Added: 3 years ago
From: jhotico
Views: 207,810
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (184)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • this is to my pop and nana i will never 4 get you. you guys were so funii lol its to bad you guys passed when i was so young but i will always remember you! and to a girl named Ebony dorsey we really didnt kno each other but u seemed very nice

    RIP

  • rip grandma frances gone but not forgotten u put a smile on everyones face and we will never forget the luv that u gave and shown everyone luv u much ur family and friendz<3<3<3

  • R.I.P. Linette I miss you so much

    I still remember how sweet you were

    Wish I had more time to get to know you better

  • I dedicate this song to my grandfather who died from cancer, and i hope he's looking down on me.

    RIP

  • i dedicate this song to my bestfriend BrandonLeeMurphy): he died so soon and none of us got to say goodbye<33 we love you&&miss you so much! you didn't deserve to go threw something like this! i can't wait to see you again someday! math&&reading are so different without you! no one rides a quad anymore<33 iloveyou<33 -BethanyAnn
  • Rest In Peace Shannah Darling ): Never Forgotten ): We Love You (: Keep Smiling Your Gorgous Smile (:

  • dis song reminds me of my boifriend dylan i was on vacation in texas and i met him at the dam ever since then i never forgot his face.

  • beautiful

    (l)

  • my daddy died when i was 13 and now im 14 :( he had to miss my birthday and its been only 5 months and im going crazy :( he sufferd from a disease called ALS or Lue Garghts disease for almost 9 years and i really miss him he was a great man <3 look at me sining bye bye its dedicated to him and look at my video called Daddys Little Girl. it shows how he ended up with the disease. i love him no matter what and r.i.p. daddyy i love u foreeveerrr

  • Comment removed

  • no her dad died

  • I just want to know why the hell you would right such a stupid clown myth on such a beautiful song... grow up

  • please dnt read on i only did it cos i hate clowns trust me dont A few years ago, two parents went out for dinner. A few hours later, the babysitter was calling to ask if she could cover up the clown statue in the kids' room, the father said,Take the kids and get out of the house. We'll call the police, we don't have a clown statue The clown statue is really a killer that escaped from jail. If you don't post this letter on to 10 ten people tonight the clown will be in your room with a chainsaw

  • what a LOSERRRRRRRRRRRRRR

  • i love this song so much.chijoke,edu,rest in peace.

  • she wrote it fur her mom but i think of it fur my dad

  • oh, this song is so sad, huhu it reminds me of the person i luv

  • Reminds me of my gran... Love u always xxx

  • who did she wrote this song for? Can someone plz tell me!

  • i love this song!!!!!

  • its just sad

  • she has a great voice for her age !!!

  • she is only 38 years old and she looks gorgeous!!

    she looks well young for her age!!

    great song mariah!

  • i just lost my man

    (heavy crying)

  • LUV DIS SONG!!!

  • Hey guys, do u know what breed is Mariah's puppy? Just asking, PLEASE DON'T HATE ME. I'm jus asking. THANKS:D

  • I think it's a Jack Russell Terrier, at least that's what it looks like ^_^

  • what a powerful song,everytime you think mariah can't ever top your other mariah favourite!she does,she tops it ..what fucking talent i love this chick,from the very start from 'vision of love' till now i've been supporting mariah...all i need to do now is fuck her,if nick can i can.

  • my Bestfriend... D only nad my trully bestfriends died july 12... she had an uncurable disease

    this day is her interment n' i did not attend b'coz i have a class but that is not enough reason actually to not attend right? i did not scrifice my time!... i'm so sorry ate Carole (tears)

  • sad song

  • i already memorize this song... i really love this song.. i also love the lyrics....!!! =)

  • i love this song its sad i lost my aunt when i was little

    <3

  • thanks 4 careing i am srry bout urs

  • Love this song

  • i juz lost my grandma tis morning..

    tis song reli hit me..

    thx mariah

  • My greatest condolence:(

  • So sorry for your lost hun. I hope u get through everything.

  • x3

    i love thisz sonqq

  • the lyrics are so strong and are rele meaningfull good job love ya xxx

  • <33333333333333

  • i know how ppl feel i lost my aunt from breast cancer but the worst memorie i cant get rid of is I was the 1 that found her dieng no joke she died in 2003 n sad to say i am starting to forget her which i dont want to she was like my second mom my family fell apart when she died R.I.P darlene brito/romero 1964-2003

  • im so srry about ur aunt

    my aunt died when i was like 3 or 4 years old

    she died in a car accident..im truly am srry about ur aunt...<3

  • this is a good song alrotomo so what are you akng about

  • so love this song! mariah u're still the best!

  • i agree with most of yas its sad but its an AWESOME SONG!

