Is Derrick Rose or Deron Williams The Best Point Guard In The NBA?

[mrmark262]

The most exciting point guard is Derrick Rose...not to say that he is the best!! Rondo is the best when it comes to assists. Derrick Rose will never win a title with that current lineup in Chicago...he is fun to watch and the rest of that team outside of Rose is above average. Chicago really needs to consider getting another talent for the team such as Dwight Howard. I would trade Boozer, Deng, Korver, and some draft picks for Dwight!! Miami is too good for Chicago right now!!

[miami4championship]

1 Rose

2 Rondo

3 CP3

[Thenewzboyof2000]

Derrick rose !!!

[TheAnime401]

Chris paul

[tech2kn0w]

jeremy lin

[wnec12]

thanks Coach, are you planing to do an updated list for this season? I would like to know if you think people improved on those weaknesses or not

[spongybon]

RAON RONDO!!!!!!!!! i didnt forget the J, theres no J in rondo

[uypogy]

JEREMY LIN! do a breakdown!

[osmanosman15]

yo coach dick let me shove my huge 12 inch steak in your nice little asshole huh babe?????

[stygianmessiah]

LINSANITY lol

[juancp95]

you guys are stupis rondo has improved alot with his shooting ability he is becoming better

[DaBigCheeseThang]

lebron travelled

[ronham12]

i think the only battle for #1 in the point guard position is CP3 and Derrick Rose but if i had to choose one it would be derrick rose

[MrThewangster23]

Alright I'd love to see rajon,d will or cp3 drop 3 straight 30 plus point games.including 34 against Miami DROSE SWAG

[blacktee31]

@MrThewangster23 True pg's aren't scorers they're passers and 3pt shooters, that's a pg's job not to score 30+ in 3 straight games. That is if we're judging by who plays the position the best and not who's the best player who happens to play at that position.

[iAmTacoNinja23]

1. Derrick Rose

2.CP3

3. Deron Williams

4. westbrook/nash/ rondo

derricks defense has improved a lot the last two years, and is up there with cp3. cp3 is a better pure pg but rose has the edge in scoring

[ChillyCloth]

Deron Williams is he best, better passer than Drose, and a better leader. As a PG you have to have that leadership, with Derrick Rose, its just not there yet..

[pnevarez37]

@ChillyCloth really? last year while both and boozer missed a combined 60games? yeah...

[simonson084]

Cp3 is the best

[phliper220]

Rose

Rondo

Nash

Cp3

Westbrook

Dwill



[jujubeejeff123]

Pure PG D.Williams... Nash is too old now

[OlegIvanovik]

It's hard to currently put Derrick Rose ahead of Deron Williams and Cp3 due to his lack of defense, less assists, steals & 3%. His strength is his athleticism and speed for getting to the rim and scoring in the inside. Cp3 has not been the same since his injury yet still plays as an elite pg. Roses success is largely due to Thibodeau's defensive system. The Bulls are one if not the best defensive team in the league with a deep bench. Being on a better team does not make you a better player.

[StreetDoggydog1995]

How is anyone better than D-Rose, if one he is the reigning MVP, making him the best player in the league (shut up Lebron fans) and he plays the best against the best point guards, no one leads a team better than D-Rose, Deron Williams is on one of the worst teams of the league, Rajon sucks, steve nash used to be amazing, but is now old, D-Rose is 7-0 against Chris Paul so don't start that shit on me and Stephen Curry can't play defense for his life, plus D-Rose is Mr. clutch these days

[desher1000]

1. Chris Paul

2. Derrick Rose

3. Deron Williams

4. Steve Nash

Because these guy's are put on ssucky teams, but they make them GREAT that is something most players can't do.

