You know, what I think I like about Eddie the most is his optimistic view of life. I've seen most of his films and, while his character is usually down on his luck, he knows things can only can get better. I know he has songwriters and dancers to help him. Don't we all - at least via YouTube ;-)
@JaGlRo But it's a movie, not reality. It was made to make unhappy people in the Great Depression happy. Pure escapism, in other words, like whatever Pixar movie happens to be out right now.
I found the movie in DVD but seen it on cable years ago and fell in love with it. I really hope that there are more people my age that can appreciate these actors and movies.
They do not make movies like this anymore. Songs in movies were meant to get the audience to lift their spirits during hard times. Who does that these days?
@thesagebrushkid I found out about Cantor from my parents, who saw his movies during the Depression. Seems to be good enough for this depression as well.
You got that right. Alot of movies during the 1900's Depression had music to uplift their spirits. The most famous was "Who's Afraid of the Big Bad Wolf" Not many people know that today and think it's just a cute little tune.
@stlgtrace I looked, and by golly, you're right! I knew Ball was a Goldwyn Girl, but I did not know where she was in this movie. Thank you for pointing it out.
Actually EC's films, which are not widely shown now because he did a lot of black face, were cutting edge in how integrated they were. Just look at a number like 'Keep Young and Beautiful' to see a early integrated dance number which portrays African American women as sex objects. Or look at "Strike Me Pink" where Ethel Merman's big number (with EC mooning over her) includes black men dancing opened chested. It's fabulous! It's gay! It was unheard of at the time.
wow ..my house went into foreclosure..after that I eventually got evicted. Now I'm staying in a friends garage! I saw this movie years ago, boy...I never thought I'd identify with this song....sad.
Yes I agree, your country is going down the drain, WHY!! Thank Mr G W Bush, he has gone already, part of history. Now MR Obama has to pick up the pieces. Good Luck to him.
@spudwas Your luck will change, it did after the 1930's. The country will get though this, you will get though this. We just need people like Eddie cantor to keep us smiling.
Ruth Etting who was in this movie made a rcord of this song. There is a DJ named Rich Conaty who plays old records from the 20's and 30's and which emenates from Hofstra U on Long Island. It is on Sunday night at 8 on the lower 80's FM.
You're right about the Warner Bros musicals. Look up Joan Blondell or Busby Berkley and see the video Remember My Fogotten Man. By the same token do You think people living in tenements wanted to see movies showing musicals about that, they were more interested in the music and the dancing.
I cannot believe it - Was doing some late hour navigation before going to sleep when Eddie Cantor came to my mind - checked Roman Scandals in imdb and noticed he sang this song. It's one of my earlies memories of my childhood (I was born in 1935) and after more than 6 decades later I hear this song again!!
I have to comment on this again. This scene is simply one of the greatest moments in american entertainment history. It has everything! It's not only a truly great tune performed by one of the best entertainers that ever lived. It has also very much heart, humour and timing.
This movie was made at the height of the depression. People went to the movies to escape from their everyday problems. Thats why those Warner Bros and RKO musicals were so popular.
Actually, Warner Bros. musicals differed from those made by other studios in that many of them not only acknowledged the Depression, but made it a major factor in the plot. That was typical of the Warners' house style -- even their musicals were injected with a dose of social realism. Watching one of those elegant Fred Astaire-Ginger Rogers musicals made during the same period by RKO, you'd think everyone in the 1930s was independently wealthy and always fabulously dressed!
This is my all time favorite Eddie Cantor clip on YouTube. I just love this song and the way Eddie performs it. I watch this clip several times a week and it always makes me smile...especially when the cops join in the dancing. I only wish that I had been the one to post this clip!
Yeah on a careful look it is the same girl. I still think the movie is quite funny. How about when he goes back to anchient Rome, and the soldiers are going to kill him, and he says, "That wouldn't only be murder, it would be birth control?" Or the "one without the parsley is the one without the poison" bit that precluded Danny Kaye's vessel with the pessel bit in The Court Jester? Gotta love the sexy "nude" costumes on the Goldwyn Girls and the racy Ruth Etting slave girl number.
Are you sure she's the same one? the "Goldwyn Girls" were supposed to look very similar. One of them is Lucille Ball. Another is Paulette Goddard. This film (Roman Scandals) is absolutely hilarious ~ check eBay for a VHS copy.
