Added: 3 years ago
From: OasisILove
Views: 284,852
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (396)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Who likes the shirt at 0:33, cause I do

  • It's all a matter of opinion and sure Bowie's is always going to be the best, but that goes without saying. Oasis had made an awesome alteration.

  • @SurfaceCollison wall flowers much better cover, sounds like a cow hung in an electric fence usually I like Oasis, but man this sucks

  • @Rattster10 Your opinion, Wall Flowers basically copied David Bowie!

  • Comment removed

  • I dislike it immensely but I dislike Oasis. They alter the chords on the first chord change and alter the main guitar riff. Not good in my opinion but I certainly can understand others liking it. To each his or her own.

  • the closest any artist will ever come to getting near to the original

  • i figured it would be better..the original is by far the best and i like the wallflowers version better then this

  • I actually like this version but in no way does it touch the original. But hatfs off to Oasisis

  • Oasis could cover any song and make it just as good as the original

  • BAXTERLICIOUS!!! 8D

  • @Rochie2K8 what are you taliking about? what has X factor got to do with oasis! shut up!

  • it's actually not that good. I'm slightly dissappointed. Too much sound not enough music!

  • the pictures are cool

  • It's alright, but the Bowie version still pisses all over it.

  • @ramthatdiver Yep, it's one of Bowie's masterpieces.

    Anyone who thinks Noels version is miles better than Bowie's, are deaf.

    And Noel would probably agree!

  • Luckily the music drowns out the vocals. Give me Bowie.

  • noel is a hero :)

  • at 38 seconds it becomes any oasis song

    

  • Comment removed

  • this cover fucking rocks! I'm surprised that this wasn't on any albums or released as a single.

  • King Crimson did a decent cover of this.

    Oasis is their usual mediocre selves.  They should leave the classics the fuck alone.

  • @willbond Hear hear :)

  • wonderfull

  • Still looking for the moulin rouge version :(

  • omg, right after the voice kicked in, I was like NO NO. Off.

  • @Rochie2K8 why would you remind us

  • 62 person are villans

  • good cover

  • Good Effort...they put their own sound on it

  • much better than the original version, in my opinion...

  • @TheNutsOfficiel no way

  • ...Fucking atrocious.

  • gooooooooooooooooooooooooood

  • Not bad but The Wallflowers version is the best cover I've heard of this song

  • These 4 minutes and 9 seconds should have never made it out of the garage.

  • musics not a competition u morons. Like or dont, there is no 1st place 2nd place.

  • Hm... not the greatest cover. The beat's all wrong.

  • this song is better now

  • shhhhit....come on....

  • exelente version

  • NOEL could do any cover in the world,and it would sound better then any oringal.

  • @savethebrits91 This does not sound better than the original.

  • @cdg428

    maybe so,but i don't care on what you think you american cunt

  • @savethebrits91

    So... that's a pretty normal reaction, as it were.

  • This is what gets me through the day! "We can be heroes"

  • #1Bowie, #2Bowie and Queen, #3Wallflowers, #Last: Oasis

  • This is AWESOME.

    Cant believe i'd never heard it before!

  • TOO MUCH DISTORSION. Fuck, Noel, this is too fucking noisy as usual. No one beats an original Bowie anyway

  • @Tlzmaniac *distortion.........you don't get it.

  • @Tlzmaniac kurt cobain did with the man who sold the world

  • @Tlzmaniac What would be the point in doing a cover that was identical?

  • Noel is a hero everyday

  • this is awful. it sounds like I karaoke version. if you want a heroes cover that tries a different angle and works then look at the tv on the radio cover. Bowie rules!

  • @mikerock dont watch it then, tit

  • @dazza2610 Ok then...I think I might watch a Beady Eye video instead...Oh there seems to be a mistake it says it was recorded in 2010 but sounds as though it was sung in 95. Does he ever move on!

  • @mikerock i dont know what that comment means? if you dont like it why the fuck are you watching it? lol and beady eyes album just got to number 3 in the album charts ? whats david bowie doing these days?

  • @dazza2610

    David Bowie is 64 you ignorant twit, as if he's still going to be recording music. And you know what? He released his last album only in 2003, which is really quite impressive - a music career spanning 4 decades! Now mikerock perhaps could have been more tactful, but in part I agree with him. Noel didn't give the song his own spin imho. But still, it's my own opinion and if you disagree I'm fine with that... just don't insult a music Great like David Bowie in the process.

  • Noel is my Hero

  • Oh it's very different from Bowie - it's full of life, joy, and a glorious call and challenge to life. Makes you wonder how he ever got around to buggering around selling clothes.

  • @MrArgos74 this is Noel, Liam sells the clothes my friend :)

    

  • After hearing this, click the real Bowie version to the right, you'll then realise how piss poor this actually is.

