I do think Beyonces performance was better, but that is because Beyonce is a dancer, the other girl I don't think was a dancer, so it just didn't look as cool. Plus Beyonce is more famous, with a bigger budget, so her's is going to look better.
you think she would just do the performance and say nothing? no. beyonce said she was inspired by the performance lorella did and met with people who worked on it. she also said how she never worked so hard in her life on it. and now you guys are bitching about her copying. huh i guess you wouldnt like it if you worked on something so hard and all of a sudden people would be bitching about it would ya? (if you dont believe me, check Wikipedia "run the world" and look at the controversy section
@ToinyBoyZz Every performer, artist, musician has been inspired by others!! Steve Jobs has said about Apple and his brilliance and creativity that, "We have always been shameless about stealing great ideas" - so shut up about dance moves and special effects. ALWAYS they are inspired by others, the performer, artist, dancer, etc. then builds on that inspiration to make it their own.
@ihatewestlifesince99 Most idea are never original - always, ALWAYS ideas are taken from something before. Always. It's even true with language, civilization itself, technology religion, philosophy, and always art, music and dance.
@MarcelineMissouri uuhmm they had the same production company, which specialises in these performances.. that's the reason for the similarities, but still it's not exactly the same.. but how much choice does one have with such things.. plus the Lorella's beat at the beginning sounds strangely familiar.. (hollaback girl)
YIKES!!!!!!!!! I hear a lot about Beyonce ripping off people but its hilariously obvious when you put them side by side. Regardless of whether or not she credited the artist & used the original creative team. What they should have done was took the IDEA alone & used that to come up with something as original as possible. The wings, drumsticks & legion of dancers are almost totally in sync with each other. Makes me wonder which idea she is going to borrow down to the millisecond for the Grammys.
seriously guys do you think Lorella is the original artist who use this concept? NO!. Lorella herself COPIED from Kagemu a Japanese artist&so on. we don't know who the original maker of this concept we just know that this concept is likely well known by great big artist because of its uniqueness.and not to mention that this era is likely dominated by digital technology. so pls get your fact right first. did u also know that the man who do Beyonce's visualization is the same with Lorella's?
@anthony8336 But did it have to be almost down to the millisecond is the question. Ideas are reused all the time. The difference is that you need to put your twist on it. Kagemu's was totally different (same concept) from Lorella's so why Beyonce couldn't have done what she did & made it her own is what is at issue. & had she truly used the same creative team as Lorella then they should have completely gotten the previous work out of their heads & built on the original idea for her performance.
Bastards everything is new except 2 things for 5 secs in total....!!!!! Fuck you haters..!!!! I'll visit this video everyday to dislike it now..!!!!!! __l_
@chocolateboyojas True. But people are a little anal about it because she's copied one other time. But that was after this whole thing. Besides, even if it is different, she should still consider getting a little more creative with her works.
OMG Beyonce has really stolen everything!!!!! The melody is from Major Lazer "Pon the floor", her performance is obviosly also stolen and not to forget her dance which she has from the tofo tofo dancers here on youtube... wtf -.-
This Lorella Cuccarini lady only mad because Beyonce entirely destroyed her performance and made it look revolutionary! She didn't even make good use of the background screen. I mean, what was she even doing...just marching in place...ooooo wooow (sarcastically)
@gimmelemons11 JEEZ!!!! Stan much? The fact remains that Beyonce would not have had a performance to "destroy" had someone not showed her Lorella's performance. You & your god Beyonce must have very different tastes because she felt inspired enough to hire Lorella's creative team to rip off the performance for the BIllboard awards. FACT!
I like to think that she did not copy, and that there was some understanding between the two artists. I am a huge Beyonce fan and don't like to think she'd be flippant enough to 'blatantly' copy someone in this age of technology.
OK FIRST OF ALL.... beyonce said she was getting insparations for the dances and perfomances of 4 from different places of the world so if yall dont know nothin then keep your big mouths shut.
Srsly? these are completely different, and as a matter of fact, lorella Cuccarini Copyed a japanese Guy called Kegumu or somet like that, so Beyonce had her own thing in this, so yeah go find somthing else to hate her on with your lonely lives. with nothing better to do.
Es logico este prieta decida copiar a lorena n solo por la calidad que tiene la creacion artistica del video de Lorella Cuccarini sino por que Beyonce sabe de la gran masa inculta musicalmente hablando que sufre la gente de USA y no tienen la inteligencia de ver hasia Europa donde en verdad hay calidad ademas cuando este chimpace empeso a cantar Lorella Cuccarini ya tenia mas de una decada siendo exitosa en toda Europa
@seriesdetv Listen why don't you go back to whatever eurotrash or south american third world country you came from. Get a proper education before you continue to make RACIST and ignorant comments. Only ignorant trash would feel the need to make a counter argument by using racist comments about another individual. By the way what fucking language are you even speaking because last time I checked "chimpanzee" is not spelled "chimpace" either in Spanish, Italian, or French. Uncultured trash!
@seriesdetv I'm not even Black. No matter. What matters is that people like you need to learn a good lesson in humanity...or at least in how to make a proper rebuttal without the use of racism and ignorance. You also need a lesson in Spanish grammar and spelling... and proper English as well before you attempt another pathetic "insult."
I LOVE Beyoncè but come on this is stealing!Moreover B did admitt after the scandal that she tried to have Tommasini(Cuccarini coreographer/ex Madonna coreo)to direct her performance but he was busy.She should have waited and not go with his idea without crediting him.Then again the routine and the visual effects are pretty similar to the ones that Timi Papp did in 2008,so i guess also Tommasini copied sombody else!
Whenever people call beyonce an average to below average singer, I laugh my fucking eyes out. Really?! Like you can hold a candle to her? Like anyone can fucking hold a candle to her?!?!? Go watch her sing ave Maria live, or at last, or ANYTHING. Her vocals are absolutely unreal. There is nothing average about her. Nothing. I know it's so incredibly unfair that none of us will EVER be as fierce and fabulous as her, but that doesn't mean you should go off and straight lie about her. Yes, this is
@graceisahurricane (this might start an argument) but her voice REALLY isn't that great. she's infamous for over-doing her vocal runs. i'm pretty sure if you asked any professional vocal coach, or something of the sort, they wouldn't be impressed with beyonce's singing.
