Idol Soup! Season 9 Episode 12 (TOP 24 IS REVEALED!!!)

[fatqwert200]

ur FATTTTTTTT



[matbolabc]

@fatqwert200 and ur gayyyy

[marcus4u1]

sorry watched :)

[marcus4u1]

this is the first vid that i eatched of you and i like you you camplamated Lilly Scott :)

[BandxOfxBrothers]

No offense to all Americans, but to those who watch this show, you're all IDIOTS! (with the exception of the ones who voted for Lilly). Honestly, how stupid do you have to be. You must not know real music. She is one of the top 4 for all the contestants (1st in my mind). I probably wont watch the rest of this season, or even the show again because it is frustrating seeing such talent going to waste all because of a bunch of Idiot Americans who don't know music (Not All Americans)

[BandxOfxBrothers]

Not trying to be rude to Americans. Have lots of Family in America, and I love going there . . . . BUT TRY TO UNDERSTAND. How could you! I almost wished I lived in America so I couldve voted for her as much as possible, and got other people to vote for her. Such a tragedy.

[ramzacloud10]

tim urban was garbage LOLOLOL

[superbaseball4]

did anyone know Angela Martin got a record label from American Idol

[PrinceTian]

Siobhan Magnus all the way!!!!!!!!!!!!

[raphyninja]

Andrew Garcia!!!!! He is awesome! vote for him!

[tiffanyrosejones]

LACEY BROWN is ThE SHIIT :)

Love her love her love her

She will be the American idol !!!!!

[zerishabe]

Did u stop posting? I missing your comments after episode12////

[mattybaum]

hand raised.

[l0r3st0]

andre garcia reminds me of danny gokey. he's seasoned, he's good with his guitar, he's very confident, very current. he'd make it to top 3 at least. but i love siobhan, and though not as popular, i hope she makes it far. her making the top 10 will be the reason i'll go to the tour. i'm impressed with todrick, too. he's current, he makes each song his own.

[robertosato5]

you should edit your videos with videos or at list pics so we who you are talking about.

[veneresquivel]

first time i've watched you,won't be the last!

[mdizzle211]

omg i've been watching you since last season you're hilarious even w/o jenn!! i love your videos <3

anywhoo on to idol my faves right now are Janell "legs" Wheeler for the girls and i would say andrew garcia for the guys but i hate cheering for the obvious front runner. Idk not really feeling the guys this year so i'll pick another girl... i really like Katie "jojo" Stevens. And if i had to choose a guy it would unfortunately be Todrick "scammer" Hall.

[gymbug112]

I really like how you did your eye makeup :)

[tumbles022]

i think its tues: girls singing, weds: guys singing, thurs: results show

[musicluver987654321]

Yeah I was mad about Angela being cut too... I felt so bad for her! :(

[CharmedForeverLove]

I really like this years line up.

I agree with your Top 12 Girls list, and put Ashley Rodriguez into it.

[NewYorkerForGood]

just like to let you know, i raised my hand at the beginning of this video.

[wuzupraphy]

Haha, your funny! I loled when you said the scrolly thing!! :P Great reviews, I agree with like everything you said!!! :D

[Darknezz9]

the good thing is sthat american idol got angela a contract yay!!!!!! kira is making a song for her. to start her singing career so yay!!!!!!!

[NewYorkerForGood]

@Darknezz9

seriously?! where'd you hear that? that's awesome! (:

[Darknezz9]

look up ellen angela on here(youtube) and ellen has angela martin as a guest on her show.She said kira diogardi(judge) will be writing a song for her.overall she's getting a record deal contract.yay!

[zayzayawesome]

The girls are gonna sing on Tuesday and then the boys on Wednesday and then the Result show on Thursday

My favorites are Lily Scott, Andrew Garcia, Aaron Kelly, Didi Benami, Ashley Rodriguez, and Todrick Hall

[amcar08]

Yay for Radiohead! Yay for you making a video for us even though you're sick. Rest up for next week!! :)

[eatglitter]

i was pissed about how they screwed angela martin...:(

[buttaman2]

Just wanted to let you know Angela Martin will be a guest on Ellen friday today at 3pm and Shelby Dressel will be a guest next week

[0xTRellyx0]

Why did they cut Angela...they even felt bad about it!

