Regardless of how you feel about the Handover, the marches played by the police band sucks, compared to days of yore. PLA/patriotic marches sound like shit. I can't help but to laugh at the idea of commanding the General Salute in English, followed by the Chinese national anthem. Would never happen in the Mainland. Only in HK!
Well, I'm not about the HKP, But in the Canadian Forces, When using the M16 Rifles ,We don't do slope arms while marching. Its usually "shoulder arms"
but for the le enfields rifles.. you may use slope arms. if thats what you mean..
Uh... no way. PLA drill=Soviet drills. Unless you're a fan of PLA drills. The HK Police is deeply rooted in the British tradition and style so at least you've got to be realistic and about it. After all they were started by the British.
I don't think you should call people names. After all I didn't call you names. Don't think you can go around and insult people all you want. That makes you less human than you are.
Hong Kong have their own history and tradition... I feel great that Hong Kong use British-styled drill, same as PLA use Soviet drill, taiwan use American drill, what's the problem?
However, it is completely undeniable that, PLA drill have been developed base on Russian drill protocol....
Taiwan is never conquered by the USA. Due to the American-friendly history, they developed their drill style based on American drill.
Hong Kong follow British drill, Macau follow Portuguese drill, Taiwan follow American-style-like drill, Mainland China follow Russian-style-like drill. Learn from adopt different culture with respect, That is the greatest point of Chinese Culture.
Yeah I agree... what's the problem? The British drill is respected and renowned around the world. After all it's one of the oldest and original drills that helped dozens of other countries to either adopt or develop their own styles. From my point of view, the British drill is what a contemporary force should look like.
You're too nationalistic and have too much pride in yourself I'm afraid. And how am I "brainwashed"? No one is brainwashed unless you yourself have been brainwashed to think that other people should be in line with your way of thinking. Be realistic my friend! :) The Hong Kong Police is respected throughout the world and we should be proud of what they are and what they have done and are continuing to do. And please admit that the PLA drill is at least based off the Soviet drill. That's fact :)
British or PLA drill aside, I wish they hadn't call out that "two-three" timing so loud in a public performance like this as if they were still a bunch of recruits learning drill. They are professionals and they should have done without that. I'm also not so sure about those white ceremonial gloves with short sleeve order uniform. Looks odd. Some contingents have gloves some don't as if they have no coordination among the departments.
I think the problem with the two-three louding timing is because they lack a drill-dedicated school that is up to standards of that of the the british army. They need to count in order to maintain accurately their often-rare display of drills this large capacity.
That might be the case, but still not an excuse in my opinion because they are professionals, this is only a 3-part movement as well as the fact that this is such a publicized performance. I'm also under the impression that these aren't just the average street cops but cadets in training, their instructors and people who perform public duties everyday. So it wasn't like they haven't touched the parade ground for ages. You can't just pull cops off the street and do choreography like this.
But I think the problem of their drill is beyond that. You see their drill's togetherness and bluntness which you'd expect from a typical HK government uniformed force, but somehow they lack that gracefulness, sharpness, assertive cadence and rthymatic swing in their march as you'd see in the Foot Guards and the Queen's Colour Sqn RAF Regt. It's also odd the way they wear they chin straps beneath their chins instead of being at the tip of the chin as it's supposed to be.
Hong Kong uniformed forces drill is a combination of old British Army and modern PLA drill movements (flag raising and lowering). They aren't pure British Army drill just like PLA drill isn't pure Soviet drill. To Hong Kong these drill movements are as much a tradition as English co-exist with Chinese as official languages in the city. There are no practical reasons why HK should adopt PLA drill apart from political ass-kissing, which is stupid and unnecessary.
@muaythai1982 It took you an entire year to come back with this? Haha. In any case I never understood why these chicken shit would want to swear online but haven't the guts to type out the swear word properly, like so :FUCK your whole family muaythai you scrotum-rotting cunt-face.
@alvindurochermtl having read your comments and arguements with several users on many military videos ,i am sure that u fucking alvin is just simply a looser that never be admitted into army in reality. you moron, go jerk off with the military marching videos urself on youtube. HAHAHA ,you looser and keyboard-fighter. i am going to block you ,asshole .
@muaythai1982 So you follow all my comments on youtube and what this makes you? A fan or a stalker who's got nothing else better to you. Truth of the matter is you started this entire thread disagreeing with me without being capable of elaborating why you think I was wrong. So if there's a walt or wanna be here, you'd be the likely suspect and not me. Oh am I suppose to feel sad now that you wanna block me? You're a retard.
