For Good - Idina Menzel - Wicked (Broadway on Broadway)

[MrPablotina]

its awesome



[ElphieBeGood]

when they put the camera on JLT i was like "ur not kristin" ahaha!

[SingingCatzzz]

wtf?!? lol wheres Kristin?? Kristin is the light of this song, her and idina are perfect together..its just not the same without her...same goes for when Kristin sings it wthout idina.. but its still amazing xD Idina looks so beautiful there!!!

[CedarPointerAPEXer]

i love idina sings like 80% of it

[loolupin]

1 person doesn't have A BEST FRIEND

[loMJveable]

I WANT KRISTIN BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[callieshorty]

excuse me??? idina menzel would blow u away!!!! she doesnt even have to try!!!! its supposed to be pushed bc its THAT song!!! its an emotional piece so yeah u can get over it!!!!! id like to c u post a video like this and do half as good!!!! i bet u cant...

[MsLILUN]

sorry and i dont want loads of hate mail and dislikes but Idina is so unbelieveably overated as a singer and in this role. That top note is struggled beyond belief and she is so fricking nasally. Im yet to hear a nice or good perfomrance. Any idina sycophants who disagree please reply with a link to prove me wrong..xx

[SingingCatzzz]

@MsLILUN you have a lot of nearve posting this, when you shouldnt have even come here,if you didnt like idina menzel. If you dont like her, then keep it to yourself. It says her name right on the name of this video, so theres no reason for you to come here hating it. Idina menzel is beautiful, and overly talented. If you disagree, im fine with that. but please dont go around getting everyone like me all worked up. theres no need for you come here with a bad attitude ruining it for ppl like me

[MsLILUN]

@SingingCatzzz Yet you have no link to prove me wrong..I was on here because I love the song ...and she was the original elphaba...Its the beauty of free speech ...If dont likeit dont read it or post a video to prove me wrong

[SingingCatzzz]

@MsLILUN here, a wonderful song be idina menzel. and btw, you still didnt have to post that comment. f you dont like her, keep it yourself. dont go around posting bad stuff about her when clearly everyone here likes her.

[MsLILUN]

@SingingCatzzz Its you tube , I can say what I want. Like i said i came on here cos i adore wicked and this song and actually have idinas album as liked her voice . I didnt come here to hate , but this is dreadful for braodway standard and when you compare her to other people this is a poor standard. Opinion is allowed...every defying gravity performance , all you see written is...she had a cold , she had astham attack ,she had sore throat, she couldnt have on every luve you tube video..

[SingingCatzzz]

@MsLILUN honest;y, this isnt worth it. if youdont relize how amazing Idina Menzel is, then i feel bad for you. Enjoy your dull life without her....

and btw, yes, it is you tube, you can say whatever you want, i just wish ppl had the comon sense to not post negitive comments on a video that a lot of ppl like, and that you would really only watch that video if you like that person.



[cuaucg]

The guy that is singing at 0:54 is cuuuute!

[TheYogiBunnie]

@cuaucg lol MHMM, AGREED

[livywoodward]

@cuaucg Yeah!!!

[ilubemmerz]

Idina is great, but I do agree xhe is pushing a little bit in this song. idk JLK's voice is kinda boring

[ilubemmerz]

Idina Menzel shows off that glinda so much. Idina needs excellence...like Kristin!

[inlovewithJLT]

@ilubemmerz Jennifer Laura Thompson is excellence. Idina overdoes this song like no other. Her volume, hand gestures, facial expressions, etc. are so overblown. I really can't stand the way she performs this song.

[KristinandIdinagirl]

Kristin and Idina are my favorite Wicked couple but JLT is my second favorite Glinda!!

[StrangeDarkSoul]

They assort very well together. :)

[Solarista6222]

I am a Kristin fan but i aprove of JLT her and Sarah Earnshaw(west end) are the only other Glinda's that i've een that i approve of!

[Puppies140]

JLT is really good.... Idina.... a mess..

[Solarista6222]

@Puppies140 you take that back! Idina was amazing!

[amidola]

This is kinda gay in a totally good way!

[Solarista6222]

@amidola it really is!

[plindiful]

@amidola in a very very very good way!

[HawkNelsonfanatic159]

Why was is JLT and not kristen chenoweth?

[JoshuaMars99]

I'm not a fan of this version. I don't think JLT's voice is enough of a contrast with Idina's to make her a good Glinda. Not hating on her by any means, just saying.

[elphabagalindafiyero]

Why's everyone hating on JLT? mean, don't get me wrong, I adore Kristin Chenoweth but, come on, there can be more than one Glinda, right? The only one Idina really didn't work with was Dallimore. But JLT's good, even if her voice lacks the warmth and operatic tone Kristin's has.

[DutchRodent]

this looks so old :P

[nyv527]

Kristin was wonderful, but Jennifer and Idina was just a whole another level of magical. Jennifer is one of the best replacements I've ever seen on Broadway!

[d0ggylover21]

i wish this was idina and kristen instead of jenniferrr. i mean jennifer is good too but kristen..yeah. haha XD

[musicequalsmylife17]

idina is the best elpaba ever.... i want to see the play before she leaves and they get another one!

