1) Jussi B. 2) Joseph Schmidt 3) Fritz Wunderlich. Some may want to argue the pecking order but I could care less. All 3 left us this jewel so beautifully sung &, after decades, NO ONE has taken their place.
Die ergreifend schlichte Schönheit dieser Stimme ist überwältigend. Ein Tenor so ganz ohne Schmalz. Echte, tief empfundene Musik in goldenem Gewand einer Jahrhundertstimme! Vielen Dank!
Not one of his strongest recordings, so to speak... he sounds rather raspy, but perhaps there's a charm to that aswell. It's a bit surprising though, as Björling practically never sounds labored...
Well, he was months from death (heart failure) when he recorded this. BTW, it is not a live performance, despite the applause. His song is part of a "gala" inserted into a studio recording of Die Fledermaus.
You are not the first person I've heard comment on the diminished quality of his singing here, but personally, I can't hear it. He sounds much like he always did.
Wunderlich's performance is better for me, but he was younger and healthier when he recorded it.
This music was composed to amuze people, so it was "popular music", kind of light music, back in the early 20th century. Common people was supposed to enjoy and value this kind of art. If we compare it to today's popular music we will reach the conclusion that Darwin was undoubtedly wrong when he stated the Theory of Evolution, or we are on our way back to the ape status!!!!
1) Jussi B. 2) Joseph Schmidt 3) Fritz Wunderlich. Some may want to argue the pecking order but I could care less. All 3 left us this jewel so beautifully sung &, after decades, NO ONE has taken their place.
Lovelytenor1 1 month ago
Die ergreifend schlichte Schönheit dieser Stimme ist überwältigend. Ein Tenor so ganz ohne Schmalz. Echte, tief empfundene Musik in goldenem Gewand einer Jahrhundertstimme! Vielen Dank!
Biter0lf 1 month ago
This aria is exquisitely beautiful. I don't care about bullshit or amusement...beauty is beauty.
BalletBabyBoy 1 month ago
Splendido! Effettivamente dal citato 2.43, canta in tedesco.
Fasolt100 2 months ago
Not one of his strongest recordings, so to speak... he sounds rather raspy, but perhaps there's a charm to that aswell. It's a bit surprising though, as Björling practically never sounds labored...
Jaaakob 2 months ago
@Jaaakob
Well, he was months from death (heart failure) when he recorded this. BTW, it is not a live performance, despite the applause. His song is part of a "gala" inserted into a studio recording of Die Fledermaus.
You are not the first person I've heard comment on the diminished quality of his singing here, but personally, I can't hear it. He sounds much like he always did.
Wunderlich's performance is better for me, but he was younger and healthier when he recorded it.
johnhoie1 1 month ago
On retrouve des défauts qui ont migré dans les générations suivantes,mais qui ici sonnent comme des qualités:Le paradoxe vocal...
abracadabranque 4 months ago
This music was composed to amuze people, so it was "popular music", kind of light music, back in the early 20th century. Common people was supposed to enjoy and value this kind of art. If we compare it to today's popular music we will reach the conclusion that Darwin was undoubtedly wrong when he stated the Theory of Evolution, or we are on our way back to the ape status!!!!
PANZERCAMPINO 5 months ago 7
@PANZERCAMPINO Darwin was right, but you're right about music. Sad, isn't it?
What has become of us? We seem to have lost our way, in many things.
Bill in Canada
baghend 2 months ago
If there was ever a tenor (and I repeat, if) to rival Bjorling, it was the incredible Fritz Wunderlich, whose version of this is probably the best.
tat1685 9 months ago
This is Swedish.
Siriusfanatiker 11 months ago
@Siriusfanatiker It is German from 2:43. Listen.
tat1685 9 months ago
Yes... it's German later, how interesting. Greatly appreciated, who doesn't love Jussi?
DottoreJojo 1 year ago
Is there a version of Jussi singing this in German?
302MarkVII 1 year ago
He is! Listen to the end!
lyghdha 1 year ago
@302MarkVII In German from 2:43.
PEAinSwe 1 year ago