This is excellent, especially if you watch the original just before. Very professional, you have far too much time on your hands; it must have taken you ages to produce. Well done.
I am SOOOOOO dying to see this in it's entirety. Everytime I try, it freezes after just seconds. Every link from YOUTUBE, same problem. Is it posted anywhere else? I love your work, as I've told you before. Thanks,...Pauly
Did you ever get my message I sent you before about it?? I said to try playing it, and then pausing it quickly and then letting it load for a while before watching it. If it's playing before the red bar has a chance to load properly, it'll just freeze.
Yeah, I got your message. And I tried but still nothing. I posted here, in case anyone was going through the same isse and perhaps had a solution or another link. Anyway, I saw your other vids, and you are amazing!
I was laughing out loud like a maniac for half of this. This is one of the funniest things I have ever seen on youtube. It was clever, well put together, and very original. It was SUPER! 8D
I LOVE IT! The insults they were shouting had me clutching my sides in laughter! Truely a triumph, I know it can be hard to make vids about The Producers.
Well, I won't say it's awesome, but it is very very good indeed! The storyline is interesting and I really love your editing skill! I never thought of making a silent movie out of a modern one. It's cool! I'll tell my friends who loves "The Producers" about your short film. This would really cheer them up. :)
Brilliant and very funny! Fast thinking on going with a B&W silent film production, refreshingly different. Made me think, some of the true silent films could have been written one way and subtitled another to give it more appeal...I enjoy your videos - looking forward to your next one!
lol, I guess I just give myself less credit than I deserve. *Sigh* It seemed lame when I was writing it, but all put together I guess it works. Thank you for the encouragement. :)
You must be like me, you've got to get that old "Self-Esteem" working!! You have talent and marvelous potential and I'd love to see more. I'm subscribing right now!
:) :) LOL, i was just watching it again myself, and the part in the beginning where Carmen's closing the doors and calling him a "Swamp donkey"... The movement of his mouth looks more like "Swamp ho"... HAHHAHHAOHIFJGPJGSAD. I started laughing.
lol, no, I'm not an editor. Thank you though! :) I believe the piano music was called "Tea for Two" and then the music in the middle is called "Running Wild"
The Best Part was the speed up portion of Roger Barts mouth popping gag. You picked just the right thing to replace the long ssssssssss noise that can't be done in a silent movie.
Hilarious. Truly hilarious. Seven minutes of my life I'd gladly trade again and again for the same video... the B/W and sped-up effects only added to the amazingness, as did the "vintage" dialogue (which was so perfect, especially where you used the movie's lines!)
Why thank you so much! I'm really glad to hear you say such things! :) I only wish the video editer I used had that scratchy movie effect. :( Oh well. lol
because, while this a genuine masterpiece, I know you have 1000's more ideas just waiting to be shown! (besides, the times number was the number of "!")lol
Mel. Your a genius! I especially like the scene where Max and Leo leave the fountain and then go right back to it in the next one. Haha. You need to send me that music file! Im putting this up on the Nathan myspace. Okay?
LOLOLOLOLOLL!!!! I know!! (sh! you're not supposed to notice the changing backgrounds! haha!) And I love how Rog-.. Anastasia's wig is on sometimes and then all of the sudden off. ahhh. It's great. And of course you can put it on the Nathan space! LOL, give me your email or something so I can send you the music if you want it.
They're just separate title slates things. I had a VERY troublesome time with them, but I won't go into those details.. lol! Thanks! I'm glad you liked it!! =)
Good job! Very entertaining!
4mewasp 10 months ago
loved it!
krissykuku 1 year ago
superb!
brieluvsKISS 1 year ago
haha i love how the lines sometimes parody the original lines x) hehehe epic :)
EmmerzColor 1 year ago
that was A-MAZING!!! lol :) made my day!
lgdlucyd 2 years ago
OH GOD that was great!!
stellansgirlmammamia 2 years ago
Bloody awesome. Loved it, there is alot of tripe on utube but this is pure class.
DEATHFLY187 2 years ago
Melanie, marry me.
FranBMan 2 years ago
It fits so well together, it looks like the film was shot for this silent short.
Xmchord 2 years ago 5
OH MY GOSH THIS IS AWESOME!
hersheypyle 2 years ago
So so so made of win!!!! 5/5
Titaniacy 2 years ago
lol. great short. pretty funny
jrsktrd 3 years ago
That was highly amusing. I only wish there'd been a "Have at you!" somewhere in it.
-The Shmo-
keletama 3 years ago
absolutely love it!!!
ErinAndK2Forever 3 years ago
Wow. This must have taken a lot of imagination and planning. Fantastic Job! It's very convincing! :)
clearater67 3 years ago
haha beautiful.