@muaythai1982 Funny you should say that, consider whatever little culture and traditional architecture your little pathetic country has all owes it to Tang dynasty China, you fucking Jap.
@muaythai1982 Haha...say what you want you dumbfuck. I'm not even from China and I don't give a fuck about China. Glad to see a few words from me had you worked all up you slave, typical Jap mentality. Don't forgot who lost the war you cunt. Why don't you go kill youself like all your cowardice fellow country love to do.
@muaythai1982 Funny you should be using the writing system of the people you dispise so much. What? Are you so ashamed of your own writing system? 支那人 is just a transliteration of the word China and it isn't even derogatory you stupid piece of shit. If you wanna swear, at least learn to know how to swear. By the way do all Japs have small dicks? Cause it looks like it from the Jap porns I've seen. haha
@muaythai1982 Not much of a come back that was, was it? Let me teach you a lesson on insulting people online. If you can't think of something really insulting to say right away, don't come back right away the way you did. Cause it really made you look like more of a retard as you already are. Let me tell you what, I'm gonna give you another day, try think of something insulting to say to me. Cause from what I'm seeing here, you're just lame as a Japanese dick.
@alvindurochermtl you are talking with yourself as if u r try to elaborate ur message. you self-arrogant chinese pig.asshole u fuckin chinese,no doubt there were lost of pigs likes u being killed by us in world war.let me teach u how to be teased like u r in front of me u chink.東亜病夫. a looser is always a looser like u. u yellow monkey chinese pig.HAHA. hey come back with more? u moron, come on,jerk off with ur military video.
@muaythai1982 Your repeated swearing indicates your lack of volcabulary and hence intelligence. The fact that you keeps saying "fuck you" to another man online shows you are probably a closet homosexual who is keen to fuck another man. Then again I'm not surprised as most Japanese men probably have small dicks so you're desparate to get what you can anyway.
ur stupid chinese descent has fucked u up
muaythai1982 7 months ago
I enjoyed this parade. It is a great show.
Hong Kong has managed to maintain and expand its separate identity which the world recognizes and admires for its economic freedoms.
Above all, the People Republic accepts that separate identity.
As an American, like others, I can travel to Hong Kong without a visa!
samlee1694 1 year ago
i just don't like the Chinese song!!
Edwardjsa 1 year ago 2
Regardless of how you feel about the Handover, the marches played by the police band sucks, compared to days of yore. PLA/patriotic marches sound like shit. I can't help but to laugh at the idea of commanding the General Salute in English, followed by the Chinese national anthem. Would never happen in the Mainland. Only in HK!
texancanadiancowboy 1 year ago 2
挺好的,还使用了中国军队喜欢用的曲子。祝愿中华人民共和国香港特别行政区未来更美好。
99b2146 1 year ago
Comment removed
bbf369 1 year ago
Can anyone tell me that why they didn't "slope arm" while marching?
Edwardjsa 2 years ago
I'm not sure if I am correct but. Your not suppose to do "Slope arms" with the M16s.
halflifecamper008 1 year ago
O... what about doing slope arm with Rifle guns, i mean the new one?
Edwardjsa 1 year ago
Well, I'm not about the HKP, But in the Canadian Forces, When using the M16 Rifles ,We don't do slope arms while marching. Its usually "shoulder arms"
but for the le enfields rifles.. you may use slope arms. if thats what you mean..
halflifecamper008 1 year ago
thx, man
Edwardjsa 1 year ago
Uh... no way. PLA drill=Soviet drills. Unless you're a fan of PLA drills. The HK Police is deeply rooted in the British tradition and style so at least you've got to be realistic and about it. After all they were started by the British.
gng11 2 years ago
You brainwashed house negro !
EdT586 2 years ago
I'm not a negro by the way, nice try.
gng11 2 years ago
I suggest you learn what the term "house negro" means ...LoL doesn't mean you are a negro !
EdT586 2 years ago
I don't think you should call people names. After all I didn't call you names. Don't think you can go around and insult people all you want. That makes you less human than you are.
gng11 2 years ago
They should stopping using British drill and start adopting PLA drill !
