@Sagax05 - you're wrong when it comes to the glee cast not singing their own songs. How can you say that when they've done concerts, and even sung at the whitehouse? They wouldn't be lipsyncing at those events.. plus ; According to IMDb's trivia section for the show's page, "All cast members do their own singing and dancing." And they are incredible. 'Nuff said.
@sagax05 Hey, asshole, there is no need to hate on glee because they covered this amazing song ( I do agree with you there ) but I think they coveted this song because it's so great, and that is definitely not disrespecting billy Joel ... Also there is no need to add that immature comment about girls fingering themselves over this .
theres nothing immature if this fangirl attack proved me point. And its pretty disrespectful, since its autotuned, and for you guys who dont know, the glee cast doesnt actually sing, they have people who sing for them xD. They just have a pretty face so there the actor. The show is bad enough but why do they have to ruin great songs like these? I don't know.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
this..is terrible. a total disrespect to the original done by the great billy joel.. seriously...fuck you. i just found this about this a minute ago. i mean its cool if you girls wanna finger yourself to this guys voice..but its terrible....
hahaha this is the song that every guy dedicate to me, beacuse my name is virginia and yes i'm catholic:) but well yes i want to wait, that's my decision.
I really think Mark has one of the best voices in the show. Seriously. A song singed by him, inmediately it becomes in a good song. No matter wich one.
@MeTheGleek i don't hate glee. . . .. i'm just more loyal to bily joel than to them. i do like a lot of glee's songs, but whoever this is, they just don;t have the same soul energy billy joel put into this song
i honestly LOVE Finn. Very much. But Puck is SUCH a better singer. I don't understand how he wasn't cast as the lead male singer.... but they're equally hot. in different ways :)
@lindsayleavittxo I think it's because whilst Puck has an amazing voice, Finn's is more generic; it's the basic 'male' voice, which, although good, lacks character (like Rachel's for the girls). But that's what they wanted out of a male lead; they wanted a comfortable, generic voice to lead, rather than one very clearly better suited to any particular genres. Hence why Rachel and Finn, although nothing particularly special (compared to the character in the others' voices), get most of the solos.
okay, people! can we please calm down? don't start jumping down my throat, i agreed that this was by no means a bad version (if you read my other comment). i just feel like no one can touch billy joel on this song. they can sing whatever the hell they want, but he wil always be the best. Just an opinion. Relax.
@13pangea Sorry, but I don't agree :) obviously Billy Joel does it the best. He is incredible and no one is ever going to be able to surpass him. Everyone else, however, has every right to sing it too, hell, I was singing along at the top of my voice in the car with my dad earlier today :P it doesn't matter how bad it sounds when you do it, because you're just paying your tribute to an amazing song, and showing it some love. :)
I love this waaaaaaaaaaay better than the Billy Joel version. (:
Darkly211 1 week ago
It's not auto tuned it's just bad quality, know the differance.
JackSpade117 1 week ago
Not only did they rip the heart and soul out of this classic Billy Joel number, but it's AUTOTUNED too. Now I remember why I steer clear of Glee.
TheAwkwardSylence 1 week ago
autotuned a little bit. nothing even close to billy joel. billy did such a good version with little technology.
spikeydewd01 2 weeks ago
Why is there no female version of this song :(
HatiChantheWolfHog 2 weeks ago
This sucks compared to Billy Joel.
BenjaminBissell 1 month ago
@Sagax05 - you're wrong when it comes to the glee cast not singing their own songs. How can you say that when they've done concerts, and even sung at the whitehouse? They wouldn't be lipsyncing at those events.. plus ; According to IMDb's trivia section for the show's page, "All cast members do their own singing and dancing." And they are incredible. 'Nuff said.
Skybreeze08 2 months ago
@Skybreeze08 I AGREE!!!! + Many of them has been on Broadway (I don't think you would get to be in a musical if you can't sing)
totallystrange123 2 months ago
@sagax05 Hey, asshole, there is no need to hate on glee because they covered this amazing song ( I do agree with you there ) but I think they coveted this song because it's so great, and that is definitely not disrespecting billy Joel ... Also there is no need to add that immature comment about girls fingering themselves over this .
xMusicMimic97x 2 months ago 3
@xMusicMimic97x
theres nothing immature if this fangirl attack proved me point. And its pretty disrespectful, since its autotuned, and for you guys who dont know, the glee cast doesnt actually sing, they have people who sing for them xD. They just have a pretty face so there the actor. The show is bad enough but why do they have to ruin great songs like these? I don't know.
sagax05 2 months ago
love this
SpotOnlover284 3 weeks ago
@sagax05 screw you
1910Madeline 2 months ago
@1910Madeline
lolusomad.
