Beautiful. The transformation of the theme in the tranquillo section is so sweet (as only Prokofiev could pull off) and I love the jolt of those slightly "off" 32th notes at the end of each scale rise (i.e. starting at the end of the 9th bar). I've listened to this 6 times in a row now. Yeah!
Kirisiah it's second "published" work. Think about how many stories and things a writer writes in his life before publishing his second book. Similar with music I think....
@KevinBeethoven i quite agree. this video made me think of this of the final fantasy vii piano collections piece "those who fight/ fight, if you search it there's some good ones out there) (like wise the linked video made me think of this etude. albeit a bit more modern, the sacrasm and emotional tension via harmonic language definately had a similar aftertaste).
This Etude, done by Kempf, is just flowing like a water... I know that de gustibus est not disputandum, but -in my opinion- Freddy Kempf gives extra weight to Prokofiev's genius, emphasizes it. Unforgettable.
this is really hard to play.. left and right hand play the same pattern but not synchronically..(if someone knows some hints for practicing let me know^^)
Prokofiev was a child prodigy, and a true genius. Already in an early opus such as this, hear how he explores new sonorities and experiments with timbres! The performer does a very good job too.
although i like all versions of this piece i've heard so far, i think that kempf's feeling is the best for this piece. it is really extraordinary. i'm actually trying to learn this. ive managed it until 0:30 so far but i hope i can all of it !!!
Is not unreasonably difficult. Half the song is a D minor chord pattern. The pattern is the same for the left hands as well, except its like one step behind.
I've been playing for 2 years, seriously (everyday practice) for about 1. I was able to slop my way through the first minute of this, of course it was a long 2 minutes when I was playing it lol!
I'll probably revisit it in a year or so.
But... as I said, its not so difficult as it sounds, is mostly all repetition.
Antonio Pompa-Baldi attempted this piece at the eleventh Van Cliburn and despite his remarkable Scriabin his Prokofiev is poor poor poor, nothing on this interpretation. Bravo Freddy Kempf.
Frustration is always by my side..And what to do if I'm so foolishly romantic. But the most important things in our life are so banal, emotions caused by art as well.
wonderful performance of a great early prokofiev piece that deserves to be heard more often. but looking at the score, it becomes apparent why so few pianists bother to learn it : in terms of technical challenges, prokofiev throws everything and the kitchen sink at the pianist. i would even say that the toccata, although also quite challenging, is fairly easy compared to this piece.
The two voices introduced from 0:30 and on the calm parts do it for me. It's interesting that the piece is based on a tonic-submediant octave jump ostinato in the left hand, from beginning to almost the entire piece (but on the coda is a mediant-tonic, giving that definitive closing feeling, whereas at the start it leaves, in combination with the dominant, the phrases with that openness and mystery)
Weak composition? This piece is awesome IMO. The lush harmonies create this somber, chilling winter wind atmosphere. It's great. And the performance, IMO, again, is exceptional.
recall after beethoven's first symphony, the music critics called his career would be forgettable and short lived. Idiots with no taste always plague the music world. ignore them.
To be honest... other than that Liszt's compositions are lost to me. Of course there are some small things here and there that I enjoy.
I guess I am not a fan of chromatic music. I suppose other than being the greatest pianist ever, liszt's legacy legacy was to show the world how music would sound without a key sig... Interesting as it can be, it is not my favorite.
when i first heard this, which was right now, i was as if i had fallen into a comma, i was like o_0, 100% surely, my favourite piano piece up until now!!!
When I first heard this, I promptly downloaded and printed the sheet music. I then sat down in front of my piano, tried the first few pages and burst into fits of laughter.
This is very good but I have a performance on LP from Gyorgy Sandor that blows this one clean out of the water, when I manage to get it copied I'm uploading it. It's incredible.
CrKrotina - You've got to be kidding - Prokofiev was a stupendous technician who could play his own gargantuan Second Concerto with ease. He had pianists like Richter and Horowitz
premiere some of his sonatas only because by that time (1940s) he was buried deep in diverse compositional projects. Many of his recordings display a transcendental mechanism equal to any pianist's at the very top echelons. Check out the Rachmaninoff g minor Prelude here on You Tube - it surprised even me.
