i obviously didnt write some god damn comment that was for comedic purposes, i made it to tell you and specificly YOU, that this is whats gggooooiiiinnnnggg to happen. and i know i spelt it wrong, who gives a shit?
Poor Dobby. After reading the whole series I got even closer to Dobby - as not only do they delve more into his character but he was brought back in book 3 or 4 I think, not just book 7. Pity, I always loved him! Go Dobby! :)
@LilGrey456 they killed Dobby because it is an unexpected death that can make people care that little more about not just that character that died, but that little bit more about the other characters and you feel more for other characters that die, it is a technique used to captivate audiences to characters, y'know, an emotional thing.
@swtlilz5 it's definitely the latter. around 2:20 you can definitely hear the same music they play when Harry, Ron and Hermione look at each other and then the picture of Umbridge on the Daily Prophet...
It shocked me that after the wedding scene there was no music until Dobby arrived, ok yes there were the odd, very scary and tantalizing snip bits but this is the next melody and solid composition
I cried listening to this, knowing Dobby is no longer with us. But i'm wrong, he's always with us, in our hearts, his name, Dobby, the free elf. Omg i just made myself cry typing that, please excuse me now, i'm going to go and stare at a picture od Dobby till my tears stop. :'(
For me all this changes in director, screenplay and music score make series look completely incoherent. I will always remember "Order Of Phoenix" which was completely abortive. And "The Half-Blood Prince" was not good, i like only this scene in the cave with Dumbledore.
@yonythemoony Maybe that's the reason. But the main cause it was that any good director of each part doesn't want to direct it the second time. Only Chris Columbus directed two parts. So they found such David Yates who likes commercial movies and make it.
@AspergianMind Desplat do "The Hobbit"? No f****** way! He would destroy it! He is way out of the league of such masters as Zimmer, Shore and Williams, and I mean, WAY below. He would be an abysmal choice.
Pretty much like he destroyed this movie. The only pieces worth listening to are this one and "Ministry of Magic" and only for the first minute or so.
Desplat did not recapture the spirit of John Williams' music. He just released a travesty of a soundtrack.
@clovie101 Keep telling yourself that, douchebag. Desplat isn't even close to the level of Williams. Or any other great composer out there. His music is bland and repetitive and uninspired, with the minor exception of this and the "Ministry of Magic" track.
At least the fact that Williams is going to be co-composing with Desplat on Part 2 lends me some hope that Williams will not let Desplat release another travesty of soundtrack.
@clovie101 Best in the series? You've got to be joking. "Death of Sirius" (what a depressing title) by Hooper was about fifty, no, hundred times better. Just because you are convinced "Sky Battle" is the best in the series, doesn't make it so.
@kamil99994 You sound like the Williams fanboy idiot of BatboyInTheDarkness. Williams isn't going to come back, and Desplat is going to stay. And you must be deaf if you didn't listened the homages that Desplat made to the Harry Potter composers.
And unlike Williams, Desplat is a Harry Potter fan and he knows how special is the saga. And his score for Part 1 was faithful to the book's spirit, something that Williams never achieved with his Hook/Home Alone-esque scores (except for POA).
@yonythemoony To be fair, I prefer the likes of Zimmer, Newton-Howard, Shore and others to Williams. Homage or no homage, including two seconds of Hedwig's Theme isn't going to salvage a piece if the rest is trash. And I don't see why being a "fan" classifies you as being able to produce more faithful and enjoyable music. Shore wasn't exactly a fan of Tolkien, yet I'd like to see someone produce a more suitable soundtrack for LOTR than him, which was the main point of my comment above. Moron.
For everybody who wanted williams to come back ,i think you need to reconsider. The series as a whole has been about change, both in the story and in the production. In the catagory of soundtracks, change is what keeps them interesting. If all the scores were like the first 2, we would get very bored, very quickly. Alex has brought his own touch to the series that will evoke its own coherence to the film. His orchestration his fantastic. And no one can judge him until theyve heard it in film.
I swore that if Dobby were not appearing in this movie, I would not watch it because to have him only in Chamber of secrets would be dumb. I'm mad they did not put him in the other films when in the books he was
John Williams is REALLY good at what he does. That's it, he's just a master at his art. I love the first soundtracks of the franchise, it's what defines what we hear when we think 'Harry Potter'; which is saying a lot. But it is true that people shouldn't judge too quickly with different composers, there have been new actors to these films, as well as directors, so a new composer is no different. I think for this one Alex did a great job with the whole sinister, darker tone of Deathly Hallows :)
He stood up to Bellatrix and that takes bravery. He had bravery and love bigger then his little body. "DOBBY HAS NO MASTER! DOBBY IS A FREE ELF, AND DOBBY HAS COME TO SAVE HARRY POTTER AND HIS FRIENDS!" He returned and died a hero. Dobby- a free elf and a true friend
John Williams is no doubt a fabulous composer, but don't judge Desplat until you've heard these songs in the movie. They fit perfectly. Desplat did an awesome job.
