Theyself is correct Bill Berry left in Oct1997, eight years after this clip. I remember seeing this song live in Dublin on the Green Tour. The image of Stipe banging the chair has stayed with me to this day. 10/10
@cpkuhnen I am old enough to have seen them do this song on the Green tour, back in 89 (I still have the tour programme somewhere) and Stipe did the Gang of Four intro in Dublin at the RDS Simmonscourt Pavilion, too. I also read most of the reviews of the UK gigs on that tour, and he did it pretty regularly, apparently.
@karmapolicemannn I agree. I think that Green was the last absolutely great album REM made, and that this is the finest song on it. I am not a snob; I was so excited that they suddenly started to get really famous, but at the same time I was hating the records that they made. To this day I think Monster and New Adventures are the only decent albums since Green.
@lexo30 Man on the Moon, Drive, Nightswimming, and Ignoreland if not more from Automatic for the People. That was their last great album in my judgment.
@karmapolicemannn Not underrated, just under the radar, saved safe and secure for us that KNOW. If the general public knew what we know, there would be, um, self awareness, which would lead to global peace and understanding, abolishment of poverty and other stuff this planet doesn't need... let's keep this hushed up.... My god they killed John Lennon for it...
he had a brain aneurysm during the monster tour and the end result was him leaving the band to have a less stressful life as a farmer in georiga. He has played with them since on occasion, however. Bill is awesome.
Actually, he had his aneurysm within a month or so after this show. It was during the european part of the Green Tour in 1990 and the band had to cancel many gigs in W Germany and elsewhere, not the Monster Tour which was in '94-'95ish.
It's years ago .. i was standing in front for this concert,it was an experience to see this band life,i remember the good sound there of this gig.REM mutch more better earlyer years recording to my opinion.Thanks for upload!
Great song and great performance. The best band in the world. REM will always be Berry, Buck, Mills, Stipe. There's no replacement for Berry. Awesome.
I went to their show in Vancouver in 2003 and they played this - Michael announced that that very performance was the first time they'd played it at a show since 1989.
Seeing this live on tour when it was new was incredible. Their early to mid 80's shows were uinique, electric things. Energetic, moody, spontaneous---that's why they are in the HOF. Not too many chances to see them without Bill after this.
watch tour film of this... listen to green... now do wank yourself silly (metaphoric lol) mind blowing. Part of the meaning of life should be clear now, this band >< hahaha.
Ive seen REM 17 or 18 times dating back to 84 but the Green tour sealed the deal, at that time they may have been THE best band in the world challenged only by U2. I saw them at the FOX in Atlanta 2 nights in a row and to quote Pulp Fiction" God damn I say God Damn"
I agree with you regarding their status after Green. The megaphone, banging on the chair, the stipe shuffle. Bono didn't have anything on Michael. So damn interesting to watch and lyrics have all thinking they were written for each of us. Example You are the Everything!
Question?? The show at the Fox did they play the entire Murmur album and then the Green album in exact order? They finished off with Fall on me, Low and one other I can't remember.
I was there too . 1989 - Dayton , Ohio . Green tour . This gives me the chills every time I see it . "You fill in the mortar , you fill in the harmony "
Much more than a song!!
hyvakoira 2 months ago
stipe's politics has hurt REM's legacy
knightschwartz 3 months ago
mike mills is the man.
mattaki 3 months ago
I remember spending all my babysitting money on REM cassettes. wow.
oophelia46 4 months ago
My favorite all time, great song !
kirsipuuful 5 months ago
His voice is comforting once you listen to their music your whole life.
AdrianneReneeR 8 months ago 3
Green was their Best album ever
ff621 1 year ago
@ff621 Best album?? Are you sure about that?
bassmanjoe 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@bassmanjoe everyone is entitled to their own opinion
ff621 4 months ago
Reach out for me, and hold me tight..... geweldige band, mooie momenten op pinkpop die ik zal koesteren
fosters36 1 year ago
we placed this video. it is awsome.
cakewin 1 year ago
Comment removed
purpletoothedfurby 1 year ago
"Green" was an incredible album. I can't say enough about it, and this song is powerful. Well done Athens, GA
Bntnredsox 2 years ago 19
This song made me discover the real REM.