Well, Argerich and Horowitz, for a start. The point is, while Prokofiev was undoubtedly a very good pianist, he wasn't up at the very top level of ability.
a composer is requested to know an instrument well, such as an orchestra leader, but isn't supposed to be a virtuose, unless he's an interprete like liszt or rachmaninoff were. Shostakovitch once played some of his compositions to prokofieff who was able to find the genius behind the technical errors.
Well,I believe that a composer-one whose compositions specialize for one particular instrument-has to be able to play them.I myself compose piano works influenced by the late romantic period (just as a composition study)but,when asked to make critical decisions about the bass line f.e. I constantly find my self in lack of imagination.And that;s because the known piano works are mostly composed in a technical manner,for technical purposes.Spanning from Beethoven to Shostakovich.
That's the reason I believe some of Liszt's late works(you know to which one's I'm referring to)and the piano works of Eric Satie are extremely radical.(as always,in my opinion) :-)
I disagree with you when you say that Prokofiev could play his 2nd concerto with ease. Here are his own words on the subject: "But I do not manage to stay calm during the most difficult parts: in the cadenza (specifically where I mark colossale) and at the beginning of the third movement, where the hands keep jumping over one another, I play badly."
Sometimes we think that composers are "Gods" but they were human just like us who struggled to learn and perfect their technique.
@Hervinbalfour that may be, composers are not gods.... yet they are prophets for they are able to go farther beyond the limits of music and come back to us with stories and tales of those distant lands
@Hervinbalfour Has a composer ever written a song where he went, "Fuck it. It's too hard, My hands can not reach those 12ths... let's leave this song for someone else to play."
@13loodLust Yes: me, at the very least. And I know that Prokofiev did so - I've played his march from Ljubov k Trjom Apelsinam (The Love for Three Oranges), and the left-hand chord @ the end can actually be physically impossible to play. Maybe not for Rachmaninov, though, but, well, HE had uniquely huge hands.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
It's rather interesting that Prokofiev himself wasn't that much of a technician. Listen to his performance of Toccata in d minor and compare it than to some of the later performances.
Rachmaninoff, as great as he was, was not completely correct with that statement. Sure Prokofiev's strong point was not emotional sensitivity but it is not completely emotionally dry. His music does not have the typical emotions like sadness or happiness but I see it has more of aggression, irritation, nervousness etc...
Wow this looks kinda difficult.
tjtheplay 1 day ago
Beautiful. The transformation of the theme in the tranquillo section is so sweet (as only Prokofiev could pull off) and I love the jolt of those slightly "off" 32th notes at the end of each scale rise (i.e. starting at the end of the 9th bar). I've listened to this 6 times in a row now. Yeah!
MrHippasus 1 month ago
I can't believe how cleanly hes able to play 0:31-0:42. That part has always killed me at higher tempos
SpR4y510 2 months ago
Kirisiah it's second "published" work. Think about how many stories and things a writer writes in his life before publishing his second book. Similar with music I think....
Chakiejan 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
you can find sheet music @ sheetsearch . com
Ir0nman86 4 months ago
wow... this is so brilliant
DavidMumo 6 months ago 3
好棒
twgirl1 6 months ago
I'm studying right now this beautiful etude, is so precious and complicated ahahah
ridehorce 6 months ago
simply fantastic...
jrmagrelis 6 months ago
Especially the last part gives me the shivers. Pure awesomeness.
MrRrrrvvvv 6 months ago
I definitely wanna study that piece of music... Wonderful and wordsless.
NukiCherrys 6 months ago
you can find free piano sheet music @ sheetsearch . com
Ir0nman86 7 months ago
Well, Freddy reigns monarch over this... brings it to life.
BarNuun 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Prokofiev sucks, he killed this one for sure though.
Before everyone starts throwing fits I know his music very well, I own a lot of his work..