If it isn't the same girl, they hired her twin. The fem in question has fairly unique features, with a prominent, elongated nose. I enjoy the feature but the film is far from funny. A relative witnessed the screenplay when it debuted, and was shocked by the partial nudity -- with one girl shown topless. Arguably, the best part of the presentation is Cantor's performance of "Keep Young and Beautiful!" with the line "You'll drive him half insane, in a bathing suit of Cellophane!" ~ Oh that Eddie.
Note: The girl who's taking a shower is also the one sitting at the sewing machine (nice touch, of the orchestra to add the extra violins for that sewing shot), and is also the woman at the table just to Cantor's right when he sits at the head of that table. QUESTION: Does any one know how they caused the vacuum cleaner to consume the sheet off the shapely jiggle-bottomed 1930's lass?
Y'know, I thought perhaps the sheet was being yanked into the ground (stage?) by an attached cord in an attempt to lend the illusion that the vacuum gobbled it up. However, I can see the sheet actually does go into the vacuum cleaner. The mystery continues.
Thank you! This had been on YouTube previously. But that one began with him using the vacuum; this one starts from the very beginning of the number. My wife and I adore this clip. We would love to see "Roman Scandals" in its entirety!
I am replying to my own comment to report that a year after I wrote this, we have seen "Roman Scandals" in its entirety because ... we bought the VHS tape!
Lucille Ball is the tall blonde at 4:16 to Cantor's left and can be seen dancing at the end of the number.
BusbyRocks1 4 months ago
iz he ERIC CANTOR in a Tea Party jamboree VOTE YOU EDDIE n ERIC¡¡
bluexxg 5 months ago
I just llurvvvvvvvvvvvvveeeeeeeeeeeeeeee this song. I love eddie
mygreatlovenova 6 months ago
I just love this song. I love eddie
mygreatlovenova 6 months ago
One of the most charming songs EVER!
rulabean 8 months ago
This song is one of my favorites! It's nothing but...NICE!! They sure don't write songs like they used too!
GMYellowstone 10 months ago
You know, what I think I like about Eddie the most is his optimistic view of life. I've seen most of his films and, while his character is usually down on his luck, he knows things can only can get better. I know he has songwriters and dancers to help him. Don't we all - at least via YouTube ;-)
percyfurler 1 year ago
Yeah, my apartment went into foreclosure,i identify.
colinwells4 1 year ago
This song reminds me of when I was kid. We watched Roman Sandles! Funny movie!
yorugua97 1 year ago
Sad that this great artist is largely forgotten today.
hemming57 1 year ago 4
@hemming57 Aint that the truth!
jdsmyhero85 1 year ago
Why don't we have this kind of spirit now!
JaGlRo 1 year ago 2
@JaGlRo But it's a movie, not reality. It was made to make unhappy people in the Great Depression happy. Pure escapism, in other words, like whatever Pixar movie happens to be out right now.
fishhead06 1 year ago
@fishhead06 Problem is, Pixar doesn't have the same affect...at all.
jdsmyhero85 1 year ago
I found the movie in DVD but seen it on cable years ago and fell in love with it. I really hope that there are more people my age that can appreciate these actors and movies.
They do not make movies like this anymore. Songs in movies were meant to get the audience to lift their spirits during hard times. Who does that these days?
thesagebrushkid 2 years ago 3
@thesagebrushkid I found out about Cantor from my parents, who saw his movies during the Depression. Seems to be good enough for this depression as well.
mbabist01 2 years ago
You got that right. Alot of movies during the 1900's Depression had music to uplift their spirits. The most famous was "Who's Afraid of the Big Bad Wolf" Not many people know that today and think it's just a cute little tune.
thesagebrushkid 2 years ago
Notice the girl in the saddle shoes towards the end, that's Lucille Ball.
stlgtrace 2 years ago
@stlgtrace I looked, and by golly, you're right! I knew Ball was a Goldwyn Girl, but I did not know where she was in this movie. Thank you for pointing it out.
mbabist01 2 years ago
Its funny and sweet to think of the great lady that Lucy would be as a young girl in saddle shoes.
newrochellephoenix 1 year ago
Yes, this was a great number and my favorite Eddie Cantor movie. The basic idea for the story was proposed by Cantor himself.