@ivkoacount None of the interviews I've read or seen with Hooper, he never said he considered scoring the final two films. Both he and Yates confirm that Hooper wanted to step down after HBP, because he was exhausted and wanted to move on. Where are you getting this stuff? Desplat is scoring Part 2, enough said.
Oh. My. Glee. My favorite composer is doing Harry Potter??? I think I just died. I'm writing this comment from Heaven. I am glad that Williams is doing collab work for Part II, though. I LOVE this.
For everybody who wanted williams to come back ,i think you need to reconsider. The series as a whole has been about change, both in the story and in the production. In the catagory of soundtracks, change is what keeps them interesting. If all the scores were like the first 2, we would get very bored, very quickly. Alex has brought his own touch to the series that will evoke its own coherence to the film. His orchestration his fantastic. And no one can judge him until theyve heard it in film.
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 you are wrong my friend :) Fans will love for John Williams to return and as @nocturne2630 pointed out-he will be collaborating and that would be good. Fans really want Williams to return and that would be the right thing to do. After all, its not like he didnt come up with the most infamous score for Harry Potter.
What he did with the Lord of the Rings score is genius, and this crap Desplat spewed out can't even compare. Where the hell is the Harry Potter theme? I understand introducing new themes...but going back to the roots of the beginning is a cornerstone of epic stories....I've listened to every track on this soundtrack and they all sound the same...with minor hints to previous themes here and there. They BETTER fix that in Part 2's score.
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 What the fuck!!! Who the fuck, ever told you that the series were about change??? The change actaly made The goblet of Fire, and The order of the phoenix such a awfull, and bad movies compared to teh others, the same with patrick doyles music, wich wasnt touchign anythign an ddidnt sound like his previous movie composers
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 ....JOHN WILLIAMS WILL RETURN TO DO A COLLABORATION WITH DESPLAT. I THINK THAT IS KINDA A GOOD WAY TO MUSICALLY END THE SERIES. THE ENDING THEME FROM THE FIRST TWO MOVIE WERE SO CONCLUSIVE IN ITS OWN WAY. I GOOD CHORD OR HARRY POTTER THEME LIKE ENDING WITH THE BEST COMPOSER IN THE WORLD AND ANOTHER WHO IS ALSO REMARKABLE, WILL BE THE EST WAY TO CONCLUDE THIS SERIES.
Everything you say is valid. But the music we associate with the entire Harry Potter franchise will always be "Hedwig's Theme"...not just because Williams was there first, but because He writes memorable scores. It would have been nice to hear an iconic, memorable, THEMATIC, score again. Desplat, while refreshingly different and appropriate for this movie, is ultimately forgettable.
Williams laid the foundation and it would have been great to see him return.
@VforVideo yes but desplat does make the music have the same hp feel to it. i think its good that they have different ppl doing the soundtrack becasue yes, it does give us more of a variety
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 I love what Alexandre Desplat has done here, but I'd have to disagree, John Williams is a stylistic chameleon and he will suit whatever manifestation the series takes. Listen to Prisoner of Azkaban soundtrack if you doubt it. Oh, and the orchestration for Deathly Hallows was done by Conrad Pope who did the orchestration for the first two Potter films, so...
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 John Williams will be collaborating with Alexandre Desplat for part 2.
Not to mention-what in the world are you talking about? John William's music is outstanding and he is great in darkening the mood as well. Look at his other works. Don't judge like you said unless you've heard all of his other works.
@Chopdopple I hear ya. It never really stood out at all did it? With some exceptions, his score remained mostly in the background. And thats not a bad a thing either, it just means it wont be the kind of in-your-face blockbuster score that wins academy awards.
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 i know and im split between being happy that Williams is back and not being happy that he's back. Williams is an amazing composer (check out his other work) and this guy did a truly AMAZING job with this ost but i cant help but remember that Williams wrote the original Hedwig's Theme.
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 u r rite in sum ways & i've also luved all the composers very much!! but i just want john williams to finish wat he started.....i mean he shud do the last part now cuz he was the 1 who gave the signature tune to the whole series the hedwig theme!! & i think he did give a lot of change to his soundtracks especially after HP1 & 2 in POA he was really different
In my opinion it sounds a lot like moments in Prisoner of Azkaban, the medieval / harpsichord feel... I think people wouldn't be satisfied unless it sounded exactly like movies 1 and 2.. which of course it wouldn't even if Williams was on board!