This shit is just wicked lol... Repeat...
EuphoricDan 8 months ago
@EuphoricDan If Prokofiev "sucks" as you say, why would you own a lot of his work?
Purplecatsoup30 6 months ago 3
@EuphoricDan You must were drunk when you wrote this nosense... Go & get a life, you museless snob!
DeliusAlkan 4 months ago
@DeliusAlkan
Sorry to offend. In the future I will be sure to only express your opinions and only in a way pleasing to you.
EuphoricDan 4 months ago
Comment removed
1862Debussy 4 months ago
Was this really his...second composition? O.o
Kirasiah 9 months ago
@Kirasiah His second published composition. There's a difference.
xtfcr7 7 months ago
sounds like something out of a video game
KevinBeethoven 9 months ago
@KevinBeethoven i quite agree. this video made me think of this of the final fantasy vii piano collections piece "those who fight/ fight, if you search it there's some good ones out there) (like wise the linked video made me think of this etude. albeit a bit more modern, the sacrasm and emotional tension via harmonic language definately had a similar aftertaste).
cem1891 9 months ago
@KevinBeethoven Frogger
InsertName125 7 months ago
kempf is a genius
ttslipknotrulez132 10 months ago 3
this should be named the "heaven etude"
ttslipknotrulez132 10 months ago 3
i thank you god for letting prokofiev be born
ttslipknotrulez132 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I'm speechless. This is music from heaven!!
stamoum 11 months ago
I'm speechless. This is music from heaven!!
stamoum 11 months ago 2
awesome......
Chakiejan 11 months ago
Rather tonal compared to his other works..
masked1one 11 months ago
@masked1one It is rather tonal...but this was still when he was young. His dissonants are still much more restrained than his later works.
frankentomato 2 months ago
Damn.
claytonlisa 1 year ago
This Etude, done by Kempf, is just flowing like a water... I know that de gustibus est not disputandum, but -in my opinion- Freddy Kempf gives extra weight to Prokofiev's genius, emphasizes it. Unforgettable.
athoverlord 1 year ago
i really really like this tune. very nice +1 for proko
LackingLack0 1 year ago
HOW THE $#^$@ CAN YOU PLAY THIS?
penguinpoop4 1 year ago 3
this is really hard to play.. left and right hand play the same pattern but not synchronically..(if someone knows some hints for practicing let me know^^)
Saphir8 1 year ago 4
dissonance is fun!
DJNotNais 1 year ago
@DJNotNais - Definitely! Listen to Villa-Lobos' 'Rudepoema' if you'd like a REALLY "fun" time......
SordidGuy 1 year ago
beautiful!
Where can I get this sheet music from?
Please tell me!
natetitus52 1 year ago
@natetitus52 imslp.org/wiki/
Omnichronicles 1 year ago
1:18 - billy strayhorn's" take the a train" was stolen from this! anyone else hear it!
ShadKiklas 1 year ago 2
LOVE. thats it.
flyaway951 1 year ago
great
belialah 1 year ago
orgasmic
newFranzFerencLiszt 1 year ago 12
It's just awesome!!
violaloveviolin 1 year ago
i want to learn it right now!!
Jamez5cz 1 year ago
Prokofiev was a child prodigy, and a true genius. Already in an early opus such as this, hear how he explores new sonorities and experiments with timbres! The performer does a very good job too.
SeadogDriftwood 1 year ago
This reminds me of being hysterically depressed and then hysterically happy and then back to hysterically depressed and then dead.
TheIrieviolet 1 year ago 4
psychooooo
11Agaja 1 year ago
Really good performance of this very difficult etude!
AntipovSvyatoslav 1 year ago
shit!! this piece is a Monster
PjGalapatz 1 year ago 8
I've never heard this before, but I love it!
4candles 1 year ago
Maestoso
Erikk91 1 year ago
I never paid much attention to Prokofiev until recently. Shame on me.
petezilla 1 year ago
Im just sitting in my room trying to fathom how the hell one is suppose to play this...
jesusff10 1 year ago 4
@jesusff10 If you're a mortal hobby player like me you're not supposed to play this, you're just supposed to admire it :D
Whoever played this, wow!
