgeous and she really sings the song great!

  • Excuse me, alot of you say that she changes the lyrics, but minor changes to lyrics in covers is completely normal to fit the song ebtter to her. i am a HUGE fan of metallica and she could NEVER do this better than metallica. But i wanna commend her for making one of the few metallica covers i could be fucked listening to. and her voice is delicious! :D

  • everything is better comparing to shakira´s back in black : /****

  • shit

  • @fessenger shit who wrote that -.-

  • I prefer this version above Metallica's.

  • awesoom beatiful nr and a wonderful good videoclip nice song........

  • butchered.

  • You know, it wouldn't have killed her read the liner notes of the original before stepping into the recording booth.

  • @Kjacket0

    What do you mean?

  • @Shaddew I mean she completely butchered the lyrics.

  • @Kjacket0

    Yeah, I noticed. Sometimes just by rotating two words.

  • metallica is awesome but this version is really good!!!!

    congratulations for the video!

  • she sings it good... but metallica is better 

  • Metallica manda, absurdas copias, vergonzosas

  • the version of metallica is best than this version in all the senses

  • the lyrics are wrong LOL

  • @BeMexRory  LOL

  • oh shut up and listen to the song people, oké, no one could do this song better than metallica,, even i know that but i think lucie did a wonderfull job with it, so give her a break..

  • @mysound4y correction; no one could do ANY metallica song better than metallica.

    and yes, this is just to irritate you :)

  • i will do this number on my funeral, its wunderfull!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Lol fail, get the lyrics right before you sing a song like this.

  • boo

  • veronica crotti ricordi

    andate a vedere e sentire

  • I never heard a cover of this sing cept this...and honestly i dont wanna hear another cover after this.

  • the orginal is better

  • @0rgasmus yes, original is better but this version is ok :)

  • @0rgasmus

    The original Orgasmus is better :D

  • @0rgasmus  The original is Different... not neccecarily better... ;-)

  • lucie done it!!! thats the best cover ive ever heart from this song!!!

  • miserable and needless :S

  • I prefer Apocalyptica version of NEM personally, but this one is good too

  • aii das lied ist einfach hammer

  • metallica is better

  • What a way to ruin this song, it would remove Cliff Buton in his grave if he hears this ... Metallica Up! counterfeit down.

    Que manera de estropear esta cancion, Cliff Buton se removeria en su tumba si escucha esto... Arriba Metallica! abajo falsificaciones.

    Sorry my bad english, is google translator xD

  • @SPANISHROBERTO killo, eres un revenio de cojones... me parece mu bien ke te guste metallica, y chúpala si no te gusta esta version. A mi me gusta, y no la escuches si a ti no y tampoco te pongas a decir tonterias. COMENAVOS!

  • @nemtark Yo te he insultao a ti? comenaBos tu padre asi saliste tu!

  • @SPANISHROBERTO a mi no, pero a la version si, respeta los gustos de los demas GILIPOLLAS!

  • @nemtark que pasa eres una niña quemada de la vida? te has casao con Lucie? solo tu puedes dar tu opinion? No, verdad? pues dejame en paz con mis opiniones que para eso hay me gusta y no me gusta en el youtube y dejame a mi y mis opiniones tranquilas, ok? Yo respetare la cancion cuando gente como tu aprenda a respetar a los demas y sus opiniones, los insultos te los metes por donde te quepan ; )

  • @SPANISHROBERTO estas amargao macho xD

  • @nemtark amargao? o te he dejado sin palabras? que sepas que a diferencia de muchos yo tengo vida social o sea no tengo motivos para estar amargado y creo que con mi comentario anterior te he dejado sin tus argumentos de contraataque y sin tus insultos ; ) vamos que te he dao una leccion de modales xD

  • @SPANISHROBERTO oh si! me acabas d dar en un comentario toooooooooooooooooooooooda la educacion ke no m han dado mis padres en todos mis año de vida.

    Encima d amargado, aburrido xDD

  • @nemtark al menos respetable no como otra gente ; )

  • @SPANISHROBERTO respetable tu? Claaaaaaaaaaaro el que va x ahí insultando los gustos de los demás.

    Venga killo, ten tu la ultima palabra como hombre que eres, que si no no duermes trankilo, k ya no t doy mas el gustazo de constestarte.

  • @nemtark Insultar? que yo sepa a la version esta no he dicho k es una mierda ni una gilipoyez, que eso son si insultos, solo he dicho que la han estropeado pero cacho y que los muertos de MetallicA (solo Cliff) se removerian en la tumba si lo oyeran... Tu en cambio que si revenio que si comenabos, gilipoyas etc etc... mas respetable que tu seguro chata ; )

  • GO JAMES HETFIELD FROM METALLICA!