sagax05 2 months ago
@sagax05 YOU'RE ABSOLUTELY WRONG!
missindependant3455 2 months ago
@missindependant3455
nope,UMad?
sagax05 2 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this..is terrible. a total disrespect to the original done by the great billy joel.. seriously...fuck you. i just found this about this a minute ago. i mean its cool if you girls wanna finger yourself to this guys voice..but its terrible....
sagax05 2 months ago
@sagax05 HEY!!!!!!! You know it is people like you that make me wish that you could dislike a comment more than once!!!!!!
totallystrange123 2 months ago 3
@totallystrange123
UMad?
sagax05 2 months ago
@totallystrange123 so totally have to agreed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SpotOnlover284 1 month ago
I'm In Love with Puck he converted me to Glee
mzsteffers92 2 months ago
The Ones That Pushed The Dislike Button Are Gonna Die Young
youareahotknocker 2 months ago 3
About a hundred percent better than the Warbler's Billy Joel cover.
sarahelfwine 3 months ago 3
puck <3
kreschty 4 months ago
hahaha this is the song that every guy dedicate to me, beacuse my name is virginia and yes i'm catholic:) but well yes i want to wait, that's my decision.
GGVirgi 4 months ago
Glee s02e03 - Grilled Cheesus
Mark does such an excellent version of this song, love it :)
StalkerSKT 4 months ago
can someone pleas remind me: when did he sing this??? Just blanked...
gleeks1231 4 months ago in playlist glee
@gleeks1231 Grilled Cheesus, Season 2.
zft51994 4 months ago
make me smile
Xtenshiii 4 months ago
The sinners are much more fun :D
KelseyLol65 4 months ago
My friend wants to marry puck lol
MrsCoryMonteith1 5 months ago
THANK YOU GRILLED CHEESUS!
NireonPhoenixDragon 5 months ago 6
in which episode did he sing this song?
badeendenliefde 5 months ago
@badeendenliefde Grilled Cheesus i think :)
StarkidGleek1 5 months ago 3
This song would be soooo much better without fucking autotune.
9i8u7y6t5r1 5 months ago
LOVE the instruments! :D
stephypoomasquerade 5 months ago
I'M IMMORTAL
KeiiFu 5 months ago
such a sexy voice... <3
gleeks1231 5 months ago in playlist glee
PUCK PUCKER UP!
jemdora 6 months ago 2
I really think Mark has one of the best voices in the show. Seriously. A song singed by him, inmediately it becomes in a good song. No matter wich one.
TheEgyptianspirit 6 months ago 39
@TheEgyptianspirit yes, true. :D We need muuuuuuuch, muuuuuuuuuch more Puckerman solos.
MsAlexisSlaughter 5 months ago 5
PLLZZZZZ I BEG THE HATERS TO GET A PULSE! I luvvvv gleeeeeee :D
MeTheGleek 6 months ago
@MeTheGleek i don't hate glee. . . .. i'm just more loyal to bily joel than to them. i do like a lot of glee's songs, but whoever this is, they just don;t have the same soul energy billy joel put into this song
13pangea 5 months ago
i honestly LOVE Finn. Very much. But Puck is SUCH a better singer. I don't understand how he wasn't cast as the lead male singer.... but they're equally hot. in different ways :)
lindsayleavittxo 6 months ago
@lindsayleavittxo I think it's because whilst Puck has an amazing voice, Finn's is more generic; it's the basic 'male' voice, which, although good, lacks character (like Rachel's for the girls). But that's what they wanted out of a male lead; they wanted a comfortable, generic voice to lead, rather than one very clearly better suited to any particular genres. Hence why Rachel and Finn, although nothing particularly special (compared to the character in the others' voices), get most of the solos.
AnHibou 5 months ago
Puck=nom<3
ImAddictedToTheMusic 6 months ago 2
I have always liked puck, i think hes adorable, but when i saw him performing this song in glee I TOTALLY FELL IN LOVE with him!! amazingly beautiful
eeevelinaa 6 months ago 2
One of my fave Glee songs!! :)
1americanidol11 7 months ago
i do not watch glee often, but i will say puck has the best voice by far.
ilovethebeatles13 7 months ago 2
@AldenTheOne Season 2 Grilled Cheesus. ;)
ParamorePeace 7 months ago
I just wanna start dancing when I hear this :)
MarijeBaby 7 months ago
Awwwwwwwwweh. Puck rawks man. But... Kurt rawkky moree. -3 BOTH RAWKS !