jwlheart 2 years ago
Wow, everyone in the 1930s was caucasian!
fishhead06 2 years ago
Actually EC's films, which are not widely shown now because he did a lot of black face, were cutting edge in how integrated they were. Just look at a number like 'Keep Young and Beautiful' to see a early integrated dance number which portrays African American women as sex objects. Or look at "Strike Me Pink" where Ethel Merman's big number (with EC mooning over her) includes black men dancing opened chested. It's fabulous! It's gay! It was unheard of at the time.
hawaiitude 2 years ago 2
I LOVE THIS SONG!!!!! In fact I just love the entire movie!!! SO amazing!!!!!
jdsmyhero85 2 years ago 3
I love this film so much. They sure don't make films like this anymore
mygreatlovenova 2 years ago 3
Thaknyou for sharing, I love this song.
mygreatlovenova 2 years ago 3
I love when the police-man starts dancing with them! That's SO cute!
jdsmyhero85 3 years ago 3
Isn't it though? They tried to enforce the law, but everyone was having so much fun--why not? LOL!
MissMinnieMousegirl 2 years ago
thanks...I'm hopeful.
spudwas 3 years ago
wow ..my house went into foreclosure..after that I eventually got evicted. Now I'm staying in a friends garage! I saw this movie years ago, boy...I never thought I'd identify with this song....sad.
spudwas 3 years ago
i'm sorry to hear that! our country's going down the drain these days.... hope your luck changes...
voglesque89 3 years ago
Yes I agree, your country is going down the drain, WHY!! Thank Mr G W Bush, he has gone already, part of history. Now MR Obama has to pick up the pieces. Good Luck to him.
gardenalien 2 years ago
@spudwas Your luck will change, it did after the 1930's. The country will get though this, you will get though this. We just need people like Eddie cantor to keep us smiling.
1992Ignorance 2 months ago
This is fantastic! *****
Have added this one to my favourites.
Thank you for posting.
Corrie121 3 years ago 5
A great movie with a great star, the one and only......Edward Arnold. Who is the Cantor guy anyway? ;>)
Joe Christopher
joechristopher2 3 years ago
Really! That's awesome! Must be a cool kid.
voglesque89 3 years ago
I love Eddie so much I named my son after him.
azusa1977 3 years ago 5
Celloid Magic....
Hawkzblade 3 years ago
I suppose all but the youngest children are dead by now. I find that sort of thing freaky.
fishhead06 3 years ago
Ruth Etting who was in this movie made a rcord of this song. There is a DJ named Rich Conaty who plays old records from the 20's and 30's and which emenates from Hofstra U on Long Island. It is on Sunday night at 8 on the lower 80's FM.
Georgewos 3 years ago
I am glad there are people still out there keeping the oldies alive. And at Hofstra no less. Thats my home town growing up.
thesagebrushkid 3 years ago 3
You're right about the Warner Bros musicals. Look up Joan Blondell or Busby Berkley and see the video Remember My Fogotten Man. By the same token do You think people living in tenements wanted to see movies showing musicals about that, they were more interested in the music and the dancing.
Georgewos 3 years ago
Monkey!
QLudwig 3 years ago 2
I cannot believe it - Was doing some late hour navigation before going to sleep when Eddie Cantor came to my mind - checked Roman Scandals in imdb and noticed he sang this song. It's one of my earlies memories of my childhood (I was born in 1935) and after more than 6 decades later I hear this song again!!
voltape 4 years ago 3
OMG! Gloria Stuart in this clip is the old lady in the film 'Titanic'. She's fabulous in Shirley Temple films. Love the old films and stars
serapidus 4 years ago
This was directed by the genius Busby Berkeley.
cineaste2 4 years ago
I have to comment on this again. This scene is simply one of the greatest moments in american entertainment history. It has everything! It's not only a truly great tune performed by one of the best entertainers that ever lived. It has also very much heart, humour and timing.
stjn00 4 years ago 2
This movie was made at the height of the depression. People went to the movies to escape from their everyday problems. Thats why those Warner Bros and RKO musicals were so popular.