@BigRalphFiennesFan Um its been decided Im all for John Williams but if he dosent return Im really glad this guy will continue and its been confirmed John williams was only rumored Alexandre is returning for Part 2 and behind John Williams hes the best choice hes the second best in HP if I look at Music and Im glad he came for Part 1 :D
@BigRalphFiennesFan Me too I really wouldve liked John William to return but I just saying if he couldnt return Im glad they stuck with this guy he says he read the books saw the movies but the only soundtracks he listened to really were 1 2 3 John williams's cause he felt he has to capture the origonal essence and yeah John wouldve been brilliant if he'd returned but in the end if it had to go down this road Im glad Desplat stuck around :D
Dobby's first and last words in the series were "Harry Potter"
BlondieCartoons 3 weeks ago in playlist Harry Potter Soundtrack!
RIP Dobby!!
webkinz08100 1 month ago
Dobbyyyyy btw why does Dobby looks older in CoS than in DHpt1??
HarryPotterRocks0930 1 month ago
@HarryPotterRocks0930 CGI -_-
jediking12 3 weeks ago
“Dobby doesn’t mean to kill, Dobby means to maim or seriously injure”
i love dobby(:
Juicyfruitgv 1 month ago in playlist harry potter deathly hallows part1 soundtrack 5
I love how mischievious this music sounds! Perfect Dobby music :D
JessicaLeighAdams 2 months ago
Alexandre Desplat is the best wizard! :)
TheManooo77 2 months ago
I WANT TO LIVE IN HOGWARTS!
NmetevesRuls 5 months ago 9
Is this from the bit with mundungus?
JazziChick 5 months ago 2
@JazziChick yeah
jediking12 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
that awkward moment when the two top rated comments are identical...
Imranrulezz 5 months ago in playlist Harry Potter Soundtrack!
@xDancingPenguinsx no, plenty of people at mine were crying :'(
NPThirteen 5 months ago
Am I the only one who sobbed in the theater when Dobby died?
xDancingPenguinsx 6 months ago 8
@xDancingPenguinsx I lost it. the bitch next to me was laughing. Told her to shove it and went back to weeping like a child.
BlueberryDoughnuts 5 months ago 5
@BlueberryDoughnuts You remind me of myself. Exactly what happened to me. (:
xDancingPenguinsx 5 months ago
@xDancingPenguinsx no! :'( i was crying like a baby hahaha
natipuli 5 months ago
R.I.P Dobby, The FREE House Elf D:
singerhp19 6 months ago 2
Whenever I hear this, I tip-toe around my house like a ninja.
xDancingPenguinsx 6 months ago 4
@xDancingPenguinsx HAHAHA you made me lmfao, even more when i noticed your name is dancingpinguin
grazycowgirl 6 months ago
@grazycowgirl Haha! Success! (:
xDancingPenguinsx 6 months ago
dobby didnt die, he faked his death and then was kidnapped by bruce lee's ghost an was trained in the ways of the ninja."
j.k. rowling said that was what happened, or is going to happen in her new harry pottor book.
"harry pottor and the things that make no sense"
TheMattShow1011 6 months ago
@TheMattShow1011 Fake. --' And it's "Harry Potter" with a -e not a -o. --'
x0ksanaGleekVersion 6 months ago
@x0ksanaGleekVersion ahhh ggggggeeeeeee. ooooof cccooooouuuurrrrssseeee iiiiitttsss nnnooottt ffffaaaakkee iiii ggggooootttt tttthhhiiiisss iiinnnnfffoooo fffrrrooommm wwwiiikkkiii! its completely fucking true!
i obviously didnt write some god damn comment that was for comedic purposes, i made it to tell you and specificly YOU, that this is whats gggooooiiiinnnnggg to happen. and i know i spelt it wrong, who gives a shit?
TheMattShow1011 6 months ago
Don't worry, Dobby, you do get avenged.
DoctorWhoRocks10000 6 months ago
Bleedin' bow an' all!
astrogirl645 7 months ago
2:19-2:33
Oh shoot, it's Umbridge :/
grammargoddess888 7 months ago
Bellatrix: HOW DARE YOU TAKE A WITCHES' WAND, ELF. RESPECT YOUR MASTERS.
Dobby: Dobby is a FREE elf. Dobby has NO master!
<3
OhSixteenCandles 7 months ago 16
DOBBY~
YOU ARE VERY SPECIAL~
YOU ARE SPECIALLY LOVLY
YOU ARE SPECIALLY LOYAL
YOU ARE SPECIALLY RESPECTFYL
kerorodo 7 months ago
Dobbeh!
MrJJ4000 7 months ago
R.I.P DOBBY
ETMHD 7 months ago
For those who believe, Hogwarts will always be there to welcome you home.