TheImpossibleTen 3 years ago
That is really great. Very nice job in cutting that all together! Very entertaining.
carolinelinnae 3 years ago
amazing! great job!!
itayiceberg 3 years ago
you are amazing!!! that was so funny!!!
cutypie12 3 years ago
How did you do this? You are the QUEEN of all youtubers!
**Long Live Roger Bart**
broadwaygirl524 3 years ago
yessssssssssss
ch0cl8teen 3 years ago
Oh my god!1 You deserve a price!!!!
5 shining stars for you!!
Pinkyvanebet 3 years ago
lol "I want that HONEY!" this is great! XD
chibiviolinist21 3 years ago
lol loved it
browning74 3 years ago
that was so funny! you did an amazing job ! i would have never thought of that and such.
metrourbaine 3 years ago
i love it
GBLR606 3 years ago
Wow, you really have a great imagination.
Two thumbs up! =D
I loved every moment of it.
MrsLionheart 3 years ago
that was AMAZING.
love it.
awagamgnalaw 3 years ago
This is so awsome! It must have taken a long time to make.
madthrawn21 3 years ago
that was great lol
drmgrl11 3 years ago
FABULOUS!!!! Where'd you get the music for this?
LV3cchProductions 3 years ago
this is genius. :D
suicidalmickeymouse 3 years ago
Great one. absolutly hilarious! thx
shermanpotter 3 years ago
i freakin love this movie and i think that it ios really amazing and funny how well this looks!!! ((you did awesome))
squeakums1103 3 years ago
Great job, well done!
quarkcsj 3 years ago
Thank you Melanie!!! FANTASTIC! HYSTERICAL! LOVED IT! Hey, do more!!!
izeizei 3 years ago
That was great!
bcdside 3 years ago
That was soooo funny!!!! Good Job!!!
RentLivesOn 3 years ago
OMG, that was hysterical! I loved it! Nice job.
TheaterRaven 3 years ago
This is excellent, especially if you watch the original just before. Very professional, you have far too much time on your hands; it must have taken you ages to produce. Well done.
simontimelord 3 years ago 6
that was hilarious! hahaha good job
gronow189 3 years ago
Absolutely brilliant! Well done.
AmyK007 4 years ago
omg amazing tell her Isaid it was great :)
PsycReaper 4 years ago
..? Tell who? me?
igvmyslf1000pts 4 years ago
This is GREAT! I love silent movies, you did such a great job! I love how you sped up some things, it looks like an actual old silent film!
sinxxxkitten 4 years ago
good job!
alberoto019 4 years ago
~*suuuper cute. good job grl.*~
dramadollam 4 years ago
that was funtastic creative and hilarryous yaaaaay
silentwulfsfan 4 years ago
I am SOOOOOO dying to see this in it's entirety. Everytime I try, it freezes after just seconds. Every link from YOUTUBE, same problem. Is it posted anywhere else? I love your work, as I've told you before. Thanks,...Pauly
Geezer 4 years ago
Did you ever get my message I sent you before about it?? I said to try playing it, and then pausing it quickly and then letting it load for a while before watching it. If it's playing before the red bar has a chance to load properly, it'll just freeze.
igvmyslf1000pts 4 years ago
Yeah, I got your message. And I tried but still nothing. I posted here, in case anyone was going through the same isse and perhaps had a solution or another link. Anyway, I saw your other vids, and you are amazing!
Geezer 4 years ago
Omigod! That was SO funny!
BBQ Chicken ahaha!
Love it!
-Becca
moofroxmisox 4 years ago
OH SO FABULOUS! Great Job!
Chapstick666 4 years ago
This was simply fab. Can't even imagine the time it took you to put it together. VERY creative.
ladypercy 4 years ago 2
haha
Jerocca 4 years ago
genius, seriously, genius.
another1shortdaymore 4 years ago
AMAZING
musicalife516 4 years ago
I was laughing out loud like a maniac for half of this. This is one of the funniest things I have ever seen on youtube. It was clever, well put together, and very original. It was SUPER! 8D
ExidoSutrin 4 years ago
Thank you, thank you, thank you, and THANK YOU!! Your kind words are greatly appreciated and I am flattered. :) :)
igvmyslf1000pts 4 years ago
this is funny! hardy har har
TheSoulMan8 4 years ago
Hahaha, that was great xD
KanuTGL 4 years ago
Those were some of the most creative insults that I have ever seen penned.