Altairograph 1 year ago
prokofiev is so hard to play....
sumimimi0 1 year ago
...wow.
Erikk91 1 year ago
Seeing the left hand makes me puck.
MrGladSlayer 1 year ago
Comment removed
GLaDOS22 1 year ago
unbelievable!
grimmbo93 1 year ago
wow if someone ask me the hardest song on the world i will probably tell him Prokofiev
311Bambino 1 year ago
@311Bambino Prokofiev isn't a song.... That's like someone asking you what your favorite fruit is and answering "Tree"
JohnEBPiano 1 year ago 5
@311Bambino Prokofiev isn't a song. He was a composer. :)
Tompelicious 1 year ago
Liszt etudes will be a good second xD
RemovdSande11 1 year ago
Amazing. I am now determined to learn this... even if it kills me
kdawghomie 1 year ago 15
@kdawghomie you'll die in glory
newFranzFerencLiszt 2 weeks ago
My god, Prokofiev amazes me more and more.. Incredible parts.....
131newclear 1 year ago
Prokofiev always manages to sneak in a little slice of warm melodic tune before going off on another direction!
dalecampbl5 1 year ago 3
I love this etude... it makes me feel so well when I hear it...! =)
cafity 1 year ago
damn those russians could play
surrealIdeal 1 year ago 5
These days, it's really easy to compose from your head without actually being able to play it.
jasonextreme 1 year ago 4
I got gooesbumps all over when I first heard this within about the first 15 seconds, such an amazing piece!
bevster1 1 year ago 2
I really recommend the Sarcasms! They are his masterpiece, in my opinion. Nice feeling to play them on the piano.
Sanitoeter666 1 year ago
@bevster1 so do i!!! it's like a natural rush
afertyus1000 1 year ago
This piece just turned me into a Prokofiev fan.
1980NewWave 1 year ago 4
good grief this is even harder than Chopin's famous "thirds" etude
just ridiculously tough
1980NewWave 1 year ago
for some reason, my emotions gets so mixed-up every time i hear this /j
rukashawn 1 year ago
amazing! does anyone know where i can find the music score?
despouv17 1 year ago
@despouv17 You can find the score at your local public library or at IMSLP.
streek23 8 months ago
amazing! does anyone know where i can find the music score?
despouv17 1 year ago
My favourite Etude. Thanks
MrTiago8989 1 year ago
superb!
GSE1916 1 year ago
ahh love this!!!!:)
MilanPtheCharming 1 year ago
Super.)
ShabalinK 1 year ago
Holy schnitzel that's good!
NemoProkofiev551 1 year ago 4
its prokofiev, to me one of the best
markmarshall39 1 year ago
my friend has to learn this!!!
iceskating31 1 year ago
I get the feeling he was under the influence of the Moonlight (3rd mvt.) and Chopin op.25 no.11 when he wrote this.
dsm2240 1 year ago
@dsm2240 no he wasnt :D:D
karazh 1 year ago
this is bad ass! I love the contrasting emotion in this one.
PhrygianBlack 2 years ago 21
Ha more people should post music videos like this. It's too hard for me but I enjoy looking and listening. Thanks!
Zupazwami 2 years ago
Comment removed
DeadstarDreams 2 years ago
hard rock-it s real hard
UranumPlanet 2 years ago 27
although i like all versions of this piece i've heard so far, i think that kempf's feeling is the best for this piece. it is really extraordinary. i'm actually trying to learn this. ive managed it until 0:30 so far but i hope i can all of it !!!
fuckslipknot21 2 years ago
I prefer Pompa Baldi on this one, but the recordings on YouTube of his performance have horrible sound quality. :(
MrStrav81 2 years ago
what fingering do you put on the staccato passage at the beginning ?
hailkayy 2 years ago
seeing the score alongside the recording pretty much made me crap myself... so ridiculously hard
professorhex1 2 years ago 7
Is not unreasonably difficult. Half the song is a D minor chord pattern. The pattern is the same for the left hands as well, except its like one step behind.