[CARLOSGURO]

The best passers Nash and Rubio, but perhaps Chris Paul the best now, Derric Rose is not a pure pg perhaps is a forward

[CutthroatFamilia]

Shit im the best pointguard

[mylesusa]

steve nash > russell westbrook

[AnthTrinh]

rondo



[HardWorkPays0ff]

1cp3 2 d rose 3 d will 4 Steve Nash 5 rajon rondo

[aznbeast124]

Top 5:

1.Derrick Rose

2.Chris Paul

3.Rajon Rondo

4.Deron Williams

5.Russel Westbrook

[AndrehNowaski]

Deron for the win

[105ziggy]

ROSE!

[TheOnlyBraveDiesel]

@105ziggy YES YES YES<3

fuck deron williams

[CJsUserName]

I'm the best PG in the league. I took my team to 3 back to back championships. Got Rookie of the Year, Defensive PLayer and MVP in one year. I average 31pts and 11 asts per game. Paul, Williams nor Rose can guard me & I play on Hall Of Fame mode. XD

[MCthebassman]

1.rose he was the MVP

2. Williams better scorer and passer than paul but not as good at scoring compared to rose

3.Paul great point but not on the level as d will or rose

[picklejarzz]

1. Williams

hes not flashy which makes him so consistent and hes a good scorer

2. Rose

Rose is a really good scorer and he can get assists because hes such an offensive threat

3. Paul

paul his teammates play better and he can find the open man which makes his team good in close situations. hes got a good mid range jumper as well. he has no meniscus in his left knee so i dont think he could be as good as rose or williams because he doesnt have that explosiveness

[iN31L]

1. Paul

2. Rose

3. Williams

4. Nash

5. Westbrook

[tmillz331]

so much for having kim kardashian in his life...

[bears4154]

Its Rose, and its Rose by a pretty decent margin. Then Dwill/Paul are pretty close, but then as are Rondo/Westbrook, who both have very different and very incomplete games. The other three are more polished, and Derrick is probably the least of the 3, but look at the records. Wheres Cp3s 60 wins? Plus, he's got so much more potential. If he continues, hes a sure fire HOF.

[jeglande2]

Play of Williams is more sure and nice dribbling....! But today Rose progress...

1. Williams

2.Rose ( He's progressing )

......

[PhilTheCreator]

1. Chris Paul

2. Deron Williams

3. Rajon Rondo

4. Derrick Rose

5. Russell Westbrook

[GuffleNoobToob]

Nash

[dmvprose1]

Rose(Rookie year takes his team to the playoffs and is now the MVP)

Paul (More assists than Rose but cant score as good)

D-will( Crossover as good as Rose and can score better than Paul)

Rondo(Most assists, can shoot as good as the Top 3 but has the best team)

Nash ( Dishes out a lot of assists and can score but is getting old)

[Isaoda10]

Damn even No-D Curry is better than rondo?

[pelcorner]

1.d will

2. d rose

3.westbrook

4.rondo

5.chris paul

[DDPxBANG]

1 D will

2 Chris Paul

3 Derrick Rose

4 Rondo

5 Nash

after watching the 2011 playoffs I just can't put Westbrook in the top 5

[thatguy123444]

definatley Deron Williams

[jmann707]

give time for john wall to get better and he should also be mentioned.

[Tehkillerbunneeh]

7:38 Damn look at that footwork!

[manonthemoon781]

First Vid I've Seen Of Yours. Gotta New Subscriber.

[laviek2]

@manonthemoon781

so just for you to know, its not a channel its a conversation

haha i love his vids!

[Sean456ism]

paul d will rondo on defence

wesbrook and rose on offence

nash and d will in my opinion are the best pg's seeiing the fllor

[grossfanyeahmate]

Coach Nick, what do you think is going to happen to Nash this season, will he be traded or stay in Phoenix, there are rumors that Nash is going either to LA lakers or Miami.

[dantheman9758]

Just got done watching the breakdown, yet another excellent one! - Your breakdowns add a new understanding to the game both as an NBA as a fan, and as a player of the game in my city rec leagues. I never played in schools, so I never had the opportunity to listen to a coach. On the playground I depended on athleticism but in my stacked 5 on 5 leagues I've made frequent unintelligent plays bc of my lack of insight. Just watching these videos seems to help my court awareness! - Big Thanks!