jatojo 2 years ago 2
Green was a really great album........ all his albums were fantastic....
ladyjanus 2 years ago 6
Theyself is correct Bill Berry left in Oct1997, eight years after this clip. I remember seeing this song live in Dublin on the Green Tour. The image of Stipe banging the chair has stayed with me to this day. 10/10
gerfarmer 2 years ago 2
I agree! maybe one of the most memorable things I've seen in concert. I was really surprised to hear the Gang of four intro...
cpkuhnen 2 years ago
@cpkuhnen I am old enough to have seen them do this song on the Green tour, back in 89 (I still have the tour programme somewhere) and Stipe did the Gang of Four intro in Dublin at the RDS Simmonscourt Pavilion, too. I also read most of the reviews of the UK gigs on that tour, and he did it pretty regularly, apparently.
lexo30 1 year ago
one of the real big musical masterpieces ever written
ilona0925 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
ilona0925 2 years ago
Pro
all the
way
amateurs
need not
apply
npspec34 2 years ago
Very underrated song.
karmapolicemannn 2 years ago 23
@karmapolicemannn I agree. I think that Green was the last absolutely great album REM made, and that this is the finest song on it. I am not a snob; I was so excited that they suddenly started to get really famous, but at the same time I was hating the records that they made. To this day I think Monster and New Adventures are the only decent albums since Green.
lexo30 1 year ago
@lexo30 I agree. I was horrified when I heard Shiny Happy People for the first time.
buddhabder 11 months ago
@lexo30 Man on the Moon, Drive, Nightswimming, and Ignoreland if not more from Automatic for the People. That was their last great album in my judgment.
whpriol1 9 months ago 2
@karmapolicemannn Not underrated, just under the radar, saved safe and secure for us that KNOW. If the general public knew what we know, there would be, um, self awareness, which would lead to global peace and understanding, abolishment of poverty and other stuff this planet doesn't need... let's keep this hushed up.... My god they killed John Lennon for it...
fixmeplz 1 year ago
Hey, don't say too much man. Otherwise we must kill you. (well, everybody makes mistakes...I let you make it good..)
Digidanny 1 year ago
Comment removed
wigglesworth6969 6 months ago
I wonder why the drummer had to leave the band...does anyone know why?
rokyfireloadat32 2 years ago
he had a brain aneurysm during the monster tour and the end result was him leaving the band to have a less stressful life as a farmer in georiga. He has played with them since on occasion, however. Bill is awesome.
tonyrubicon 2 years ago 4
Actually, he had his aneurysm within a month or so after this show. It was during the european part of the Green Tour in 1990 and the band had to cancel many gigs in W Germany and elsewhere, not the Monster Tour which was in '94-'95ish.
naguszed 2 years ago
No, it was during the Monster tour that he had the aneurysm.
theyself 2 years ago
Comment removed
rexstalin 2 years ago
He said once, al last I will see REM!!!!!
domusaimports 2 years ago
The "We live as we dream, alone" comes from a Gang of Four song titled that, if you're wondering.
BirdofSaxony 2 years ago
Yes and the "trick" of the beaten chair with a stick also comes from Gang Of Four when they 'd play "He'd Send In The Army" live....
lyonslaforet 2 years ago
fuking brill stipe we luv ya
dastipe 3 years ago
It's years ago .. i was standing in front for this concert,it was an experience to see this band life,i remember the good sound there of this gig.REM mutch more better earlyer years recording to my opinion.Thanks for upload!
Schildjer 3 years ago
This outstanding song is featured on page 6 of 'The Song For Today' by Jimmie Oliver.
KJRolling 3 years ago
great performance,the intro with banging on a chair is legend.
KerreyTheBitterSugar 3 years ago 5
We Live,
As we Dream.
Alone.
tsungvarsky 3 years ago 2
Stipe looked good with hair
Terminator7653 3 years ago 2
Excellent, Johnny Quest.
White gloves?
To quote Ringo, "I've got blisters on my fingers!"
Or was that the walrus.
Let my machine talk to me.
npspec34 3 years ago
we live as we dream: alone...bloody hell, that's awesome
attirem 3 years ago
what's with the white gloves on the drummer?
tsungvarsky 3 years ago
i wonder is this about GB Sr.?