I've been playing for 2 years, seriously (everyday practice) for about 1. I was able to slop my way through the first minute of this, of course it was a long 2 minutes when I was playing it lol!
I'll probably revisit it in a year or so.
But... as I said, its not so difficult as it sounds, is mostly all repetition.
EuphoricDan 2 years ago
@EuphoricDan Try to play it at the tempo of BALDI or SANDOR, with the staccato passage clean at the beginning i give u 3 years ^^
hailkayy 2 years ago
increible...
Nahui0llin 2 years ago 2
amo este estudio <3
julywapo 2 years ago
Antonio Pompa-Baldi attempted this piece at the eleventh Van Cliburn and despite his remarkable Scriabin his Prokofiev is poor poor poor, nothing on this interpretation. Bravo Freddy Kempf.
breakbeatmalaria 2 years ago 2
I liked pompa baldi interpretation, he tossed it off as if it were nothing, powerfully !
hailkayy 2 years ago
That is very true, but listen to the contrast between Kempf's tranquillo and Pompa-Baldi's, and how distinctly he articulates the 32nd note runs
breakbeatmalaria 2 years ago
Don't know anything about music nor gods or techniques, I don't know anything and I even don't want to know anything when I'm listening to Prokofiev.
He's....oh, words can only do harm when trying to define him.
I feel.
pyskute 2 years ago 82
This has been flagged as spam show
Don't "feel." THINK.
LesMusiqueEtDanse 2 years ago
Romanticizing what need not be romanticized is frustrating.
Exanimousx 2 years ago
Frustration is always by my side..And what to do if I'm so foolishly romantic. But the most important things in our life are so banal, emotions caused by art as well.
pyskute 2 years ago
@pyskute pretentious twat
rafeman111 1 year ago
@pyskute pretentious twat, but i agree
rafeman111 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This song makes me feel lost.
pookiehohn 2 years ago
This is absolutely stunning. Prokofiev is my favourite composer and this is one of the best of his great masterpieces.
X3RX3SCZ 2 years ago
this is beautiful
ilikeknives133 2 years ago 2
wonderful performance of a great early prokofiev piece that deserves to be heard more often. but looking at the score, it becomes apparent why so few pianists bother to learn it : in terms of technical challenges, prokofiev throws everything and the kitchen sink at the pianist. i would even say that the toccata, although also quite challenging, is fairly easy compared to this piece.
Belamus 2 years ago
The two voices introduced from 0:30 and on the calm parts do it for me. It's interesting that the piece is based on a tonic-submediant octave jump ostinato in the left hand, from beginning to almost the entire piece (but on the coda is a mediant-tonic, giving that definitive closing feeling, whereas at the start it leaves, in combination with the dominant, the phrases with that openness and mystery)
mordent17 2 years ago
Comment removed
hailkayy 2 years ago
prokofiev is so unique!!! and this song is one of the best. I love this composer he has created a complete unique and new harmonic world.
my favorites are:: toccata, march, dance of the knights, peter and the wolf,and all sonatas and etudes for piano.
BetterOffDead1337 2 years ago 4
Such fury! Beautiful!
ASirensSoliloquy 2 years ago 5
Weak composition? This piece is awesome IMO. The lush harmonies create this somber, chilling winter wind atmosphere. It's great. And the performance, IMO, again, is exceptional.
mordent17 2 years ago 8
recall after beethoven's first symphony, the music critics called his career would be forgettable and short lived. Idiots with no taste always plague the music world. ignore them.
charleshoskinson 2 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
Weak composition, ok performance.
allegrissimo 2 years ago
have you lost your mind?
BNM321zxy 2 years ago
You have to... but once you get it, it´s remarcably beautiful
GangrenaD 2 years ago
Comment removed
Hervinbalfour 2 years ago
the technique looks so difficult in this,
lizarthopinsky 2 years ago 2
Wow--this is incredible--eerie and powerful--interesting and wonderful to listen to from start to finish. What a masterpiece to me.