666pounder27 7 months ago 74
><
(-)
theateam2012 7 months ago
2:20 - 2:36 !!!!!!!!
IlidaCullen 7 months ago
@IlidaCullen Umbridge in the Daily Prophet Headline???
ianjozeljerez 7 months ago
@ianjozeljerez
oh yeah.. haha!! I love this moment!!! (the music)
IlidaCullen 7 months ago
@IlidaCullen Yeah... :DDD matches the score to the scene!
ianjozeljerez 7 months ago
Here lies Dobby, a free elf
RIP
iwanttodanceallnight 7 months ago 4
every freaking time i watch his death i cry my eyes out!! :''''(
Dadlummusue 8 months ago 5
those 6 people are going to receive the true injury of dobby. just wait.
wontonboi64 8 months ago 7
Thank you thank you for uploading this epic soundtrack :).
ErAgOn2610 9 months ago in playlist Harry Potter Soundtrack! 6
when we were at the midnight showing when the movie came out, a guy behind us squeled in a girly voice "DOBBY!"
THEJBTV123 9 months ago 8
since Dobby died by a knife i do not use knifes anymore!
TheTJFilmproduction 9 months ago 8
"Master Weasley, it's so good to see you."
marcusduck 9 months ago 5
This has been flagged as spam show
"Dobby did not mean to kill, merely maim or severely injure, but never kill!"
:D ;D ^^
i love it <3
Necron094 9 months ago
@TeamEdwardJacob44 Like Yoda in S.W.
20Sympathy04 9 months ago
@keesvdijkhuizen AGREED. SO awkward! XD
jinnangelcat 9 months ago
I LOVE DOBBY!!!!!! <3
dawsongirl13 10 months ago 2
Poor Dobby. After reading the whole series I got even closer to Dobby - as not only do they delve more into his character but he was brought back in book 3 or 4 I think, not just book 7. Pity, I always loved him! Go Dobby! :)
OnionAnimations 10 months ago 7
@OnionAnimations he was in 2,4,5,6 & 7, i hate how he got cut out
LOZmaster85RB 10 months ago 6
DOBBYYY! :D He's so funny in this movie. x) But, naturally, I cried like a big baby when he died. :(
shizuka139 10 months ago 9
that awkward moment when the two top rated comments are identical...
keesvdijkhuizen 10 months ago 109
2:10 The Dobbfather
Winduct 10 months ago 7
How the two highest comments are exactly the same...
IMissYellow 10 months ago 11
R.I.P. Dobby
mbljs 11 months ago 11
Why the fuck did they kill Dobby :(
LilGrey456 11 months ago 2
@LilGrey456 'cause that was unexpected that is why JK Rowling killed Dobby
IMissYellow 10 months ago
@LilGrey456 they killed Dobby because it is an unexpected death that can make people care that little more about not just that character that died, but that little bit more about the other characters and you feel more for other characters that die, it is a technique used to captivate audiences to characters, y'know, an emotional thing.
KennyFilmsOfficial 10 months ago 4
@swtlilz5 it's definitely the latter. around 2:20 you can definitely hear the same music they play when Harry, Ron and Hermione look at each other and then the picture of Umbridge on the Daily Prophet...
lbetweenthebars 11 months ago
i love Bellatrix and i liked Dobby .........i dont know
bellacissyblack 11 months ago
2:18
Dobby Corleone
juanitokolimense 11 months ago
I'm waiting Molly to kill Bellatrix in Part two...
Hope they don't cut out this scene!
LydiaTereK 1 year ago
I cried like a four year old who just fell of their tricycle when I witnessed Dobby's death in the theater. :'(
OhSoVeryDelicious 1 year ago 3
WE MISS U DOBBY!!! FIRST SIRIUS AND NOW DOBBY... HOW COULD YOU KILL SO MANY BELOVED PPL BELATRIX?!
MaddieDiamondwillow 1 year ago 3
RIP Dobby
radioactivecakeX 1 year ago
2:34 - Great inclusion of Hooper's original Ministry of Magic theme. Great suspension throughout before Desplat's original theme comes into play
FastBBBB 1 year ago
DOBBBYYYYYYYYYY! :-(
FulhamAngel 1 year ago
DOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB-BB YYYYYYYYYY D: We all miss you!