@anoziraflaminghot Vocal runs aside, she has perfect pitch, tone, and she's also one of the best dancers out there. She doesn't have to be barbara streistand when it comes to singing, but lets face it, she has more musical talent (singing and dancing) than other female artist out there. she can perform circles around people every female entainer that I know of, at least. she's like the female michael jackson. her purpose in life is to entertain. not just sing, and not just dance.
@graceisahurricane i really honestly think she's overrated. she might be one of the "best" in the game, but she's not the best in general. there's billions of musicians out there who don't get signed but have more talent than any celebrity out there. the opera singers of the world completely shit on the top 40 billboard chart artists. and i don't think beyonce is that great of a dancer. she always looks like she's having a spasm.
@anoziraflaminghot What coreography are you watching?! Just by watching her you can tell she was born with soul and rythm. And really, opera singers?? Opera is a completely different genre than the people in the top 40s. why? its dreadful to listen too. And if these musicians your talking about are so talented, than why aren't they signed? I'll tell you why. They don't have the sparkle, or "it" factor if you will, that is nessecary for any great entertainer. Beyonce puts on a REAL show!
@graceisahurricane seriously, beyonce's dancing is mediocre. and yes, opera. those singers are the best of the best. i know it's a different genre, but no other singers can compare. the top 40 is what's dreadful to listen to -__- lady gaga, justin bieber, katy perry, beyonce, etc. all completely dreadful and a poor example of music. and those artists aren't signed because talent doesn't sell! cheesy pop tunes sale! outrageous personalities sale, not quality! beyonce is only mediocre at best.
@anoziraflaminghot oh really? so you can dance and sing like that? beyonce is a strong and powerful woman and she doesn't take shit from anyone. whenever she sings a song, she does it perfectly, its almost impossible to find a flaw in her performances. and her performances? everything is amazing from every angle. every light, every beat, every cue, every move... beyonce has it down. the fact that she can sing, while dance her sasha fierce faboulous moves and not sound all shaky... talent! and..
@graceisahurricane i can find a flaw in every single one of her performances. and you can dance to ANY genre of music. you obviously prefer hip-hop, r&b, and electronic music to dance to. and it's obviously what YOU can dance to. there are dance moves for ANYTHING. just because a specific genre that makes you happy, doesn't mean it's the only genre that can. her singing isn't great on any standards. she really isn't that great.
@graceisahurricane You need to calm down. Beyoncé may be talented but ripping off another person's concept/performance is just not a nice thing to do. Credits should be given, right? Great artists don't steal. They create, OR they acknowledge the person that inspired them. Right? Check Janet and Michael Jackson - two artists that doesn't copy or steal.
@anoziraflaminghot whats so entertaining about someone singing a song, just standing there? even if the notes are impressively high, and the song is sung perfectly, it has no soul. opera singers have powerful voices, but the songs they sing dont make you happy, they dont make you wanna dance. im guessing you dont like MJ either? & leave justin bieber out of this. he is in no way, musically talented. popular music is good for a reason. opera wont make you happy. ya freakum dress does!
now im not gonna lie beyonce's performance was crazy unreal...have to give her props she did her thing whether she copied Lorella Cuccarini 2010 performance or not buuuuuuuut she really did jack the whole ladies routine for real! i mean like she copied it so much that ms. cuccarini's coreographer need a cut from this profit! beyonce is slowly getting played out so she has no choice now but to jack people shit...it aint the first time she did it pretty sure it wont be the last!
That's only plagiarism if the original's not mentioned. Beyonce DID give credit to the singer for her billboards performance, it's all in her interview. Why don't some of you go and check it out?
I thought she took the basic idea from it but no she actually stole the whole routine, I think it's okay to be inspired by someone but you have the make your own version out of it ..
She does not steal the routines she has people who come up with the performances she is just a performer who hires people do not get upset with her about what she does on stage and before you saw Cuccarini's performance you probable what Beyonce did was so great.
@BeyonceParfumsVEVO How is she better? you're just an ignorant fanatic what do you know about this? Lorella is a genius and that woman copied everything, that is a very shameful and unprofessional thing to do, she's pathetic.
She's just ALWAYS STEALING the work from another people and (blind) fans says "who cares, she's better, she's a hero"????? C'mon people, don't be stupid!!
Beyonce is a SINGER not a choreographer -_- swear people are so dumb these days Beyonce hires people to make up her dances, props, scene because Beyonce is a singer just like any other singer/dancer does janet, Britney, Chris Brown, Usher, Michael Jackson and plenty more do it what is the big deal Beyonce is paid to sing i swear you people know nothing but hate
Oh c'mon ppl!! Of course Beyoncé performance is better! She's a WORLD famous artist. Everybody in the world knows Beyoncé! Who of you guys knew who the hell Lorella Cuccarini was before watching this video???
Have you a freakin' idea of how much more money Beyoncé makes compared to an average Italian pop artist?
Sorry but she copied big time! No doubt about that!
it's very IRONIC thought that the song Lorella is singing has the exact melody of Michael Jackon's "The way you make me feel" exact medlody...so guys tho I know beyonce is not original...most major recording artists are not.
you know what ? that kind of presentation is being used widely nowadays ... maybe its just a coincidence that they had the same concept .. but that background is appropriate to beyonce's song . yeah there are some similarities.. but i don't think she copied it ...
Beyonce is just an anomaly. The original is ORIGINAL and any copying is just a "derivative". Just like stating that Crystal is better than Cristal when we know that there is NO DERIVATIVE WITHOUT THE ORIGINAL. It is easy to improve on something already done. I am certain there are 10's of thousands of choreographers out there that can recreate better renditions but they seldom if ever take credit for copying. Where would we be if all we did is regurgitate the same thing?
if it was me it would be an honor to have beyonce be inspired by stuff...but at the same time dont jack my moves and make it seem like you came up with it first...its the principle of the matter...even if she is beyonce so what...dont steal other people stuff...be original...or just give people their credit
but it is sucking that that timing of beyonce's wings, army and drums occured at the same time. stealing, i don't think so, but she couldn't wing it out later in the song?!?!?
i think beyonce is getting a bad rap, how can someone be inspired by something and others NOT think you're stealing it. as far as referencing it, should beyonce, in the middle of a video/performance/song say, "who runs the woooorld, girls! thank you lorella cuccarini. who runs the woooorld, thank you diplo". it makes no sense, if we should be mad at her, we should be made at every artist that came out since 1700 when beethoven used a 'b minor' and mozart didn't like it!!