TakaNyasu 4 years ago
haha, I'd like to thank the create-your-own-Shakesperean-insult website I used...
igvmyslf1000pts 4 years ago
I LOVE IT! The insults they were shouting had me clutching my sides in laughter! Truely a triumph, I know it can be hard to make vids about The Producers.
meggyeggy89 4 years ago
GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
weker1 4 years ago
A really well made video - very clever. Nice captions - good work!!!
ActingTilDeath 4 years ago
this si so great and so talented. I LOVE carmen ghia!!!!!!!!!1
phoenixawed 4 years ago
That was really funny. It was well done and hilarious. Good job!
TomBoyDragon3 4 years ago
hehe i enjoyed that! well done
ted1990 4 years ago
Well, I won't say it's awesome, but it is very very good indeed! The storyline is interesting and I really love your editing skill! I never thought of making a silent movie out of a modern one. It's cool! I'll tell my friends who loves "The Producers" about your short film. This would really cheer them up. :)
koukinyx 4 years ago
"That dame is demented" LMAO!
mcrbaby91 4 years ago
Brilliant and very funny! Fast thinking on going with a B&W silent film production, refreshingly different. Made me think, some of the true silent films could have been written one way and subtitled another to give it more appeal...I enjoy your videos - looking forward to your next one!
Earthgem 4 years ago
Good work! Really enjoyed watching... Now I'll have to see the producers again :D
talentfrei85 4 years ago
Why in the world would you think it was lame? I thought it was great! Naomi
NClackum 4 years ago
lol, I guess I just give myself less credit than I deserve. *Sigh* It seemed lame when I was writing it, but all put together I guess it works. Thank you for the encouragement. :)
igvmyslf1000pts 4 years ago
You must be like me, you've got to get that old "Self-Esteem" working!! You have talent and marvelous potential and I'd love to see more. I'm subscribing right now!
NClackum 4 years ago
lol, yes, I'm afraid I lack in the self-esteem category. Thank you very much for your kind words. They are much appreciated. :)
igvmyslf1000pts 4 years ago
That was fantastic! Hilarious and cute! Loved it!
PixieSpells 4 years ago
That was AMAZING... ARF lol
onesingularsensation 4 years ago
i love the script writing
chris5034 4 years ago
I love what you did with the story line it really works! even though the producers is great this movie is great too!
lilcuteactor 4 years ago
Nathan Lane and Gary Beach ruling the world...2gether?!
nathanlaneluva 4 years ago
i must've watched this one like a thousand times and it NEVER gets old. in fact, it gets funnier every single time.
bialystockandbloom 4 years ago
:) :) LOL, i was just watching it again myself, and the part in the beginning where Carmen's closing the doors and calling him a "Swamp donkey"... The movement of his mouth looks more like "Swamp ho"... HAHHAHHAOHIFJGPJGSAD. I started laughing.
igvmyslf1000pts 4 years ago
This is GREAT!!!!
cowandturtle2 4 years ago
That was so marvelous!!! You should really make more. :D
lamezzoenfrancais 4 years ago
lol!!! just as funny as the parody trailer! i cant believe ur not an editor! u totaly should be!
zeanbean 4 years ago
how do you capture the video? Brilliant, by the way! :-) so creative
Edenberry 4 years ago
Cords from the video and audio OUT from the TV to the computer's IN. that's about all I know, haha.
igvmyslf1000pts 4 years ago
Excellent!
JacquiT3 4 years ago
umm wow...if ur not an editor..you should be
and where did u get the piano music/what's it called?
ymeitry 4 years ago
lol, no, I'm not an editor. Thank you though! :) I believe the piano music was called "Tea for Two" and then the music in the middle is called "Running Wild"
igvmyslf1000pts 4 years ago
I love it!! It's soo funny!
Cutekatelyn 4 years ago
hilarious! I LOVED IT!
moosey1113 4 years ago
that was great!
gilgalad24 4 years ago
i love it
jparis233 4 years ago
that was excellent well done xD
bethysue88 4 years ago
Very nice. I am obsessed with both versions of The Producers and this is a third. I enjoyed it very much. Job well done.
larkin38 5 years ago
ahhaha thats sick!
bosherrz 5 years ago
LOL! I loved it. Very weel done!
lexymalfoy 5 years ago
i <3 this!
lunalove101 5 years ago
"Arf!"
kuroineko13 5 years ago
I loved it!
RikaMcGonagall 5 years ago
LMAOOO Carmen. And of course, rather than marrying the Grand Dutchess, Leo is seduced by the extremely friendly Cherokee Indian.
CaptainCrane 5 years ago
And not ot 4get the cop and the salior!
nathanlaneluva 5 years ago
Fantastically warped--I love it! :)
beatlegirl9977 5 years ago
I love it! Brilliant job! <3
OSilentOne 5 years ago
That was awesome!!! Nice job!