Brandisofthesand 1 year ago 3
It shocked me that after the wedding scene there was no music until Dobby arrived, ok yes there were the odd, very scary and tantalizing snip bits but this is the next melody and solid composition
FastBBBB 1 year ago
Comment removed
FastBBBB 1 year ago
Comment removed
FastBBBB 1 year ago
I tottaly love dobby and I love his SHOES ! haha :D
SaarzNL 1 year ago
I cried listening to this, knowing Dobby is no longer with us. But i'm wrong, he's always with us, in our hearts, his name, Dobby, the free elf. Omg i just made myself cry typing that, please excuse me now, i'm going to go and stare at a picture od Dobby till my tears stop. :'(
snowyangel97 1 year ago
@snowyangel97 In this scene Dobby is still alive.
lilfixit1 1 year ago 2
For me all this changes in director, screenplay and music score make series look completely incoherent. I will always remember "Order Of Phoenix" which was completely abortive. And "The Half-Blood Prince" was not good, i like only this scene in the cave with Dumbledore.
KarolinaMisia 1 year ago
@KarolinaMisia The real problem was that the movies started to be filmed before the books finished.
yonythemoony 11 months ago
@yonythemoony Maybe that's the reason. But the main cause it was that any good director of each part doesn't want to direct it the second time. Only Chris Columbus directed two parts. So they found such David Yates who likes commercial movies and make it.
KarolinaMisia 11 months ago
@TeamEdwardJacob44 nah i liked mundungus. except the way the movie portrayed him was not how i expected him to look.
iliketoplaythepiano1 1 year ago
It was awful when watching theDH in a theatre; the audience laughed when they saw Dobby for the frst time. I knew better that he would die soon.
LadyOfNargothrond 1 year ago
Dobby: ...HELL-OH! XD
I nearly choked on my apple peels when he appeared on Harry's bed at Hogwarts in CoS
acrobatsutr 1 year ago 3
Me and my boyfriend never cried so hard at Dobby's death.
PandoraChun 1 year ago 4
Who would consider that Alexandre Desplat would be an excellent alternative for Howard Shore if he couldn't return to do "The Hobbit" Pts. 1&2?
If he could recapture the spirit of John Williams he can do the same for Howard Shore.
AspergianMind 1 year ago 2
@AspergianMind Desplat do "The Hobbit"? No f****** way! He would destroy it! He is way out of the league of such masters as Zimmer, Shore and Williams, and I mean, WAY below. He would be an abysmal choice.
Pretty much like he destroyed this movie. The only pieces worth listening to are this one and "Ministry of Magic" and only for the first minute or so.
Desplat did not recapture the spirit of John Williams' music. He just released a travesty of a soundtrack.
kamil99994 1 year ago
@kamil99994 eat a bag of baby dicks. Desplat did better for this series than williams.
clovie101 1 year ago 2
@clovie101 Keep telling yourself that, douchebag. Desplat isn't even close to the level of Williams. Or any other great composer out there. His music is bland and repetitive and uninspired, with the minor exception of this and the "Ministry of Magic" track.
At least the fact that Williams is going to be co-composing with Desplat on Part 2 lends me some hope that Williams will not let Desplat release another travesty of soundtrack.
kamil99994 1 year ago
@kamil99994 No, that was just a rumor bitch.
clovie101 1 year ago
@clovie101 Well then, I have no hope for the Part 2 soundtrack either, dumbass.
kamil99994 1 year ago
@kamil99994 sucks for you. i bet it will be the best.
clovie101 1 year ago
@clovie101 Keep dreaming. But you'll have to wake up eventually and realise...that it's not.
"Sky Battle" has to be the worst battle music I've ever heard. I am terrified to think what Desplat will do with the "Battle of Hogwarts".
kamil99994 1 year ago
@kamil99994 HAHA dude you suck at lying.
clovie101 1 year ago
@clovie101 Lying? I didn't lie. "Sky Battle" IS the worst battle music I've ever heard.
Quite frankly, I don't even know why I am arguing with you, when my original comment wasn't even aimed at you.
kamil99994 1 year ago
@kamil99994 by worst you mean best in the series then yes.
clovie101 1 year ago
@clovie101 Best in the series? You've got to be joking. "Death of Sirius" (what a depressing title) by Hooper was about fifty, no, hundred times better. Just because you are convinced "Sky Battle" is the best in the series, doesn't make it so.
kamil99994 1 year ago
@kamil99994 , and just because you say it isn't, means shit.
Im saying we all have different opinions, and just because its not the same of yours doesn't mean im wrong.
clovie101 1 year ago
@clovie101 "we all have different opinions."
Finally we get to the point. Now that we've cleared THAT up, at least there's one thing we can agree on.
No, it doesn't mean you are wrong, neither does it mean I'm wrong. So goodbye.
kamil99994 1 year ago
@kamil99994 You sound like the Williams fanboy idiot of BatboyInTheDarkness. Williams isn't going to come back, and Desplat is going to stay. And you must be deaf if you didn't listened the homages that Desplat made to the Harry Potter composers.