@madrobin Don't be so lame. You give credits in documentation or commentary. It is done all the time. Maybe her lack of education is the reason she does not know about plagiarism, or maybe it is your lack of education. IN either case it is immoral and unethical and speaks volumes to ones character.
@paconot u make NO sense, was that a doc we just watched? of course you give credit via commentary or at the end of something. 'b' is always giving credit to old films/songs/dancers/designers, everytime i hear her talk, i personally haven't heard anything for this or 'countdown' but b/c i never heard it, does it mean she never gave props? think back to all the things you've seen in your life, ppl have copied things since day 1. immoral/unethical? she redid a dance, not fuk another guy..CALMATE!
@paconot again, calmate! since you're so educated, tell me how one properly credits someone in the midst of a performance. u either do it b4/after it's done. it's not my fault if u or someone else didn't hear b personally thank lorella. would u b so bold w/ ur statement if we were talking about m. jackson, b/c he 'stole' j. brown's moves, or l. kravitz, b/c he 'stole' hendrix's style, it's not that deep, but check ur carfax, b/c documentation means more than to take note...AND I'M THROUGH!!!
@madrobin "would u b so bold w/ ur statement if we were talking about m. jackson..."
ABSOLUTELY. Because those people when borrowing got permission. Everyone knew who inspired their talents and collateral. Those are legally documented. A far cry from okay let's shank this one out and deal with it afterward. And I guess if you have enough money that is okay. Well, not really because integrity is so important. Please do not defend that. Beyonce is wealthy enough to get it right!
Damn that was fucked up, i understand being inspired but at least give credit ..most artist when they become "inspired" they normally clue to the audience where it come from or include the originator in the performance somewhere
just because one person uses something doesn't mean another can't. they only said it was copying because beyonce probably got more attention from it than the original did. and get over this Illuminati shit!! nobody fuckin cares if you hate her and "everybody else" that's in it stop watching them. if they're devil worshipers stop listening to them theirs plenty of artist in the world we all gone die anyways so sit back and enjoy the damn ride!!!
Brought here because of a headlining article showing how she copied the Countdown video and this performance. Well they forgot to mention the Single Ladies dance moves as well! "Best video of all time" psh yea right!
nothing is original anymore everythings been done and anything you see and think is an original is just an improvement on what has been done before its just that you prbably didn't see the original.
It's OBVIOUS she and her team were inspired by the IDEA of this technology, whats wrong with two artists using this idea? Get real people, you think nobody else in the world can use a soup can JUST because Andy did? NO, everyone should use it, because it's a good idea, use it and abuse it, thats art motherfuckaz
@TylerWallach There's nothing wrong with using the same technology, and I think she did a greta performance, but there are so many similarities between hers and Lorella's: the wings, the moving balls, the shapes, the hundreds of "clones", using that virtual stick as a weapon...
I think she could have done something different with it, although, I have to admit, she did it best, even if she copied most of the elements!
They are Similar, yes Beyoncé had inspiration she's not the first artist! ALSO - BEYONCÉ CAN PULL IT OFF, the other performer you can see her shadow, the effect is lost and her graphics aren't as good!
It is similar but I dont see as much as I thought like pple were portraying it was hard to look at both lol I kept focusing on Bey cuse she just always takes my mind
Thumbs up if you think ppl are over reacting beyonce is a great performer so is lorella btw everyone beyonce said she was inspired by lorella's performanceand has any1 thought ab the company they it's on there part to they didn't make any changes except on beyonce's it looks better so SHUTUP U LOSERS HATE WHEN A BLACK WOMAN HAS SUCESS AND YALL HAVE TO FIND SOMETHING TO BAG ON THERE CAREER also America is original none of you European country's wouldn't have pop or hip hop if it wasn't for us no
Beyonce BADDEST BITCH IN THE GAME EVEN HER BABY IS ALREADY SLAYING SHE BROCKE TWIITER AWARD WITHOUT USING and She The youngest Artist to resive a LEGEND AWARD of the World Music awwards HATZERZ DEAL
@fazz3173 not true at all...in fact, Rock n Roll, Country and Rap music ARE originally American products...as are Baseball, American Football and Basketball. WE have given the world ENTERTAINMENT...we have given the world a different kind of culture...one that many have tried to emmulate and copy. That's not to say that those things wouldn't exist without us BUT not near as developed or as good!!
im italian and beyonce rock it! she took it to another level. what lorella did was so booring that nobody even talked about this in italy. and yet..beyonce is on everybody's lyps for her performance.
@MarkTheCode Well they aren't singing the same song. Lorella's song is much slower than Beyonce's which means she doesn't need to use to much energy. She would just be over doing it. And the video is trying to point out how Lorella came up with the graphic background idea first and Beyonce copied her and did the same thing. Otherwise Beyonce's performance was more entertaining than Lorella's.
This isn't Beyonce's first performance with projection, so you may stop thinking now that Cuccarini created the concept. Both performances are amazing, but I feel, to Beyonce's credit, this is by far her greatest performance ever, and if that's what she was going for, you can tell she succeeded when in the end she broke her stance with a smile like "Omg I'm glad that's over". What's even more amazing is how she maintained voice control thru all the head bopping. Lorella Cuccarini, amazing also.
lmao ppl had me thinking that beyonce did the exact same thing this girl did lmao Beyonce just took what she did and made it better i dont call that copying lol its not the same at all
STFU !!! BEYONCE SAID IT HERSELF THAT SHE WAS INSPIRED AND SHE WAS GOING TO USE THE CONCEPTS OF LORELLA CUCCARINI! SHE SAID IT IN AN INTERVIEW SHE GAVE PROPS AND CREDIT ! THATS NOT COPYING ! COPYING IS SOMETHING LIKE YOU COPY AND DONT GIVE CREDT SOMETHING LIKE NICKI MINAJ DOES ! SO STFU !