CaptSpalding 5 years ago
VERY funny!
geshrat2202 5 years ago
LOL!!! Nice!! That rocked! Way to go!
grizabella626 5 years ago
FANTASTIC!
lalatheviper 5 years ago
The Best Part was the speed up portion of Roger Barts mouth popping gag. You picked just the right thing to replace the long ssssssssss noise that can't be done in a silent movie.
vilkomen 5 years ago
LORD I WANT THAT HONEY!!! once again...perfect as always! :)
brbcool8 5 years ago
Absolutely awesome!!
miglir 5 years ago
"There's a girl I want to marry..."
"A girl?"
"YES!"
haha i love that part- good job : )
(ps- love all your vids!)
blehrox 5 years ago
hehe! Thank you! :)
igvmyslf1000pts 5 years ago
That was cute ^_^ Kinda retarded and gay, but it was really cute!
dreammaster 5 years ago
retarded and gay??? Well, sorry, I only had limited resources to work with
igvmyslf1000pts 5 years ago
ha ha ha ha ,that was freaking awesome!!!
6123 5 years ago
Ah I love making short films like this - silent with titles and in b&w. But I think this outdoes my "old fashioned wedding" series.
:D
Prime22806 5 years ago
Hilarious. Truly hilarious. Seven minutes of my life I'd gladly trade again and again for the same video... the B/W and sped-up effects only added to the amazingness, as did the "vintage" dialogue (which was so perfect, especially where you used the movie's lines!)
EtruriaElibe 5 years ago
Why thank you so much! I'm really glad to hear you say such things! :) I only wish the video editer I used had that scratchy movie effect. :( Oh well. lol
igvmyslf1000pts 5 years ago
OMG! Haha. That was so funny! Your videos rock my socks!
FronkRitastein 5 years ago
hehe! thank you mucho!!
igvmyslf1000pts 5 years ago
omh this is bloody briljant.. this movie had me entertaint at 4 30 in the morning.. not many movies do that
drdarkxl 5 years ago
Ha, ha. This made me laugh. I liked the music too.
Where do you come up with these ideas? :)
mskubelik96 5 years ago
Lol!!
That's so funny.
bialystockbloom 5 years ago
Melanie you never cease to amaze the crap out of me. You are so cool ^_^
Sagerious 5 years ago
*sigh*... I know. LOL! j/k! Thank you so very very much!! =)
igvmyslf1000pts 5 years ago
That was... AMAZING
I always sing/hum producers songs (which annoyes my freinds lol) but you truly are the producers queen... Queen of all Broadway
FlaschHouse 5 years ago
Okay... in all actuality, the presentations are more like 'times 764264gazillion' =^)
comic102975 5 years ago
and the Genius.. is un numberable!!
comic102975 5 years ago
hahahahah! Oh Clayton, you flatter me too much. lol =)
igvmyslf1000pts 5 years ago
It's well deserved though =^)
"...and I try..."
comic102975 5 years ago
Again.... Standing Ovation!(times 30)
You are a friggin GENIUS!(times 50)
comic102975 5 years ago
Thank you and thank you! *bows* Waaaaiiiittt.. how come the standing ovation was only times 30...while the genius state ment was times 50?? j/kkk
igvmyslf1000pts 5 years ago
because, while this a genuine masterpiece, I know you have 1000's more ideas just waiting to be shown! (besides, the times number was the number of "!")lol
comic102975 5 years ago
You're brilliant! Yet another amazing video! :)
OneBlazeOfGloryGlory 5 years ago
Mel. Your a genius! I especially like the scene where Max and Leo leave the fountain and then go right back to it in the next one. Haha. You need to send me that music file! Im putting this up on the Nathan myspace. Okay?
keeperschild 5 years ago
LOLOLOLOLOLL!!!! I know!! (sh! you're not supposed to notice the changing backgrounds! haha!) And I love how Rog-.. Anastasia's wig is on sometimes and then all of the sudden off. ahhh. It's great. And of course you can put it on the Nathan space! LOL, give me your email or something so I can send you the music if you want it.
igvmyslf1000pts 5 years ago
that was so great mel i really enjoy it.
JEFFYjackass 5 years ago
Cool! Thanks!
igvmyslf1000pts 5 years ago
Yep, absolutely brilliant. I'm still LOLing, lol.
DawsonIsABlank 5 years ago
That was freakin' hilarious. How in the world do you put in the text??
*Gasps in awe*
DawsonIsABlank 5 years ago
They're just separate title slates things. I had a VERY troublesome time with them, but I won't go into those details.. lol! Thanks! I'm glad you liked it!! =)
igvmyslf1000pts 5 years ago