  • awesome version, fresh, proud, powerful. if your going to do a cover, do it your own way, not a limp effort like the wallflowers version,not a oasis fan but i love this.

  • Wow amazing photos! Where are they from?

  • OMG this i absolutely amazing! Love Bowie and i love OASIS!! Noel marry me now

  • This is the first time ive heard this version! Just as good as the original

  • 34567x better then bowie's

  • shocking...

  • Wallflowers is better

  • the best cover from Heroes is Clan of Xymox

  • che belle immagini di liam e noel che doolci!!!

  • this cover has not the 'strenght-giving song' vibe of the original,,,, i know everybody always speak shit about covers but this really isnt a good cover... its not solemn

  • Normally I quite like Oasis, but I'm going to stick to Bowie. 'm Afraid this just doesn't work for me...

  • Was this on a particular single?

  • @RahenyBohs

    It was on the D'You Know What I Mean? single.

  • @HoosierBallz thanks

  • watch?v=46CNp89_52Y

  • My 2nd. favorite coverversion.

    Respect to Oasis for going their own way, and yet stay true to the original.

  • Comment removed

  • Ive always liked Oasis and we do Heoes. But it can be a very, very boring song unless you put the necessary dynamics into it, both vocals and instrumentation.

    Oasis, bless 'em, go at it 100% from the start, but leaving no space to increase the dynamics of the performance. See Bowie do it live - Concert for New York, with Queen, or all other concerts and he does the business.

  • Always loved this version just as much as Bowie's original.

  • i want that haircut at 0:20 !!

  • Bloody hell! I was getting ready to hate this, but I just can't! For me, this is the final proof that noel is a far better singer than liam, something i have always said. I actually don't like Oasis, but i do like some of the songs that Noel sings.

  • I prefer this to the original because of the amazing energy - not that Bowie COULDN'T do amazing energy, he's a fucking master, but his voice and the instrumentation just weren't as soaring as Noel's are here.

  • music sounds great , but noel just fucking kills the whole song with his singing

  • @jasoninertia While back in the day, Noel was somewhat of an 'uncut gem', it's way better than you're making it out to be.

  • ohhh how i miss noel galagher productions,hopes he comes back soon,,nobody else has picked up the batton where he left off

  • What a terrible version !

  • @Sagge60 its better than the original dont care wit anyone says its the truth anyone denying it is lying

  • @bigSlide94 Not better,but different

  • 42 of these views are done by Retarded people.

  • annoying theres no acoustic version of this, other than an amateur recording on youtube - the acoustic ROCKS. Problem with this version is that Noel's voice is way to low in realtion to the instruments - makes it sounds messy. but the acoustic version is so so cool :(

  • Crackin version

    

  • I love it =D

  • its a great cover, Covers arent supossed to sound the same as the original, the idea of a cover is to get a song, and make it sound your way, wich Oasis did, and did a great job..

  • oasis = talentless fucks lol

  • @ryanpk12

    the only talentlenss fuk I see here, is you =P

  • @ryanpk12 But one thing we can discern about Oasis is that they are Infinitley more Talented than you and alot richer. if they were so untalented then nobody would buy their records would they. Oasis played the biggest open air gig in the world and sold out Wembley Stadium on countless occasions. So yeah they " Have no talent" Dumbass

  • @ryanpk12 which is why they were one of the best bands every yeah ? fuckin tosser

  • Orginal = brilliance. Cover = brilliance. End Of.

    Handbags away everybody, just enjoy the choon ....or fuck off. :D

    Peace and Lurve ;)

  • i don't really like oasis tbh, but give credit where credit is due, this is pretty good for a cover, but as others have said, has NOTHING on the original.

  • amazin!!x

  • the only cover of Heroes which is worst than the x-factor cover.

  • @sonofsilence what the hell are you on? this is the best cover of the song (of course not as good as the original, they never are) and you say its worse than a spaniard shrek singing on it.... jesus is currently weeping

  • Not a huge fan of Oasis, but I like this cover

  • porra, uma merda! Horrivel!

  • If ever a cover version was better than the original this is it.

  • Buena versión, pero como la original nada.

  • what do you mean we 'can' be heroes?!

    the gallaghers already are!

  • at the start it songs like thankyou for the good times :)

  • Started listening to this cover with an open mind, ended up closed ears.

  • I prefer this version. I adore and respect Bowie. But i am just so fucking amazinly big oasis fan :)

  • Love it!

    I'm a massive Bowie fan and this happens to be my favourite track of his.

    Well done Noel - great cover.

  • Generic shite but then again, what more did I expect from Oasis?

    Played with the soul of a cabbage. Bowies is so much better it's just ridiculous.