  • It sounds like Apocalyptica minus the vocals.. I have to admit so far no one has Outdone Metallica, I don't think anyone will!!!!!

  • perfect singer for the coolest song ever

  • Brilliant

  • yeah i agree . Metallicas version is THE best . But this one is very good :) I love this one .

  • einfach Wundervoll *-*

  • Of course Metallica is better but I agree with Shawty01100. Check out the Bif Naked cover - that version sounds good too

  • yeah metallica is better, but for a girl with a beautiful voice like this it doesnt matter who's better the lyric says enough (l)

  • Es ist wunderschoen .. !! Aber metallica ist einfach nunmaL besser :)

  • she has a beautiful voice and harmonizes really well, she is a lot better than others but never/not close to metallica

  • Metallica´s version is simply the best one. But i like this version so much!:O i´ve never heard it before. LOve it(L)

  • sorry.. Lucie leave it to the experts huh.... try singing lady ga ga and leave the ROCK Music to the rockers...

  • @cruizee69 Uh, "try singing lady ga ga and leave the ROCK Music to the rockers"? Really? I think her voice is great. And it's not rock, it's metal. I'm not trying to flame you or anything I just REALLY didn't like the Lady Ga Ga remark. It's seems kinda prejudiced

  • @PrideInIndividuality - oh well... all I can say is ... if she wants to make it big then she should be clever enough to write her own music and stop riding on other people's perfection and their awesome hits. Nothing Else matters is a true classic from Metallica and that is where it should stop. If you like her music good for you... I DON'T - this is my opinion and I am sure you wouldn't like metallica if you are in to her.

  • @cruizee69 Okay, I agree she should write her own music. I love Metallica, and their version is better, that's true, Just the Lady Gaga remark sounds like your saying women should only sing pop. I hate people that say that. Now, that may not have been what you meant, it just sounded like it to me. If not, I'm sorry I misunderstood that. But if you don't like her, that's completely your opinion. I personally don't think she was bad, but Metallica is still better

  • @PrideInIndividuality hahaaa well all I am a woman and I love all sorts of music but she is not in any sort of metal range nor rock for that matter... she is light pop like beyonce. (halo). I thinks it is really out of her character and by me suggesting lady gaga music well that is not much further from her style. I love girl rockers Baby Animals, Pink for examples and well I don't hear them singing out of her range. Probably would be seen dead singing Lucie songs. Have a good one.

  • She's good , and the idea of a cover is to sing a song in you're own way, and i believe that her cover is really good.

  • How could she ever cover Metallica..? Nobody covers Metallica... What the fuck?

  • @JustJessey Cos its better?!!!

  • @JustJessey I think they gave her permission so STFU!

  • Comment removed

  • Johanna kurkelas version is better

  • this is the most depressing song in the world !

  • This is amazing...so wonderful!!!

  • C'est pas la Callas mais elle est cool !

  • In my opinion ist the Metallica version better...its just the original...

  • Metallica is awful, get out

  • @Vyr METALLICA IS THE BEST!!!

  • omg who the fuck allowed her to cover METALLICA! <3

    baah that sounds so female ..

    metallica cant be coverd they are UNIQUE

  • @xyBADROBOTxy It was me! I was the guy behind this wonderful cover!!

  • I actually Love this!!

    

  • What makes this so good, it that she doesn't want to beat Metallica.

    it's just a tribute.

  • this is the first song? ore not?

  • of course it can't compete with the original version, it was never ment to either. but silvas voice gives it a softer touch. i think it works well in its own right.

  • @bjarnyg I totally agree! I think her cover is really serene and female. Its nice, but her voice is what stands out and not the song itself. Thats why I prefer the original version. When Hetfield sings it, he really touchs my soul. He puts so deep emotions in it. And also, I like the song more with guitars than with piano! Just my opinion! =)

  • metellica is better, but this is nice too...

  • tew me this version beats metalica

  • Better version than Metallica's... such a beautiful voice... :-P

  • @nickie2011

    Well, might be a beautifull voice, but I don't feel the same "Soul" in this song... The original is sung with the heart of the band putting their emotions through the guitar, and through the voice of James.

  • totally agree the metallica version is useless and souless. its amazing how many metallica fans are on here listening to this superior version....

  • fucking bitch, that song is from metallica!!