[dantheman9758]

Off topic but I just noticed in your intro @ 00:07 "Tonight: Basketball, Lakers/Kicks. Tomorrow: Boxing, Lane/Satterfield"

Battlin' Bob Satterfield! The dude from the movie Resurrecting the Champ! (well the real one at least) haha

[MrFrEaK4NBA]

Coach, I'm in 7th grade.I play on the A team as starting point. I should always every play try to break down the defense by picking it apart right? Like attacking and kicking

[AnthonyShin1029123]

Derrick Rose #1

Deron Willims #2

CP3 #3

R.Rondo #4

S.Nash #5

[rjybanez311]

1. paul

2. williams

3. rose

4. rondo

5. brooke

legend. iverson

[hisword21]

i know this breakdown was a long time ago, but i had to vote. i truly believe that deron williams is the best point guard in the league cuuz statwise he is the only point guard to average 20 and 10, and thats with a midseason trade too. he is just such a smart bball player, not as exciting but he knows how to play the game. hes smart and unselfish, what i look for in a pg

rose would be my second just cuz hes super athletic,

i love rondos passion for the game, but i think he should shoot more

[MrFrEaK4NBA]

#1 Chris Paul 2# Derrick Rose 3# Deron Williams #4 Rajon Rondo #5 Westbrook

[ianets15]

1. Deron Williams

2. Chris Paul

3. Steve Nash

4. Derrick Rose

5. Stephen Curry

Rondo is so overrated he is so offensively challenged he has no jumper and horrible free throw shooter. only good for defense and passing

[GiacShabadoo]

@ianets15 i'm not a rondo fan but these statements make me wanna throw up

[whiteboyballa23]

@ianets15 point guards arnt made for scoring. it definitly helps but passing is the most important

[VpY22]

@ianets15 although i agree that Rondo is overrated, i disagree about your point about passiing. sometimes to be a great point guard you just need to be a great passer and hit the open shots when its available. Rondo would be a top 5 point guard but his performance is tainted because of who he plays with. if you he can put up the same numbers while NOT having a ray allen, kg or pierce on his team, then he would def be top five.

[cavaliers4ever]

@ianets15 dont you think that thats what POINT GUARD is supposed to do???

[8MunchenBayern8]

@ianets15 Derron William and Steve Nash better than Derrick Rose? go die in a fire

[mylesusa]

@ianets15 offensively challenged? have you ever seen him drive...?

[desher1000]

@mylesusa Rondo is a good offender but her isn't consistent in his scoring so i think janets15 was right

[ChillyCloth]

@ianets15

His jump shot is getting better, but Rondo is actually underrated offensively, he makes the Celtics so much better on offense it's not just the stats and the assists, he just plays so hard and pushes defense more than anyone else on his team. He's literally leading 3 Hall of Famers way older than him. The fact that you put Steve Nash and Stephen Curry on that Top 5 list clearly shows you just plain dislike Rondo, and is not viewing this from an unbiased perspective.

[whiteboyballa23]

@ianets15 you are ridiculously dumb...

[BallaholicNo10in89]

@ianets15 lmao rose at 4 and curry at 5, gtfo

[jwinarta]

CP3, Derrick Rose, Deron Williams, Steve Nash, Rajon Rondo

top 5 pg in the league, not in any particular order...

anyone with Westbrook in their top 5 only watches highlights

[kiwipikito]

idk why this conversation still gets brought up... today in 2011 the best point  guard in the league is Deron Williams hands down: size,speed,great finisher and an amazing passes DWill all Day!!!