Georgewos 4 years ago
Actually, Warner Bros. musicals differed from those made by other studios in that many of them not only acknowledged the Depression, but made it a major factor in the plot. That was typical of the Warners' house style -- even their musicals were injected with a dose of social realism. Watching one of those elegant Fred Astaire-Ginger Rogers musicals made during the same period by RKO, you'd think everyone in the 1930s was independently wealthy and always fabulously dressed!
scotpens 3 years ago 3
wow! Thank you for that insightful comment- I totally see what you mean!
voglesque89 3 years ago
Great clip, but it's the usual New Deal collectivist propaganda, very anti-capitalist.
But I love Eddie!
ND2525 4 years ago
Another reason to like it.
fishhead06 4 years ago 3
This is Eddie Cantor at his best and, by the way, this would make a great theme song for Habitat for Humanity!
Kind67 4 years ago
This is so good it almost makes you cry. Dear Hollywood, please do some more movies like this!
stjn00 4 years ago 2
This picture has some fairly racy pre-Production Code stuff, including the famous naked-slave-girls-in-chains scene. Pretty kinky for 1933!
scotpens 4 years ago
This is my all time favorite Eddie Cantor clip on YouTube. I just love this song and the way Eddie performs it. I watch this clip several times a week and it always makes me smile...especially when the cops join in the dancing. I only wish that I had been the one to post this clip!
arieseire 4 years ago 2
It's a doughnut. Wonderful clip. It cheers me up every time I watch it. Thanks for posting this.
chem100 4 years ago
Yeah on a careful look it is the same girl. I still think the movie is quite funny. How about when he goes back to anchient Rome, and the soldiers are going to kill him, and he says, "That wouldn't only be murder, it would be birth control?" Or the "one without the parsley is the one without the poison" bit that precluded Danny Kaye's vessel with the pessel bit in The Court Jester? Gotta love the sexy "nude" costumes on the Goldwyn Girls and the racy Ruth Etting slave girl number.
BelovedRogue 4 years ago
>I still think the movie is funny.
Which part? The only laugh was the Emperor getting yanked off his chariot with a bullwhip.
>Or, "one without the parsley is the one without >the poison" bit that precluded Danny Kaye's vessel >with the pessel bit...
I never saw that Kaye piece. (I know you meant "predate" and not "Preclude.")
neatoauctions 4 years ago
Are you sure she's the same one? the "Goldwyn Girls" were supposed to look very similar. One of them is Lucille Ball. Another is Paulette Goddard. This film (Roman Scandals) is absolutely hilarious ~ check eBay for a VHS copy.
BelovedRogue 4 years ago
If it isn't the same girl, they hired her twin. The fem in question has fairly unique features, with a prominent, elongated nose. I enjoy the feature but the film is far from funny. A relative witnessed the screenplay when it debuted, and was shocked by the partial nudity -- with one girl shown topless. Arguably, the best part of the presentation is Cantor's performance of "Keep Young and Beautiful!" with the line "You'll drive him half insane, in a bathing suit of Cellophane!" ~ Oh that Eddie.
neatoauctions 4 years ago
Note: The girl who's taking a shower is also the one sitting at the sewing machine (nice touch, of the orchestra to add the extra violins for that sewing shot), and is also the woman at the table just to Cantor's right when he sits at the head of that table. QUESTION: Does any one know how they caused the vacuum cleaner to consume the sheet off the shapely jiggle-bottomed 1930's lass?
neatoauctions 4 years ago
Y'know, I thought perhaps the sheet was being yanked into the ground (stage?) by an attached cord in an attempt to lend the illusion that the vacuum gobbled it up. However, I can see the sheet actually does go into the vacuum cleaner. The mystery continues.
neatoauctions 4 years ago
well, if they could make King Kong the same year...
voltape 4 years ago
Great, never seen this before, but I loved the bagel bit as well!
ascliff 4 years ago
Yeah, I'm pretty sure it's a doughnut.
thewackingtons 4 years ago
(nobody cares)
voglesque89 4 years ago
I love it where he throws a bagel in the basket!
fishhead06 4 years ago
Yes! Great job getting this number up!
bigsexyshaq 4 years ago
Thank you! This had been on YouTube previously. But that one began with him using the vacuum; this one starts from the very beginning of the number. My wife and I adore this clip. We would love to see "Roman Scandals" in its entirety!
solarvegan 4 years ago
I am replying to my own comment to report that a year after I wrote this, we have seen "Roman Scandals" in its entirety because ... we bought the VHS tape!
solarvegan 2 years ago