The version that I'm being taught is different from this. The ONLY similarity between this video form and the form I'm learning is the directional movements.
I've studied since 1988, and taught since 1993 and this is how 3 different schools that I've taught at do this form. My guess is that there is some variation based on each school/instructor/association.
The form performed as it should be actually looks beautifull.. I do not think the performer in this video tried to do it as it should be done, but rather make every motion as big as possible so it would be easier to see what she is doing so people could learn it.
There is some variation in the poomse from school to school. We learn an out-to-in block at the beginning and end like this video does, but unlike the videa, we also do out-to-in blocks when moving forward in backstance. It all depends on where you learn. It's not a Korean translation issue.
Variation is one thing but to change a technique from one to another is not a variation.. It is a new poomsae. If you think of the poomsae as simple block, punch, kick combos it does not really matter.. But what if the maker of the poomsae wanted to teach someting more? That maybe a block is not just a block? Surely changing a motion to the oppusite is a BIG DEAL..
I do not know them my self but I asked my proffessor (I study in TKD in Korea) a 9th dan what they used to do and he confirmed this. The video is clearly wrong. One reason for this can be that they actually learned the form from a book (possibly korean so they could not read the instructions only see the pictures?) and on pictures the inward middle section block is the same ending position as the outward middle section block
Yes I think it is important to know the roots of our system. These are the poomsae that was origionally taught to all students before the taegeuk were made.
Thanks to the person who posted this:-) If I learn these poomsae I will put them up here on youtube to or perhaps DeEnlightener would like to contribute? I think the performance is too robotic.. Probably becouse she is showing each technique.
This is Palgwe, advanced form of Taeguk which is why it's different
hiddeninthemist 9 months ago
The version that I'm being taught is different from this. The ONLY similarity between this video form and the form I'm learning is the directional movements.
LordDeimos775 4 years ago
The version that I'm learning is more of a attacking form.
LordDeimos775 4 years ago
this was exactly the same form i learned when i was yellow belt. this one just looked more fancy. lol
mhymullaney 3 years ago
whats different with kukiwon?
darrel1551 4 years ago
I've studied since 1988, and taught since 1993 and this is how 3 different schools that I've taught at do this form. My guess is that there is some variation based on each school/instructor/association.
reallybadmagicguy 4 years ago
The form performed as it should be actually looks beautifull.. I do not think the performer in this video tried to do it as it should be done, but rather make every motion as big as possible so it would be easier to see what she is doing so people could learn it.
oni043 4 years ago
There is some variation in the poomse from school to school. We learn an out-to-in block at the beginning and end like this video does, but unlike the videa, we also do out-to-in blocks when moving forward in backstance. It all depends on where you learn. It's not a Korean translation issue.
jlfst77 4 years ago
Variation is one thing but to change a technique from one to another is not a variation.. It is a new poomsae. If you think of the poomsae as simple block, punch, kick combos it does not really matter.. But what if the maker of the poomsae wanted to teach someting more? That maybe a block is not just a block? Surely changing a motion to the oppusite is a BIG DEAL..
oni043 4 years ago
I do not know them my self but I asked my proffessor (I study in TKD in Korea) a 9th dan what they used to do and he confirmed this. The video is clearly wrong. One reason for this can be that they actually learned the form from a book (possibly korean so they could not read the instructions only see the pictures?) and on pictures the inward middle section block is the same ending position as the outward middle section block
oni043 4 years ago
Yeah I think you are right.
But thanks for the person who has posted this.
DeEnlightener 4 years ago
Yes I think it is important to know the roots of our system. These are the poomsae that was origionally taught to all students before the taegeuk were made.
Thanks to the person who posted this:-) If I learn these poomsae I will put them up here on youtube to or perhaps DeEnlightener would like to contribute? I think the performance is too robotic.. Probably becouse she is showing each technique.
oni043 4 years ago