[StreetDoggydog1995]

@kiwipikito true, except D-Rose and CP3 do all of that better than him and D-Rose is 7-0 against CP3, making D-Rose the best in the league

[kiwipikito]

@StreetDoggydog1995 how? 1.deron and paul are both great passers with great vision but deron is like 4 inches taller and way stronger than paul....so deron>paul

.2. derrick rose is about the same size and strength wise and faster than williams but doesn't have the passsing ability wiliams has and for a PG that is the most important thing so williams>rose ...and dont forget williams plays with a bunch of scrubs unlike paul and rose who play one stacked team with other all stars around them

[StreetDoggydog1995]

@kiwipikito actually D-Rose scores more and has more assists per game, more rebounds and more blocks per game than Deron making him the better point guard, plus he is still getting better, while Williams has plateaued recently

[ChillyCloth]

@StreetDoggydog1995

Williams is old as fuk, are you kidding me

[ChillyCloth]

@StreetDoggydog1995

The Bulls are 4-1 without Derrick Rose, CP3's Hornets aren't that great, and his arrival in Los Angeles is still a work in progress, the better individual Point Guard is CP3, but in a couple of years Drose will be the ebst because CP3 is aging.

[SiNsCere1100]

if you put westbrook in your top 5 point guards in the league , you should start watching more basketball.....

[nonameghost]

first Dwill

[aaron4life333]

1.D-wills

2.Rajon rondo

3.cp3

4.d-rose

5.westbrook

THATS HOW IT IS IN THIS VIDEO!

[JokerFreak73]

WHY?! Why would you make me listen to that song for FIFTEEN MINUTES!?

[WemSum]

1. Williams

2.Rose

3.Paul

[getrealhood]

DERON WILLIAMS !!! And thats final

[GeorgiaBoy50DEV]

1.Rose

2.Williams

3.Paul

4.Rondo

5. Westbrook

[FaithInDefiance]

1. Rose

2. Nash

3. Paul

4. Williams

5. Rando

[FogtsZz]

1. CP3

2.RRondo, D-Rose

3.D-Will

4.Nash, Kidd

5.Westbrook

[motherfucker1ization]

Jason Kidd, JJ. Barea, Chauncey Billups, Jrue Holiday, John Wall, D.J. Augustin, Andre Miller, Tyreke Evans, Stephen Curry, Brandon Jennings, Raymond Felton, Tony Parker!!! where the hell did they go??

[SwaggKiddJay]

@motherfucker1ization jj barea -____- and i don't know shit about basketball you are a fucking stupid stupid ass nigga

[motherfucker1ization]

@SwaggKiddJay who the fuck asks questions like tht? stupid prick

[PhilTheCreator]

@motherfucker1ization Felton, Miller, Augustin and Holiday definalty shouldn't be in the list of top point guards smh

[motherfucker1ization]

1) Derrick Rose

2) Rajon Rondo

3)Jason Kidd

4)Russel Westbrook

5) Steve Nash

[CBug905]

why would they put russell westbrook but don't even mention Nash im mean he's better then westbrook

[ReversedSkateboards]

Rajon Rondo,Derrick Rose, and Chris Paul p.s i'm using my brothers account

[victorvang89]

Rondo shouldnt even be in the top 5, i think any PG would get as many assists as him if they were passing to KG, Ray Allen, and Pierce...plus Rondo cant do anything else but pass

[waseem9001]

RONDO IS

[kyle08ish]

Deron williams is the best at being a point guard, it's not the prettiest game to watch, but it's the most effective game that will get the job done and help your team.

[patriatich]

Can someone please tell me whose the guy shooting the 3 @ 5:41

[Anthony22Morrow]

@patriatich Marco Belinelli

[BasketballBenJay]

Best PG's

1.Chris Paul

2.Deron Williams

3.Rajon Rondo

4.Derrick Rose

5.Russel Westbrook

[RaphialLee]

@BasketballBenJay i would say Chris paul and Rondo

[RaphialLee]

1. Chris Paul

2. Rajon Rondo

3.or 4. Steve Nash & Derron Williams

5. Derick Rose

[Convisis]

Nash, Rondo, CP3 are the best playmaking PGs; Nash, Curry, DWill, CP3 are the best shooting PGs; DRose, Tyreke Evans, Tony Parker are the best 1-on-1 off the dribble PGs; Westbrook is the most out-of-control PG.