[timmysiko1212]

my ideal top 12... katie stevens, crystal bowersox, lily scott, paige miles, didi benami, haeley vauhn, andrew garcia, jermaine sellers, tim urban, aaron kelly, todrick hall, alex lambert... and yes, tim and alex are only on this list cause i think they're hot. don't judge me :-)

[rayna876]

i was pissed that tori kelly got cut!

[tommyng17]

I pissed off about Angela cut..

[curlingiron7658]

Why the heck was Angela cut? I mean...GRRR!!!! She reminded me of a mix of Paris Bennett, and Lil Rounds when she was good on Idol. I am so mad!!!! I cant believet a few people made it through this year, they were just average.

[LAURATHECPK]

michelle delamor!

[mjesings]

i'm excited to hear her sing, have they shown here at all this season?

[smithjt1]

I <3 Crystal... She is my favorite. Soo authentic.

[mjesings]

she is pretty wonderful.

[BuffaloHeroes]

Tori is clearly better then Haley !.

[mjesings]

i think they're pretty equal.

[Spikesgirl80]

I don't know about anybody else, but I was like who the hell is Paige Miles? Lol. I don't remember her at all.

[mjesings]

lol i was wondering the same thing!

[rayna876]

i thought that to, and i couldnt find anything on her

[VaunTV]

I Agree, Angela should SO still be on the show.. ugh excited for top 12 girls n guys though lol

[mjesings]

woohoo me too, so excited

[yoSTina87]

And I hope you get to feeling better Mollie! =)

[mjesings]

thanks! *cough*

[yoSTina87]

i was upset about angela. she really deserved this. I'm really excited to see what Andrew, Jermaine, Todrick, Katie, Didi and Crystal are going to do. There my faves at the moment. And Aaron is adorable! lol

[matbolabc]

Lilly Scott FTW!!

[mjesings]

i like her, i just hope she fixes her grandma hair color lol

[vickyvicks0]

oh oh oh! and how cool is it that now they are allow have twitter accounts and myspace and facebook!

Im following all my favorites.

[mjesings]

yes! that's SO cool!

[vickyvicks0]

the whole tyler thing makes me mad! lol! but I guess its betther than not been shown at all like joe munoz (why did he change his name to joe! I liked jose better) and tim urban

[joaooo222]

Poor Angela!

Katie to win :P

[pingupingu18]

They never showed Tim Urban making it, but I'm glad he did.

[steelerboy786]

feel better molly even though ur losing ur voice ur reviews r still awesome kudos i felt sorry for angela martin i guess third time isnt a charm i thought she shud've gone through i really like ashley rodriguez shes gonna go far

[willycosme]

I'm mad that Angela Martin didn't make it, it was also her last chance to audition, Anyways my top 3 are Katie Stevens, Andrew Garcia and Ashley Rodriguez.

[grumpykitty7]

the results show is next Thursday and the info says that four contestants are eliminated, I'm excited to see what songs people pick

my throats been sore for days ugh - I hope you feel better soon :)

[mjesings]

ohhh goodness, so that means i have to do 3 vids next week lol

[denwri76]

Angela Martin's elimination was a little hard to watch. She was crying even before Kara told her she didn't make the 24.

[mjesings]

yeah i felt so bad for her :(

[Speedsacspeed]

Health advice!!!!! take about 300 MG of lipoic acid twice a day for a total about 600 MG a day - with food ---------go to health food store you can get it

Its the miracle suppliment for overall good health- even helps fade Keloid scars HAHA Im serious its great to take

[mjesings]

LOL i will try to look for it!!! i'm always sick in the winter, ugh

[mistermagoo90]

*raises my hand* How did Angela not make it through? How did Haeley Vaughn make it and not Tori Kelly? Or Tim Urban & Lee DeWyze and not Thaddeus Johnson. and who is Joe Munoz or Paige Miles?

[Speedsacspeed]

angela was 50/50 voice wise to my mind but all things taken in I put her in top 24

Janel was a super disappointment one trick pony- Haeley overall sort of sucks but has good moments-

[matbolabc]

I almost cried when Angela walked out of those doors. Did you notice that she had nobody there to comfort her, she just walked away all by herself :(

[matbolabc]

Angela Martin was my favorite. She's 28 so she can't come back next year....... :(

[gym1cheerman07]

i would pick the same top 12 :) its going to be a really good year!