  • Das Lied ist schön. <3

    Aber das von Metallica ist besser !!! x3

    This song is beautiful . <3

    But the one from Metallica is better !!! x3

  • Sie singt mir irgendwie zu sehr gedrückt...und Metallica mit Nothing else matters ist natürlich hundertmal besser.

    Also schönes Video, aber das Lied gefällt mir garnicht o.0

  • Esto es el ejemplo de lo que nunca se debe hacer, hay canciones que es un sacrilegio que otro las cante!!! METALLICA SIEMPRE SERAN LOS MEJORES

  • wtf, i show this song to a frind (girl) and she said me, this song isn't of Metallica is by Silvas !!!

    wtf!

    Joder que asco, te dicen k es de la L. Silvas esta i que Metallica l ha copiado!

    What The Fuck!

    PD: sorry for my fucking noob english xd (lol)

    Que visqui Metallica!

  • Ich sehe dies mehr als eine Homage an Metallica an und nicht als eigenständiges Lied .. sorry..

  • this song is of metalica.... menudo plagio....

  • Larga vida a metallica

  • love it!!!

    OMG♥♥♥

    xxxx

  • metallica rules, but she also sings it very well

    love her too

  • @Hariclee she gets the lyrics wrong !!!!

  • *-* ich Liebs <3

  • aver aki no ablamos d q si metallica es mejor o no esta cancion mola y punto...

  • I really love her voice. Hers is the best tribute.

  • je prefert l'original de metallica

  • Metallica's version is a legend. But this song is still AMAZING, a great version that I'm SURE i'll listen to OFTEN!

    I LOVED IT :)

    <3

  • great cover! im so proud to be a metallica fan, james hetfield is the best song writer of all time!

  • amazing!!!!

  • even if metallica´s better the song is just... WOW powerful it take us to another world...

  • La original, todos sabemos que esta muy bien, pero esta para ser una version esta bastante bien

  • wow!!!

  • Preciosa.. <3

  • This is shit. Simple.

  • @gimmetee This is great: You're just tone deaf

  • there is no competition between Metallica and Lucie... Lucie just raped this awesome song by using a fricking piano... piano is a great instrument if used properly...

  • my musik

  • i defenetly love this version, amazing!

  • but i know..<3

  • me gusta pero como METALICA(L) no hay nada (L)

    I love Metalicaaaa (L)

  • Metallicas S&M version is by far the greatest version of this song, but I really do like this version. Good tribute to an amazing song.

  • I like the arrangement of the song, she obviously thought out of the box, but it could in no way match the intensity of the original.. but it sounds kinda beautiful.. but no comparison with metallica!

  • its not that different idk what people talking about its still good only difference is that a girl is singing it -.-

  • Comment removed

  • This is just a 'different' version of Metallica's original...I'm sure they're honored that their song is well-liked and transformed into different interpretations including the one by apocalyptica's which is only instrumental....SO, give this singer a break...it's a slow song that's supposed to be melancholy...and this version pulls it off

    So, stop with the negativity...Metallica wouldn't do that;)

  • That woman butchers the beautiful song. She makes the song cold and meaningless. Seems like she just wanted to make a hit song out of it... disgusting.

  • I agree!!!!!!!

  • @EetFuk10 lucie making a hit??? dont think so. she's not rihanna or lady gaga. she actually has talent. she doesn't have to try to please stupid metallica fans. she just loves the band and covered their beautiful song. there's no competition involved. i dont know what you guys are smoking.

  • @crazydanger For your information, I'm not smoking anything. I just think she ruined this beautiful song. It's not meant to be soulless... empty. Hetfield has a heart and soul when he performs this song.

    What also bothers me is the lack of guitar. The guitar solo at the end is one of the highlighs of the song and it's only a half song without it.

  • @EetFuk10 You never saw Lucie Silvas perform!! If you did, you never will say those words about the performing thing! Come too my channel and you will change your opinion. Her emotions when she performs is the biggest reason i'm a fan of hers. And she is one of the best in the world!!

  • oe men alexshurtugal .oe lastima q no te gusto mi comentario pero igual imagino q no sabes tocar guitarra entonces no entiendes lo q he escrito =) solo soy una persona q aprecia la musik ya sea de la banda original o no .lo q importa es la interpretacion de la cancion y bueno tenes q tocar esa cancion para entender lo q he escrito =)

  • this song was meant to be played with guitar, as a "metal-ballad" this style kinda killed the emotion James Hetfield puts in it

  • i am not into pop, so i like metallicas ORIGINAL verision much better sorry guys :) but she's not bad ;)

  • vaya mierda

    ¡¡¡¡ METALLICA FOR EVER !!!!