EdT586 2 years ago
Hong Kong have their own history and tradition... I feel great that Hong Kong use British-styled drill, same as PLA use Soviet drill, taiwan use American drill, what's the problem?
michaelymt 2 years ago 11
The PLA does NOT use Russian drill, the PLA's drill is unique and unlike the Russian or North Koreans, I should know I teach military drill !
Only conquered nations use drill of it conquerors like India, Pakistan, Taiwan, Japan and the Philippines !
EdT586 2 years ago
However, it is completely undeniable that, PLA drill have been developed base on Russian drill protocol....
Taiwan is never conquered by the USA. Due to the American-friendly history, they developed their drill style based on American drill.
Hong Kong follow British drill, Macau follow Portuguese drill, Taiwan follow American-style-like drill, Mainland China follow Russian-style-like drill. Learn from adopt different culture with respect, That is the greatest point of Chinese Culture.
michaelymt 2 years ago 3
Yeah I agree... what's the problem? The British drill is respected and renowned around the world. After all it's one of the oldest and original drills that helped dozens of other countries to either adopt or develop their own styles. From my point of view, the British drill is what a contemporary force should look like.
gng11 2 years ago
@michaelymt
50 years from now, China should be proud and confident enough to make her own honor guard drills.
Phead128 1 year ago
@michaelymt PLA don't use Soviet Drill, they are using Russian and German drill mixed
mklooking 1 year ago
You're too nationalistic and have too much pride in yourself I'm afraid. And how am I "brainwashed"? No one is brainwashed unless you yourself have been brainwashed to think that other people should be in line with your way of thinking. Be realistic my friend! :) The Hong Kong Police is respected throughout the world and we should be proud of what they are and what they have done and are continuing to do. And please admit that the PLA drill is at least based off the Soviet drill. That's fact :)
gng11 2 years ago 2
British or PLA drill aside, I wish they hadn't call out that "two-three" timing so loud in a public performance like this as if they were still a bunch of recruits learning drill. They are professionals and they should have done without that. I'm also not so sure about those white ceremonial gloves with short sleeve order uniform. Looks odd. Some contingents have gloves some don't as if they have no coordination among the departments.
alvindurochermtl 2 years ago
I think the problem with the two-three louding timing is because they lack a drill-dedicated school that is up to standards of that of the the british army. They need to count in order to maintain accurately their often-rare display of drills this large capacity.
gng11 2 years ago
That might be the case, but still not an excuse in my opinion because they are professionals, this is only a 3-part movement as well as the fact that this is such a publicized performance. I'm also under the impression that these aren't just the average street cops but cadets in training, their instructors and people who perform public duties everyday. So it wasn't like they haven't touched the parade ground for ages. You can't just pull cops off the street and do choreography like this.
alvindurochermtl 2 years ago
But I think the problem of their drill is beyond that. You see their drill's togetherness and bluntness which you'd expect from a typical HK government uniformed force, but somehow they lack that gracefulness, sharpness, assertive cadence and rthymatic swing in their march as you'd see in the Foot Guards and the Queen's Colour Sqn RAF Regt. It's also odd the way they wear they chin straps beneath their chins instead of being at the tip of the chin as it's supposed to be.
alvindurochermtl 2 years ago 2
@alvindurochermtl Send some Metropolitan Police to re-drill them. ;)
gng11 5 months ago
Hong Kong uniformed forces drill is a combination of old British Army and modern PLA drill movements (flag raising and lowering). They aren't pure British Army drill just like PLA drill isn't pure Soviet drill. To Hong Kong these drill movements are as much a tradition as English co-exist with Chinese as official languages in the city. There are no practical reasons why HK should adopt PLA drill apart from political ass-kissing, which is stupid and unnecessary.
alvindurochermtl 2 years ago 8
PLA drill? IS there any?
Edwardjsa 2 years ago
@alvindurochermtl Stop bull-shitting
muaythai1982 1 year ago 2
@muaythai1982 Accusing someone of bullshitting without elaborating why, now that's real bullshitting.
alvindurochermtl 1 year ago
@alvindurochermtl so do you
muaythai1982 1 year ago
@muaythai1982 Is this supposed to be a come-back? This only shows you know shit about drill.
alvindurochermtl 1 year ago
@alvindurochermtl you only know about shit drill
muaythai1982 1 year ago
@alvindurochermtl F o U o C o K your mum
muaythai1982 8 months ago
@muaythai1982 It took you an entire year to come back with this? Haha. In any case I never understood why these chicken shit would want to swear online but haven't the guts to type out the swear word properly, like so :FUCK your whole family muaythai you scrotum-rotting cunt-face.