[mjesings]

indeed :)

[mjesings]

aw thanks! glad you like em :)

[mjesings]

nice :)

[MrJoe849]

I think this year will bring us the show's worst singers. Waaay too many people have been cut in the name of publicity. FIrst it was that vocal coach, now it's the curly haired girl at the end.

I mean, awesome black guy gets cut, but guy who took off his shirt during auditions remains? COME ON!! I honest to God think I might not even watch the whole season, which is a first for me. I still have a tiny bit of hope cuz I haven't heard all of them sing.

[mjesings]

yeah a LOT of great people were cut...i guess we'll just have to wait and see what this season brings

[gumbercules82]

Really? Watch it back Angela wasn't that good.

Also the lambert and other young guy(Dallas audition) were bad as well. Dede and Bowersox are really good.

[mjesings]

r u kidding? angela is great!

[matbolabc]

Ummm Angela was AMAZING, idk who you were listening to 0_o

[DotsVoiceStudios]

OMG SWEETIE! Even though you feel sick, you look GREAT! Get some rest and feel better! Stay away from sugar and caffeine to heal your voice. You are so adorable and I enjoy your reviews and agree with you! My stupid DVR cut out after my fav Crystal Bowersox made it through, but thanks for catching me up! Not sure if I'm going to post a video or not, but glad you were a good sport and got thru this one all in one piece!

[mjesings]

aww thanks Dot! the show must go on! ;-)

[cpollock911]

Sad that they let Angela and Shelby go, they were both part of my favorite girls this year.

My top 12 are Todrick Hall, Andrew Garcia, Aaron Kelley, Alex Lambert, John Park, Jermaine Sellers, Siobhan Magnus, Crystal Bowersox, Katie Stevens, Didi Benami (yeah!), Lilly Scott, and Ashley Rodriguez

[mjesings]

nice top 12 :)

[Arkansas19852003]

My Favorites are:

Janell Wheeler

Crystal Bowersox

Ashley Rodriguez

AARON KELLY

Tim Urban

John Park

[mjesings]

i haven't hopped on the tim urban train yet...but we'll see

[Arkansas19852003]

yeah, he isnt the bast singer, but I hope he makes it far because i think he has a great attitude and strong morales like a former idol contestant from my region KRIS ALLEN!

[piercechan]

Angela should have made it, she needs the opportunity and it really really upsets me to see her go. Hopefully, someone will help her out and get her a record deal. I think this won't be the last we see of her.

[mjesings]

i just can't believe that they cut her, it makes me think that there are some underlying issues...just doesn't make sense

[ExtraChapstick]

I really think Angela should have gotten through. She's gotten so close so many times and really has a great voice... It was sad.

[mjesings]

totally!

[1pimpsamrazo]

what happened to Chris Golightly ( Orphan )they showed him celebrating with the top 24 and then they didn't show him as one of the top 12 guys ?

[mjesings]

i heard that he got disqualified because idol found out about a contract he had before he tried out, so they replaced him with tim urban

[buttaman2]

I didn't like Thaddius getting cut and they should have never said he was great and did nothing wrong since there was guys that made the top 24 that did make mistakes.Made them look so fake.But hes only 16 and he will be even better next year if he works and trys next year.

[mjesings]

yeah that actually really pissed me off "you didn't do anything wrong" then why cut him?

[zerishabe]

Would u please make more recording before you lose that voice. Enjoyed your analysis, comments and voice too.

[mjesings]

thanks :)

[Lushdarkness]

Aww, I'm sorry about your voice being scratchy. :/ hope you'll get over it soon.

No personal favorites this year (unlike last year...can't help comparing everyone to Adam). I kind of like Andrew Garcia, but he reminds me of Danny and no one replaces Danny. The white-haired chick has fairly good pipes, and the dreadlocked girl is awesome too. I hope Aaron Kelly makes it far. He's got insane vocals for someone whose only sixteen years old...

[mjesings]

i think Aaron will make it pretty far.