ParamorePeace 7 months ago
@ParamorePeace it took me a while to figure out what you meant by "rawk"... is it so difficult to just write rock?
sofieheterjeg 6 months ago
Mark Wayne Salling is the sexiest thing ever to roam the earth's surface.
AbooWalshies316 7 months ago
I wish Kurt sang this. -3
ParamorePeace 7 months ago
NICE SONG ON GRILLED CHEESUUUUUUUUUS !!! -3
ParamorePeace 7 months ago
'mark salling should sing more in Glee
thegirlwholuvs2read 7 months ago
I love Mark Salling and also Puck ♥
StevenILoveYou1 7 months ago 5
i would love to press the replay button for the rest of my life, but i just cand find it.
where is it????
DOnlyNameAvailable 7 months ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
i love puck and his voice!!
tuggers101 8 months ago in playlist Glee
Comment removed
tuggers101 8 months ago in playlist Glee
4 people are bad and old. prepare for your death
DOnlyNameAvailable 8 months ago in playlist Glee 6
thumbs up if you knew this song before glee
RebuildReach 8 months ago 4
you can't not love puck ! he is the best !! Mark Salling also has a album on spotify just search for mark salling :D love ! <3
moviegirl981 8 months ago 2
damn that boy can sing! Puck should get more solos
HolyinserthereBatman 8 months ago 56
@HolyinserthereBatman I know...Puck and Kurt should get most of the male solos on Glee :)
NYChica23 8 months ago
Puck(the actor who plays him at least) is the best singer on Glee.
Tuuralihn 8 months ago 6
One of my favorite glee songs
ImDefyingGravity97 8 months ago 6
Love this song, so much energy and Puck adds a hint more! Perfect song for him!
JaguarF9 9 months ago 5
Favorite Puck song! So awesome! X3
Bananaaddict3 9 months ago 5
i prefer sweet caroline but i like it too
lsdasfnid 9 months ago 4
why u have a fucking perfect voice ??? S2
caah743 9 months ago 6
HAHAHAHA The like bar looks like a blunt. Posting while hi... thumbs up guys.
Silverwolfrunniing 9 months ago
okay, people! can we please calm down? don't start jumping down my throat, i agreed that this was by no means a bad version (if you read my other comment). i just feel like no one can touch billy joel on this song. they can sing whatever the hell they want, but he wil always be the best. Just an opinion. Relax.
13pangea 9 months ago 2
Awsome !
FifteenMusicNotes 9 months ago
i wish i could sing that high pitched - seriously
bmanrawk 9 months ago
what episode???
AldenTheOne 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i wanna suck pucks meatgrinder
TheDuckbluck1 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
i wanna suck pucks dick
TheDuckbluck1 9 months ago
i wanna suck pucks dick
TheDuckbluck1 9 months ago
puck got a big dick
TheDuckbluck1 9 months ago
it's not a bad version, but they just dont have the same energy the billy joel did. he really FELT it; they're just performing it
13pangea 9 months ago
Sorry, but billy joel is the only one who should be allowed to sing this song. all true billy joel fans and admirers know this to be true
13pangea 9 months ago
@13pangea Sorry, but I don't agree :) obviously Billy Joel does it the best. He is incredible and no one is ever going to be able to surpass him. Everyone else, however, has every right to sing it too, hell, I was singing along at the top of my voice in the car with my dad earlier today :P it doesn't matter how bad it sounds when you do it, because you're just paying your tribute to an amazing song, and showing it some love. :)
musicalkaty 9 months ago 4
@musicalkaty i totally agree with you. everyone should have a right to sing what they want. whenever i listen to this or the original, i sing it too
GameReaper94 9 months ago
This is actually my favorite Glee cover so far :)
4eva4given 10 months ago 3
well this cover don't come even close to the billy joel original sorry... actullay this sound pretty lousy :( lame gleee
dudigozal 10 months ago
@dudigozal a cover isn't about mimicking the original or trying to better it it is about putting a personal twist on a song.
mokibearblack 10 months ago 3
This is a good cover but I LOVE Billy Joel's original :)
KendellLGS 10 months ago
i love the part where they all dance and twist around :)
ilovealyna0306 10 months ago 4
That is the reason why i'm Agnostic. :) I'm a bad boy.
darkwebon 11 months ago
thumbs up if you hear the autotune
tails228 11 months ago
@tails228 guess no1 does!
turlogholmes 9 months ago
I LUV IT! And i am soooo glad some1 else uploaded it so now i don't have to watch the vevo ADs <3
bcbgvbhi 11 months ago 3
It is one of the best songs ever in glee
Nanna301296 11 months ago 121
I looooove this song!!!! puck sings amazing!!
mayakats1999 1 year ago 7