[Eli0Matic]

stephen Curry ????

[Convisis]

@Eli0Matic great young all-round PG, would be the best 'shooting PG' along with Nash.

[xXILOVEGIRLSXx123]

Derrick Rose is the best point guard in the League and I'm a Boston Celtics Fan.

[drewgilchrist]

THe best guard lbs for lbs is D Will. it's not about flair and excitement.. it's about getting the job done.

[jmann707]

in a couple more years john wall would be number 1. rightnow he's about 6th on the list.

[OMGITZANIME]

Are you gonna have anymore of these?

[EmmanStation01]

rajon rondo assists are good but darrick rose is butter darrick rose is the bast pg

[mrmark262]

Derrick Rose brings to the nba the excitement that Michael Jordan and Magic brought...his dunks are without question the most exciting in the nba to watch and his speed cannot be matched by anybody. The bulls are one scorer short of an nba finals entrance and if they get a man like Dwight Howard watch out Miami!

[305Southbeach]

You should do this with every poistion.

Thumps up...

[bdarthvaderb]

erm Coach, i don't really think Westbrook gets into the hoop and finishes strong BETTER than Rose. If you notice most of Rose driving into the lane highlights, i think he finish the BEST in the NBA. just my thoughts.

[bballbreakdown]

@bdarthvaderb OK - it's pretty darn close, both of them are incredible finishers...

[iemserious]

@bdarthvaderb lBJ is the best finisher in the league and i hate him -_-

[Zebeldarebel]

I don't like D-rose as a point guard, he is not fundamentally sound in the PG role as D-Will or CP3.

[ulisessanti]

1. D Will & CP3

3. D Rose

4. S Nash

5. R Westbrook & R Rondo

[bballbreakdown]

@ulisessanti Thanks for the vote! Make sure to check out our more recent posts - we just did a Mini-Doc on Reggie Jackson - the OKC Thunder's first round pick!

Coach Nick

[pampillone]

nash is the best one

great ball handler

great finisher at the rim great three point shooter

great midrange shooter

best passer

best freethrow shooter

always plays for the team

is there anyone else who does all these things?

[rockfan96channel]

nash doesnt get consideration on this vid?

[roxursox35]

1.CP3

2.D Rose

3.Nash

4.Rondo

5.D Will

[playcube006]

deron williams# 1 drose isnt really a pg more of a sg so its dwill #1 cp3#2

[playcube006]

those numbers are of  rondo avgs 11 and rpse avgs 7

[celticpride859]

1.Rondo

2.Rose

3.D-Will

4.Nash

5.CP3

[mrxpapa1]

1)CP3

2)D-Will

3)D-Rose

4)Rondo

5)Westbrook

[chiladin]

1) Rose(He's the friggin MVP at only 22)

2.) Deron(Can score at will and play SG and still give you 10 dimes)

3.) CP3(Highest IQ out of all the PG's but his size won't allow him to dominate against Rose or Deron in head-to-head matchups).

4.) Westbrook(Athletic freak but only average basketball IQ and mentally he's a head case).

5) Rondo( Great passer, defender and a champion but he couldn't perform like the other in their systems but all of the the other PG's would dominate in Boston).

[Kamille1125]

CP3 is the Definition of a "REAL PG" but there's no doubt that D-rose is also a good pg..

[mishomcgrady]

he said it ... Deron Williams has the complete game ... 8:36

totally agree .

