You do know that he wrote his PhD thesis about this topic and was awarded for it? As the best thesis of the year.... If I were you I would just go and sit in one of his lectures, it is really enlightening and a lot of fun. I personally enjoed it.
Come on man. Use your brain. What is "idiotic" about it. What are the factual errors? Any dimwit can hurl abuse, but if you want to make a contribution to the debate, point out what you regard as Dr Rane's errors. Make an argument or shut up.
i could make numerous arguments to this however I would recommend you pick up the book Israel and the Arabs by Ahron Bregman and Juhan El-Tahri. By the name you can tell it will be very objective and will show both perspectives. Great read.
You do know that he wrote his PhD thesis about this topic and was awarded for it? As the best thesis of the year.... If I were you I would just go and sit in one of his lectures, it is really enlightening and a lot of fun. I personally enjoed it.
NK3010 2 years ago
Good to listen to a reasoned argument. Good post. Well done ummahmedia.
chavahat 3 years ago
this is idiotic, he seemed intelligent too.
pskizzle 3 years ago
Come on man. Use your brain. What is "idiotic" about it. What are the factual errors? Any dimwit can hurl abuse, but if you want to make a contribution to the debate, point out what you regard as Dr Rane's errors. Make an argument or shut up.
chavahat 3 years ago
i could make numerous arguments to this however I would recommend you pick up the book Israel and the Arabs by Ahron Bregman and Juhan El-Tahri. By the name you can tell it will be very objective and will show both perspectives. Great read.
pskizzle 3 years ago
You say you COULD make numerous arguments, but you don't. Go ahead. I'll read them. What are the factual errors? In what way is this guy an idiot?
chavahat 3 years ago