124bjw 2 years ago 2
Jaw-dropping virtuosity!
paopaomanalansan 2 years ago 2
Yes that is wonderful!
Nadarification 2 years ago
Absolutely scintillating.
TimK999 2 years ago
what a beautiful piece of art
Thank you also for partituras
best regards
huteca70 2 years ago
You just made me be a fan of another classical music composer!
So far on list:
Ferenc Liszt (Franz Liszt)
Sergei Prokofiev
Sergei Rachmaninov
Modest Petrovich Mussorgsky
And mostly any other Romantic Period composer.
Starbirdy9999 2 years ago 2
Also on the list:
Claude Debussy
Felix Mendelssohn
Mostly Ferenc Liszt (Franz Liszt) and Sergei Rachmaninov are favorites.
Starbirdy9999 2 years ago 3
I like liszt's unfinished 4th mephisto waltz.
To be honest... other than that Liszt's compositions are lost to me. Of course there are some small things here and there that I enjoy.
I guess I am not a fan of chromatic music. I suppose other than being the greatest pianist ever, liszt's legacy legacy was to show the world how music would sound without a key sig... Interesting as it can be, it is not my favorite.
EuphoricDan 2 years ago 5
I really agree with you. Liszt is one my favorite music composers, though also like Sergei Rachmaninov's compositions as some of my most favorites.
Starbirdy9999 2 years ago
He missed a note.
Invalidpoint 2 years ago 3
and *you* missed the point entirely.
supermanifold 2 years ago
when i first heard this, which was right now, i was as if i had fallen into a comma, i was like o_0, 100% surely, my favourite piano piece up until now!!!
fuckslipknot21 2 years ago 2
When I first heard this, I promptly downloaded and printed the sheet music. I then sat down in front of my piano, tried the first few pages and burst into fits of laughter.
Does anyone have finger extensions for sale?
ostrorawr 2 years ago 6
wtf... well, i liked it mate, good luck to you
fuckslipknot21 2 years ago
what are finger extensions?
paganiniGOGO 2 years ago
They are extensions. For fingers.
ostrorawr 2 years ago 7
How do they work and what do they do?
paganiniGOGO 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
hmm, where did you download it from (sheet), did you buy it or was it free, plzz tell me the webpage, i cannot find it anywhere for free...
fuckslipknot21 2 years ago
They're up on the International Music Score Library Project (IMSLP).
ostrorawr 2 years ago 2
thanks very much, i found them!
and why did you burst into laughters when you saw them??
fuckslipknot21 2 years ago
some parts are ridiculously hard to play (for me anyways)...
ostrorawr 2 years ago
IMSLP users hi-five (via internet)!
Ltlevim 2 years ago 4
IMSLP is a lot of win!
faraz1729 2 years ago 3
Well, then high-five.
Starbirdy9999 2 years ago
Search the composer on Wikipedia. At the bottom of the page it'll say Free Scores. Just follow those links.
S2HVU 2 years ago
I found it using Utorrent
rubik56 2 years ago
WOOOOOOOOW Amaziiing! :D
DreDre349 2 years ago
oh yes O_O
Visualizzated 2 years ago
amazing interpretation by kempf...I love his playing
universalmind3000 2 years ago 5
This man is genius....
vladrik1 2 years ago 5
This is very good but I have a performance on LP from Gyorgy Sandor that blows this one clean out of the water, when I manage to get it copied I'm uploading it. It's incredible.
deviantrake 2 years ago
Agreed.
Gyorgy Sandor is my favorite for Prokofiev.
ReturnOfTheStienway 2 years ago
Oops. This is regards to Isbrother
neversroad 2 years ago
CrKrotina - You've got to be kidding - Prokofiev was a stupendous technician who could play his own gargantuan Second Concerto with ease. He had pianists like Richter and Horowitz
premiere some of his sonatas only because by that time (1940s) he was buried deep in diverse compositional projects. Many of his recordings display a transcendental mechanism equal to any pianist's at the very top echelons. Check out the Rachmaninoff g minor Prelude here on You Tube - it surprised even me.