YouDolo 3 years ago
Just politicians in general.
buttholesurfer666 3 years ago
Gran cancion... me encanta!!!
ALBERTILANDIA 3 years ago 2
"let my machine talk to me"
Albg0ne 3 years ago
"I demand a recount"
ZoophPA 3 years ago 2
Saw them in Chicago a couple weeks ago. I'm still flying high from it. They are just fucking awesome!
rchslion14 3 years ago 2
I saw them in Chicago, too! Wow, that was a fantastic concert. First time I'd seen them live.
BeginXtheXBegin 3 years ago
im in this crowd somewhere...
naguszed 3 years ago
michael is good in every second of his life. great song, of course
bbblahok 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Pompous asshole but I love this album.
ZoophPA 3 years ago
'This is my world and i am a world leader pretend'
Sound like anyone we know now? Great song...filthy hot group and one of the best live bands in the world!
chayaus 3 years ago 7
wow. i haven't heard this song since green first came out. i forgot how good it was.
lotharjones7 3 years ago 2
This is an amazing song; don't know why it wasn't a single. This isn't the best performance of the song on Youtube, though.
quartzy 3 years ago
Great song and great performance. The best band in the world. REM will always be Berry, Buck, Mills, Stipe. There's no replacement for Berry. Awesome.
jackskeleton0 3 years ago
Fanflippintastic!
woohoosh 4 years ago 3
Great stuff and a great Gang of Four tribute intro
dagga36 4 years ago
I love this song
ginamari 4 years ago
I went to their show in Vancouver in 2003 and they played this - Michael announced that that very performance was the first time they'd played it at a show since 1989.
Sean1983 4 years ago
This is just beautiful.
stipelover 4 years ago 4
mine too!
kukai888 4 years ago 2
Seeing this live on tour when it was new was incredible. Their early to mid 80's shows were uinique, electric things. Energetic, moody, spontaneous---that's why they are in the HOF. Not too many chances to see them without Bill after this.
JLDB1987 4 years ago
Amazing! This is insanely freakin awesome
SuperWaffleNinja 4 years ago 2
This is such a great song and I've been wanting to see them perform it live. I guess this will have to do.
BeginXtheXBegin 4 years ago 2
can sum1 send me this song mp3 format
danielsleigh 4 years ago
Great song and band from my home state of Georgia.....Go Dawgs....UGA and Athens, Georgia rule!!!
RIPmyers 4 years ago
watch tour film of this... listen to green... now do wank yourself silly (metaphoric lol) mind blowing. Part of the meaning of life should be clear now, this band >< hahaha.
Interpol134 4 years ago 2
Ive seen REM 17 or 18 times dating back to 84 but the Green tour sealed the deal, at that time they may have been THE best band in the world challenged only by U2. I saw them at the FOX in Atlanta 2 nights in a row and to quote Pulp Fiction" God damn I say God Damn"
ddoublled 4 years ago
I agree with you regarding their status after Green. The megaphone, banging on the chair, the stipe shuffle. Bono didn't have anything on Michael. So damn interesting to watch and lyrics have all thinking they were written for each of us. Example You are the Everything!
Question?? The show at the Fox did they play the entire Murmur album and then the Green album in exact order? They finished off with Fall on me, Low and one other I can't remember.
STHNER 4 years ago
Great memories.I was 19 when I saw them.That chair-whacking was beautiful.Plus their After Hours.
funkydafunker 4 years ago
Nice man. . thanks.
Nice Gang Of 4 intro/Jon King chair bash.
REMchout 4 years ago
The best.
KareKare77 4 years ago
I was there too . 1989 - Dayton , Ohio . Green tour . This gives me the chills every time I see it . "You fill in the mortar , you fill in the harmony "
joeybellfurie 4 years ago
Possibly their best song behind Leave and Swan Song H.
Generalk 4 years ago
awesome. i.was.there.
naguszed 4 years ago
thank you
demetrios4voto 4 years ago
thank you! to elphantalla1
demetrios4voto 4 years ago
:-D brilliant!
Pyroman1990 4 years ago
absolutely vintage
iconoclast2202 4 years ago
This is great! Do you have more clips from this show?
stipelover 4 years ago