[ElizaDFan]

omg you have no idea. I've been a fan of Angela's since the beginning. I'm so upset right now. I don't what the judges were thinking? how could she not make it? it makes absolutely no sense.

[mjesings]

no sense at all...completely ridiculous.

[eclipeser]

am i the only one who realy just dosent...like Haeley Vaughn i dont know i just dont like her

[stephanieLDSgirl]

@eclipeser

I love her! But everyone has their opinion, and I respect yours.

[eclipeser]

thank you and you know shes not horibal shes good but she was definitly not the best and that girl who kara sat with i think would have been a better addition haeley could ve auditions again

[mjesings]

i like her!

[efil4own1]

I'm pissed about Angela getting cut too. Hopefully Oprah sees this and gives her all that she deserves...although I think Angela's personal problems may have weighed in the judges' decision to cut her.

[stephanieLDSgirl]

@efil4own1

Maybe you're right...in that case they're pretty heartless.

[efil4own1]

For what it's worth, they probably wouldn't want her to stay in Hollywood knowing her daughter is sick and her mother has problems that she might need to be called back home to help solve (they did find her mother alive, from what I hear). As good as she was, and as much as I wanted her to stay, no point in keeping her with her personal life being so volatile.

[yourimaginaryenemy]

There's so much raw talent this year! I'm loving Crystal too. She's my fave. My top 12 would be: Casey J, Todrick H, Siobhan M, Didi B, Crystal B, Katie S, Andrew G, Michael L, Alex L, Ashley R, Katelyn E, and John P.

[mjesings]

totally agree!

[xcutegirlx25]

i love this top 24 this year

[mjesings]

i do too, it's gonna be really hard to narrow it down to top 12...

[stephanieLDSgirl]

I'm really quite angry about Angela getting cut also. I wanted to smack Kara honestly...like how patronizing can you be? Like that's going to make her feel better....Anyway, I hope that someone who's sees this will give her her big break. Where's Oprah? lol

[mjesings]

exaaaactly...kara, stfu!

[Ronyka222]

I'm soooo mad that they sent Angela Martin home!!!She had a GREAT,GREAT VOICE!!Kara said there's other ways to do it....BIATCH PLEASE!!I hope somebody picks her up,tho or something.She was better than some of the girls that made it!!Bull sh!t!!

[mjesings]

uggghhh!!! i know! it's such bs!

[sweetmama231]

I agree that there is no reason why they should have cut Angela . She could have easily replaced Katelyn or Lacey. And i totally don't understand them picking Tim Urban. From what we've seen, he wasn't that great, and they cut guys who had way better voices and performances.

[JulianTheGreat01]

Originally, Chris Golighty (the foster kid) was in, but he got DQ'd, so they brought back Tim

[mjesings]

yeah i heard that chris golightly had gotten dq'd so they replaced him with tim urban...of all ppl!!!?

[yoSTina87]

@sweetmama231 I totally agree with you! I can't even remember Tim Urban, I liked Thaddeus!

[RsMark051]

wow..i'm madd too about angela .........grrrrrrrrrrrr

[mjesings]

me too :(

[sultan1122]

I am so mad angela didn't make it through, She's really poor, her mom is missing, she doesn't have a father, this was her last season she could audition AND her daughter has a disorder. On top of that.... Girl can SING, she's probably better than 75% of the people that went through, and on the same level of the other 25% SO MAD :< And i feel you with the spoiler thing, i saw it and was totally surprised and was hoping it was a mistake..

[mjesings]

it's so terrible. they made a huge mistake.

[willycosme]

Quick question, please answer it.. wasnt Paige the girl from season 8 who was stuck in a group with Tatiana, Nathanial and the blonde chick?

[mjesings]

hmmmmm....i don't remember, it's possible!

[denwri76]

@willycosme I think it was Nancy Wilson who was stuck in the group with Tatiana, Nathanial & the blonde chick.

[matbolabc]

no that was nancy wilson

[willycosme]

I cant listen to this now cuz i have no audio, ill have to watch it on my iphone later but WOW I cant believe Chris was desqualified and replaced by Tim Urban, SCANDALOUS<3 Also Go Ashley & Andrew<3

[kahlua0000]

first! =)

[mjesings]

w00t!