  • feel so sad hearing this song...

    but i like it.....so much

  • nina i miss yooh this makes when cry when i think of yooh

  • I just lost my grandmother a couple of days ago so this hits home. Goodbye my best friend. I LOVE YOU :)

  • this song jz makes me want 2 cry.. it's co touching...

  • dis is a sad song but i love it.

  • just lift 2 da sky cause we will neva say goodbye....GOODBYE GRANDMA.... MAY U R.I.P.....

  • This song is just soo awesome , its really touching and it says something .. very good song .. also is she is a WONDERFUL role model for young woman

  • R.I.P Alexandra Rae Gravino..such a young heart. god has recieved a very beutiful angel. at only 15 years old. now that your gone it is hard to beleive that you were once here. but when you were here it is hard to believe you are now gone. may you rest in eternal peace<333333333333333333333333­333333

  • ooo.. so touchin... and oso sad.. nice song... is it for sichuan's earthquake? my sis told me dat dis song was officially offered for sichuan

  • i love it makes me cry!!!

  • nice voice

  • i love this song everytime i listen to this song i thing about my close friend who just passed in march.R.I.P lunard rodgers a.k.a jr. I LUV U MELROSE SOLIDER:)

  • thats a pretty song

  • i just lost 2 very special ppl that were close to me and this song really helped me when it came out...

    RIP TONY!!!

    RIP JEFF!!

    i lov and miss yall so much.

  • Who did she record that song for?

    Anyone know for sure?

    It's beautiful.

  • it's for her dad but she used some words that can also be inflicted to all of her fans that just lost somebody

  • Oh, okay.

    Thanks.

    :)

  • i recently lost my grandma the hospital didnt pick up on the fact that she had a stroke or a heart attack they then moved her in to a care home 2 weeks later she died in her sleep i never got my chance to say goodbye R.I.P grandma miss you so much

  • so sad but so nice...keep on rockin mariah!

  • Nick Cannon is one lucky guy!!!

  • ..i love mariah so much

  • ima guy and all but this songs really good i liked it

  • love it!!!!

  • i do believe this is a beautiful song, i think highly of Mariah however why must she make a video all about her self?? the song has a strong meanin too it.. it should have a strong video to go with it! not a video bout how glamorous she is?! still a great song and artist, just a disappointment

  • iis thiis ong for her mom or dad cuz iits really sad love iit !!! :D

  • you have been a fav since your first song, it's great to have you back on top,bye,bye means so much to me,the memory of my 2 lost children live forever in your music,thank you

  • I love this song,its sad but realy beautiful.

  • nice song,i luv it this song..aha

  • im so sorry miriah

  • this song makes me really sad. um it once made me start crying because me and my best friend were in a fight and because im think im in love with this guy named lalo at my school but he doesnt like me so ya. and this teacher at my school called me sexy and that teacher was a girl just like me! crazy

  • fuck nick cannon that bitch stole my futurre wife

  • i love this song!

  • i like it!!!!

  • I LUV THIS SONGGGGGGGGGGG!!

    we will never say BYE.. never

  • she looks a lot thinner!

  • nice

  • CECCANO REGNA

  • i love this video and i just lost my baby he went to jail i miss you baby and i will never forget you baby you will always be mine your my one and only and i will wait for you to get out of jail thats how much i love you!!!!!

  • i love dis song it just remindes me of my best friends

  • love this song

  • R.I.P Mariah she was only 11 she is alwayz in my heart.... I could never forget my 8 friends who died in sum kind of way they were so young it hurts to talk about them im breakin into tears rite now........ I LOVE AND ALWAYZ REMEMBER MY LOVES NEVER FORGOTTEN

  • nick cannon one lucky bloke

  • Still a total babe

  • i luv tis song it remains me of my primo i luv you pepe alvarado

  • great video, big song, big meaning

  • this song rules

  • I miss my uncle jim so much

    i think about him when i listen to this

    When i was younger my mum and dad didnt have much time for me as they worked, he really cared about me. I love him so much and cry about him so much. A piece of my heart is missing. R.I.P i will see you in heaven and i cant wait for that day i do.

  • i feel your pain just be strong

  • R.I.P. Mom and lil sis. There's always been a missing piece of the puzzle since you left me and I think I think of you everyday. This song reminds me of us, and makes me cry always. But when you left this Earth, you left behind your strength. And because of that, you made me stronger, and I am okay. ILY4EVA <3 Lili

  • this song is my song to my friend veornica who is moving away. I wish she would stay. because she means so much to me. I know that everyone is posting this about someoen dyin but this makes me feel like i mdyin. part of my heart will be gone. hours away..

  • omg your comment almost brought me to tears but thats probably coz Mariahs singing at the same time.

  • WA ! love this song luhs . [[:

  • great video.

  • this song is 4 a friend of mine who died recently, he will always be in my mind.

  • R.I.P.grandma i miss u

  • fav

  • rip mom i will always be thinking about you its ashame you had to die when i was just a baby. i loove you so much!