[grossfanyeahmate]

1. D.Rose

2. S.Nash

3. D.Williams

4. CP3

5. R.Westbrook

[boynextdoor1214]

i cant believe you people actually think rose is the best pg

[Redkid90]

1)D.Rose

2)CP3

3)D-Wills

4)Rondo'

5)J.WAll



[13SuperKings]

@Redkid90 John Wall need to prove himself first

[Kuanito1]

1.D.Rose

2.CP3

3.D-Will

4.R.Rondo

5.JJ.Barea

[mungojerry311]

Rose beyond any doubt in my mind.

[zIPerfect]

DERRICK ROSE NO CONTEST

[5519822018]

D-will = best PG in the league

[Antonio12Goncalves]

1. Derrick Rose

2. Rajon Rondo

3. Deron Williams

4. Chris Paul

5. Steve Nash

[buttafrumdastuy]

@Antonio12Goncalves exactly

[SwaggKiddJay]

1)CP3

2)D-Will

3)Nash

4)Rose

5)Rondo

And that's Final

[ballaboy9100]

@SwaggKiddJay not even D. Rose number 1

[motherfucker1ization]

@SwaggKiddJay u dont knw shit abt basketball ho

[SwaggKiddJay]

@motherfucker1ization and would you care to explain well you can't cause your arguments are gonna come from d-rose and how he is MVP and shit but he is not even a complete PG more like a 2 guard don't come at me with this shit cause my list is accurate nash is a legend who is still good so he really should be at the top.

[XxMusicBoyRookiexX]

@SwaggKiddJay i agree with your list

[TheGshockReviews]

RONDO!!!!!!! THEN ROSE!!!!!!!!!

[TheAssistMachine]

John Wall is coming up in a couple of season...

[MRNBAGEORGE]

1)Rondo

2)Rose

3)Nash

4)Paul

5)westbrook

[PhilTheCreator]

@MRNBAGEORGE you are dumb as fuck where is deron williams??

[thekiddontplay11]

D ROSE BEST EVER EVEN BETTER THAN MAGIC ONLY Y MAGIC WAS GO BECAUSE HE WAS 6'8

[joshuacoolkid96]

derrick rose problems can be fix with time as well as westbrook 

[Fbundles]

my top 5

1)cp3

2)deron williams

3)rondo

4)nash

5) drose

p.s Rose did not deserve mvp lebron did

[Fbundles]

CP3 IS THE BEST PG

[305Southbeach]

Coach did you say at 6:50 19% or 90?

[TheBrison123]

19 shots



[TheBrison123]

of the pgs shots wow i shot like 25 and we always win responde back coach

[305Southbeach]

What about John Wall?

[thizizheat4ever]

1. Rose

2. Nash

3. Rondo

4. Williams

5. Paul

[Johnissogreat]

Rajon Rondo

[mkirylka]

This guy said deron williams is not the fastest on the court = ??????

HE is one of the fastest point guards in the NBA

[synergysportstech]

@mkirylka Deron Williams is not anywhere close to the speed of Rose or Westbrook. It's just fact.

[JaeQuinn]

@mkirylka D-Will really isnt that fast, just deceptively quick, doesnt measure up with speed of rose, westbrook, cp3, hell even tp

[mkirylka]

1) d rose mvp

2)D Williams

3)cp3

4)Rondo

5)nash and westbrook

[tommybrown187]

all of em been in the league longer than d.rose and aint none of did what he already has, and none of them are as talented as he is. nuff said

[JaeQuinn]

@tommybrown187, he is a beast , he got his mvp, but the discussion is about the best POINT GUARD, he doesnt have the smarts of say d-will or cp3( who to me are still the best pgs hands down), doesnt run and offense well, and takes a myriad of bad shots, less than accurate passes at times, and no defensive presence at ALL, he is exciting tho



[carlwinslow12]

@Jojoguy121 oh dont worry, you're excused. you need to calm the fuck down buddy, and look at the stats. being a point guard isn't about scoring, it's about making your team better and getting them to score. which is exactly what rondo does. in terms of scoring, then yeah rose is better than rondo, but if you're talking about being a point guard, you gotta be kidding me if you say rose is better. don't flame me man. it's just my opinion.