This is an old technique anyway. No one "owns" it. Heck, before either of these women were born. Think 1960's graphics. Again popular in the 70s
iamlost2 2 days ago
I do think Beyonces performance was better, but that is because Beyonce is a dancer, the other girl I don't think was a dancer, so it just didn't look as cool. Plus Beyonce is more famous, with a bigger budget, so her's is going to look better.
rahrahrevenge 1 week ago
Beyonce was ovbiously better. but still, the fact that her best performance so far is a lil too insipired in other one, is quite dissapointed.
raul7193 1 week ago
you think she would just do the performance and say nothing? no. beyonce said she was inspired by the performance lorella did and met with people who worked on it. she also said how she never worked so hard in her life on it. and now you guys are bitching about her copying. huh i guess you wouldnt like it if you worked on something so hard and all of a sudden people would be bitching about it would ya? (if you dont believe me, check Wikipedia "run the world" and look at the controversy section
MrBeirdo13 2 weeks ago
BEYONCE WHYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY? even if you did it 10 times better (which is even more annoying for the fan of the people you copy) WHYYYYYYY?
ToinyBoyZz 2 weeks ago
@ToinyBoyZz Every performer, artist, musician has been inspired by others!! Steve Jobs has said about Apple and his brilliance and creativity that, "We have always been shameless about stealing great ideas" - so shut up about dance moves and special effects. ALWAYS they are inspired by others, the performer, artist, dancer, etc. then builds on that inspiration to make it their own.
iamlost2 2 days ago
Beyonce did a waaaaaaay better!!!!!
Cianenunes 2 weeks ago
Both copied Kagemu.
marcioshima 3 weeks ago
It does not matter if she copied now I could understand if she Copied and it sucked BUT she did way better then the first person to do it.
devonte627 3 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I am a japanese fashion model.★
come visit us my channelლ(╹◡╹ლ)
gorigorirarara893 3 weeks ago
Beyonce .. and WHO?!
D3IM2NTEII1 1 month ago
she is better but it's not her idea so not her glory...
soloonelyy 1 month ago 4
where in the hell do people find this shit
NaturalBaker 1 month ago
Beyonce amazing
Second I do not even know what her name is just dumb
leah1400 1 month ago
Beyonce will have a career as long as real talented people come up w/ original ideas she can rip off
ihatewestlifesince99 1 month ago 8
@ihatewestlifesince99 you got no proof of what you're saying so it's very invalid
Sayitasitisable 5 days ago
@ihatewestlifesince99 Most idea are never original - always, ALWAYS ideas are taken from something before. Always. It's even true with language, civilization itself, technology religion, philosophy, and always art, music and dance.
iamlost2 2 days ago
Holy crap lady B copied everything!!!
MarcelineMissouri 1 month ago 15
@MarcelineMissouri uuhmm they had the same production company, which specialises in these performances.. that's the reason for the similarities, but still it's not exactly the same.. but how much choice does one have with such things.. plus the Lorella's beat at the beginning sounds strangely familiar.. (hollaback girl)
OskarAwards 3 weeks ago
YIKES!!!!!!!!! I hear a lot about Beyonce ripping off people but its hilariously obvious when you put them side by side. Regardless of whether or not she credited the artist & used the original creative team. What they should have done was took the IDEA alone & used that to come up with something as original as possible. The wings, drumsticks & legion of dancers are almost totally in sync with each other. Makes me wonder which idea she is going to borrow down to the millisecond for the Grammys.
unyversalone 1 month ago
Beyonce
wendixyta 1 month ago
It isn't Beyonce there steal it, it is the creators of billboard awards!
Missmijavkat 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
seriously guys do you think Lorella is the original artist who use this concept? NO!. Lorella herself COPIED from Kagemu a Japanese artist&so on. we don't know who the original maker of this concept we just know that this concept is likely well known by great big artist because of its uniqueness.and not to mention that this era is likely dominated by digital technology. so pls get your fact right first. did u also know that the man who do Beyonce's visualization is the same with Lorella's?
anthony8336 2 months ago
@anthony8336 But did it have to be almost down to the millisecond is the question. Ideas are reused all the time. The difference is that you need to put your twist on it. Kagemu's was totally different (same concept) from Lorella's so why Beyonce couldn't have done what she did & made it her own is what is at issue. & had she truly used the same creative team as Lorella then they should have completely gotten the previous work out of their heads & built on the original idea for her performance.
unyversalone 1 month ago
Comment removed
anthony8336 2 months ago
Comment removed
anthony8336 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
fuck you beyonce haters!
Eyuelize 2 months ago
Bastards everything is new except 2 things for 5 secs in total....!!!!! Fuck you haters..!!!! I'll visit this video everyday to dislike it now..!!!!!! __l_
chocolateboyojas 2 months ago
Bastards only the theme is same , almost ALL other effects are totally different..!!!!!!!
chocolateboyojas 2 months ago
@chocolateboyojas True. But people are a little anal about it because she's copied one other time. But that was after this whole thing. Besides, even if it is different, she should still consider getting a little more creative with her works.
JustKeepOnTrollin 1 month ago
@seriesdetv Lorella ? yeah she is famous in Nigeria dumb !
09neftali 2 months ago
lol Perfume did this in 2010
IZIxxxx 2 months ago
@IZIxxxx what song did they perform?
chortstuff 2 months ago
@chortstuff look up Perfume no Okite
IZIxxxx 2 months ago
@IZIxxxx oh shit. I looked it up and they did an awesome performance.
chortstuff 2 months ago
Oh my god
menbouWonderwall 2 months ago
OMG Beyonce has really stolen everything!!!!! The melody is from Major Lazer "Pon the floor", her performance is obviosly also stolen and not to forget her dance which she has from the tofo tofo dancers here on youtube... wtf -.-
Rotzfresh89 2 months ago
omg is all i can say. I love the who runs the world performance but I didn't know someone else had already used that concept wow
cuddles762002 2 months ago
I'd rather see someone copy and improve it than someone who dont try something new.
in 10 million new ideas there must be at least a million that copied others,
unjichan 2 months ago 2
Comment removed
kepaha2000 2 months ago
Comment removed
kepaha2000 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Beyonce's concept in her performance, even the music Mazor Lazer's Pon De Floor and the Tofo Tofo dance. (Better search it guys).