[iTouchSinger]

@musicequalsmylife17 idina left in like 2004.....

[musicequalsmylife17]

@iTouchSinger i no i ment to say i wanted to see her before she left but yeah typos happen..

[KristinandIdinagirl]

@iTouchSinger Her last show was January 9th, 2005. It's a long story.

[IsabelNSCarvalho]

Sooo cute!!

[xxmoussexx]

SHE IS THE BEST ELPHABA!!! IDINA FOREVER! x

[degeorgetitanic]

@ChocoboEmperor yea but she is not superwomen haha, nor is any Elphaba. They have ALL hit flubbed notes

[jealousmaenad]

@degeorgetitanic true. nobody sings perfectly all the time.

[sherifa1scott]

Idina Menzel is poo compared to Alexia Khadime - AK is just amazing :D and u cant deny that cuz its a fact!

[alley458]

@sherifa1scott lets not forget who was the ORIGINAL and brought this life to Elpaba shall we? Cause i for one disagree strongly with that fact.

[Lorzaliiez]

@sherifa1scott Guess what, Alexia IS amazing, but Idina Menzel totally out-ranks her.

[dolphcharge]

no offense, but you try singing that note before 10 in the morning after performing 8 times a week.

[randomwig]

when was this?

[JWDramaGrl]

The guy lip syncing cracked. me. up. Such passion! Haha LOVE IT! Miss Cheno though.

[trendyxxfish]

check out teal singing the wizard and i at some even i forgot what it was called... she was wearing this orange dress. i think it was the oscar party or something ? this guy is totally singing, its hilarious.

[slavetomyworld]

i think idina over powers the other girl... hard core. poor girl just can't keep up

[westsidestory97]

@slavetomyworld

but she has to belt those notes to hit them well... shes an alto. =/

[msm471]

Jennifer Laura Thompson isnt an alto...

and if she was this is the lowest part of Glinda's score. So shouldnt she be at home? I dont know. I'm not a music expert.

[westsidestory97]

no, i meant Idina

[msm471]

Idina isn't an alto.

She's a mezzo-soprano. But i understand where your coming from.

[coolchris12345]

i agree not the same without kristen :/ x

[dixiegirl101]

I agree. Jennifer just doesn't have that high pitch. Idina has a higher pitch than she normally does as Elphie. :)

[bobbie406]

ah i have a shirt like the one idinas wearing i got it for x-mas

love this performance lots

[deniserogue]

yeah it's not the same without Kristin. JLT is too much pop imo. Kristin has this great operatic voice that blends well with Idina's strong vocals.

i love Idina's shirt here. i think it actually says Defy Gravity? :)

[Aleenapoo]

Yeah, it does and Jennifer's says "Popular"! Haha! The songs each character is most known for!

[deniserogue]

thanks. :) i saw that in the Wicked souvenir online shop too. :)

[smartyballer20]

i love how they cut the first part and went straight to idina's verse, it just ain't the same without both kristin and idina and their chemistry

[ashleighho270]

whos the other girl?

[Jigglesw]

Jennifer Laura Thompson Kritin Chenoweths replacement

[elphie4evergreen]

yes, is not the same without Kristin. There is no chemistry among idina and JLT plus, for me, JLT sucks as a performer. So, I want Kristin!!

[Aleenapoo]

I'm with you all the way on that one!

[natalouga]

where's cheno...?? it's not the same without her...!!!!!

[dallywinstonfan101]

I'M SORRY BUT I JUST CAN'T HEAR THIS OR SEE THIS BEING PERFORMED AND FEEL THE SAME WAY IF ONE OF MY FAVORITE GIRLS IS MISSING. I'M SORRY TO ALL THE JLT FANS BUT IT JUST LOSES ITS SACREDNESS. Chenzel for life.

[Kelaiah01]

Its amazing to me, to see Idina paired with a Glinda she can see eye-to-eye with (after all, Kirsten's like 4'11" isn't she?). XD JLT is gorgeous, and her build is almost identical to Idina. I think it'd be fun to see them in a movie together as sisters (there is a resemblance between them), that'd be awesome! :D

JLT is so underrated (but don't worry, Kristen fans, Cheno shall always rock).

[sophia1044]

Chenoweth kicks ass

[openanotherdoor]

Woot woot for the Cheno, yeah!

[NYCJamesChristian]

That was cute.

A Queen[i mean this affectionately] is lipsynching along with Idina at 0:53!!

[bobbie406]

this is good .... love idina :D

[greenboro7240]

i love idina menzel and kristen chenoweth they are amazing i wish this was kristen with idina

[dawaninthecorner56]

@greenboro7240 It is kristen. :)

[iLoveMusic1011]

i like it. but i like kristin and idina more!

[katlin8807]

this song will never get old. I love it so much! And every single Glinda/Elphaba combo ever has done it in their own way that makes it equally amazing! I'm a Chenzel fan till I die but JLT and Idina did an amazing job on this as well!