And unlike Williams, Desplat is a Harry Potter fan and he knows how special is the saga. And his score for Part 1 was faithful to the book's spirit, something that Williams never achieved with his Hook/Home Alone-esque scores (except for POA).
yonythemoony 11 months ago
@yonythemoony To be fair, I prefer the likes of Zimmer, Newton-Howard, Shore and others to Williams. Homage or no homage, including two seconds of Hedwig's Theme isn't going to salvage a piece if the rest is trash. And I don't see why being a "fan" classifies you as being able to produce more faithful and enjoyable music. Shore wasn't exactly a fan of Tolkien, yet I'd like to see someone produce a more suitable soundtrack for LOTR than him, which was the main point of my comment above. Moron.
kamil99994 11 months ago
@kamil99994 i respectvily disagree. i nelieve that desplat did a godd job but we all have our opinions.
MrTmans9s 11 months ago
@MrTmans9s Fair enough.
kamil99994 11 months ago
@MyDanDoo we shall see.
davedirector7 1 year ago
@MyDanDoo are you a man who interviews filmmakers? I am not lying. If you don't believe then you do not have to. I was at the premiere.
davedirector7 1 year ago
"Dobby did not mean to kill, merely maim or severely injure, but never kill!"
theLegendofZelda2009 1 year ago 220
@theLegendofZelda2009 i luv ur username!
Zelda0923 8 months ago
from 2:35 onwards im guessing thats when you see harry and ron outside the ministry
PunkyFish208 1 year ago 3
@PunkyFish208 Yeah
yonythemoony 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
2
For everybody who wanted williams to come back ,i think you need to reconsider. The series as a whole has been about change, both in the story and in the production. In the catagory of soundtracks, change is what keeps them interesting. If all the scores were like the first 2, we would get very bored, very quickly. Alex has brought his own touch to the series that will evoke its own coherence to the film. His orchestration his fantastic. And no one can judge him until theyve heard it in film.
Amentis6 1 year ago
I hear Dobby's theme from CoS at 0:09.
ToMBRoBBeRBaKuRa 1 year ago
So I'm guessing at 2:21 Dobby meets Don Corleone lol
RZ8990 1 year ago 4
I swore that if Dobby were not appearing in this movie, I would not watch it because to have him only in Chamber of secrets would be dumb. I'm mad they did not put him in the other films when in the books he was
davedirector7 1 year ago
@davedirector7 Leaving out Dobby and Winky in the fourth book was a huge mistake.
lilfixit1 1 year ago 8
Dobby was really annoying in Chamber of Secrets ('I'm helping by breaking your arm, Harry Potter') but he was really awesome here.
All the more sad to see him go.
Advancedgod 1 year ago
Did anyone else smile when Dobby was revealed in this scene? I certainly did and it hurt lol
davedirector7 1 year ago 5
i still wish richard harris could of been dumbledoore
takahashiwongwong 1 year ago
@takahashiwongwong I wish so too, but he died just after he finished Chamber of secrets. May he rest in peace
davedirector7 1 year ago
@davedirector7 i know ): hell always be the real dumbledoore in my eyes if he was alive today ehs still be dumbledoore
takahashiwongwong 1 year ago
John Williams is REALLY good at what he does. That's it, he's just a master at his art. I love the first soundtracks of the franchise, it's what defines what we hear when we think 'Harry Potter'; which is saying a lot. But it is true that people shouldn't judge too quickly with different composers, there have been new actors to these films, as well as directors, so a new composer is no different. I think for this one Alex did a great job with the whole sinister, darker tone of Deathly Hallows :)
Kapolena 1 year ago 2
@Kapolena to add to that: John Williams has been nominated for 45 oscars throughout his life. Including for the Harry Potter score
davedirector7 1 year ago
He stood up to Bellatrix and that takes bravery. He had bravery and love bigger then his little body. "DOBBY HAS NO MASTER! DOBBY IS A FREE ELF, AND DOBBY HAS COME TO SAVE HARRY POTTER AND HIS FRIENDS!" He returned and died a hero. Dobby- a free elf and a true friend
davedirector7 1 year ago 3
"Dobby did not mean to kill, only to maim or seriously injure" :D
macnsky 1 year ago 63
Oh goodness. I got so happy when Dobby appeared.
iwantorlando05 1 year ago 5
Dobby is Desplat's favorite character in the Harry Potter books. He said it in a interview:
Do you have a favorite Potter character, in both story and music?
I love Dobby. He is fun, innocent, brave and wears great, red sneakers.
yonythemoony 1 year ago 2
RIP Dobby, a Free Elf ♥
Jctotallyrocks 1 year ago 12
I MISS DOBY!