What's heppening to Beyonce? It's not original anymore... Inspiration, improving those things are way of stealing others creativity.
Great artists are good in stealing.
MsMysticworld 2 months ago
i thing beyonce's was so much better, but please be human and put credit or just say that was your inspired to do it !
licerlo 2 months ago
This Lorella Cuccarini lady only mad because Beyonce entirely destroyed her performance and made it look revolutionary! She didn't even make good use of the background screen. I mean, what was she even doing...just marching in place...ooooo wooow (sarcastically)
gimmelemons11 2 months ago
@gimmelemons11 JEEZ!!!! Stan much? The fact remains that Beyonce would not have had a performance to "destroy" had someone not showed her Lorella's performance. You & your god Beyonce must have very different tastes because she felt inspired enough to hire Lorella's creative team to rip off the performance for the BIllboard awards. FACT!
unyversalone 1 month ago 3
The question is, who did this Lorella lady steal it from? haha
KimaOnline 2 months ago
I like to think that she did not copy, and that there was some understanding between the two artists. I am a huge Beyonce fan and don't like to think she'd be flippant enough to 'blatantly' copy someone in this age of technology.
KimaOnline 2 months ago
@KimaOnline She saw the performance and talked with the choreographer of it. The original creators were aware she did it, have no fear :)
ivoryalacrity1 1 month ago
this is inspiration not imitation so you guys just need to stfu and stop hating!
NecrophiliacZebra 2 months ago
If you have haters than obviously ur doing something right. Hop of beyonces back. LUV U BEY.
blueshark411 2 months ago
OK FIRST OF ALL.... beyonce said she was getting insparations for the dances and perfomances of 4 from different places of the world so if yall dont know nothin then keep your big mouths shut.
blueshark411 2 months ago
Srsly? these are completely different, and as a matter of fact, lorella Cuccarini Copyed a japanese Guy called Kegumu or somet like that, so Beyonce had her own thing in this, so yeah go find somthing else to hate her on with your lonely lives. with nothing better to do.
WackoJackoLmfao 2 months ago
what a bitch. this offends me.
anoziraflaminghot 3 months ago
Es logico este prieta decida copiar a lorena n solo por la calidad que tiene la creacion artistica del video de Lorella Cuccarini sino por que Beyonce sabe de la gran masa inculta musicalmente hablando que sufre la gente de USA y no tienen la inteligencia de ver hasia Europa donde en verdad hay calidad ademas cuando este chimpace empeso a cantar Lorella Cuccarini ya tenia mas de una decada siendo exitosa en toda Europa
seriesdetv 3 months ago
@seriesdetv Listen why don't you go back to whatever eurotrash or south american third world country you came from. Get a proper education before you continue to make RACIST and ignorant comments. Only ignorant trash would feel the need to make a counter argument by using racist comments about another individual. By the way what fucking language are you even speaking because last time I checked "chimpanzee" is not spelled "chimpace" either in Spanish, Italian, or French. Uncultured trash!
bitrejo 3 months ago
@bitrejo It hurt? LOL back to Nigeria!!!!!!
seriesdetv 3 months ago
@seriesdetv I'm not even Black. No matter. What matters is that people like you need to learn a good lesson in humanity...or at least in how to make a proper rebuttal without the use of racism and ignorance. You also need a lesson in Spanish grammar and spelling... and proper English as well before you attempt another pathetic "insult."
bitrejo 3 months ago
@bitrejo aaaaaaaaaaa jajajajajajaja block again !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
seriesdetv 3 months ago
I LOVE Beyoncè but come on this is stealing!Moreover B did admitt after the scandal that she tried to have Tommasini(Cuccarini coreographer/ex Madonna coreo)to direct her performance but he was busy.She should have waited and not go with his idea without crediting him.Then again the routine and the visual effects are pretty similar to the ones that Timi Papp did in 2008,so i guess also Tommasini copied sombody else!
sarahJolie 3 months ago
Whenever people call beyonce an average to below average singer, I laugh my fucking eyes out. Really?! Like you can hold a candle to her? Like anyone can fucking hold a candle to her?!?!? Go watch her sing ave Maria live, or at last, or ANYTHING. Her vocals are absolutely unreal. There is nothing average about her. Nothing. I know it's so incredibly unfair that none of us will EVER be as fierce and fabulous as her, but that doesn't mean you should go off and straight lie about her. Yes, this is
graceisahurricane 3 months ago
@graceisahurricane (this might start an argument) but her voice REALLY isn't that great. she's infamous for over-doing her vocal runs. i'm pretty sure if you asked any professional vocal coach, or something of the sort, they wouldn't be impressed with beyonce's singing.
anoziraflaminghot 3 months ago
@anoziraflaminghot Vocal runs aside, she has perfect pitch, tone, and she's also one of the best dancers out there. She doesn't have to be barbara streistand when it comes to singing, but lets face it, she has more musical talent (singing and dancing) than other female artist out there. she can perform circles around people every female entainer that I know of, at least. she's like the female michael jackson. her purpose in life is to entertain. not just sing, and not just dance.
graceisahurricane 3 months ago
@graceisahurricane i really honestly think she's overrated. she might be one of the "best" in the game, but she's not the best in general. there's billions of musicians out there who don't get signed but have more talent than any celebrity out there. the opera singers of the world completely shit on the top 40 billboard chart artists. and i don't think beyonce is that great of a dancer. she always looks like she's having a spasm.
anoziraflaminghot 3 months ago
@anoziraflaminghot What coreography are you watching?! Just by watching her you can tell she was born with soul and rythm. And really, opera singers?? Opera is a completely different genre than the people in the top 40s. why? its dreadful to listen too. And if these musicians your talking about are so talented, than why aren't they signed? I'll tell you why. They don't have the sparkle, or "it" factor if you will, that is nessecary for any great entertainer. Beyonce puts on a REAL show!
graceisahurricane 2 months ago
@graceisahurricane seriously, beyonce's dancing is mediocre. and yes, opera. those singers are the best of the best. i know it's a different genre, but no other singers can compare. the top 40 is what's dreadful to listen to -__- lady gaga, justin bieber, katy perry, beyonce, etc. all completely dreadful and a poor example of music. and those artists aren't signed because talent doesn't sell! cheesy pop tunes sale! outrageous personalities sale, not quality! beyonce is only mediocre at best.