  • @simplelife88393 Someone's ears ARE working

  • @simplelife88393

    Could say the same about Bowie's version of Who songs.

  • i prefer this version sooooo much more. with bowie, he talks the first half of the song, and screams the second half. It never sounds in tune or in time with the music- but it becomes a great song with this cover.

  • @mtstrat1 It's because it's mean to be slightly melancholic, not a damn rock-tune for you to jam out to. Song's about his manager's affair while in berlin, referring to the berlin wall.

  • Comment removed

  • @precinkt OH thank you for the correction

  • @mtstrat1 Spot on pal.My sentiments exactly!!!

  • Id love to hear noel do more bowie songs. This is amazing!

  • I'd listen to Noel over Bowie any day. Nothing against Bowie, just prefer Noel.

  • it's very oasis style. of course, i prefer bowie's version.

  • I love that Oasis touch that some songs get!

  • It's a decent cover but Bowie's voice wins imo. By far :)

  • I like this version... DB vocals better but the instrumental is just as fluid...:)

  • Bedste cover af det nummer - uden tvivl!!!

  • i hope the bloody comment thing works... EXCELLENT VERSION OASIS! Meg P

  • Oasis will always be the one sound one trick pony, great singer though.

  • @TheRedo92 You've obviously heard nothing of them then.

  • DAVID BOWIE.OASIS.KASABIAN...GENIUS GENE KEEP FLOWING :)

  • I like them both but nothing can beat the original :)

  • WALL OF SOUND...BE HERE NOW COCAINE DAYS AHHH

  • This is an absolutely fantastic cover. The original song was recorded and performed by it's creator - take a bow Mr Bowie - so of course it'll have more connection with it's meaning and soul. But Noel makes this his own and you can tell he is loving every minute of it... just as i am by listening to it again.

  • @DigOutYourSoul88 Glad to know there's someone who doesn't have to obnoxiously muscle in with an unwanted critique of how it can't touch the original, which is apparently the case with every single cover of any song, ever. Different takes on tunes can be great and the originals never fade away, just love the music!

  • Yuck

  • noel.......that's all i have to say. usually cover versions are bad.....and then there's this.

  • oasisi mitici, forever

  • great original and great cover

  • I like the bass line :)

  • Ok where can I download this song? I love both of them but this one is cool!! Is there somewhere that I can get this one?

  • Noel Gallagher=Legend. 'Nuff said. I'm mad fer it!!! ;-)

  • i love the songs without liam, soooo much better and passionate

  • Amen, izzyhavinalaugh.

  • good lad noel

    we lu yaaaaaaaaa

  • Much better than The Wallflowers' version. That one sucks due to the whispering voice from the singer and because the only good song by The Wallflowers is the one appearing at the opening of the TV Series 'The Guardian' (the one starring the same guy who's at 'The Mentalist'). I know, distortion that some people may not like, and stretched out lyrics, but it sounds nice.

  • God this would have been shit if Liam had sung it

  • excellent pics of the glory days with best blokes in the business !!!!!! lets hope they repair the relationship

  • this one is awsome

  • wow at 0:50 Noel really looks like Liam.

  • Hola Pau.

  • I've been wanting to hear this for years. Nice upload!

  • They shouldve have done this. Queens version cannot be replicated.

  • @weallfollowmanutd you fucking numpty.

  • @weallfollowmanutd it was Bowie, EINSTEIN.

  • Oasis = Heroes

  • i love the cover better tehn the orignal personaly. but yeah i love the song and go david bowie for writing it ^.^ this song you knwo i may be wrong.. probily on but it sounds like... like its about the berlin wall

  • This is a nice cover.

  • so glad noel did the vocals for it, although liam is a great singer, his style wouldve been abit too whineey for this song whereas noels huskier voice fits it beautifully!!! oasis and bowie, to great artist that modern music can never outdo

  • C'mon, What's so bad about this?

  • Oasis rules! I love them the way they are!

  • Bowie even loved this version. Enough said.

  • This is a song that all songwriters wish they had written. It will never go out of stlye.

  • awesome

  • Yeah its a Great Song.......and Oasis Do a GREAT JOB ! :)

  • no doubt that the original version is the best, but this is the oasis style, no bullshit here, good oasis version...Christiane F. don't try to be that hero....

  • fanno cagare oasis con questa canzone..baaa

  • preferisco la versione originale.

  • love the backing to this! bowie's will always be the best but this has the be the best cover

    if you dont like it then i dont know why you're bothering to listen to bowie covers in the first place, what else were you expecting from oasis? just dont listen to it

  • can anyone tell me what album this is on

  • No album. It's on audio single

    D'You Know What I Mean? (1997) .

  • Liam is a cock but this is a great cover maybe the best i have heard

  • @68hillbill that's Noel singin', I love the man

  • pretty good.