( OOOPS I DIDN'T MEAN TO GIVE THAT ONE AWAY)
initotwinit 1 year ago
John Williams is no doubt a fabulous composer, but don't judge Desplat until you've heard these songs in the movie. They fit perfectly. Desplat did an awesome job.
LondonOfJazz 1 year ago 3
dobby is sooo great & in this movie - perfect - xD
NoParesLaMusic 1 year ago
ahh!! i really love the beginning of this!
yanfeb15 1 year ago
hello!! what is the name of the song when Harry dance whit hermione?? i
rockeryuna 1 year ago 2
@rockeryuna O'Children by Nick Cave. Awesome Song *_*
TheWasski 1 year ago
@TheWasski that song has been on repeat on my computer for hours.
seabury 1 year ago
HEY PEOPLE! I dont like WILLIAMS! Do you have ears??? He's just like Desplat. I LIKE HOOPER BACK!
wish62988 1 year ago
@wish62988 Hooper isn't coming back, he said we wasn't going to do more HP films after OOTP and HBP. Get that through your thick head.
mcjwserenity 1 year ago
@mcjwserenity Hooper considered to do part 2, Get that through your rude head.
ivkoacount 1 year ago
@ivkoacount None of the interviews I've read or seen with Hooper, he never said he considered scoring the final two films. Both he and Yates confirm that Hooper wanted to step down after HBP, because he was exhausted and wanted to move on. Where are you getting this stuff? Desplat is scoring Part 2, enough said.
mcjwserenity 1 year ago
This sounds really good, and I think all songs will fit perfectly to the movie! :'3
AngelofKawaii 1 year ago
Wow. People John Williams will be collaborating in part 2 lol don't worry. But i agree about the changing of the soundtracks
davedirector7 1 year ago
Oh. My. Glee. My favorite composer is doing Harry Potter??? I think I just died. I'm writing this comment from Heaven. I am glad that Williams is doing collab work for Part II, though. I LOVE this.
LizzayMartini 1 year ago
Can't wait for the sheet music!!!
L00K3R4 1 year ago
this sounds like Danny Elfman...
JOHN WILLIAMS FOR PATR II! Pleeeeeaseeee.
MeSandyMusic 1 year ago
@MeSandyMusic No. Fail. Alexandre Desplat has already been commissioned to do Part II. End of story.
ToManyLetters 1 year ago
dobby =´( i Love him <3
NoParesLaMusic 1 year ago
For everybody who wanted williams to come back ,i think you need to reconsider. The series as a whole has been about change, both in the story and in the production. In the catagory of soundtracks, change is what keeps them interesting. If all the scores were like the first 2, we would get very bored, very quickly. Alex has brought his own touch to the series that will evoke its own coherence to the film. His orchestration his fantastic. And no one can judge him until theyve heard it in film.
Sk1nnyV1nny22 1 year ago 103
@Sk1nnyV1nny22
I saw it... and in the movie it's wondurfull!!! ^^
Falc0nify 1 year ago
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 you are wrong my friend :) Fans will love for John Williams to return and as @nocturne2630 pointed out-he will be collaborating and that would be good. Fans really want Williams to return and that would be the right thing to do. After all, its not like he didnt come up with the most infamous score for Harry Potter.
davedirector7 1 year ago
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 One name comes to mind.
Howard Shore.
What he did with the Lord of the Rings score is genius, and this crap Desplat spewed out can't even compare. Where the hell is the Harry Potter theme? I understand introducing new themes...but going back to the roots of the beginning is a cornerstone of epic stories....I've listened to every track on this soundtrack and they all sound the same...with minor hints to previous themes here and there. They BETTER fix that in Part 2's score.
thenacanoroc 1 year ago
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 What the fuck!!! Who the fuck, ever told you that the series were about change??? The change actaly made The goblet of Fire, and The order of the phoenix such a awfull, and bad movies compared to teh others, the same with patrick doyles music, wich wasnt touchign anythign an ddidnt sound like his previous movie composers
ivkoacount 1 year ago
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 ....JOHN WILLIAMS WILL RETURN TO DO A COLLABORATION WITH DESPLAT. I THINK THAT IS KINDA A GOOD WAY TO MUSICALLY END THE SERIES. THE ENDING THEME FROM THE FIRST TWO MOVIE WERE SO CONCLUSIVE IN ITS OWN WAY. I GOOD CHORD OR HARRY POTTER THEME LIKE ENDING WITH THE BEST COMPOSER IN THE WORLD AND ANOTHER WHO IS ALSO REMARKABLE, WILL BE THE EST WAY TO CONCLUDE THIS SERIES.
euphzilla321 1 year ago
@Sk1nnyV1nny22
Everything you say is valid. But the music we associate with the entire Harry Potter franchise will always be "Hedwig's Theme"...not just because Williams was there first, but because He writes memorable scores. It would have been nice to hear an iconic, memorable, THEMATIC, score again. Desplat, while refreshingly different and appropriate for this movie, is ultimately forgettable.