anoziraflaminghot 2 months ago
@anoziraflaminghot oh really? so you can dance and sing like that? beyonce is a strong and powerful woman and she doesn't take shit from anyone. whenever she sings a song, she does it perfectly, its almost impossible to find a flaw in her performances. and her performances? everything is amazing from every angle. every light, every beat, every cue, every move... beyonce has it down. the fact that she can sing, while dance her sasha fierce faboulous moves and not sound all shaky... talent! and..
graceisahurricane 2 months ago
@graceisahurricane i can find a flaw in every single one of her performances. and you can dance to ANY genre of music. you obviously prefer hip-hop, r&b, and electronic music to dance to. and it's obviously what YOU can dance to. there are dance moves for ANYTHING. just because a specific genre that makes you happy, doesn't mean it's the only genre that can. her singing isn't great on any standards. she really isn't that great.
anoziraflaminghot 2 months ago
@graceisahurricane You need to calm down. Beyoncé may be talented but ripping off another person's concept/performance is just not a nice thing to do. Credits should be given, right? Great artists don't steal. They create, OR they acknowledge the person that inspired them. Right? Check Janet and Michael Jackson - two artists that doesn't copy or steal.
marabou15 2 months ago
@anoziraflaminghot whats so entertaining about someone singing a song, just standing there? even if the notes are impressively high, and the song is sung perfectly, it has no soul. opera singers have powerful voices, but the songs they sing dont make you happy, they dont make you wanna dance. im guessing you dont like MJ either? & leave justin bieber out of this. he is in no way, musically talented. popular music is good for a reason. opera wont make you happy. ya freakum dress does!
graceisahurricane 2 months ago
Lorella Cuccarini ? who the fuch she is ?
BEYONCE RUN THE FUCKING SHOW ! ;)
09neftali 3 months ago
@09neftali yes! in nigeria Lol
seriesdetv 3 months ago
but whos is better?
perez201014 3 months ago
Lorella Cuccarini
WatchATHFepisodes 3 months ago
now im not gonna lie beyonce's performance was crazy unreal...have to give her props she did her thing whether she copied Lorella Cuccarini 2010 performance or not buuuuuuuut she really did jack the whole ladies routine for real! i mean like she copied it so much that ms. cuccarini's coreographer need a cut from this profit! beyonce is slowly getting played out so she has no choice now but to jack people shit...it aint the first time she did it pretty sure it wont be the last!
beautysynnoman26 3 months ago
That's only plagiarism if the original's not mentioned. Beyonce DID give credit to the singer for her billboards performance, it's all in her interview. Why don't some of you go and check it out?
MarkTheCode 3 months ago
@MarkTheCode The problem is the fact that, credit or not, she isn't innovative
Rockafella107 3 months ago
I thought she took the basic idea from it but no she actually stole the whole routine, I think it's okay to be inspired by someone but you have the make your own version out of it ..
Kejenaa 3 months ago
She does not steal the routines she has people who come up with the performances she is just a performer who hires people do not get upset with her about what she does on stage and before you saw Cuccarini's performance you probable what Beyonce did was so great.
Teyla0016 3 months ago
la copia supero a la original buen trabajp por beyonce(y)
iinventaiiweah 3 months ago
She's a big fat bitch, she's a liar, she's not pregnant and she's a pure copycat
MrGitanoBoy 3 months ago
@MrGitanoBoy looool i love wat u said got me cracking up
SuperRennny 3 months ago
beyoncé is BETTER !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
BeyonceParfumsVEVO 4 months ago 10
Of course Beyonce better
Who is this idiot anyway?
leah1400 1 month ago
@BeyonceParfumsVEVO How is she better? you're just an ignorant fanatic what do you know about this? Lorella is a genius and that woman copied everything, that is a very shameful and unprofessional thing to do, she's pathetic.
daiveedino 1 month ago
Good artists copy. Great artists steal.
- Pablo Picasso.
MarkTheCode 4 months ago 10
She's just ALWAYS STEALING the work from another people and (blind) fans says "who cares, she's better, she's a hero"????? C'mon people, don't be stupid!!
siletsahar 4 months ago 2
Realmente nada se cria, tudo se copia (inda mais se tratando de Beyonce...)
siletsahar 4 months ago
Beyonce is a SINGER not a choreographer -_- swear people are so dumb these days Beyonce hires people to make up her dances, props, scene because Beyonce is a singer just like any other singer/dancer does janet, Britney, Chris Brown, Usher, Michael Jackson and plenty more do it what is the big deal Beyonce is paid to sing i swear you people know nothing but hate
gammin5 4 months ago
@gammin5 Singer? Yeah maybe an average to below average one.
alexavwenz 4 months ago
ugg i'm so tired of her being "inspired" by other people!!!
drkmgic 4 months ago 2
/watch?v=cK12BvLM04M
Beyonce performance was better, i think..
joeddemicamprock 4 months ago
sí, se parecen un montón pero me quedo con el de Beyonce, y eso que a mí esta mujer no me gusta nada...
theploplo1 4 months ago
beyonce .
XEROX,XEROX,XEROX,XEROX
kaduzinho3 4 months ago
Well, if it worked for Led Zeppelin, make it work for you Beyonce.
nognilk 4 months ago
Who cares about this other woman, beyonce rules...even if she copied it. I still love her!
DigitalDude2000 4 months ago
Oh c'mon ppl!! Of course Beyoncé performance is better! She's a WORLD famous artist. Everybody in the world knows Beyoncé! Who of you guys knew who the hell Lorella Cuccarini was before watching this video???
Have you a freakin' idea of how much more money Beyoncé makes compared to an average Italian pop artist?
Sorry but she copied big time! No doubt about that!
Hotaruccia 4 months ago
ILLUMINATTI
.
FaIIenBh0y 4 months ago 3
it's very IRONIC thought that the song Lorella is singing has the exact melody of Michael Jackon's "The way you make me feel" exact medlody...so guys tho I know beyonce is not original...most major recording artists are not.
coulorfully 4 months ago
you know what ? that kind of presentation is being used widely nowadays ... maybe its just a coincidence that they had the same concept .. but that background is appropriate to beyonce's song . yeah there are some similarities.. but i don't think she copied it ...
popfun11 4 months ago
Even if Beyonce's performance is BETTER, Beyonce is just a COPYCAT !!!