MISHA1119 2 years ago 7
He wasn't THAT good. He admitted that he couldn't manage parts of his Toccatta, for example.
ultrallama101 2 years ago 2
who can? Even Argerich stated that it was the most difficult piece in the repertoire.
mpaton2006 2 years ago 2
Well, Argerich and Horowitz, for a start. The point is, while Prokofiev was undoubtedly a very good pianist, he wasn't up at the very top level of ability.
ultrallama101 2 years ago 2
a composer is requested to know an instrument well, such as an orchestra leader, but isn't supposed to be a virtuose, unless he's an interprete like liszt or rachmaninoff were. Shostakovitch once played some of his compositions to prokofieff who was able to find the genius behind the technical errors.
martimtavares 2 years ago 3
Right. But I'm not claiming a composer does have to be a virtuoso.
ultrallama101 2 years ago
Well,I believe that a composer-one whose compositions specialize for one particular instrument-has to be able to play them.I myself compose piano works influenced by the late romantic period (just as a composition study)but,when asked to make critical decisions about the bass line f.e. I constantly find my self in lack of imagination.And that;s because the known piano works are mostly composed in a technical manner,for technical purposes.Spanning from Beethoven to Shostakovich.
HelveteKeiser 2 years ago
That's the reason I believe some of Liszt's late works(you know to which one's I'm referring to)and the piano works of Eric Satie are extremely radical.(as always,in my opinion) :-)
HelveteKeiser 2 years ago
I disagree with you when you say that Prokofiev could play his 2nd concerto with ease. Here are his own words on the subject: "But I do not manage to stay calm during the most difficult parts: in the cadenza (specifically where I mark colossale) and at the beginning of the third movement, where the hands keep jumping over one another, I play badly."
Sometimes we think that composers are "Gods" but they were human just like us who struggled to learn and perfect their technique.
Hervinbalfour 2 years ago 65
@Hervinbalfour that may be, composers are not gods.... yet they are prophets for they are able to go farther beyond the limits of music and come back to us with stories and tales of those distant lands
lorenzotrojan 1 year ago 3
@Hervinbalfour BRAVO! You're right!
EdiEllerymissing 1 year ago
@Hervinbalfour
You've got to understand though that his idea of playing badly might be unnoticeable to anybody else. Still I suppose he did not consider it easy.
Few would.
intervalkid 1 year ago
@Hervinbalfour Has a composer ever written a song where he went, "Fuck it. It's too hard, My hands can not reach those 12ths... let's leave this song for someone else to play."
13loodLust 1 year ago
@13loodLust Yes: me, at the very least. And I know that Prokofiev did so - I've played his march from Ljubov k Trjom Apelsinam (The Love for Three Oranges), and the left-hand chord @ the end can actually be physically impossible to play. Maybe not for Rachmaninov, though, but, well, HE had uniquely huge hands.
SeadogDriftwood 1 year ago
@Hervinbalfour Prokofiev IS, WAS, and WILL BE a GOD... although not necessarily in performance arts :)
LordN3mrod 1 year ago
This is crazy! I love in the middle of the sixteenth runs the dotted 16th followed by 32nd, it throws you right off! so unexpected haha :D
npelletier89 2 years ago 5
Pure genius, the emotions burst like champagne bubbles, lol.
MillionDollarVirg 2 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It's rather interesting that Prokofiev himself wasn't that much of a technician. Listen to his performance of Toccata in d minor and compare it than to some of the later performances.
CrkotinaOutOfNowhere 2 years ago
Rachmaninov was right to say Prok's music comes rather from the brain than of the heart...
jasonextreme 2 years ago
Rachmaninoff, as great as he was, was not completely correct with that statement. Sure Prokofiev's strong point was not emotional sensitivity but it is not completely emotionally dry. His music does not have the typical emotions like sadness or happiness but I see it has more of aggression, irritation, nervousness etc...
morvensky 2 years ago 4