  • this song reminds me my best friend.....i love this song!!!

  • R.I.P Ginelle Smith my best freind..

    R.I.P Great Grandma..

    R.I.P Romelo's Dad..

    R.I.P Spexx(the dancer)

  • this is a reali gud song but I dont get why she has nick cannon in te video if the song is called bye bye.

  • this song reminds me of my aunt that died of ALS in January 2008 :[

  • GREAT SONG ;D

    R.I.P IYKE FALLON SOLJA

  • This song reminds me about my old dog. I had her since I was born even before ans then my parents put her down exactly a year ago, I am the only one in my family who still misses her and crys about it every night.

  • i miss you uncle and grandpa

  • i feel so bad for her bcuz i love my grandma and i dont no what i would do without her

  • Nick Canon is so pathetic!!!!

    He is just a sextoy for Mariah!!!!

    hahahahahaha!!!!!

  • i luv thisd song

    i miss you guys

    r.i.p anna the best freind ever

  • i love.

  • i love this song it was mine and my uncles before he died:(

  • ahamazin... thts all i kansayy

  • dont like it that much..

  • nick cannon and mariah carey get married.

  • did that dude dy or somethingg??????? =Z

  • no lol.

    that ''dude''

    is who mariah is now married too.

  • =( omg。。。。 i think im crying。。。。 =(

  • omg ive listned to this over and over its amazing

  • i have too mabey 100 times

  • omg, i love this so much!

  • Let's make this song become Mimi's 19th #1 Single!!!

  • Another great single....It will reach number 1 in the Usa.Well done Mariah.....

  • nick cannon is in the video because they are married. it all happened in secret. i love this video x

  • ok i get the point of the song and it relating to past friends and family but why is nick cannon in the video?

  • omg i lost a dog and a best friend in a car accident

  • LOVE THIS SONG A BIG THANKYOU TO U MARIAH I LOVE U even though u are married mariah forever hope mariah and nick's love will last forever happy marriage!!

  • omg most amazing song ever

  • R.I.P Kwame....we miss you... :'(

  • bye bye to u to

  • jhfk

  • i miss u grandpa..:(( r.i.p

  • Amazing Song.

  • wow, nick cannons in this a lot,,, they got married, holy shitt! omg

  • love this so much xx its very sweet

  • love this song :)

  • Great song, very moving, not even the so-called haters would resist choking up tears and they too would be moved.

  • ukg

  • This song is very touching. Her new cd is awesome.

  • mariah is the Best love u <3

    amazing song

  • amazing song .. mariah is the best . i love her since i was 14 and now im 21 =D <3 love u mariah

  • She is so awesome.. all these haters here..probably all have huge fat azzes sitting around watching YouTube all day. Work it.. she does.. step away from the fridge..step away from the fridge.

  • nicee One!!

  • MADONNA is nr 1 in 30 countries! she beated her own record! never any female artist in the history of music as achieved this!!!

    poor Mariah..

  • MARIAH IS THE BEST! MAKE THIS SONG # 1

  • maravilloso me encanto se ve mas hum,ana mariah obio la cancion me emosiona cundo es asi sincera cundo a parte de cantante es mujer q siente algo mas q la fama

  • the kid crying at 1:13 is named joe duffy he goes my school

  • NICK CANNON IS UGLY!

  • Love it!! She's amazing and I hope she keep's comming with more.

  • She needs a new stylist..other than that..she's awesome.

  • the ending is nice with the pictures. aw. :[ <3

  • amazing...gives me goosebumps

  • I can't believe she is 40! Maybe that's why her vids are so old-school.

  • she is 38 years old. which isn't 40. her birthday is march 27, 1970.

  • even with their almost 40 years she is beautiful *-*

  • 40 is not old, especially for rich people. Halle Berry is 43.

  • yeah ur right

  • This video SUCKS!

  • i dont like he vid at all. i thin is not emotional as the song. i thought there coud be light or something. she is not fat an she hasnot fat face. -.-. this is serious. he looks nice. really nice

  • i like this vid!

  • She still has a FAT FACE!

  • sHE LOST TOO MUCH WEIGHT!

  • i noticed that too .maybe that's where all that marriage publicity crap came from.

  • the guy in the yellow!!! is that nick cannon????

  • he died from that big booty sittin on his face

  • WHAT THE HELL IS THIS CRAP??

  • im wondering if that is luis miguel @ 3:43?! did he die already?!

  • She is so beautiful!!

    Now its my favourite video!!

  • aaw the bit at the end with all the photos is really touching. The pets as well! They included little cats and dogs! so sad..

  • I don't know why, but I love the shot of her looking out the hotel window, and the one of her in the hat.

  • i love it.

  • GO MIMI!!!!!

    awesome video

    it was emotional

    but it wasn't dragging

    so uhhhh yeah

    great vid

  • Your right