Pink Floyd - 20) The Doctor (Working Title For Comfortably Numb)

[PinkFloydFan95]

how did you get this last july ? it was only released on monday

[BlazefireBootlegs]

@PinkFloydFan95 These demos weren't released on immersion. these have been floating around for years. The demos immersion has are ones recorded when Roger had no idea what the wall was going to be.

[PinkFloydFan95]

i think this may have been slightly better than the other comfortably numb :) i love it but i think i love this more :) more about the lyrics in this one and less about the guitar solo sent down from god himself and put into Mr David Gilmour's hands !

[DeltaOracle257]

...so.....dark.

[Mymloch]

Creepy



[TheTrubouklad4ik]

awesome, such a beautiful version of the 30 years of hiding...

[RICKROLLBLENDER]

MIND FUCK!!!!!!

[EDOM666DEVORE]

i like this one the same but its different except the first verse its not as describing how hes numb and the vocals are messed i see how this one was not on the album instead but it could of been since they play another brick in the wall like 3 different ways

[Paisley194]

:D Listen, im a physician, and i can handle your condition like a magician.. Failure.

[PSXGAMER22]

@Paisley194 ya you can see why they dumped those lyrics lol

[deansusky]

Nothing can touch the solo on this amazing song ,,FLOYD is life and food for yr brain

[deansusky]

Takes guts to do a floyd cover ,,the greatest band ever

[AngelMTZ8A]

3:27 the second solo is better !!!

[ThePinkfloyd1969]

i love the first verse its fucking epic

[Timmeh938]

amazing version!!! though I think the oiriginal is batter because the last solo is one of the f****ing best in all of rock history

[MALZZZZification]

Thanks man

[SporeFan01234]

They really perfected it with the final version, This version is still great though.

[ReSistaNceCitizenX]

At 3:01 ---> " Put away the shotgun/Yeah have another blue one/Have your finger tips gone numb?/ Amazing

[kokkinoskoufitsa3]

horrible lyrics :D. This goes to show that artists don't radomnly crap out masterpieces. They work them and rework them again and again.

[ReSistaNceCitizenX]

@kokkinoskoufitsa3 As a recording engineer and an artist myself, I totally agree with you. It can take a veryyyyy long time sometimes to compose a song/album that you and or your band consider perfect.

The lyrics aren't better then the current ones, but the Instrumentation is FLAWLESS.

[PoliticsAddict]

@kokkinoskoufitsa3 well I wouldn't say horrible. Definitely not the final copy polished versions but these lyrics are the truth, the real deal into pinks misery. don't you get it? the lyrics define the song, not the progression or melody. in the end these lyrics are the mind of pink and the horror..

[kokkinoskoufitsa3]

@PoliticsAddict I agree with you, but, personally, these lyrics throw me out of the mood

[kmfdm10392]

the chorus is pretty much the same, but the verse lyrics are atrocious.

[PoliticsAddict]

@kmfdm10392 atrocious? and you're one to talk..

[vagabondfloydzep]

davids grungier version



[MrBobbyGandalf]

Have your fingertips gone numb?

My head has, that's for fucking sure!!

[Pinkyfl0yd]

I'm really crying now!

Never heard of it, just amazing!

I do not know how to thank you!