Williams laid the foundation and it would have been great to see him return.
VforVideo 1 year ago 11
@VforVideo yes but desplat does make the music have the same hp feel to it. i think its good that they have different ppl doing the soundtrack becasue yes, it does give us more of a variety
MultiRandom6 1 year ago
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 I love what Alexandre Desplat has done here, but I'd have to disagree, John Williams is a stylistic chameleon and he will suit whatever manifestation the series takes. Listen to Prisoner of Azkaban soundtrack if you doubt it. Oh, and the orchestration for Deathly Hallows was done by Conrad Pope who did the orchestration for the first two Potter films, so...
williamjesnider 1 year ago
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 John Williams will be collaborating with Alexandre Desplat for part 2.
Not to mention-what in the world are you talking about? John William's music is outstanding and he is great in darkening the mood as well. Look at his other works. Don't judge like you said unless you've heard all of his other works.
davedirector7 1 year ago
I agree, although I was very disappointed with the Order of the Phoenix score.
MelissaAnnLegard1989 1 year ago
@Sk1nnyV1nny22
you are soo right !! (-:
cherry7590 1 year ago
Comment removed
Sk1nnyV1nny22 1 year ago
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 While I quite agree with you, and while I love these pieces, I don't think they fit for the character or scene they were applied to.
Chopdopple 1 year ago
@Chopdopple I hear ya. It never really stood out at all did it? With some exceptions, his score remained mostly in the background. And thats not a bad a thing either, it just means it wont be the kind of in-your-face blockbuster score that wins academy awards.
Sk1nnyV1nny22 1 year ago
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 i know and im split between being happy that Williams is back and not being happy that he's back. Williams is an amazing composer (check out his other work) and this guy did a truly AMAZING job with this ost but i cant help but remember that Williams wrote the original Hedwig's Theme.
DragonHeart956 1 year ago
@Sk1nnyV1nny22 u r rite in sum ways & i've also luved all the composers very much!! but i just want john williams to finish wat he started.....i mean he shud do the last part now cuz he was the 1 who gave the signature tune to the whole series the hedwig theme!! & i think he did give a lot of change to his soundtracks especially after HP1 & 2 in POA he was really different
potterati101 1 year ago
Masterpiece of OST.
leViviano 1 year ago 25
In my opinion it sounds a lot like moments in Prisoner of Azkaban, the medieval / harpsichord feel... I think people wouldn't be satisfied unless it sounded exactly like movies 1 and 2.. which of course it wouldn't even if Williams was on board!
sebudner 1 year ago
this doesn't sound like harry potter at all
baconater1029 1 year ago
@baconater1029 That's because it's supposed to sound like Dobby lol (I get what you're saying though).
I do think that Desplat did a very good job though, but I understand where you're coming from.
WVUBeasT44 1 year ago
@baconater1029 yes it does
SuperAwsomeGamerBros 1 year ago
Dont get me wrong i luv this music but i realy want john williams for part 2
JOHN WILLIAMS FOR PART 2!!!!!! THUMBS UP IF YOU AGREE
BigRalphFiennesFan 1 year ago
@BigRalphFiennesFan Um its been decided Im all for John Williams but if he dosent return Im really glad this guy will continue and its been confirmed John williams was only rumored Alexandre is returning for Part 2 and behind John Williams hes the best choice hes the second best in HP if I look at Music and Im glad he came for Part 1 :D
SirTimothyMarton 1 year ago
@SirTimothyMarton yeah, his music is realy good and i like it, but i really wanted john williams for part 2.
BigRalphFiennesFan 1 year ago
@BigRalphFiennesFan Me too I really wouldve liked John William to return but I just saying if he couldnt return Im glad they stuck with this guy he says he read the books saw the movies but the only soundtracks he listened to really were 1 2 3 John williams's cause he felt he has to capture the origonal essence and yeah John wouldve been brilliant if he'd returned but in the end if it had to go down this road Im glad Desplat stuck around :D
SirTimothyMarton 1 year ago
@SirTimothyMarton aww thanks, thats probably the nicest reply ive had all week :)
BigRalphFiennesFan 1 year ago
@BigRalphFiennesFan lol :D I was just giving my opinion :D and I truly feel it came out the best way in the end :D
SirTimothyMarton 1 year ago
@BigRalphFiennesFan Mr. Desplat has already been confirmed for part II. Fail.
ToManyLetters 1 year ago