MoiJusteMoa 4 months ago 4
Beyonce Performance Is Better !
KaylLiiss 4 months ago
White people create...
Beyonce plagiate
Maritalitaful 4 months ago
Lots of money, zero creativity, zero personality. Is this how she wants girls to run the world?
supercarolita81 4 months ago 10
Beyoncé's performance is so much better so who cares
JuIiaFelatio 4 months ago
An obvious influence, but I like Beyonce's version better.
muadhnate 4 months ago
@Ilove2dance81 You have just revealed your ignorance to the entire internet.
paconot 4 months ago
Pop Stars ruin everything.
gjvmnd 4 months ago 2
Beyonce is just an anomaly. The original is ORIGINAL and any copying is just a "derivative". Just like stating that Crystal is better than Cristal when we know that there is NO DERIVATIVE WITHOUT THE ORIGINAL. It is easy to improve on something already done. I am certain there are 10's of thousands of choreographers out there that can recreate better renditions but they seldom if ever take credit for copying. Where would we be if all we did is regurgitate the same thing?
paconot 4 months ago
beyonce is and will be better
kath19erine 4 months ago
beyonce es y sera mejor
kath19erine 4 months ago
BEYONCE JUST LAUGHED AT HER!!! SHE DOES IT BETTER THAN THE ORIGINAL! she's a heroooooooo !!!!!
MiiniexMouse 4 months ago
if it was me it would be an honor to have beyonce be inspired by stuff...but at the same time dont jack my moves and make it seem like you came up with it first...its the principle of the matter...even if she is beyonce so what...dont steal other people stuff...be original...or just give people their credit
gabri2889 4 months ago 13
@gabri2889 well she said she was getting ideas from other entertainers watch year ov 4. she does give credit to the ones that she could
blueshark411 2 months ago
yall always got excuses for this stealing bitch
cs2cl 4 months ago 5
but it is sucking that that timing of beyonce's wings, army and drums occured at the same time. stealing, i don't think so, but she couldn't wing it out later in the song?!?!?
madrobin 4 months ago
i think beyonce is getting a bad rap, how can someone be inspired by something and others NOT think you're stealing it. as far as referencing it, should beyonce, in the middle of a video/performance/song say, "who runs the woooorld, girls! thank you lorella cuccarini. who runs the woooorld, thank you diplo". it makes no sense, if we should be mad at her, we should be made at every artist that came out since 1700 when beethoven used a 'b minor' and mozart didn't like it!!
madrobin 4 months ago
@madrobin Don't be so lame. You give credits in documentation or commentary. It is done all the time. Maybe her lack of education is the reason she does not know about plagiarism, or maybe it is your lack of education. IN either case it is immoral and unethical and speaks volumes to ones character.
paconot 4 months ago
@paconot u make NO sense, was that a doc we just watched? of course you give credit via commentary or at the end of something. 'b' is always giving credit to old films/songs/dancers/designers, everytime i hear her talk, i personally haven't heard anything for this or 'countdown' but b/c i never heard it, does it mean she never gave props? think back to all the things you've seen in your life, ppl have copied things since day 1. immoral/unethical? she redid a dance, not fuk another guy..CALMATE!
madrobin 4 months ago
@madrobin Man, get some EDUCATION. Documentation just means to make note. Dumb azzzzzzz!
paconot 3 months ago
@paconot again, calmate! since you're so educated, tell me how one properly credits someone in the midst of a performance. u either do it b4/after it's done. it's not my fault if u or someone else didn't hear b personally thank lorella. would u b so bold w/ ur statement if we were talking about m. jackson, b/c he 'stole' j. brown's moves, or l. kravitz, b/c he 'stole' hendrix's style, it's not that deep, but check ur carfax, b/c documentation means more than to take note...AND I'M THROUGH!!!
madrobin 3 months ago
@madrobin "would u b so bold w/ ur statement if we were talking about m. jackson..."
ABSOLUTELY. Because those people when borrowing got permission. Everyone knew who inspired their talents and collateral. Those are legally documented. A far cry from okay let's shank this one out and deal with it afterward. And I guess if you have enough money that is okay. Well, not really because integrity is so important. Please do not defend that. Beyonce is wealthy enough to get it right!
paconot 2 months ago
grande Cuccarini!!!!
Robertina15 4 months ago
Damn that was fucked up, i understand being inspired but at least give credit ..most artist when they become "inspired" they normally clue to the audience where it come from or include the originator in the performance somewhere
nishap1991 4 months ago
just because one person uses something doesn't mean another can't. they only said it was copying because beyonce probably got more attention from it than the original did. and get over this Illuminati shit!! nobody fuckin cares if you hate her and "everybody else" that's in it stop watching them. if they're devil worshipers stop listening to them theirs plenty of artist in the world we all gone die anyways so sit back and enjoy the damn ride!!!
Anointedwithpraise 4 months ago
Brought here because of a headlining article showing how she copied the Countdown video and this performance. Well they forgot to mention the Single Ladies dance moves as well! "Best video of all time" psh yea right!
utubeusername0001 4 months ago 3
@utubeusername0001 she actually gave Bob Fosse credit for his inspiration on single ladies.
dbuckleytv 4 months ago
thieving bitch
seanysean2 4 months ago
nothing is original anymore everythings been done and anything you see and think is an original is just an improvement on what has been done before its just that you prbably didn't see the original.
Cyatty 4 months ago
Steal what? Lorella Cuccarini is not a software engineer who owns any patents to the technology used. #clue
MrEvelDoer 4 months ago
Same technology but Beyonce's much better than Lorella's....much much much better
krisstinne100 4 months ago
From what I see, she took ideas and made it her own. Still shady.
MOTat18 4 months ago
It's OBVIOUS she and her team were inspired by the IDEA of this technology, whats wrong with two artists using this idea? Get real people, you think nobody else in the world can use a soup can JUST because Andy did? NO, everyone should use it, because it's a good idea, use it and abuse it, thats art motherfuckaz
TylerWallach 4 months ago
@TylerWallach There's nothing wrong with using the same technology, and I think she did a greta performance, but there are so many similarities between hers and Lorella's: the wings, the moving balls, the shapes, the hundreds of "clones", using that virtual stick as a weapon...