alvindurochermtl 8 months ago
@alvindurochermtl :FUCK your whole family alvin you scrotum-rotting cunt-face.
muaythai1982 8 months ago
@muaythai1982 Looks like you've just learned how to copy and paste. Good for you, you little retard.
alvindurochermtl 7 months ago
@alvindurochermtl you little new zealander,fuck yourself,you stupid moron
muaythai1982 7 months ago
@muaythai1982 funny you should call me little, consider you are nothng more than a little fucking jap yourself.
alvindurochermtl 7 months ago
@alvindurochermtl having read your comments and arguements with several users on many military videos ,i am sure that u fucking alvin is just simply a looser that never be admitted into army in reality. you moron, go jerk off with the military marching videos urself on youtube. HAHAHA ,you looser and keyboard-fighter. i am going to block you ,asshole .
muaythai1982 7 months ago
@muaythai1982 So you follow all my comments on youtube and what this makes you? A fan or a stalker who's got nothing else better to you. Truth of the matter is you started this entire thread disagreeing with me without being capable of elaborating why you think I was wrong. So if there's a walt or wanna be here, you'd be the likely suspect and not me. Oh am I suppose to feel sad now that you wanna block me? You're a retard.
alvindurochermtl 7 months ago
@alvindurochermtl YOU F-U~C-KING CHINESE PIG
muaythai1982 7 months ago
@muaythai1982 Funny you should say that, consider whatever little culture and traditional architecture your little pathetic country has all owes it to Tang dynasty China, you fucking Jap.
alvindurochermtl 7 months ago
@alvindurochermtl Look at your fucking country is doing,what a shit ,what a shame. Fuck you Ching. Sick man of East Asia. that's all.支那人
muaythai1982 7 months ago
@alvindurochermtl Look at what your country is doing,you stupid chinaman, Ching people.always a chinese pig 支那人
muaythai1982 7 months ago
@muaythai1982 Haha...say what you want you dumbfuck. I'm not even from China and I don't give a fuck about China. Glad to see a few words from me had you worked all up you slave, typical Jap mentality. Don't forgot who lost the war you cunt. Why don't you go kill youself like all your cowardice fellow country love to do.
alvindurochermtl 7 months ago
@alvindurochermtl You Moron,hahaha. You stupid asshole dickhead. go fuck yourself with your military video.
muaythai1982 7 months ago
@muaythai1982 Funny you should be using the writing system of the people you dispise so much. What? Are you so ashamed of your own writing system? 支那人 is just a transliteration of the word China and it isn't even derogatory you stupid piece of shit. If you wanna swear, at least learn to know how to swear. By the way do all Japs have small dicks? Cause it looks like it from the Jap porns I've seen. haha
alvindurochermtl 7 months ago
@alvindurochermtl i should call u a little asshole 東亜病夫 with small dickhead
muaythai1982 7 months ago
@muaythai1982 Not much of a come back that was, was it? Let me teach you a lesson on insulting people online. If you can't think of something really insulting to say right away, don't come back right away the way you did. Cause it really made you look like more of a retard as you already are. Let me tell you what, I'm gonna give you another day, try think of something insulting to say to me. Cause from what I'm seeing here, you're just lame as a Japanese dick.
alvindurochermtl 7 months ago
@alvindurochermtl you are talking with yourself as if u r try to elaborate ur message. you self-arrogant chinese pig.asshole u fuckin chinese,no doubt there were lost of pigs likes u being killed by us in world war.let me teach u how to be teased like u r in front of me u chink.東亜病夫. a looser is always a looser like u. u yellow monkey chinese pig.HAHA. hey come back with more? u moron, come on,jerk off with ur military video.
muaythai1982 7 months ago
@muaythai1982 Your repeated swearing indicates your lack of volcabulary and hence intelligence. The fact that you keeps saying "fuck you" to another man online shows you are probably a closet homosexual who is keen to fuck another man. Then again I'm not surprised as most Japanese men probably have small dicks so you're desparate to get what you can anyway.
alvindurochermtl 7 months ago
@muaythai1982 you are just afraid of our great power of the great China.
1988medstudent 6 months ago
@muaythai1982 You Chinese Pig
muaythai1982 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@muaythai1982Is this supposed to be a come-back? This only shows you know shit about drill.
alvindurochermtl 1 year ago