I think she could have done something different with it, although, I have to admit, she did it best, even if she copied most of the elements!
PinuVF 4 months ago
FRAUD BITCH
KERIFEMALEMJ 4 months ago 9
that's just awful from Beyonce. Well, I'm very disapointed in her...
InXTheXEndXAgain 4 months ago 7
@InXTheXEndXAgain i agree with you. i didn't expect it from her.
amalia114 4 months ago
tsss !!!! Beyoncé a mieux travailler sa performance elle et plus dynamique !! on peut pas les comparé
cycyde241 4 months ago
Plágio descarado!
21061992digo 5 months ago
They are Similar, yes Beyoncé had inspiration she's not the first artist! ALSO - BEYONCÉ CAN PULL IT OFF, the other performer you can see her shadow, the effect is lost and her graphics aren't as good!
SpicyShakeel 5 months ago
It is similar but I dont see as much as I thought like pple were portraying it was hard to look at both lol I kept focusing on Bey cuse she just always takes my mind
95stewartgirl 5 months ago
since when a triangle was a automatic assumption of an illumanti?
yall get a life
anduthoughtiwascrazy 5 months ago 5
SMH tht just sad..
shanexxD 5 months ago
@MrsStrangerInMoscow yeah,Beyonce steals a lot of stuff other artist do.Still a good performance though.
MJJSmoothCriminal 5 months ago
Thumbs up if you think ppl are over reacting beyonce is a great performer so is lorella btw everyone beyonce said she was inspired by lorella's performanceand has any1 thought ab the company they it's on there part to they didn't make any changes except on beyonce's it looks better so SHUTUP U LOSERS HATE WHEN A BLACK WOMAN HAS SUCESS AND YALL HAVE TO FIND SOMETHING TO BAG ON THERE CAREER also America is original none of you European country's wouldn't have pop or hip hop if it wasn't for us no
bettybooptulip 5 months ago
Beyonce BADDEST BITCH IN THE GAME EVEN HER BABY IS ALREADY SLAYING SHE BROCKE TWIITER AWARD WITHOUT USING and She The youngest Artist to resive a LEGEND AWARD of the World Music awwards HATZERZ DEAL
beyonceboy100 6 months ago
And yur point
jerkin2200 6 months ago
on line on gugolrep.com!
sabighel88 6 months ago
i don't even know lorella... I only know beyonce and this is why i was brought to this video...
90Blessed 6 months ago
NOTHING is original in AMERICA.. ;')
fazz3173 6 months ago 45
@fazz3173 cos America itself is stolen!
MayssaTV 4 months ago
@fazz3173 not true at all...in fact, Rock n Roll, Country and Rap music ARE originally American products...as are Baseball, American Football and Basketball. WE have given the world ENTERTAINMENT...we have given the world a different kind of culture...one that many have tried to emmulate and copy. That's not to say that those things wouldn't exist without us BUT not near as developed or as good!!
TEBKOE 3 months ago
TRIANGLES
ARE TRIANGLES
NOTHING MORE
jesus fucking christ
slayer3to10 6 months ago
it is REALLY Illuminati
look at the triangulum -s
and the things shapes at the screen ....beyonce ? really?
kokym8 6 months ago
Beyonce is an unoriginal thief.
4dancingdreams 6 months ago 2
im italian and beyonce rock it! she took it to another level. what lorella did was so booring that nobody even talked about this in italy. and yet..beyonce is on everybody's lyps for her performance.
TheUrbanStile 6 months ago
I noticed alot more triangles and the one dollar bill triangle than the other chick... just saying...Beyonce is just blatant with it
MrRickySuperstar 6 months ago
Beyonce is soooo sexy. I wish I was her guard or something so I could work my way up to fuking her.
dfg93353 7 months ago
@dfg93353 Lmfao, that wouldnt happen unless you rape her or something. And you would get in a BIG trouble.
SlowY00 6 months ago
The difference is so huge it blinds so many isnt it? How can't you see the power inside beyonce?
MarkTheCode 7 months ago
@MarkTheCode Well they aren't singing the same song. Lorella's song is much slower than Beyonce's which means she doesn't need to use to much energy. She would just be over doing it. And the video is trying to point out how Lorella came up with the graphic background idea first and Beyonce copied her and did the same thing. Otherwise Beyonce's performance was more entertaining than Lorella's.
janetjacksonstan 6 months ago
This isn't Beyonce's first performance with projection, so you may stop thinking now that Cuccarini created the concept. Both performances are amazing, but I feel, to Beyonce's credit, this is by far her greatest performance ever, and if that's what she was going for, you can tell she succeeded when in the end she broke her stance with a smile like "Omg I'm glad that's over". What's even more amazing is how she maintained voice control thru all the head bopping. Lorella Cuccarini, amazing also.
klabz11 7 months ago
BEYONCE was better - she made the technology look good. The other woman looked bored and stiff
Rotarrius 7 months ago
lmao ppl had me thinking that beyonce did the exact same thing this girl did lmao Beyonce just took what she did and made it better i dont call that copying lol its not the same at all
breezy52393 7 months ago
BEYONCE 4EVER.
rudyjapan 7 months ago
Look at the video from 1:06 and on. It's silly, but it matches! They definitely should do a duo cover.
yukiplus 7 months ago
And Societies were built on plagarism...oops or should sociologists say borrowed elements of another great empire's culture.
MegaLBoogey 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
STFU !!! BEYONCE SAID IT HERSELF THAT SHE WAS INSPIRED AND SHE WAS GOING TO USE THE CONCEPTS OF LORELLA CUCCARINI! SHE SAID IT IN AN INTERVIEW SHE GAVE PROPS AND CREDIT ! THATS NOT COPYING ! COPYING IS SOMETHING LIKE YOU COPY AND DONT GIVE CREDT SOMETHING LIKE NICKI MINAJ DOES ! SO STFU !
itsPrinceNick 7 months ago
nada a ver
TheRafinhacardoso 7 months ago
BEYONCE IS A COPY CAT
aaleidass 7 months ago